Archives for category: Corruption

The New York Times Magazine published an in-depth story about the experiences of some of Jeffrey Epstein’s teenage victims. The story, by Jen Percy, is a powerful, heart-wrenching account of what happened to several teenagers who were sexually abused and raped by Epstein. This is a gift article; you can read it without a subscription.

The focus of the story is how Epstein persuaded the girls to bring him their friends. He used them to increase the number of girls whom he raped. When girls got too “old,” say 17 or 18, or when he tired of them, he dismissed them.

The central character in the story is Marina, who was 13 when she first went to Epstein’s mansion to give him a “massage.” The massage was a prelude to sexual activity and rape.

Like the other girls in the story, Marina needed money. She had been raped and assaulted by her mother’s boyfriend. Her home situation was desperate. Epstein paid her $300 to massage him, and an extra $300 for every new girl she brought to him.

Think of it: a 13-year-old child was taking a taxi from Queens to East 71 Street in Manhattan (which Epstein paid for) and collecting $300 to join Epstein’s pedophile games. She brought her friends, and eventually they brought their friends.

Why is the Justice Department refusing to release the balance of the Epstein files? Why do the Republican majorities in both current houses of Congress refuse to demand their release? Why have they forgotten about the legislation they passed last year requiring the Justice Department to release ALL the files? Why are the files already released so heavily redacted, blotting out the names of the men who shared teenage girls with Epstein?

Epstein was a sex maniac and a pedophile. Why are Republicans blocking access to the names of the powerful men who shared the girls he recruited?

The CEO and founder of Nvidia lost his job because he had extramarital affairs with consenting adults. Why has no one in the Epstein files in this country been exposed and held accountable for pedophilia?

Stephen Dyer has tracked charter schools over the years and knows their problems better than anyone else. They are very costly. Many have very low performance. They have enabled scandals and corruption due to lax oversight.

In this post, he presents his ideas about why charter legislation must change:

Yesterday, I discussed how Tuesday’s election results here and in Texas, as well as the political fallout therefrom will almost certainly result in the death knell for the ~ $1 billion EdChoice voucher program.

Today, it’s the Charter School program, which costs Ohio taxpayers 50 percent more than EdChoice annually. About $20 billion in total since 1998.

I’ve gone through this carnival of horrors many times, but let’s deal with the topline issues with Ohio’s Charter Schools.

  1. They receive 2 out of every 3 of failing grades on the most recent state report card
  2. More than 1 in 3 are on the state’s lowest-performing building list.
  3. More than 9 in 10 “Dropout Recovery” charters are on the list.
  4. About 1 in 5 charters have been on the list since 2018.
  5. More than 1 in 2 charter schools that have ever opened in Ohio are now closed.
  6. They received more than 1/2 of all F grades ever given to schools on Ohio’s Report Card, despite representing about 10% of all Ohio school buildings.
  7. They spend almost double the share of their funding on non-instructional administrators that Ohio’s traditional public schools spend.
  8. They receive more than double the state funding that a traditional Ohio public school student receives.
  9. They spend more, on average, per pupil than a traditional Ohio Public School District, even though charters can’t collect local revenue (except for a handful in Cleveland).
  10. They produced the single largest taxpayer ripoff scam in Ohio history, largely enabled by Sen. Jon Husted, and are constantly being busted for fraud and other corrupt practices.
  11. Charter School students are about 7 percent of the state’s school population, but receive 12 percent of the state’s funding for schools.
  12. That funding (along with EdChoice vouchers) is preventing the state from fully funding its own formula to provide resources to the state’s 1.5 million traditional public school students.
  13. More than 1 in 10 Ohio charter schools are on the state’s suspected test cheating list and 7 out of every 10 schools suspected of cheating on their state tests are charter schools.
  14. More than 1 in 4 of the state’s “high performing” charter schools are on the state’s suspected test cheating list.
  15. They have cost charter school graduates between $247 million and $321 million since 2018 and will cost them between $1.8 billion and $6.7 billion over their collective lifetimes.

A LOT to chew on there. But let’s deal with the three major issues overall issues with charters:

  1. They cost too much
  2. They perform too poorly
  3. They are scandal ridden

So how do we deal with each of these issues now? A few thoughts.

Costing too much

The original sin of Ohio Charter Schools is paying them like they cost the same to operate as traditional public schools. Under Ohio’s current Fair School Funding Plan, costs are calculated based on the overall cost of teachers, principals, administrative assistants, superintendents, treasurers, etc. for Ohio’s public school districts.

The issue with Ohio Charter Schools is they pay their people (except for administrators) way less than traditional schools. In fact, according to state data, they pay their teachers about 37 percent less. So just applying that lower teacher salary to the formula to pay Ohio Charter Schools cuts their funding by about $167 million.

Do that for principals, superintendents, treasurers, administrative assistants, etc. and you would realize additional cost savings.

In addition, you should limit their administrative costs to no more than 10 percent more than the average traditional public school. Currently, the average administrative expenditure in traditional public schools is about 13 percent of the overall spend. Limiting charters to just 10 percent more than that would free up another $210 million or so.

And online schools need a drastic reduction in state aid coupled with requirements to provide up-to-date computers and internet links. 

Brick and mortar charters and online schools need their own, separate funding formulas¹. 

Finally, tying per pupil funding for Charter Schools to no greater than what the state would have paid the school district of residence would also limit their funding to something that makes sense. If the state is paying $5,000 for a student to attend the local public school district, why should it pay $12,000 for that same student to attend a poorer performing charter school²?

Poor Performance

Which brings us to performance. 

Look, Ohio Charter School performance has always been pretty damn poor. The state only spent $8 million of the $71 million the state lied the Obama Administration into giving them a decade ago to grow high-quality Charters. Now we’ve got another $100 million in federal money to expand high-performing Charters here, but we have nowhere near that number of high-quality Charters.

So what can be done?

First, we need to immediately close Charters that have performance index scores that rank in the bottom 5 percent of Ohio public school districts³. If districts that score in the bottom 5 percent on Performance Index Score is bad enough to allow Charter Schools to open, certainly it’s fair that Charters who perform no better shouldn’t be operating and continue siphoning money away from kids in traditional public school districts.

Yes, those students would have to return to traditional public schools, but because the state pays so much more for those kids in Charters, there would also be savings when the kids return to the traditional public schools. Depending on how many years you’d want to include the 5 percent cut off⁴, you’d save $50 million to $450 million.

As for where would districts put these kids now? Just do to Charters what’s been done to Districts: Offer their buildings to the Districts that now need to take the kids at low to no cost. 

And no lottery money should be used to fund Charters. 

Like, ever.

Second, we need a much tighter automatic closure law that takes into account all the report card elements, not just cherry picked elements that put charters in the best light. So if a Charter underperforms the school district of residence from which the student is coming on more measures than it outperforms the district, the Charter can’t take the kid.

This is loosely based on a plan that former state Sen. Joe Schiavoni proposed more than a decade ago. Still works.

And if the Charter School does not outperform the lowest performing public school district in the state on more report card measures than it underperforms, it needs to close, regardless of whose kids the school takes. If you want to do this for two consecutive years or something, I’d listen.

Scandal Ridden

The primary issue with Ohio Charter Schools is their oversight is almost non existent. Yeah, they are audited every year, but as then-Auditor Dave Yost proved — that doesn’t mean they’re getting shut down. He gave the state’s highest auditing award to the Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow (ECOT) the same year they were actively ripping off taxpayers to the tune of $120 million plus. 

While more than 1/2 of all Ohio Charter Schools that have ever opened are now closed, only about 2 dozen of those closures were due to the state’s lax automatic closure law. 

In 2015, we tried putting the onus on Charter School Sponsors to take a more active approach to policing Charter School behavior — to great fanfare and hope from me. But that has largely failed because 1/3 of Ohio’s Charter Schools are on the state’s list of worst-performing schools. 

So here’s how to improve accountability and reduce the possibility of another ECOT scandal.

First, we ban for-profit operators from running Ohio Charter Schools. This is something former House Speaker (and current 20-year federal resident) Larry Householder proposed not long ago. Most states do not let private, for-profit companies to run their Charter Schools. Ohio should join them. Eliminating the profit motive should reduce costs as well, as I found back when Householder proposed the idea. For-profit schools spent about $1,200 more per pupil back then.

Second, we require that all charter school sponsors have to be publicly accountable entities. One of the elements that leads to us being deemed the Wild, Wild West of Charter Schools by Charter School advocates is that so many non-profits that have little to do with education run our Charter Schools, including an orphanage and a housing organization. This arrangement is almost unique in the country. 

Requiring Ohio Charter Schools to be run by school districts or the state would ensure more public accountability, as well as create better partnerships between the traditional and charter sectors — partnerships that have been nearly non-existent here as these schools were first and foremost a political, not an education reform project of big Republican campaign donors.

Finally, we need a transparent, KnowYourCharter.com-like state website where people can compare their schools and Charters easily and understandably. Sunshine is the best disinfectant, after all. 

Bottom Line

Doing these things will greatly reduce the taxpayer investment in Charter Schools, but will ensure a better Charter School program. Think quality, not quantity here. 

Would you rather have a huge Charter School program filled mostly with failed operations that cost state taxpayers more than school districts? Or fewer, higher performing schools that complement the traditional schools?

I have often differed with many public school advocates on Charter Schools. I have said they can work in limited circumstances. We have spent $20 billion and 30 years proving that they can’t work here in their current form as a broad-based education solution. 

As Charter School advocate Macke Raymond put it many years ago: Parental Choice has not improved education the way the School Choice advocates thought. 

That doesn’t mean Charter Schools can’t work in some form or fashion here. 

But I think we can all agree that after $20 billion and 30 years, this Charter School form is not working. 

They need to be reined in with the money saved from that re-directed to fully funding the state’s school funding formula and reducing the need and amount of property taxes collected.

It’s time for this program’s GLP-1 treatment.

Slimmer and better.

Our taxpayers and, most importantly, our kids deserve it.

To read the footnotes, open the link.

One of the first resignations after the midterm elections was that of Harmeet Dhillon. She was the Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Civil Rights Division in the Justice Department. She not only oversaw the major civil rights laws, she also was responsible for those rights that protected students and staff in schools. Trump was trying to eliminate the U.S. Department of Education, and wrestling queen Secretary Linda McMahon sent the Department’s Office of Civil Rights to the Justice Department, to be overseen by Harmeet Dhillon.

Dhillon opposes most if not all civil rights laws, as they have been written and interpreted by legislators, judges, juries, lawyers, and citizens. Most people think that civil rights laws are intended to rectify past injustice or to safeguard those whose opportunities have been curtailed by state action or institutions. Dhillon prefers to ignore the history of civil rights in this country and to enforce strict equality, with no preferential treatment for anyone.

Her attention has been laser-focused on voter fraud and elections, supporting Trump’s strong belief that elections are rigged, that undocumented people are casting ballots, and that her office must pursue these crimes.

Jan Resseger, indefatigable champion of the underdog, explains how Dhillon used her position to undermine civil rights laws.

She writes:

Harmeet Dhillon, the Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights in the U.S. Department of Justice, resigned on November 5.

President Trump has demanded that Education Secretary Linda McMahon shut down the U.S. Department of Education, and McMahon has distributed much of the work to other departments through “interagency agreements.” In the past six months, after the U.S. Department of Education began collaborating with the Justice Department through an interagency agreement, Harmeet Dhillon had undertaken leadership of much of the work of the Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights.

The NY Times‘ Glenn Thrush, Michael Bender, and Alan Feuer describe Dhillon’s resignation this week and her aggressive and twisted approach to civil rights enforcement:

“Harmeet Dhillon, the chief of the Justice Department’s civil rights division, resigned on Thursday after conflicts with department leaders, including disagreements over legal strategy in the midterm elections… Ms. Dhillon, whose tenure was defined by a successful pressure campaign against universities and unsuccessful efforts to obtain voting data from states had been telling friends for weeks that she planned to step down… In less than two years on the job, Ms. Dhillon repurposed a unit created to address Jim Crow injustices into a battering ram against the left, setting aside its longtime mission of fighting discrimination against Black people to battle campus antisemitism and diversity initiatives… Ms. Dhillon’s hard-line approach, laid out in a series of April 2025 memos declaring her intention to pursue a conservative culture war agenda, prompted the departure of hundreds of career officials in the unit. That left her short-handed to pursue many of her objectives, including the deployment of 1,000 election monitors around the country on Election Day….”

There is no indication that Dhillion’s resignation indicates any change in the civil rights strategy of the Trump administration.  Neither does Dhillon’s resignation appear to have been caused by the Democrats’ midterm rout. While her resignation was not announced until November 5, Dhillon had submitted a letter of resignation three weeks prior to last Tuesday’s election, and there is widespread agreement that resigning was her own choice, and not the President’s.  In August, the NY Times’ Glenn Thrush and Michael Bender reported: “She has told people in her orbit she may quit if she is not promoted to deputy attorney general, a post vacated by Todd Blanche when he rose to be attorney general—and would only stay if she respects the alternative pick.”

Coverage of Harmeet Dhillon’s policies at the Department of Justice’s civil rights division has addressed a number of urgently important issues.  The Washington Post‘s Perry Stein and Jeremy Roebuck track Dhillon’s failure to investigate the ICE practices that included the killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis.  And Democracy Docket‘s Matt Cohen and Yunior Rivas explore the federal investigations and lawsuits that DOJ filed under her leadership to challenge voter registration lists and interfere with the November mid-term election.

However, at the heart of Dhillon’s agenda was the twisted destruction of the federal government’s attempt to protect the educational mission of the Civil Rights Movement, which had sought to end racial segregation in the public schools and address the nation’s appalling educational inequality.

Dhillon’s primary agenda for K-12 public schools was to end the protection of diversity, equity and inclusion for groups of students who had attended segregated schools and whose rights had been violated historically. Dhillon’s agenda for the nation’s colleges and universities similarly sought to impose the Trump administration’s expansive interpretation of the 2023 Supreme Court decision in Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard, a case Dhillon and her colleagues have interpreted as not only banning affirmative action, but also as terminating “diversity, equity, and inclusion” policies and initiatives across K-12 public schools and higher education.

“Dhillon dramatically transformed the civil rights division in a little over a year and a half,” writes The Guardian’s Sam Levine, “reorienting its mission away from the work it had traditionally done protecting the civil rights of minorities.  Under her leadership, the department dropped many cases alleging discrimination against racial minorities in voting, housing, employment and education. Scores of career lawyers also left the division under her leadership, leading to an exodus of expertise of civil rights enforcement.”

In early October, Glenn Thrush elaboratedon the disruptive transformation of DOJ’s Civil Rights Division after Dhillon’s appointment: Dhillon hired “130 lawyers who have recently joined the Justice Department’s short-staffed civil rights division as the Trump administration has struggled to fill the depleted ranks of a unit that was once a magnet for legal talent. Since early 2025, upward of 300 nonpolitical career employees, representing decades of experience, have left the division after its leader, Harmeet Dhillon, repurposed it to pursue President Trump’s agenda. As a consequence, the division has opened its doors to recruits, many of them conservatives, some with education and work histories that might have disqualified them from being hired in the past… Some have left a trail of hyperpartisan, conspiratorial and, in some instances, bizarre statements….”

Harmeet Dhillon’s Impact on Higher Education      

Dhillon filed lawsuits  threatening federal research grants to universities that she alleged were promoting “diversity, equity, and inclusion.” As reported by Thrush, Bender and Feuer, “In higher education, she mounted repeated challenges to admissions practices and campus speech policies, opening high-profile investigations and lawsuits against elite institutions. She sued Harvard twice, once over accusations of antisemitism and another over claims that the school’s admissions policies discriminated against white and Asian people (she lost both times). She also spoke out in support of parent rights groups, fueling the administration’s push to pare back protections for transgender students… In June 2025, Ms. Dhillon and her team pushed James E. Ryan, the president of the University of Virginia, into early retirement over his reluctance to adopt Mr. Trump’s anti-diversity policies and narrow view of anti-Semitism.” (parenthetical phrase in the original)

Last summer, Bender and Thrush exposed Dhillon‘s proactive strategy for pursuing her agenda: “After being confirmed to lead the civil rights division, Ms. Dhillon perused the U.S. News & World Report rankings of top undergraduate, law school and medical school programs, dispatching demands for admissions data, including applicants’ gender, race and test scores. She concluded that medical schools at U.C.L.A. and Yale were discriminating against white and Asian applicants. (Each school expressed confidence in its admissions practices.) At least 15 other top medical schools are under investigation… Over the past year, she has investigated the University of California system, Arizona State University, George Mason, the City University of New York, and the University of Nevada, Las Vegas… Mrs. Dhillon has targeted Harvard University as a prominent part of her battle against liberal academia, but it has the resources and the will to fight back.” (parenthetical phrase in the original)

Harmeet Dhillon’s Impact on K-12 Public Education     

Last July, after Education Secretary Linda McMahon transferred some of the responsibility for civil rights enforcement in public schools from the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR)  to be housed through an interagency agreement at the Department of Justice’s civil rights division, Education Week’s Alyson Klein explored what the new arrangement would mean:

“Former employees of both agencies… point to big structural differences between the two offices. OCR must consider every complaint it receives and generally seeks an administrative—rather than a legal—resolution whereas the Justice Department more commonly pursues litigation, and does so selectively… What’s more, the shift may give the Trump administration more potent legal tools to investigate and litigate against schools and districts that run afoul of its policies on DEI and transgender students. Earlier this summer, shortly after the transfer was announced, Harmeet Dhillon… told conservative radio host Glenn Beck that her office would pursue legal action to prevent students from having ‘illegal gender ideology… forced down their throats’ without parental permission… In her interview with Beck, Dhillon… also lambasted laws in states like California that she contends give preference in competitions for public contracts to historically disadvantaged groups, such as racial minorities. That’s a sign her agency may use its authority to pursue legal cases against districts it believes allow for racial preferences that the Trump administration contends are illegal.”

Finally, Dhillon’s division took an historic step away from civil rights enforcement in the nation’s public schools by terminating a mass of civil rights consent decrees.  The NY Times‘ Bender reported: “The Justice Department… ended its watchdog role in more than 50 cases enforcing racial desegregation in schools, mostly in the Deep South, a significant milestone in the Trump administration’s bid to overhaul civil rights enforcement in America. Justice Department records showed that 57 desegregation orders have been dismissed since the start of President Trump’s second term, although it could not be verified late Thursday that a judge had ruled in each one. Nearly 80 percent of the cases were in five Southern states—Alabama with five, Georgia with 15, Louisiana with 11, Mississippi with 13, and South Carolina with one… The Justice Department suggested that the desegregation cases were relics of the nation’s past that continued to impose unnecessary financial burdens on local governments. ‘In some cases, school districts have been under federal control for more than 60 years,’ Ms. Dhillon said in a statement.  Dhillon continued: ‘In this administration, we are ending prolonged federal oversight of these school districts because the effort does not reflect the reality of those classrooms today.’ ”

Bender describes the response of groups who work for the protection of civil rights: “Groups including the N.A.A.C.P. have said that desegregation orders do more than change the racial makeup of classrooms by mandating equal funding, access to high-quality facilities and fair representation in advanced placement programs.”

Harmeet Dhillon’s Impact on Education in America     

More than anyone in Donald Trump’s second administration, Harmeet Dhillon has represented the threat to a decades-long effort to repair the educational injustices of slavery and Jim Crow.

In his newest book, Dangerous Learning, constitutional law professor Derek W. Black summarizes what civil rights advocates have worked to achieve during the lifetimes of most of us who are reading this post today:  “Brown v. Board of Education and its progeny fundamentally altered the way society thinks about education, not just of Black children but of all children. Laws prohibiting discrimination against students based on sex, language status, ethnicity, alienage, disability, poverty, and homelessness all grew out of the foundation Brown laid. For the past half century, the federal legal apparatus as well as several state regimes have aimed to deliver equal educational opportunity.” (Dangerous Learning, p. 275)

Harmeet Dhillon has most prominently represented the Trump administration’s attack on that legacy. Dhillon has now left the administration, but there are others who will continue twisting the meaning of our nation’s civil rights struggle and attempting to undo the progress we have made. Protecting all children’s rights in the nation’s public schools, and protecting K-12 public schools and the nation’s colleges and universities from the imposition of a narrow and distorted ideology will continue to require public vigilance and advocacy.

Heather Cox Richardson analyzes Trump’s reactions to the Democratic uprising against his administration and his inhumane policies. As she notes, Trump replaced his chief of staff Susie Wiles with her deputy Stephen Miller. Miller is the most vicious of Trump’s inner circle. He has consistently pushed 3,000 deportations per day, with the hope of reaching one million deportations yearly. His goal is an all-white America, which is ridiculous because we are a multiethnic, multiracial society. He is mean.

Richardson wrote:

On Tuesday, Americans rejected the Trump administration. It turns out most people hated the idea of a strongman who ignored the Constitution, undermined democracy, and tried to rewrite America’s history in order to impose a white, Christian nationalist regime that enriched him and his cronies at the expense of everyone else.

Voters made their position very clear. A majority of more than 12 million demanded an end to corruption, an end to Trump’s war on Iran, an end to costly tariffs, and an end to the masked agents kidnapping Black and Brown people off the streets.

By a margin of more than 13%, they voted for a country based on the rule of law in which everyone is held accountable for their actions and no one can break the law with impunity. They voted for the system of checks and balances established by the Framers of the Constitution. They voted for policies that supported the American people, making it possible for them to afford food and housing and healthcare rather than continuing to funnel money to billionaires.

They voted for the multicultural country Trump and his loyalists mocked. They elected Democratic Black candidates Keisha Lance Bottoms to govern Georgia, David Crowley to govern Wisconsin, Aaron Ford to govern Nevada, and Stacey Plaskett to govern the U.S. Virgin Islands. They elected Byron Donalds, a Black Republican, to govern Florida.

Voters elected Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed to be the nation’s first Muslim senator, and they reelected Representative Ilhan Omar, whom Trump has made a key target of his attacks, with an astonishing 76.5% of her district’s vote.

As Valerie Gonzalez, Mike Catalini, and Jonathan J. Cooper of the Associated Press reported, Hispanic voters shifted hard away from the Republican Party and swung back toward the Democrats in 2026, with 7 out of 10 Hispanic voters in Texas backing Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico. In a rejection of Trump’s attacks on immigrants, for the first time since 2008, Democrats won every House district that touches the U.S.-Mexico border, and voters have sent fourteen new Hispanic Democrats to Congress.

Black voters, especially in the American South, turned out in unusually high numbers, and they voted for Democrats at higher rates than they did in 2024. Emily Cochrane of the New York Times reported that about 80% of Black votes in congressional races across the country were for Democratic candidates.

The message was unmistakable.

Since his 2024 reelection, Trump and his allies have repeatedly insisted that his victory of about 2.3 million voters over Democratic candidate Vice President Kamala Harris, earning him less than 50% of the vote, was a “mandate.” Compared to the margin of more than 12 million voters delivered on Tuesday, it was a fizzle. The Economist noted that Tuesday’s Democratic victory was “the biggest congressional landslide in 50 years.” Recognizing the direction of the tide, since the election, panicked Republicans have called for regrouping, ending the war on Iran, and addressing affordability.

Trump initially appeared dazed by the rebuke, but today he woke up and threw their rejection of his agenda back in Americans’ teeth.

Ousting his chief of staff, Susie Wiles, Trump replaced her with the architect of some of his administration’s most extreme policies: Stephen Miller.

Miller is a fervent white nationalist who appears to believe in the racist “great replacement theory,” the idea that Black and Brown immigrants to Europe and the United States are destroying “Western culture.”

Miller’s elevation to chief of staff doesn’t necessarily change much; he already was a powerful force in the White House. Miller drove the “Muslim ban” in Trump’s first term and, in his second, the administration’s arrest, incarceration, and deportation plans for undocumented immigrants. His push for masked agents to arrest 3,000 people a day led to the murders of U.S. citizens Renee Goode and Alex Pretti, as well as the shooting deaths of immigrants and their mistreatment and deaths in concentration camps.

Miller has been a key proponent of Trump’s seizing power through emergency declarations that he uses to ignore the law. Frustrated by opposition to his plan to hurt Black and Brown people, Miller pushed for Trump to crush the opposition by invoking the Insurrection Act.

And Miller was central to the administration’s undermining of disability rights. Mike Hixenbaugh of NBC News reported that after Trump complained about seeing homeless encampments in Washington, D.C., Miller argued for a plan to make it easier to round up mentally ill homeless people and institutionalize them. Making that happen required abandoning enforcement of the 1999 Supreme Court decision Olmstead v. L.C., which established that disabled Americans have a right to live in their communities rather than being forced into institutions.

The Department of Justice went along with Miller’s plan and issued a memo saying that it would no longer enforce Olmstead. While the initial targets were unhoused people, Hixenbaugh notes, the administration quickly backed away from at least five disability rights cases designed to keep physically or mentally disabled children and adults out of institutions. Hixenbaugh points out that the administration’s refusal to enforce Olmstead is sending a message to the states that, with the dramatic cuts to Medicaid in the Republicans’ so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” they should “feel free to cut services that help disabled people remain at home,” forcing them into institutions.

As Phillips S. O’Brien wrote in Phillip’s Newsletter, Miller also supports Russia’s version of its war on Ukraine and has taken a strong and public stand against the embattled U.S. ally. O’Brien notes that Trump’s elevation of Miller now illustrates the president’s determination to get whatever he can for Russia’s president Vladimir Putin before the new Congress starts investigations and puts up roadblocks.

So, rather than moderating his behavior after voters’ dramatic rebuke, Trump is demonstrating by elevating Miller that he is hardening his position. He is surrounding himself with the most extreme of his advisors: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, whom he has supported in the face of calls for his impeachment; Natalie Harp, the smiling aide who appears glued to his side; and Russell Vought, the director of the Office of Management and Budget and a key author of Project 2025, who Trump boasted before the election would soon “be one of the very important people in the history of our country, in my opinion.” He noted: “We have some big surprises coming up in another few weeks, right, Russ?”

Trump’s elevation of Miller was a deliberate declaration that he doesn’t care what the American people want. Representative LaMonica McIver (D-NJ), whom the administration has targeted because of her attempt to conduct oversight of a detention facility, was clear: “Stephen Miller is a white supremacist,” she said in a statement. “By promoting the person responsible for ICE detaining our neighbors and killing people in the streets, Donald Trump is doubling down on the cruelty and corruption that have defined his administration. The president is panicked after losing power in Congress and this is a signal about what he will prioritize in the final stretch of his presidency: grievance and cruelty.”

Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) posted: “Donald Trump learned nothing from his historic defeat. Stephen Miller is the architect of the most barbaric, inhumane policies of this administration. Trump couldn’t have made a worse choice. Our Democratic majorities will fight him every step of the way.”

House minority leader Hakeem Jeffries posted: “Stephen Miller is a dangerous xenophobe and reckless extremist who has American blood on his hands. His presence in government should be eradicated like a malignant tumor. Fire him today.”

But Trump’s embrace of Miller was not aimed at Democrats alone. It is a shot across the bow of Republicans who might want to jump ship. When Meredith Lee Hill of Politico told one House Republican that Trump had tapped Miller to be his chief of staff, the lawmaker replied: “Please tell me you’re lying to me right now, just to get a reaction.”

Trump is making it clear to Republicans that he intends to force the party to stay behind an even more extreme weapon of MAGA than the one voters rejected Tuesday, incinerating their hopes for 2028. Alex Isenstadt of Axios reported today that Trump has told advisors that he intends to keep raising money so he can continue to wield power over Republican candidates in 2028.

And in a sign that MAGA leaders are determined to keep Republicans in line, Philip Wegmann of the Wall Street Journal reported yesterday that the White House sent a memo to more than 3,000 Republican-oriented groups, warning them: “As always, we are monitoring statements, press releases, and media engagements from your organizations.”

It all feels very desperate.

Tonight Trump appeared in a campaign hat at a NASA event at which he rambled from topic to topic, slurring his words and sounding tired. He said he had declared all of space “open for American settlement, American civilization, and American freedom.” He said that “[w]ithin two years, NASA will launch the first ever nuclear powered spacecraft to Mars,” before veering off to talk about his uncle, who was a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Trump promised that “before the end of my term, the United States will return American astronauts to the surface of the Moon. So exciting. And soon thereafter the United States will establish a permanent presence on lunar soil.”

To a silent audience, Trump said: “By the way, I was not on the ballot, just in case you had any questions. Because if we were on the ballot we would’ve won.”

This is a terrific article by Peggy Noonan that appeared in The Wall Street Journal. It is a gift article so you don’t need to be a subscriber to read it.

Why did the Democrats win a sweeping victory?

It was prices. It was the Iran war. It was blatant corruption.

But it was something more:

In election coverage on the Free Press, Meghan McCain noted that when you see Mar-a-Lago in the media, it’s always like they’re having nonstop parties out of “The Great Gatsby.” All the reveling, it’s fancy and rich and careless, and in a time, outside the club, of want and anxiety.

It’s all stilettos and tuxes and gowns and pricey surgery and shiny tuxedo loafers in there, and in the White House. On Halloween night, three days before the epochal election, the festivities were huge and jungle-themed. Yahoo News called it “a camp, spandex-and-glitter-filled affair” with a caviar bar. Some guests dressed “in elaborate or barely-there costumes.” The Washington Post pool report had people dressed as leopards and snakes and in “tiger-print dinner jackets….”

This administration’s soul is seen in its social life, and it is the opposite of populism—it is more like a low-class, high-tack oligarchy dominated by patricians who feel no obligation to even fake a little class.

Ultimately, she writes, Trump views his rabid supporters with contempt. Maybe some sensed it.

Robert Reich, former Secretary of Labor, says that the central issue in the midterm elections is whether to continue the enrichment of the richest or to bolster the well-being of the rest of the citizenry.,

He writes:

Friends,

America makes its choice November 3.

It’s not really a choice between two parties. After all, a record 45 percent of American voters now call themselves “independent” and don’t align with either party. And most of us who still describe ourselves as Republicans or Democrats don’t have much love for whichever party we’re registered with. 

Nor will it be a choice between the “left” and the “right,” as those terms have been used for the last half-century — representing preferences by the left for more and bigger social safety nets and by the right for lower taxes. These days, big business wants more government in the form of subsidies, bailouts, no-bid government contracts, and a giant military-technology state. 

The real choice is between ever more concentrated wealth and power at the top — in the billionaire class, tech bros, Wall Street, and the C-suites of giant corporations — versus more wealth and power in what used to be the American working middle class. 

That’s what the “affordability crisis” is all about. It also underlies America’s growing concern about corruption. 

For the last few weeks it’s looked as if America was about to choose the second path, for The People and against Big Money. 

But Big Money is now striking back. Elon Musk is pouring hundreds of millions into supporting Republican candidates, as are Big Crypto, AIPAC, AI, and Trump’s MAGA Inc. (and its related super PACs). 

“Dark money” — anonymous campaign donations flowing through so-called “nonprofits,” mostly from wealthy individuals and CEOs — is also dropping into the system. 

Democratic candidates are being outspent 2-to-1 by super PACs and megadonors. More than in any midterm since the Supreme Court’s shameful Citizens United decision, Big Money is going almost exclusively to the GOP. The Supreme Court has given Republicans an additional spending advantage by allowing super PACs to work in close cooperation with candidates.

Texas’s James Talarico hasn’t taken any corporate PAC money, for example, and has an army of volunteers going door to door for him and has accumulated one of the largest small-donor war chests of any candidate in this election cycle. But his opponent, Ken Paxton, is relying almost entirely on $158 million he’s got from Musk via a Republican super PAC.

This enormous gusher of Big Money for Republicans has no regulatory oversight because the Federal Election Commission has no quorum and therefore can’t function. 

At the state level, Big Money is attacking ballot measures to increase taxes on the super-rich — such as California’s Proposition 40, a one-time 5 percent tax on billionaires. Google multibillionaire Sergey Brin is sinking hundreds of millions into defeating it. Gavin Newsom also opposes it. But another California presidential hopeful, Ro Khanna, is pushing for it, to his great credit. (Note to California voters: Vote YES on 40 and NO on the poison pills, Props 41 and 42.)

This election is the clearest contest yet between Big Money and The People. Spending by super PACs and other megadonors in the current midterms is over 50 percent higher than in the 2022 midterms, in inflation-adjusted dollars. 

I wish I were more confident that The People will prevail. Democrats are doing well in the polls, but polling is flawed when it comes to the influence of Big Money. Many so-called “low-information” voters are more likely to be swayed by media advertising and less likely to respond to polls or tell pollsters truthfully how they intend to vote. 

When this is over, if the Democrats take back the House and at least come close to retaking control of the Senate, high on their agenda must be seeking to get Big Money out of our politics — via constitutional amendment or public financing of elections (matching small-dollar donations). And also going after the source of much of the Big Money by enacting a national wealth tax. 

In the meantime: stay calm, support good candidates, do whatever you can to get out the vote, and vote as soon as you can.

Timothy Snyder is one of the world’s leading historians of European history. He has been a staunch defender of Ukraine in its fight to survive the Russian invasion of 2022.

He explains in this post how wrong Trump is about Ukraine. Trump has abandoned our European allies and aligned the U.S. with the aggressor, Vladimir Putin.

Professor Snyder writes:

Donald Trump has just claimed that the United States had done “a lot” for Ukraine, but that Ukraine has done “nothing” for the United States. 

This is unjust in the highest degree. And not just untrue in the normal sense — it is a big lie, designed to bring about horror and chaos.

At the moment, the United States has agreed to purchase Russian diesel, which breaks its own laws as well as international sanctions agreements, and in effect places America on the Russian side of the war. It is also denying Ukraine access to Starlink services (which have been paid for), thereby making it much harder for Ukraine to defend its people against Russian attacks. The United States provides almost no military aid to Ukraine, and it has been the policy of the Trump administration to deny such aid. Europeans purchase American arms and deliver them to Ukraine, but even these contractual agreements are not being met by the American side. The most important weapons in question are Patriot interceptors, which Ukrainians need to defend themselves from Russian ballistic missiles. 

In other words, the Trump administration has acted to make Ukrainians more vulnerable to Russian attacks. In case there was any doubt about the general drift of this: The president of the United States has now repeatedly called for the president of Ukraine to leave office. And so the question is not how much the United States is doing for Ukraine. The question is why the United States is working to help the Russian aggressor right now.

But that might not even be the greatest injustice in Trump’s statement that “You know what, we’ve given a lot to Ukraine. They’ve given nothing to us.” Ukrainians have fought the largest war since 1945 for almost five years now. The war is longer than the First World War and longer than the American engagement in the Second World War. They suffer military and civilian casualties every day. Proportional to population, they have suffered losses on a scale Americans have never experienced, with the exception of the Civil War. They live through the equivalent of a 9/11 in Russian terror attacks every few weeks. 

And yet Ukrainians are defending themselves, and very effectively. In so doing they are also giving a great deal to us. Because they have been doing so for so long and so well, it is — sadly — all to easy to take for granted Ukrainian contributions to American and world security. So I will just enumerate a few of them here. 

Ukraine is defending the basic principle of international law, which is that states are sovereign and that one state should not seize territory from another by way of aggression. 

Ukraine is fulfilling the entire NATO mission, which is to defend Europe from Russian aggression. It is doing the job that NATO assigns to its thirty-two members, which include the United States and Canada. Ukraine is doing this job itself.

Ukraine is making a world war less likely. Russia has already brought to life the most worrying security concern on the scale of Europe, which is a Russian invasion of a European country. On the scale of the world, the greatest risk is Chinese aggression in Taiwan. By defending itself, Ukraine has demonstrated the difficulties in offensive operations, and made such a war less likely.

Kyiv, Lukianivka neighborhood, September 2026, TS

Ukraine is making a nuclear war less likely. Russia is a nuclear power. Ukraine is not. If Russia is allowed to defeat Ukraine, other middle powers will likely draw the conclusion that they need to build nuclear weapons in order to defend themselves. By holding back Russia, Ukraine is also holding back nuclear proliferation.

Ukraine is defending us all from oligarchy, from the rule of the very wealthy. Putin’s idea that Ukraine is not a real country is the example of an oligarchical fantasy, the kind of centibillionaire nonsense that can take lives and destroy the planet. By resisting Russian aggression, Ukraine is showing that democracy can defend itself.

Ukraine is providing an example of freedom. In Ukraine, even during conditions of war, civil society functions, and people speak their minds. Under Russian occupation, an entirely different mode of life prevails: women are raped; children are deported to Russia to be assimilated; local activists are murdered; young men are forced into the Russian army to die; total uniformity is imposed. 

And so what Trump says is wrong in the very broadest of senses. Ukraine is doing work for our security and for our liberty. Ukrainians have held off the worse and bought the rest of us time. 

And Trump’s claim is also wrong in the narrow sense. Ukraine has been providing battlefield intelligence to the United States from the beginning of the war. It has shared its experience of modern warfare with American institutions. It even sent — in these most trying of times inside Ukraine — hundreds of its own experienced air defense troops to the Near East to help protect Americans and their allies from Iranian drones. Imagine what those Ukrainian crews, separated from their embattled country to defend Americans, are thinking right now, as their contributions are denied, and as their own families are put in greater danger by US policy.

Trump’s statement is not only unjust. It is not only a lie. It is a big lie, whose purpose is not to describe the world but to change it, to blame the victim and assist the aggressor, to betray the ally and destroy the alliances, to create a world in which everyone must feel unsafe except the wealthy and powerful, a world in which all that matters are the personal feelings and personal dealings of a handful of oligarchs and dictators.

A journalist in Texas wrote the following. He/she lives in Austin and requested anonymity to avoid reprisals. I have double-checked the information shared. It is accurate.

The journalist describes Governor Greg Abbott’s tactic to destroy public education: state takeovers. This allows the state to dismiss the locally elected school board and replace it with people loyal to Governor Abbott and State Superintendent Mike Morath, a non-educator picked by Abbott. After the state takeover, teachers leave, enrollment declines..public schools being to the state, not to the district.

The journalist wrote the following to me:

Texas public schools are under attack. And no Texas district is being attacked on as many fronts as Austin ISD.

 State policies and targeted investigations are taking a toll, pulling time, energy, and funds from the real work of supporting Austin’s students, teachers, and campus communities. The district is facing a long list of challenges, all created or exacerbated by many years of anti-public school policies from state leaders. Students and teachers feel the impact on campuses every day. Families are leaving the district. Budgets are becoming tighter each year. Charters and vouchers are siphoning students from public schools and concentrating need at many campuses. And despite this community’s deep belief in engaging education, teaching is increasingly focused on testing – the near-inevitable result of a punitive high-stakes testing environment.

 Austin is sometimes described as the blueberry in the tomato soup – the brightest blue community in what has long been a deeply red state. That makes the district a favorite target for state leaders, who routinely attack it to score political points.Students, teachers, families, and the city are suffering as those attacks weaken a district in that should be among the strongest urban districts in the country.

 The community shows up for Austin ISD schools, and people across the economic spectrum continue to choose Austin ISD schools, which educate a mix of students who are diverse in every way. About half come from families classified as having economic disadvantage and half do not. About half are Hispanic, almost a third are emergent bilingual, and nearly one in ten are immigrants from all over the world.

 Austin ISD’s school board looks a lot like the city itself – racially and economically diverse, highly educated, and politically progressive. All were elected with strong support from their local union and their local communities. All serve as volunteers in a role that demands many hours and invites public critique along with the joy. All have seen the impact of state policies on Texas public schools. Many are longtime public education advocates. And all have become far too familiar withthe power the Texas Education Agency holds over Texas districts.

 In Texas, state takeovers are becoming a go-to remedy. Houston ISD was the first big district to fall, in 2023. Then, last year, the pace escalated. A single school with five F ratings in a row can trigger a takeover. Four more districts are now under state control, including Fort Worth ISD – another of the state’s largest urban districts. When the 2026-27 school year began, some 250,000 Texas students walked into classrooms that are now under state control.

 It’s an unprecedented experiment, and an aggressive exercise of state power over local communities. Now Austin ISD – rated a B under the state’s narrow accountability system – is the latest Texas district at risk of state takeover. And that is just the biggest threat among many, many others.

 Here’s a short list of challenges Austin ISD is facing right now:

 

• Investigation of student walkouts

State leaders have targeted Austin ISD for a special investigation after students at many campuses walked out to protest ICE. In a community as diverse as Austin, issues involving immigration are felt deeply and personally. Their protests were part of a student movement across the state and the country in late January. Yet Governor Greg Abbot and Attorney General Ken Paxton have focused special attention on Austin ISD, with an investigation that still has not been completed. The Texas Education Agency has warned that walkouts could lead to a state takeover.

 

• Investigation of which bathroom a single student has used

Attorney General Paxton has also targeted Austin ISD for alleged violations of the state’s “bathroom bill,” which requires people at sites including public schools to use the bathroom that matches their sex at birth. The bill depends on people reporting districts for alleged violations – something that happened two times when someone complained about the bathroom a single transgender student was using at an Austin ISD high school, which was followed by a complaint at the district’s performing arts center. The law holds the district accountable, allowing fines of up to $5000 a day for documented violations. But the law also allows the full weight of the state to be weaponized against individual students – children in public schools.

 

• Funding crisis

For years, public education funding has failed to keep up with inflation or a long and growing list of mandates from the state. Texas consistently ranks in the bottom ten states in per-student funding. Yet schools must also pay for expensive security mandates, serve students who are emergent bilingual or who receive special education services despite funding that leaves immense gaps, and follow many other state demands that are neither optional nor funded. Across the state, dozens of schools have closed, class sizes are growing, programs and student supports are being cut, and teachers are quitting or taking second jobs. Texas offers no funding for many things it simply does not require, including school nurses and school librarians. Transportation is funded at a fraction of the actual cost to districts. In Austin ISD, the 2026-27 budget included about $205 million in deeply painful cuts. The district closed eleven campuses. They are selling property to help plug the holes. And still funding is not keeping up with costs. That crisis has been deepened by the passage of a $1 billion statewide voucher after many years of successful resistance by the Texas Legislature. Passage was only possible after the sitting governor primaried legislators who voted against vouchers, then had President Trump call lawmakers the morning of the vote. The cost is expected to double this year.

 

• State comptroller audit

At a campaign stop in El Paso in August, Governor Greg Abbott asked the Texas Comptroller to investigate the use of taxpayer money at up to four Texas school districts. The goal, according to the Governor, was to prevent funds from “being absorbed by central office growth, administrative bloat, consultants, and the web of noninstructional bureaucracy.” News reports say districts are being asked for data far beyond what an audit focused on the use of funds would require. The list includes lists of library books, demands for documents related to DEI, scrutiny of foreign workers, and information about Social Security numbers that advocates fear is an attempt to understand how many students may be undocumented.

 

• Investigation of Pride Week celebration

Austin ISD has a long history of celebrating Pride Week. Since 2014, that meant supporting activities that included flying Pride flags at district facilities, participating as a district in the community’s Pride Parade, offering age-appropriate activities focused on respect for other people, and supporting campuses that chose to host their own after-school events for families. Staff and families have often said that they have chosen the district because of AISD’s welcoming climate. And the district continued to celebrate Pride Week – along with Juneteenth, Cesar Chavez Day, and other important community celebrations – even after trustees received a death threat targeting the parade. Since 2024, AISD’s Pride Week celebrations have grown smaller and smaller, and less and less visible. In 2026, the district chose not to participate in the community’s parade, inviting PTA leaders to step into the district’s place. As a result, the parade shrank from dozens of people with district support to just a handful. And still, in April, the Texas Education Agency began an investigation into Austin ISD for Pride Week. That investigation was launched in response to a complaint not from within the community, but from a conservative member of the State Board of Education who represents a district in Fort Worth, about 200 miles away. On social media, he called for defunding the district and for a criminal investigation of the superintendent. He also shared concerns that if the practice is not stopped in Austin ISD, it will expand to other communities in the state.

 This is not normal, even in Texas, except for Austin ISD. Each investigation or audit takes precious resources that no Texas district has to spare. Time and funds are diverted from the work that matters most – of educating students, supporting teachers, and inspiring a lifelong love of learning that prepares Austin’s students for the futures they deserve. 

 It does not have to be this way. And it’s both painful and promising to imagine what might be if the State of Texas would offer support rather than sanctions, and if they would also simply get out of the district’s way.

 Austin ISD has a strong board with a broad mix of highly relevant experience. All nine members were endorsed by the district’s union, Education Austin, and all serve by working long hours without pay. Six members are former K-12 educators in Texas public schools – including five who taught in the district, one who worked as the district’s head of multilingual education, and several who are current or former professors in programs that teach future teachers. Another is an educational anthropologist who teaches at UT and ran programs for students in the district. Another is a journalist with a law degree and a long background in advocacy and family engagement. And another is a former foster child who was in the first graduating class of Austin ISD’s Ann Richards School for Young Women Leaders, ranked as one of the top public high schools in the country. Another worked as an accountant after a career as a teacher. Together, the board holds five masters’ degrees, one law degree, and two Ph.Ds. Another trustee is earning a doctorate now. They have hired a superintendent who is a graduate of the district and the son of a longtime teacher. He’s an unconventional choice – with an MBA, an engineering degree, and a career in construction and district operations – but he has also brought stability after a series of rapid superintendent turnovers. And he has worked with the board and community to navigate immensely challenging times.

 As they have tackled issue after issue, district leaders have also managed to do important and thoughtful work in many areas. The community approved a $2.4 billion bond and a crucial increase in the tax rate for operations with powerful support from district voters. The district has created systems to focus resources where they are needed most – essential but also not easy in a district with such a broad range of economic opportunity and economic need. They cleared a large backlog of special education evaluations that grew during the pandemic. They have sharply reduced the number of F-rated campuses and steadily grown the number of highly rated campuses – a measure that must be a focus no matter how flawed and opaque the state’s metrics are. And they are seeing impressive results from a grant-funded investment in early literacy.

 And still, Austin ISD risks being taken over by the state.

 The community’s worry about a takeover goes far beyond the loss of elected control. Their fears are also based in facts about what has happened since the state took control of Houston ISD. State leaders routinely call the takeover an unparalleled success, citing a higher rating for the district and near zero F rated schools. But the costs have been immense – of lost opportunity, financial cost, and damage to community and careers.

 Reports document practices that serve scores but sacrifice student learning – limiting access to 8th grade Algebra by systematically holding some students back, gaming college readiness measures in ways that are legal but offer little benefit, removing both libraries and librarians, and reducing teaching to timed and scripted lessons. Campuses have closed, enrollment has plummeted by more than 20,000 students, and teachers are fleeing. Hundreds of their replacements are uncertified. And the state-appointed leaders have eaten into the district’s fund balance by pulling hundreds of millions from reserves in ways that will be impossible to sustain.

 Good reporting and strategic advocacy are helping the whole story from Houston ISD reach more people. Our state owes deep thanks to Community Voices for Public Education for its advocacy from the beginning, the Commission on the Takeover of HISD for its new in-depth report, state and local education union leaders for advocating and organizing, elected trustees for becoming the resistance, and doctoral student Dan Dawer for work to examine the takeover through an academic lens.

 In Austin, a group called Keep Austin Schools Independent has formed to inform and organize our community. We are also lucky to have strong trustee candidates who are stepping up, not knowing what their role will be but knowing their voices will matter.

 Takeovers are looming for more Texas districts. 

 Education is on the ballot in Texas in a way it has never been before. And the results of the election could make things far better or far worse, not just here in Austin, but also for public schools across our state. Voters in the Democratic primaries chose proven public education supporters up and down the ballot. And for people who know that change is needed for Texas public schools, Gina Hinojosa, the Democratic nominee for Texas Governor, is carrying a whole state’s hopes. She’s the mom of children who chose Austin ISD schools, a former AISD school board president, and a Texas House member who served her community and fought for Texas students on the public education committee. Her office became a place of pilgrimage for public education advocates, who would visit their own representatives, then stop by her office, too.

 A huge amount is at stake – not only for Austin, but for public education statewide. Dozens of Texas districts are just one or two years away from potential takeover. Schools are struggling after years of underfunding. And increasingly, the state’s vision of education is focused on the narrow measure of standardized tests – despite clear evidence that families and educators want and need something more for the 5 million students of Texas

On October 20, Trump offered two rewards.

One was $1 million for anyone who reported voter fraud that led to the arrest and conviction of the fraudsters. So far, no one has claimed the prize, but who knows? There is still time.

The other was a reward for anyone reporting fraud in government spending. That’s the one I wanted to blow the whistle on.

Here is an open-and-shut case of fraud.

In 2025, the private prison operator CoreCivic offered to see a huge prison complex to the state of Minnesota for $75 million. The state turned down the offer.

The same prison complex was purchased by Trump’s Department of Homeland Security a year later for $495 million.

The story was reported by The New York Times:

CoreCivic, a private prison company, approached the Minnesota Department of Corrections last year offering to sell a long-shuttered detention facility. The price: $75 million.

State officials passed. They didn’t have the funds to buy the Prairie Correctional Facility in western Minnesota, nor did they need a prison of its size or have the ability to staff it.

Last summer, to their astonishment, the 1,600-bed prison sold for more than $495 million. The buyer: the Department of Homeland Security.

Why is the federal government getting ripped off?

Clearly somebody at CoreCivic had a big payday.

I went online to learn how to report this fraud.

My report, I discovered, is not covered by the federal whistleblower program.

First of all, the departments covered by statute do not include the Department of Homeland Security. Even if they overpaid by more than $400 million, so what?

The Department of Justice will approve awards pursuant to the Fraud Rewards Program in its sole discretion and may decline to pay a reward as it deems appropriate. At this time, the $10,000 to $30,000 reward payments that are made pursuant to the Fraud Rewards Program will be limited to: (1) Federal health care offenses and related crimes involving health care benefit programs or fraud against patients or others in the health care industry; or (2) fraud on programs or benefits administered by the Department of Agriculture (e.g., the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program), the Department of Labor (e.g., unemployment fraud), the Department of Health and Human Services, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Department of Education (e.g., student aid fraud), the Department of Veterans Affairs, or the Small Business Administration. The Fraud Rewards Program places a particular emphasis on submissions involving the following subject matter areas: hospice, home health care, day care, and special services fraud.

See? No DHS frauds are covered by the program.

Then, reading through the guidelines, I discovered that I am not eligible to report the fraud because it was published. My knowledge of the fraud comes not from inside information, but from reading about it in The New York Times.

Original Information: An individual must provide, in writing, original information, meaning:

  1. Information that is derived from the individual’s independent knowledge or independent analysis.
    1. Independent knowledge means factual information in the individual’s possession that is not derived from publicly available sources. The individual may gain independent knowledge from their experiences, communications, and observations in their business or social interactions.
    2. Independent analysis means the individual’s own analysis, whether done alone or in combination with others. Analysis means the individual’s examination and evaluation of information that may be publicly available, but which reveals information that is not generally known or available to the public.

In conclusion, I can’t report the fraud because I read about it in the newspaper and it was committed by the DHS.

Adam Kinzinger, former member of Congress, writes powerfully here about the most dangerous threat to our democracy: the super-rich who fund politicians to buy government contracts and/or to determine policy decisions.

Kinzinger was a Republican Congressman from Illinois and a military veteran. He and Liz Cheney were the only Republican members of the January 6 Commission. They knew they would pay a price. Cheney lost her Congressional seat in Wyoming to a Trump-aligned conservative. Kinzinger retired from Congress.

He writes here about the importance of limiting the power of wealthy individuals in politics.

Both parties are susceptible to the lure of big campaign contributions. Democrats and Republicans have accepted money from AIPAC to shape government policy toward Israel.

Trump openly courted specific industries to give money to his campaign in exchange for favorable policies. He promised to protect the fossil fuel industry if they gave significant sums to his campaign. As president, he has delivered. He opened protected federal lands to drilling and has canceled government contracts for wind power and other alternative sources of energy. He has encouraged the revival of coal mining. He has gutted environmental regulations to allow pollution of water and the air. A payback to his donors.

And then there is the case of Elon Musk. He has become the richest man in the world with the help of munificent government contracts. In the past few years, he has deployed his riches to try to buy the government and its policies.

Adam Kinzinger details here the case for getting big money out of politics, or at least limiting its power to buy the government it wants.

He writes:

Last Wednesday, the richest man in the world logged on to the social media platform he owns and issued an ominous threat.

“Live by the sword, die by the sword,” Elon Musk wrote. “Those who pick fights with me should understand that I will find out who is really pulling the strings and come for them, not just their puppets…”

What set him off was a story in Politico reporting that if Democrats win control of Congress next week, they plan to investigate him: his time running DOGE, the federal contracts his companies hold, and reports that he ordered Starlink service slowed for Ukraine’s military. When journalist Kara Swisher suggested on her podcast that he could end up facing legal trouble, he shot back that she “really wants to go to prison.”

To recap, a man whose company is paid billions of dollars by the federal government is warning members of Congress that if they look into how he got that money, he will come after them, and after whoever he decides is behind them.

And he isn’t just posting. He’s paying.

The Wall Street Journal captured it in a single chart. One line belongs to George Soros, the liberal megadonor who has spent the better part of two decades as the right’s favorite villain. It climbs slowly, step by step, over more than twenty years, to roughly $624 million. The other line belongs to Musk. For twenty years, it sits flat at zero. Then, around 2024, it turns and shoots almost straight up, past Soros, to roughly $759 million. Two decades of Soros, overtaken in about two years.

Image

Graph courtesy of the Wall Street Journal.

According to a Washington Post analysis of federal filings, Musk has now put about $446 million into this year’s midterm elections alone. That’s the most any individual donor has ever given. It’s well beyond the roughly $290 million he spent electing Donald Trump in 2024. In September, he gave $158 million to the main super PAC backing Republican Senate candidates in just two checks. He’s put another $10 million into a group backing Ken Paxton in Texas.

We have never seen anything like this. And we absolutely should not accept it.

Money has distorted American politics for a long time, and both parties have their megadonors. I spent years in Congress watching how much time members spent dialing for dollars instead of doing their jobs, and how much influence followed the checks. If you’ve ever felt like Washington listens more to the people with money than to people like you, you’re not imagining it. That’s why broad campaign finance reform is needed.

I also believe companies and the people who run them have a right to take part in our political process. That’s part of living in a free country. This column isn’t about that.

This is about something different, and it’s much more dangerous.

Buying the Government That Pays You

Elon Musk isn’t just the richest man in the world. He got there, in large part, with the help of the American taxpayer. SpaceX has received more than $20 billion in federal contracts, with NASA and the Pentagon among its biggest customers. Starlink has become essential infrastructure for our military and our allies. His companies depend on decisions made by the very government he’s now spending hundreds of millions of dollars to shape.

Think about what that means. The man whose company is paid billions by the federal government is spending a fortune to decide who runs the federal government. The senators he helps elect will vote on defense budgets that include his contracts. The agencies that regulate his companies answer to the president he helped put in office. Even if every one of those decisions were made in good faith, how could anyone know?

Here’s the part most people don’t realize: we already decided, decades ago, that this kind of thing is wrong.

For more than 75 years, federal law has barred government contractors from making political contributions. The whole point is to avoid even the appearance that taxpayer-funded contracts are for sale. Courts have upheld that ban even as they’ve struck down other campaign finance laws. Regulators have enforced it against contractors who tried to give to super PACs.

So how is Musk allowed to do this? Because of a loophole. The ban covers the company holding the contract, and federal regulators read it narrowly. In their view, Musk’s spending doesn’t count, because it comes from him as an individual rather than from SpaceX or Tesla. The company can’t spend a dime.

But the man who controls the company can spend nearly half a billion dollars in a single election.

Sell to It or Buy It. Not Both.

I support sweeping campaign finance reform. But the fix for this particular problem isn’t radical, and we don’t have to start from scratch because some states already do it.

New Jersey has a pay-to-play law that doesn’t stop at the company holding the contract. It covers the company’s principal owners, officers, and directors, and anyone who controls 10 percent or more of the business.

Connecticut goes further, covering any shareholder with a stake of 5 percent or more.

Both laws were passed after real scandals, by legislators who saw what happens when contracts and campaign cash get tangled together. And they’ve worked. New Jersey’s own election watchdog said its law was achieving exactly what it was meant to do: reducing political contributions from the people doing business with the government.

Congress should do the same thing at the federal level. Extend the existing contractor ban to cover the owners, executives, and major shareholders of companies that take big federal contracts. Apply it to everyone, on the left and the right, no matter which party they support.

Nobody needs to take anything away from Elon Musk. This is just a very reasonable choice: if you want to keep selling to the United States government, you don’t get to buy it too. If you’d rather spend unlimited money on elections, you’re free to stop bidding on taxpayer contracts.

Pick one.

What Money Can’t Buy

Elon Musk can buy a lot of things. He can buy television ads in every market in America. He can buy a social media platform and tilt it toward the candidates he likes. He can fund a get-out-the-vote operation bigger than some political parties.

What he can’t buy is your vote. Not unless you let him.

A week from now, Americans will decide this election, not Elon Musk. Every ad he pays for still has to convince a person. Every dollar he spends still has to get past the voter in the booth. That’s the one place in American democracy where the richest man in the world and a retired schoolteacher in Ohio count exactly the same.

So show up. Bring someone with you. And then let’s get to work making sure that no one, no matter how rich, can ever again buy the government that pays them.

— Adam