The U.S. Supreme Court ruled against the Trump administration and its cancellation of grants and contracts that refer to “diversity, equity, and inclusion.” Most of those actions occurred during the reign of terror conducted by Elon Musk’s “Department of Government Efficiency.”

Bloomberg News reported:

The US Supreme Court dealt President Donald Trump a setback in his drive to cancel billions of dollars in federal grants, leaving intact a ruling that the administration was probably acting illegally by targeting research projects he said were “DEI programs.”

With no noted dissents on Monday, the justices rejected an appeal by the administration in a clash with faculty members and researchers at the University of California.

The rebuff keeps in place a federal appeals court ruling that for now requires the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities to continue funding $59 million in grants. The appeals court said Trump probably violated the Constitution’s free speech clause by discriminating against the grantees because of their viewpoints.

More broadly, the high court’s sidestepping of the case leaves unanswered questions about a controversy that raged during Trump’s first months in office last year. Trump directed agencies to terminate grants that involved diversity, equity and inclusion, as well as “gender ideology” and “environmental justice.” Universities and researchers say the blitz of terminations upended cutting-edge studies in science, medicine and other areas…

Much of the grant cancellation occurred under the direction of the Department of Government Efficiency, the Elon Musk-led effort that tore through the federal government last year, firing workers, dismantling agencies and canceling billions of dollars in spending. DOGE, as the office is known, claimed to have canceled $110 billion in grants and contracts, though the actual savings to the government might have been far less than that.

The administration drew criticism for the wholesale, and in at least some cases erratic, nature of the terminations. The New York Times reported  in March that DOGE officials relied on ChatGPT to select which National Endowment for the Humanities grants to target.

In the University of California case, the researchers faulted the administration for relying on keywords, including “diversity,” to determine which grants were problematic. They say the approach scooped in projects with titles mentioning “Leaf Diversity” and “Diversity Within the Legume Rhizobia Mutualism.”

The case was filed by University of California professors whose federal grants were terminated.

The LA Times reported:

The Supreme Court refused Monday to hear an appeal from President Trump and cut off research grants to University of California professors that promote diversity, equity and inclusion.

Without a comment or dissent, the justices turned down the administration’s appeal and let stand a 9th Circuit Court ruling that held the cutoff of these research grants violated the 1st Amendment.

The court’s action is a significant win for the embattled professors and a defeat for Trump.
At issue in the appeal was whether the administration’s plan could cut off about $150 million in UC research grants that were awarded by the National Endowment for Humanities and the National Science Foundation. It was a small part of a larger fight nationwide that could affect several billion dollars in government grants.

Six UC professors filed a class-action suit to challenge the terminations. They cited constitutional claims including due process of law as well as a violation of government procedures.

But the Supreme Court narrowed the claims in different and much larger cases involving health and education grants. It said claims for canceled grants must go to the Court of Federal Claims and cannot be overturned by a federal judge.
Citing those decisions, the 9th Circuit Court in May limited the UC case to a 1st Amendment claim.

The government may not use “its power to punish or suppress disfavored expression,” the appeals court said.

Its judges agreed the government may choose to fund some programs and not others, but they said officials may not discriminate against qualified grant recipients because of their viewpoint.

The New York Times Magazine published an in-depth story about the experiences of some of Jeffrey Epstein’s teenage victims. The story, by Jen Percy, is a powerful, heart-wrenching account of what happened to several teenagers who were sexually abused and raped by Epstein. This is a gift article; you can read it without a subscription.

The focus of the story is how Epstein persuaded the girls to bring him their friends. He used them to increase the number of girls whom he raped. When girls got too “old,” say 17 or 18, or when he tired of them, he dismissed them.

The central character in the story is Marina, who was 13 when she first went to Epstein’s mansion to give him a “massage.” The massage was a prelude to sexual activity and rape.

Like the other girls in the story, Marina needed money. She had been raped and assaulted by her mother’s boyfriend. Her home situation was desperate. Epstein paid her $300 to massage him, and an extra $300 for every new girl she brought to him.

Think of it: a 13-year-old child was taking a taxi from Queens to East 71 Street in Manhattan (which Epstein paid for) and collecting $300 to join Epstein’s pedophile games. She brought her friends, and eventually they brought their friends.

Why is the Justice Department refusing to release the balance of the Epstein files? Why do the Republican majorities in both current houses of Congress refuse to demand their release? Why have they forgotten about the legislation they passed last year requiring the Justice Department to release ALL the files? Why are the files already released so heavily redacted, blotting out the names of the men who shared teenage girls with Epstein?

Epstein was a sex maniac and a pedophile. Why are Republicans blocking access to the names of the powerful men who shared the girls he recruited?

The CEO and founder of Nvidia lost his job because he had extramarital affairs with consenting adults. Why has no one in the Epstein files in this country been exposed and held accountable for pedophilia?

Former Governor Glenn Youngkin of Virginia was proud that his state was first to join the federal voucher program created by the Trump administration. But he took only the first step, not the mandatory second step. When Democratic Governor Abigail Spanberger learned about Youngkin’s error, she withdrew Virginia’s application.

The federal voucher program is designed to subsidize children in religious and other private schools. Public schools are allowed to seek subsidies for miscellany like after-school tutoring, but that’s a pittance compared to the subsidies for non-public school tuition.

The Washington Post reported:

Despite months of former governor Glenn Youngkin (R) touting his decision to enroll Virginia in a new federal school voucher program, a recent letter from the IRS revealed that his administration did not complete the process, according to documents reviewed by The Washington Post, and his successor will reverse Youngkin’s decision.

Gov. Abigail Spanberger (D) will not finish the process to join the initiative, a spokesperson for her office told The Post in a statement.
The letter, which was sent by IRS acting chief counsel Kevin Salinger to Spanberger’s office in late October and has not been previously reported, said Virginia did not complete a mandatory second step to enroll in the program because a portal to submit a list of scholarship-granting organizations was not available at the time Youngkin’s administration started the process.

“As made clear by the IRS, former Governor Youngkin — whose endeavors since leaving office include touting the Commonwealth’s involvement in this federal program — did not actually enter Virginia into the program,” the spokesperson for Spanberger told The Post. “The Spanberger Administration, at this point, does not believe this program would benefit students in public schools, and the Commonwealth will not be participating this year.

“The program, which will become the nation’s first federally funded school voucher program when it launches in full in 2027, was created by last year’s Republican tax and spending bill. It is poised to direct billions of tax dollars to private schools and, perhaps, to public school students.

The program is intended to provide a dollar-for-dollar credit for donations to scholarship-granting organizations, or SGOs. Those organizations will then pass along the money to eligible families, who can use the cash to pay for tuition and other school-related costs.

Taxpayers can get all the money they donated back as a credit when they file their federal taxes — up to $1,700 for individuals and $3,400 for married couples.

The Congressional Budget Office estimated that the program will cost the federal government $26 billion over 10 years.

The program was designed to primarily benefit students attending private schools, but SGOs may also be set up to help pay out-of-pocket expenses for public school students, such as tutoring and school supplies, which has complicated the politics for some Democrats, who generally oppose voucher programs.

The federal voucher program is designed to legitimize vouchers and to siphon students away from public schools,

Governor Spanberger said, “No, thank you.”

I wrote about Emily Hanford’s “Sold a Story 2” last week. Her first season (“Sold a Story”) was devoted to the assertion that reading teachers have been deceived and have failed to learn that phonics is the one best way to teach reading. I am a proponent of phonics but firmly believe that states should not mandate how to teach. I do not believe in a “science of reading” or a science of any other subject. There are many ways to be a good teacher, not a single method.

In season 2, Hanford discovers “Direct Instruction” and again asserts that teachers have been deceived by the education establishment, which (she says) prefers unscripted, loosey-goosey, “discovery” methods.

Hanford shows her hand in Episode 6 of the second season. She chooses to highlight the use of Direct Instruction at Baker Mitchell’s four-school charter chain in North Carolina. More than a decade ago, I wrote about Baker Mitchell and his charter chain (Roger Bacon Academy) as a prime example of profiteering and conflict of interest in charter world. It’s a strange choice for an exemplar.

Baker Mitchell operates his charters for profit and has collected millions of dollars from them. He is paid 16% of their revenues to manage them. He owns a separate for-profit company (Coastal Habitat Conservancy) to collect rent on land and buildings and sell supplies to the schools. Another Mitchell company sells school uniforms. He is an entrepreneur, not an educator. When the Tea Party won control of North Carolina in 2010, the hard-right Republicans in the state legislature passed a charter law in June 2011, and Baker Mitchell saw a business opportunity.

But! Hanford admired the fact that these charters used DI.

At this point, I am going to post part of the online discussion between Trevor Aleo and Nick Covington about “Sold a Story 2.”

They begin by writing: “‘Obedient and Loyal to Those in Authority”: The Charter Network Hanford Hoped You Wouldn’t Google.'”

I hope you are intrigued enough to read their commentary in full.

I am posting only the beginning.

Nick: I think I’ve been even-handed in my criticism of this season, so I ask forgiveness for the heel turn I’m about to make: Emily Hanford is lying to you and thinks you’re gullible. That’s my takeaway from Episode 6 after the most cursory Google search for Baker Mitchell, the charter school founder at the center of this week’s narrative. I can’t focus on anything else. The way Hanford frames Baker Mitchell and his charter school network—and what she omits to make it work in her favor—is the story, and all of my energy today has gone into bringing that to our readers.

Trevor: This was definitely the mask off episode of the season. I noted in our previous episode that Hanford at least attempted to hide the ideological underpinnings guiding the Sold A Story project, but this week we went from subtext to text in a fairly jarring manner. This episode was basically a really bad infomercial about charter schools from 2008. I joked last week that Hanford’s arguments were so recycled that it seems like she spent the last 20 years in a cryogenic chamber. After this week, I’m actually concerned it’s true. Maybe the American Enterprise Institute keeps her on ice when she isn’t podcasting on their behalf?

What Hanford Doesn’t Tell You About Baker Mitchell

Nick: Episode 6 opens innocuously enough, “Baker Mitchell is an engineer. He loves science. He was hoping his children would too,” followed by an interview clip of Mitchell talking about instilling a love of science for his own children, all of which led him to found a school. “That one school has become four,” Hanford says, “A group of charter schools in and around the city of Wilmington, North Carolina named for Roger Bacon, the 13th century scholar who helped develop the scientific method.” Much of the episode focuses on the experience of teachers, students, and parents at Roger Bacon Academy schools, emphasizing the call-and-response aspect of Direct Instruction.

About halfway through the episode, though, Hanford pauses, “A note: there has been controversy surrounding the Roger Bacon schools for reasons that have nothing to do with Direct Instruction — including a high-profile lawsuit about their dress code by the ACLU,” before picking the thread right back up, “We visited the Roger Bacon schools because Direct Instruction has lasted for 26 years…” Hold up. Controversy, dress code, and the ACLU? I wonder what’s going on there that Hanford felt it needed mention withoutelaboration? How has Direct Instruction survived for so long here where it hasn’t elsewhere? Here’s where a Google search undoes the narrative.

Baker Mitchell was an engineer, but he was also an entrepreneur. According to his CV, Mitchell built a successful computer software company and sold it off in 1989. He then spent the next decade writing courses and volunteer teaching before moving to North Carolina and opening The Roger Bacon Academy in 1999. Today there is no single school of Mitchell’s called Roger Bacon Academy. What Hanford describes as “a group of [four] charter schools in and around the city of Wilmington” are actually branded Classical Charter Schools of America and managed by Mitchell’s for-profit Roger Bacon Academy, Inc. Yet neither the classical charter brand nor the for-profit status show up anywhere in the episode.

In 2014, ProPublica investigated how Mitchell’s operation works. The schools themselves may be non-profits, but the non-profit school board hired the for-profit Roger Bacon Academy to manage them, with Baker Mitchell on both sides of the transaction. In other words, Mitchell hired himself, an arrangement ProPublica points out “is illegal in many other states.” He then sold or leased the schools nearly everything they needed—from desks, computers, and teacher training to the land and buildings themselves—with no competitive bidding. As early as 2001, the IRS denied the group’s application for tax-exemption and documented what they called “a clear conflict of interest” in Mitchell controlling the management company and the schools buying its services. That didn’t prevent him from taking $20 million in management fees and rent from just the first six years of his first two schools. None of Mitchell’s apparent self-dealing appears in the episode.

Trevor: But, Nick! Can you really put a price on children’s ability to retrieve knowledge from their long term memory? Caring about rampant self dealing, fraud, and corruption is so education establishment coded. Who taught you to care about that stuff? John Dewey? Jean-Jacques Rousseau? Good teaching isn’t political!

Nick: Funny you mention that, Trevor—Mitchell was also a political activist, putting his thumb on the scale of state policy in his favor. In 2011, the North Carolina state legislature raised the cap on charter schools and put Mitchell on the Charter School Advisory Council, whose job it was to review new charter applications. As the ProPublica piece documents, Mitchell’s schools suddenly benefitted from a number of “unusual” exemptions and exceptions. In 2013, Mitchell used his influence to push for new charter school regulations that loosened teacher certification rules and gave property managers like himself tax-breaks for leasing to charter schools. He eventually resigned from the state’s Charter School Advisory Board in 2014 after being dogged by questions about his impartiality and conflicts of interest. That Mitchell saw his education work as deeply political is mentioned nowhere in the episode, and that’s before we even get to the curriculum.

Classical Charter Schools

Nick: If you’re curious about the bit in the episode with middle-schoolers naming Roman emperors and taking Latin, that comes from the classical charter school angle, which “teaches a classical curriculum espousing the values of traditional western civilization.” That’s left out of the episode, along with the School Pledge taken directly from the 2026-2027 Parent and Student Handbook, which includes vows to guard against “the stains of falsehood from the fascination with experts…and the over-reliance on rational argument.” Bit of tension there for a podcast series about evidence-based practices, so I can understand not leading the episode with it, but the School Pledge then closes with this stanza:

I pledge to be obedient and loyal to those in authority

in my family,

in my school, and

in my community and country,

So long as I shall live.

Trevor: It feels like Hanford is making us speed run every bad right-wing education/policy fad from the last 15 years. In addition to all the issues with this particular charter school system, there are so many issues with the broader classical school movement that I feel like I have to start in the historical weeds and work my way back from there.

First of all, the idea that “the West” is an unbroken chain stretching from ancient Greece through Western Europe and ultimately culminating in a Disneyfied version of American exceptionalism is utter pish. The Western tradition is not some sacred heirloom of Christendom. The idea that Europe can “claim” Greece’s intellectual legacy as its property attempts to project modern borders onto ancient history as though they are timeless and static cultural boundaries. What these classical charter schools call “the Western tradition” was shaped by centuries of intellectual exchange across Europe, North Africa, and the Arabic-speaking world—not within a self-contained cultural space called “the West.” In fact, much of the Greek philosophy that helped transform medieval Europe, including the Trivium referenced in the CCSA materials above, reached Latin readers through Arabic-language scholarship and translation networks linking the Islamic world with Iberia and Siciliy. The Muslim and Jewish cultures and scholars (not just the Christian ones!) who kept this knowledge alive did not simply pass along an untouched Athenian inheritance; they translated, interpreted, challenged, extended, and generally enriched it.

This is not a purely pedantic point about historical accuracy. It proves that people like Mitchell know nothing of the history that they seek to venerate. They are either wholly cynical, treating the good, beautiful, and true as marketing buzzwords for CCSA promotional materials, or they are embarrassingly dim, eschewing the complex texture of history for smooth brained fairytales to reinforce their political priors. Either way, their celebration of “the West” is not born out of intellectual curiosity, a desire to live a more fully examined life, or even a belief students should engage with powerful ideas from the past. The entire project is just reactionary politics cosplaying the life of the mind. Nevermind the fact that it’s hard to take grandiose claims of value-based education seriously when, as you’ve already detailed, these schools basically become cash cows for entrepreneurial grifters seeking to better monetize their own liberal arts educations.

Please open the link and finish reading.

Andy Borowitz reviews Friday’s flight grounding. He is, as usual, magnificent!

I wonder whether the FAA cuts imposed by DOGE played a role in this massive malfunction.

Neither Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security, nor Sean Duffy, Secretary of transportation, has relevant experience to run the nation’s air space. Mullin owned a successful plumbing business. Duffy was a television “personality.”

This is what Borowitz posted:

On Friday night, Trump ceded the podium to Beavis and Butthead. (Alex Wong/Getty Images)

On Friday night, as the nation’s worst ground stop since 9/11 stranded millions of Americans, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin declared, “This is what the leadership of President Trump looks like.” 

I couldn’t agree more.

Mullin, Mitch McConnell’s rival-in-sentience, wasn’t alone during Friday night’s clown show. His sidekick was Transportation Secretary-slash-startled-deer Sean Duffy, a former cast member of MTV’s “The Real World.” At the White House podium, he demonstrated why he was the least qualified person to manage an emergency since Michael “Heckuva Job, Brownie” Brown bungled the response to Hurricane Katrina.

Rather than dispense information that might help the throngs of desperate passengers forced to eat at their concourse’s mobbed Sbarro, he went on a whingeing rant about Congress’s refusal to appropriate the funds necessary to update FAA systems, which apparently run on dial-up modems and AOL free trial disks.

For a reality-show veteran, Duffy appeared shockingly divorced from reality. 

When he complained about “Congress,” he neglected to note that Republicans have controlled both its houses for the past two years, during which they have done nothing but accede to their demented death-cult leader’s every whim. Furthermore, Trump’s supposed obsession with the FAA’s infrastructure was somewhat undercut by his decision to cede the White House podium Friday night to his Cabinet’s version of Beavis and Butthead. (I’ll leave it to MTV veteran Duffy to determine which one he is.)

Has the woeful state of the nation’s aviation systems really been keeping Trump up at night? Apparently not so much as America’s desperate need for an army of masked thugs to shoot innocent people on the street. The approximately $115 billion Congress has shoveled into the ICE dumpster fire is more than double what it would take to transform the FAA’s infrastructure into something befitting a first-world country.

How has Trump actually demonstrated his deep concern about air safety? On January 21, 2025—his second day in office—he fired the entire membership of the Aviation Security Advisory Committee. 

You might wonder why he thought eliminating people who keep the skies safe was a good idea. To the extent that Donald Trump has thoughts, they’re not original. His anti-immigrant rhetoric, for example, owes a debt to a prominent German political leader of the 1930s and 40s. And his decision to axe air safety advisors calls to mind the wrecking ball that Ronald Reagan wielded on August 5, 1981, when he fired 11,345 air traffic controllers in one fell swoop.

For decades, anti-union Republicans have hailed Reagan’s draconian response to the strike by members of the Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization (PATCO) as the beginning of the end of the American labor movement. But it was also the beginning of a crisis in air safety.

Ronald Reagan fired almost all of the nation’s air traffic controllers in a single day. What could possibly go wrong? (Photo: Dirck Halstead/Getty Images)

Joseph A. McCartin, a Georgetown professor and author of Collision Course: Ronald Reagan, the Air Traffic Controllers, and the Strike That Changed America, writes, “Reagan’s decision to ban all strikers meant that it took years for the system to come back to its prestrike staffing levels.” That system is still reeling.

According to a 2023 report, “Ensuring adequate staffing and training for air traffic controllers—an essential part of maintaining the safety and efficiency of the National Airspace System (NAS)—has been a challenge for the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), especially at the Nation’s most critical facilities.”

Who issued this alarming report? The U.S. Department of Transportation’s Office of Inspector General. In the first Friday of his second term, Trump purged over a dozen Inspectors General in an overnight massacre. The Department of Transportation’s Inspector General was among them.

Heckuva job, Trumpy.

In the recent election, there were many inspiring stories of candidates who challenged the status quo and won. One of those stories is the triumph of Gina Hinojosa over Texas Governor Greg Abbott. Abbott had a huge war chest and the support of several billionaires, including Elon Musk.

The polls were not encouraging to Hinojosa. At best, the polls showed her within striking distance of Abbott. The pundits and pollsters took James Talarico seriously, but not Hinojosa. They didn’t think she had a chance.

But when all the votes were counted, Hinojosa beat Abbott by 7 points. Literally no one expected that.

Best of all, Hinojosa made public schools the centerpiece of her campaign. Wouldn’t it be great if other Democratic candidates noticed the power of that issue?

I can’t help wondering: would David Jolley have won the Governor’s race in Florida if he had put the Republican attack on public schools at the center of his campaign? Would Democrats in other states have captured the governor’s seat had they run as champions of the people’s schools and critics of the privatizers? Obviously, we can’t know, but those planning to run in 2028 should study Gina Hinojosa’s central message: Fighting for public schools is a winning issue.

Do you want to know what she said before she declared that she was running for Governor? In 2025, she was a keynote speaker at the conference of the Network for Public Education in Columbus, Ohio. If you want to know Gina, watch her speak to a room full of friends. This was before Governor Abbott dragged his odious voucher plan across the finish line.

Clearly, the public did not like what Abbott had done, which imperiled their schools and their communities.

Julian Vasquez-Heilig recently wrote about Gina Hinojosa’s improbable rise. It is an inspiring story.

Fourteen years ago, Gina Hinojosa was a mother fighting to save her son’s elementary school. Today, she is preparing to govern Texas. Sometimes the most extraordinary political journeys begin with something as ordinary, and as powerful, as a mother’s love.

In 2011, facing severe budget pressures compounded by inadequate state funding, the Austin Independent School District identified historic Pease Elementary as a potential closure. Imagine discovering that the place where your child was learning to read, making friends, and beginning to imagine his future might disappear because officials needed to reduce expenses. Imagine being told that the decision came down to budgets and efficiency, as though a spreadsheet could measure what a neighborhood school means to the families who love it.

Gina could have complained, signed a petition, and hoped somebody would listen. Instead, she organized with other parents, ran for the Austin school board in 2012, and won. Fourteen years later, that same mother is the governor-elect of Texas, having defeated Greg Abbott despite being dramatically outspent 8-1. The woman who once fought to protect her son’s school now has an opportunity to influence the education of approximately 5.5 million Texas public school students.

In 2016, Gina was elected to the Texas House of Representatives, where she was repeatedly re-elected.

Again, to quote Julian Vasquez-Heilig:

There is something extraordinary about that progression. Gina did not begin with a grand ambition to govern millions of people. She began with one school, one neighborhood, and parents afraid of losing something precious. Her responsibilities expanded from one district to the Legislature and now to the governor’s office. The very education policies that compelled her to challenge the status quo ultimately set her on a path to lead the state that created them, and gave her the opportunity to change them…

Gina Hinojosa’s extraordinary journey began with a fight to save her son’s elementary school and carried her all the way to the governor’s mansion. The very education policies that inspired her to challenge the system helped create the leader who now has an opportunity to transform it. Let Texas stop making headlines for fighting over education and start making history for improving it. And when future generations ask how it all began, let us tell them about a mother who stood up when her child’s school was threatened, who refused to be silenced, and who discovered that the love of a parent could become the beginning of something much greater.

Andy Spears is a veteran education journalist from Tennessee. He writes now on a Substack blog where he covers more states than Tennessee, but continues to be an authoritative voice about his own state.

In this post, he describes what to expect from the newly elected governor, Marsha Blackburn. “She is no fan of public education,” he says. She is a hard-right politician in the Trump mold.

Among her big donors were two billionaires who are avid supporters of privatization: Jeff Yass of Pennsylvania and the Walton family. Yass gave millions to Texas Governor Greg Abbott to use on behalf of passing voucher legislation (Abbott used it to whup moderate Republicans in the Legislature who opposed vouchers). The Walton/Walmart family has been the single largest donor to charter schools (other than the federal government).

Spears writes:

U.S. Senator Marsha Blackburn narrowly won the race to become Tennessee’s next Governor. She earned 45.5% of the vote to Democrat Jerri Green’s 43%. 

Now, Blackburn begins the process of setting up a transition team and installing the leaders who will shape her Administration. 

What will she do on public schools? 

The short answer: She is 100% supportive of the GOP agenda over the past 15 years. An agenda that has led Tennessee to last place in the nation in investment in schools. An agenda that means there’s now a $300 million private school discount coupon program. An agenda that leaves teachers behind. 

In her first interview after winning, Blackburn said she plans to set up a Tennessee DOGE. You’ll recall DOGE was set up under Elon Musk at the federal level and decimated a number of programs – including essentially wiping out US AID. The cuts to US AID are responsible for more than 700,000 deaths in the countries that used to rely on the U.S. for assistance with hunger, HIV/AIDS relief, and more.

I’m not excited about a DOGE-style round of cuts to Tennessee’s government. 

And her insistence on marching in lockstep with Trump means she’s likely to look for ways to further tear down public schools. 

Blackburn’s top financial backer was a Pennsylvania billionaire who loves school vouchers. 

School Voucher Advocate is Largest Single Donor in Tennessee Gov's Race

School Voucher Advocate is Largest Single Donor in Tennessee Gov’s Race

·JUN 20Read full story

Now, Yass is taking sides in the race to replace Lee. Yass is the largest single contributor in the gubernatorial race, giving $1 million to a political action committee (PAC) supporting Marsha Blackburn, according to Tennessee Lookout.

Blackburn also received support from a billionaire heir to the Walmart family fortune – yes, another backer of school vouchers.

Billionaire Walmart Heir Jumps on Blackburn Bandwagon

Billionaire Walmart Heir Jumps on Blackburn Bandwagon

ANDY SPEARS

The youngest son of Walmart founder Sam Walton is now on the Marsha Blackburn bandwagon.

The latest campaign financial reportindicates that pro-Blackburn Team Tennessee PAC received $100,000 from Walton in the last reporting period.

In public statements, Blackburn has pledged to further obligate taxpayers to school vouchers – adding additional money to the voucher program. 

Keep in mind, Tennessee students currently accepting vouchers score an average of 20 points BEHIND their public school counterparts. But thanks to Bill Lee and the GOP-controlled General Assembly, the state will no longer track the performance of students receiving vouchers. 

Stephen Dyer has tracked charter schools over the years and knows their problems better than anyone else. They are very costly. Many have very low performance. They have enabled scandals and corruption due to lax oversight.

In this post, he presents his ideas about why charter legislation must change:

Yesterday, I discussed how Tuesday’s election results here and in Texas, as well as the political fallout therefrom will almost certainly result in the death knell for the ~ $1 billion EdChoice voucher program.

Today, it’s the Charter School program, which costs Ohio taxpayers 50 percent more than EdChoice annually. About $20 billion in total since 1998.

I’ve gone through this carnival of horrors many times, but let’s deal with the topline issues with Ohio’s Charter Schools.

  1. They receive 2 out of every 3 of failing grades on the most recent state report card
  2. More than 1 in 3 are on the state’s lowest-performing building list.
  3. More than 9 in 10 “Dropout Recovery” charters are on the list.
  4. About 1 in 5 charters have been on the list since 2018.
  5. More than 1 in 2 charter schools that have ever opened in Ohio are now closed.
  6. They received more than 1/2 of all F grades ever given to schools on Ohio’s Report Card, despite representing about 10% of all Ohio school buildings.
  7. They spend almost double the share of their funding on non-instructional administrators that Ohio’s traditional public schools spend.
  8. They receive more than double the state funding that a traditional Ohio public school student receives.
  9. They spend more, on average, per pupil than a traditional Ohio Public School District, even though charters can’t collect local revenue (except for a handful in Cleveland).
  10. They produced the single largest taxpayer ripoff scam in Ohio history, largely enabled by Sen. Jon Husted, and are constantly being busted for fraud and other corrupt practices.
  11. Charter School students are about 7 percent of the state’s school population, but receive 12 percent of the state’s funding for schools.
  12. That funding (along with EdChoice vouchers) is preventing the state from fully funding its own formula to provide resources to the state’s 1.5 million traditional public school students.
  13. More than 1 in 10 Ohio charter schools are on the state’s suspected test cheating list and 7 out of every 10 schools suspected of cheating on their state tests are charter schools.
  14. More than 1 in 4 of the state’s “high performing” charter schools are on the state’s suspected test cheating list.
  15. They have cost charter school graduates between $247 million and $321 million since 2018 and will cost them between $1.8 billion and $6.7 billion over their collective lifetimes.

A LOT to chew on there. But let’s deal with the three major issues overall issues with charters:

  1. They cost too much
  2. They perform too poorly
  3. They are scandal ridden

So how do we deal with each of these issues now? A few thoughts.

Costing too much

The original sin of Ohio Charter Schools is paying them like they cost the same to operate as traditional public schools. Under Ohio’s current Fair School Funding Plan, costs are calculated based on the overall cost of teachers, principals, administrative assistants, superintendents, treasurers, etc. for Ohio’s public school districts.

The issue with Ohio Charter Schools is they pay their people (except for administrators) way less than traditional schools. In fact, according to state data, they pay their teachers about 37 percent less. So just applying that lower teacher salary to the formula to pay Ohio Charter Schools cuts their funding by about $167 million.

Do that for principals, superintendents, treasurers, administrative assistants, etc. and you would realize additional cost savings.

In addition, you should limit their administrative costs to no more than 10 percent more than the average traditional public school. Currently, the average administrative expenditure in traditional public schools is about 13 percent of the overall spend. Limiting charters to just 10 percent more than that would free up another $210 million or so.

And online schools need a drastic reduction in state aid coupled with requirements to provide up-to-date computers and internet links. 

Brick and mortar charters and online schools need their own, separate funding formulas¹. 

Finally, tying per pupil funding for Charter Schools to no greater than what the state would have paid the school district of residence would also limit their funding to something that makes sense. If the state is paying $5,000 for a student to attend the local public school district, why should it pay $12,000 for that same student to attend a poorer performing charter school²?

Poor Performance

Which brings us to performance. 

Look, Ohio Charter School performance has always been pretty damn poor. The state only spent $8 million of the $71 million the state lied the Obama Administration into giving them a decade ago to grow high-quality Charters. Now we’ve got another $100 million in federal money to expand high-performing Charters here, but we have nowhere near that number of high-quality Charters.

So what can be done?

First, we need to immediately close Charters that have performance index scores that rank in the bottom 5 percent of Ohio public school districts³. If districts that score in the bottom 5 percent on Performance Index Score is bad enough to allow Charter Schools to open, certainly it’s fair that Charters who perform no better shouldn’t be operating and continue siphoning money away from kids in traditional public school districts.

Yes, those students would have to return to traditional public schools, but because the state pays so much more for those kids in Charters, there would also be savings when the kids return to the traditional public schools. Depending on how many years you’d want to include the 5 percent cut off⁴, you’d save $50 million to $450 million.

As for where would districts put these kids now? Just do to Charters what’s been done to Districts: Offer their buildings to the Districts that now need to take the kids at low to no cost. 

And no lottery money should be used to fund Charters. 

Like, ever.

Second, we need a much tighter automatic closure law that takes into account all the report card elements, not just cherry picked elements that put charters in the best light. So if a Charter underperforms the school district of residence from which the student is coming on more measures than it outperforms the district, the Charter can’t take the kid.

This is loosely based on a plan that former state Sen. Joe Schiavoni proposed more than a decade ago. Still works.

And if the Charter School does not outperform the lowest performing public school district in the state on more report card measures than it underperforms, it needs to close, regardless of whose kids the school takes. If you want to do this for two consecutive years or something, I’d listen.

Scandal Ridden

The primary issue with Ohio Charter Schools is their oversight is almost non existent. Yeah, they are audited every year, but as then-Auditor Dave Yost proved — that doesn’t mean they’re getting shut down. He gave the state’s highest auditing award to the Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow (ECOT) the same year they were actively ripping off taxpayers to the tune of $120 million plus. 

While more than 1/2 of all Ohio Charter Schools that have ever opened are now closed, only about 2 dozen of those closures were due to the state’s lax automatic closure law. 

In 2015, we tried putting the onus on Charter School Sponsors to take a more active approach to policing Charter School behavior — to great fanfare and hope from me. But that has largely failed because 1/3 of Ohio’s Charter Schools are on the state’s list of worst-performing schools. 

So here’s how to improve accountability and reduce the possibility of another ECOT scandal.

First, we ban for-profit operators from running Ohio Charter Schools. This is something former House Speaker (and current 20-year federal resident) Larry Householder proposed not long ago. Most states do not let private, for-profit companies to run their Charter Schools. Ohio should join them. Eliminating the profit motive should reduce costs as well, as I found back when Householder proposed the idea. For-profit schools spent about $1,200 more per pupil back then.

Second, we require that all charter school sponsors have to be publicly accountable entities. One of the elements that leads to us being deemed the Wild, Wild West of Charter Schools by Charter School advocates is that so many non-profits that have little to do with education run our Charter Schools, including an orphanage and a housing organization. This arrangement is almost unique in the country. 

Requiring Ohio Charter Schools to be run by school districts or the state would ensure more public accountability, as well as create better partnerships between the traditional and charter sectors — partnerships that have been nearly non-existent here as these schools were first and foremost a political, not an education reform project of big Republican campaign donors.

Finally, we need a transparent, KnowYourCharter.com-like state website where people can compare their schools and Charters easily and understandably. Sunshine is the best disinfectant, after all. 

Bottom Line

Doing these things will greatly reduce the taxpayer investment in Charter Schools, but will ensure a better Charter School program. Think quality, not quantity here. 

Would you rather have a huge Charter School program filled mostly with failed operations that cost state taxpayers more than school districts? Or fewer, higher performing schools that complement the traditional schools?

I have often differed with many public school advocates on Charter Schools. I have said they can work in limited circumstances. We have spent $20 billion and 30 years proving that they can’t work here in their current form as a broad-based education solution. 

As Charter School advocate Macke Raymond put it many years ago: Parental Choice has not improved education the way the School Choice advocates thought. 

That doesn’t mean Charter Schools can’t work in some form or fashion here. 

But I think we can all agree that after $20 billion and 30 years, this Charter School form is not working. 

They need to be reined in with the money saved from that re-directed to fully funding the state’s school funding formula and reducing the need and amount of property taxes collected.

It’s time for this program’s GLP-1 treatment.

Slimmer and better.

Our taxpayers and, most importantly, our kids deserve it.

To read the footnotes, open the link.

When Lyndon B. Johnson was President in the late 1960s, opponents of the war in Vietnam used to taunt him with this phrase when he appeared at public events: “Hey, hey, LBJ! How many kids did you kill today?”

These days, the same phrase could be used to describe Robert F. Kennedy Jr, Secretary of Health and Human Services, who has been a “vaccine skeptic” for many years. Now that RFK is the nation’s top public health official, he has pushed to make vaccines voluntary, not mandatory, and sided with parents who seek exemptions for religious or personal reasons.

In the year 2000, the U.S. had officially eliminated measles, due to near universal vaccination of children. Worldwide, the U.S. was considered the gold standard in public health.

With the number of unvaccinated children rising, so is the number of measles cases. See uuuh

The CDC (US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) would normally be leading a national campaign to persuade parents to vaccinate their children and to warn states and communities to strengthen their vaccine mandates for the sake of their children.

But under RFK, every part of the public health agency has experienced large numbers of layoffs and deep budget cuts (in response to Elon Musk’s deeply irresponsible DOGE operation).

RFK has overseen rapid turnover in leadership as well as the imposition of his negative view of vaccines. He has said that vaccines create more problems than they solve. Some parents would hesitate before subjecting their young children to vaccines, if they listened to the nation’s leading public health official.

The CDC has reported 5,182 measles infections, matching a high not seen since 1991, twenty-five years. Eight people have died in the recent outbreak. The U.S. may lose its international reputation as a nation that has eradicated measles.

These are the data from the CDC website:

Key CDC Measles and Vaccine Data (2026)

  • Case Counts & Outbreaks:
    • 5,182 confirmed cases span 47 U.S. jurisdictions (plus 18 cases among international visitors).
    • 43 new outbreaks have been recorded in 2026, with 96% of cases (4,993 out of 5,182) linked to outbreaks.
    • By comparison, there were 2,289 confirmed cases in all of 2025 and 285 in 2024. [1]
  • Vaccination Status of Cases:
    • 96% of reported cases are among individuals who are unvaccinated or have an unknown vaccination status.
    • 2% received one dose of the MMR Vaccine, and 2% received the recommended two doses. [1]
  • Vaccine Effectiveness & Recommendations:
    • One dose of the MMR vaccine is 93% effective against measles; two doses are 97% effective.
    • The CDC recommends two doses: the first at 12 to 15 months of age and the second at 4 to 6 years old. [1]
  • Kindergarten Coverage:
    • During the 2025–26 school year, 92.4% of U.S. kindergartners received the MMR vaccine, down from 95.2% during the 2019–20 school year. [1]

Even its own website demonstrates the importance of vaccinations, for measles and other diseases. Exemptions should be few, very few. Yet the suspiciousness of vaccines and of government advice that was cultivated during COVID is feeding the fears of parents. That must stop. An administration that discourages vaccines cannot claim to be Making America Healthy Again.

1. Map of measles cases: https://share.google/pZQCqJs4MyazkBmw8

Veteran educator Nancy Bailey knows that the “science of reading” movement has promoted a zeal for “direct instruction,” an approach to teaching that relies heavily on scripts. Bailey looks here at the way Emily Hanford’s influential “Sold a Story” has promoted direct instruction and discouraged discovery learning.

She writes:

“Play is often talked about as if it were a relief from serious learning. But for children play is serious learning. Play is really the work of childhood.”

~Fred Rogers, You Are Special: Neighborly Words of Wisdom from Mister Rogers (1995)

Emily Hanford’s Sold a Story 2 is a tribute to Siegfried “Zig” Engelmann, whose Direct Instruction (DI) explicitly teaches scripted lessons, broken into small steps. One problem with this is that Engelmann opposed discovery learning.

His ideas matter, but so does the research of Piaget, Vygotsky, Erikson, and others. Discovery learning through play has been shown to be critical to a child’s growth and development. Children learn well by actively experimenting and problem-solving.

APM reviews why DI did not become mainstream after Project Follow Through, a massive, costly federal government project during the Johnson administration to see which programs helped disadvantaged children. Problems included insufficient funding, a lack of randomization, and biased testing.

Direct instruction may have shown impressive results on certain performance tests, and it may have been rejected because it doesn’t conform to the mainstream view. But its size and problems don’t make it definitive. The High/Scope Perry Preschool Project also appeared to do well.

The report notes that Gene Glass, a well-respected scholar and former president of the American Educational Research Association, disliked Direct Instruction.

I wish Emily would have compared DI and discovery learning. She could have discussed the Perry Preschool Project findings in detail.

The case for discovery learning.

Whatever the results of Project Follow Through, DI hasn’t been missing from public schools. Siegfried Engelmann and colleagues published DI curricula like DISTAR, Reading Mastery, Connecting Math Concepts, and Language for Learning in the 1960s, and McGraw-Hill still publishes them. Many have been used with students considered at high risk and with learning disabilitiesrt . They’re still found in more than 10,000 schoolsworldwide.

Research generally shows that DISTAR doesn’t perform better than traditional basal reader programs, except for progress in word-attack skills (Kudar, 1990). Like many phonics programs, students still lack comprehension skills.

DI was popular with Teach Like a Champion, but concerns surfaced about overcompliance and rigidness often found in charter schools that advertised “no excuses.”

As a resource teacher, I used SRA Corrective Reading and Morphograph Spelling, also co-created by Engelmann, with middle and high school students in the 1980s and 90s. DI can help children with reading difficulties and/or autism, especially with small groups, but students need much more.

Veteran early childhood (PK-3) teacher educator Karl Wheatley, writing for the National Education Policy Center,questions the lack of student choice with DI and self-determination in relation to human motivation, identity formation, internalization of values, and the effects on mental and physical health.

Yes, there are times when direct instruction is useful, but as an all-purpose instructional model, its effectiveness has been vastly overstated, and misunderstood. In a nutshell, the claim that direct, explicit instruction is more effective and more efficient than partial guidance is absolutely true in one way and absolutely false in another way.

Preschoolers learn much but probably don’t need algebra.

One troubling issue about public education today involves the high expectations that often appear beyond a child’s age and development.

In Sold a Story 2 Emily references Engelmann’s teaching preschoolers algebra and notes:

Most kids aren’t taught algebra until they’re in middle school or even high school. But these kids haven’t started elementary school yet.

These kids are in preschool.

Why? Why algebra at this age? Why make children learn faster? It’s cringeworthy to see kindergarten teachers using DI to teach the Science of Reading, sounds and decoding with large groups. Five-year-olds sit on the floor, wiggle, stare at the teacher making commands and seem forced to comply. Precocious children yell out answers, and quieter ones or those with auditory difficulties are lost.

Kindergarten never used to be structured this way. This age group was never expected to enter first grade as readers. When such instruction turns to standards with demanded mastery by all students, how many children fall behind?

The National Association for the Education of Young Children debunked the either or of DI and discovery learning.

…in the face of increased pressure on literacy and mathematics, driven in part by the No Child Left Behind Act and development of the Common Core Standards, policy-makers and some parents are expecting preschool programs to look more like classrooms for older children. They believe direct instruction is the way to meet these expectations.

They considered studies comparing DI and Discovery Learning

…children given direct instruction learned the intended use of the toy. Ultimately, the children in the free-play condition did so, as well. But the children in the exploration groups also discovered additional uses of the toy or its pieces. The authors concluded that this group showed creativity and problem solving skills not necessary in the direct instruction condition.

How many parents use Engelmann’s Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons,to teach early learners and believe their children are lacking because they’re not reading by age three?

The HighScope Perry Preschool Study is worthy of serious consideration, too.

The High Scope Perry Preschool Project involves discovery learning, appeared to score high in the Project Follow Through project and has had interesting long-term results.

According to Schweinhart and Weikart (1993), the High/Scope Perry study used an experimentally designed longitudinal study to show program effects, even decades after the program. They:

  • identified 123 young African American children living in poverty and at risk for school failure.
  • randomly assigned 58 of them to a program group and 65 of them to a no-program group.
  • I
  • collected data on both groups at ages 3 through 11 and then at age 14, 15, 19, and 27
  • after each phase of data collection they analyzed the data and wrote project reports.

They called the Perry Preschool Study a landmark study claiming it established the lasting human and financial value of early childhood education and led to the establishment of the HighScope Educational Research Foundation.

In Perry — Through Age 40 we learn:

The longitudinal study found that at age 40, participants who experienced the preschool program:

  • Were less likely to experience teenage pregnancy
  • Were more likely to graduate from high school
  • Were more likely to maintain employment and have higher earnings
  • Were less likely to commit crimes
  • Were more likely to own a home and a car

If you’re not aware of the High Scope Perry Preschool, find the book Educating Young Children through the High/Scope Educational Research Foundation. It’s filled with the kinds of activities where professional teachers plan and guide small groups of children in play-based and unstructured play. Students are active participants in learning. The results continue to be promising.

Educating Young Children should be a resource for any preschool. DI shouldn’t replace discovery learning. Some DI might be helpful to students who need lessons broken down.

DI should be able to co-exist with discovery learning. Promoting DI as the only way to teach is strangely deceptive. Teaching and learning are much more than scripted instruction and discovery learning is critical to child development.

References 

Kuder, S. J. (1990). Effectiveness of the DISTAR Reading Program for Children with Learning Disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23(1), 69–71. https://doi.org/10.1177/002221949002300114

Schweinhart, L. J., & Weikart, D. P. (1993). Success by Empowerment: The High/Scope Perry Preschool Study Through Age 27. Young Children, 49(1), 54–58.