David French is an opinion columnist for The New York Times. He has a background as a military lawyer; he served in combat in Iraq. He wrote for The National Review. He is conservative in his politics. He contends in this article that Pete Hegseth should be impeached for his role in the Iran war.

He writes:

Pete Hegseth has violated federal law, he’s violated the laws of war, he’s violated the Constitution, and he should be impeached, convicted, removed from power and barred from serving in federal office ever again.

Sadly, however, the first effort to impeach Hegseth has failed, at least for now. The lame duck Republican-controlled Congress voted 211 to 204 to essentially kill impeachment by referring the charges to a committee, where it will undoubtedly die — unless Democrats revive the effort in 2027.

They should. Impeaching Hegseth isn’t a matter of retribution or vengeance. It’s about imposing accountability for an unconstitutional war. But even more is at stake — impeaching and convicting Hegseth would help restore the primacy of Congress in the American government.

Last month, I wrote that Hegseth should be impeached, and in response I received a number of messages asking a fair question, even from people who very much oppose the Trump administration and Hegseth’s actions as secretary of defense: Why Hegseth in particular? What are the high crimes and misdemeanors he’s guilty of that require his removal?

Let me answer that question in detail.

As a starting point, we’ll turn to the failed resolution filed by Thomas Massie, the eccentric outgoing Republican representative from Kentucky. It contains eight separate charges against Hegseth.

The first three are directly related to the decision to wage the Iran war, accusing Hegseth of attacking Iran without congressional authorization, continuing the war after Congress voted to terminate hostilities and still fighting the war after the 60-day expiration period defined by the War Powers Resolution, a 1973 act of Congress that was supposed to sharply limit the president’s ability to wage war unilaterally.

Two charges are directly related to Hegseth’s conduct of hostilities, accusing him of ignoring laws that are designed to minimize civilian casualties and engaging in extrajudicial killings in his lethal campaign against suspected drug traffickers in the Caribbean and the Pacific.

Massie’s resolution also accuses Hegseth of violating the free speech rights of Senator Mark Kelly (a retired Navy pilot and former astronaut) by attempting to punish Kelly for making a video with several other Democratic lawmakers that said service members had a duty to defy unlawful orders.

The final two charges accuse Hegseth of kidnapping Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores of Venezuela and of waging war against the Houthis in Yemen without congressional authorization.

I want to focus on what are, in my view, the three most important charges: the claims that Hegseth defied the War Powers Resolution in the decision to attack Iran and wage protracted war against Iran.

But first, it’s important to state (or restate) that impeachment is a political remedy for misconduct in office. It is not a criminal trial. It does not require proof beyond a reasonable doubt that an executive branch official committed a felony to merit impeachment or conviction.

High crimes and misdemeanors are whatever Congress says they are, but that does not mean that Congress should exercise unbounded authority and use impeachment as a means of targeting political enemies.

If Congress is going to impeach and convict a member of the cabinet, it is prudent to do so for concrete, obvious violations of federal law or other forms of extreme misconduct. And there are few abuses of power more extreme than waging war in defiance of the Constitution and Congress.

But first, a bit of background.

The War Powers Resolution was passed in 1973 in response to Richard Nixon’s extraordinary use of power during the Vietnam War. Nixon notoriously conducted a secret bombing campaign in Cambodia during the war, for example. The resolution was designed to strike a balance between Congress’s exclusive power to declare war and the president’s exclusive authority to command the armed forces.

Presidents don’t have to wait for Congress to act to order troops into combat when they’re being attacked or when an attack is imminent. American forces, for example, were already engaged in large-scale combatwith Japanese forces before Congress declared war on Dec. 8, 1941. They had a right to respond to Japanese attacks.

But the existence of an emergency should not permit the president to circumvent Congress for an indefinite or protracted period of time.

The War Powers Resolution squares that circle. If a president initiates military action, he has 48 hours to inform the speaker of the House and the president pro tempore of the Senate.

That notification then triggers a 60-day clock. If Congress doesn’t authorize the military action, the president has to terminate unauthorized hostilities. If Congress passes a concurrent resolution in both houses, the president still has to terminate hostilities.

As of today, the president hasn’t sought a declaration of war, the 60-day clock has expired and both houses of Congress have passed Concurrent Resolution 86, requiring the president to terminate the war. In other words, the Trump administration is in open defiance of the War Powers Resolution.

Presidents of both parties have long argued that the War Powers Resolution is unconstitutional. They’ve claimed it encroaches on the president’s inherent authority to command the armed forces. But — and I cannot emphasize this enough — that is not the president’s call to make.

The Supreme Court has not explicitly ruled on the constitutionality of the resolution, and it probably will not. For generations it has avoided deciding interbranch disputes regarding the use of the armed forces. That means it is up to Congress to assert its authority. It cannot rely on voluntary presidential compliance. It cannot rely on Supreme Court intervention.

If Congress wants to enforce its authority, it has two primary levers: funding and impeachment. And between those two, impeachment is the far better remedy. It is better to remove a lawless secretary of defense from office than it is to defund the troops under his command.

In fact, I’d argue that if Congress wants to reclaim its constitutional role as the sole entity that can declare war, it is a constitutional necessity to impeach and convict senior members of the Trump administration (if not Trump himself) for waging war with Iran.

Reserving the power to declare war to Congress was no minor matter. As Abraham Lincoln wrote all the way back in 1848: “Kings had always been involving and impoverishing their people in wars, pretending generally, if not always, that the good of the people was the object. This our convention understood to be the most oppressive of all kingly oppressions and they resolved to so frame the Constitution that no one man should hold the power of bringing this oppression upon us.”

In addition, as I’ve written before, it is simply wrong to say that the Constitution creates three coequal branches of government. In our representative democracy, the most representative branch of government — Congress — is supposed to reign supreme.

Yes, other branches can certainly check it. (No branch of government has unchecked power.) Presidents can veto legislation. Courts exercise the power of judicial review of congressional statutes. But Congress alone possesses the power of the purse. Congress alone possesses the power to declare war. And Congress alone can impeach and remove presidents, cabinet officials and federal judges.

One of the central problems of our democracy is that generations of congressional abdication of power to the executive branch have turned the structure upside down. It is that presidents have reigned supreme. It’s destabilizing our country. Presidents were never intended to be kings — far from it.

I can think of few better ways for Congress to reassert its place in American government than by removing a secretary of defense who shares responsibility for the most outrageous act of constitutional defiance in warmaking in modern American history.

Against these charges, Hegseth can offer two primary defenses. First, that the administration did nothing wrong or unusual. And second, that he was simply following orders. In other words, Congress, you’re going after the wrong guy.

The first defense relies on the argument that the Trump administration was merely following modern precedents set by other presidents. President Barack Obama, for example, did not receive congressional approval before launching airstrikes against Libya in 2011. Nor did he receive specific congressional approval for his anti-ISIS military operations in 2014.

I also think that Obama should have sought congressional approval before ordering both military actions, but there are very substantial legal differences between the Trump administration’s war against Iran and Obama’s campaigns against Libya and ISIS.

In Libya, NATO forces operated under the authority of a United Nations Security Council resolution authorizing the use of force. The U.N. Charter is a Senate-ratified treaty (in much the same way that the North Atlantic Treaty, which created NATO, is Senate ratified) that empowers the use of military force. In addition, Congress never used its authority under the War Powers Resolution to attempt to terminate hostilities in Libya.

The ISIS mission was conducted under the auspices of two congressional authorizationsfor the use of force, the 2001 authorization for use of military force against Al Qaeda (in 2004, the precursor to ISIS — Al Qaeda in Iraq — essentially merged with Al Qaeda) and the 2002 authorization for use of force in Iraq, which allowed U.S. forces to “defend the national security of the United States against the continuing threat posed by Iraq.”

In reality, presidents have repeatedly sought congressional approval for prolonged military action, and no modern president before Trump has faced — much less defied — a concurrent resolution requiring an end to a war.

President George H.W. Bush notified Congress in accordance with the War Powers Resolution when he ordered the invasion of Panama in 1989 and ended combat operations before the expiration of the 60-day clock.

In fact, in February 1990, the House passed a resolution declaring that Bush had “acted decisively and appropriately in ordering United States forces to intervene in Panama.”

Bush also obtained congressional approvaland a U.N. Security Council resolution authorizing Operation Desert Storm.

President George W. Bush received congressional approval for both the Afghanistan and Iraq wars. His decision to obtain congressional approval for the invasion of Iraq was particularly notable. His own Department of Justice told him it was unnecessary, but he disagreed and went to Congress anyway.

What about Hegseth’s claim that he was merely following orders? In a combative news conference on Tuesday, Hegseth saidthat every operation in Iran, South America, the Caribbean and Yemen was a “lawful operation ordered by the commander in chief, then ordered by myself.”

It is true that Trump bears primary responsibility for the military operations executed under his command. He deserves impeachment and conviction as well. But Trump does not bear exclusive responsibility.

To make this point, I’m going to turn to the Nuremberg trials. But I want to be very clear: I do not believe that Hegseth’s violations of the law are in any way comparable in scope or savagery to the conduct of Nazis in World War II. I am comparing legal principles, not atrocities.

The Nuremberg trials established a legal principle that’s applicable beyond Hitler’s Germany: Powerful subordinates can and should be held accountable for waging war without legal justification. They share responsibility with the leader of the nation for the actions undertaken in its name.

In Count 1, the Nuremberg prosecutors prosecuted multiple senior Nazi leaders who “participated as leaders, organizers, instigators or accomplices” in the “formulation or execution of a common plan or conspiracy to commit, or which involved the commission of, crimes against peace, war crimes and crimes against humanity.”

Count 2 charged defendants with participating in the “planning, preparation, initiation and waging of wars of aggression, which were also wars in violation of international treaties, agreements and assurances.”

As I said, impeachment isn’t a criminal proceeding, and thankfully, the charges against Hegseth are nowhere near as grave as the charges against the Nazi defendants. But did Hegseth conspire or have a common plan to wage war against Iran without congressional approval and in defiance of the acts of Congress and congressional resolutions? Did he plan, prepare, initiate and wage war in violation of the Constitution, acts of Congress and congressional resolutions?

And consider this: Hegseth had an option unavailable to senior Nazi leaders. He could resign at any time and publicly dissent from the administration’s course of action, without fear for his life.

In addition, American law has long imposed on subordinates an affirmative obligation to refuse to obey clearly unlawful orders.

My focus on the War Powers Resolution should not be taken in any way as a judgment that Hegseth is innocent of the other charges against him. I agree with Andrew McCarthy, my former National Review colleague, who wrote, “I do not believe there is any viable justification for the extrajudicial killings by military force of operators of suspected drug boats.”

If any evidence emerges during impeachment proceedings that Hegseth ordered attacks on sailors who were clinging to the destroyed wreckage of their boat — as The Washington Post reported in 2025 — that’s so clearly illegal that the Department of Defense Law of War Manual uses it as a textbook example of a war crime.

Hegseth’s attempt to punish Senator Kelly for publicly stating that service members have a duty to disobey illegal orders was also laughably unconstitutional. It was a clear abuse of power for which he is individually responsible. If he were impeached on that basis alone, it would be well deserved.

The impeachment charges provide an opportunity for the House and the Senate to think bigger — to recover their power (and, quite frankly, for some of them, their dignity) by at least holding the secretary of defense accountable for his role in waging an unconstitutional war. The president, of course, is primarily responsible — and one day he should face a reckoning for his constitutional crimes — but he is not solely responsible.

Hegseth shares the blame, and no amount of finger-pointing and excuse-making can change the fact that he played his own role in arrogantly leading our nation into an unconstitutional war. Congress must relieve him of his command.

I watched the documentary about Elon Musk directed by Alex Gibney called MUSK and urge you to watch it too.

For some reason, it lasted only a few days in movie theaters. Was it because it’s a four-hour film? Or was it because of political pressure?

It’s a devastating portrait of Elon Musk.

There is testimony from his business partners, his first wife, and one of his “baby mamas.” You relive his disgraceful performance as leader of Trump’s failed DOGE. You see him speaking to far-right parties in France and the UK, encouraging hatred of immigrants.

It’s easy to forget that Musk himself is an immigrant from South Africa and that he grew up as a beneficiary of apartheid.

As we know, Musk is the world’s first trillionaire. A large part of his wealth was built on federal government contracts. The board of SpaceX is composed of his cronies. They give him outrageous compensation packages. In 2018, the board awarded him a pay package worth more than $50 billion in stock. In 2025, Elon was given a package worth about $1 trillion over a decade, not in cash but in stock.

Musk is probably the least philanthropic billionaire in the world. He has not endowed a university, a hospital, a museum or any other public institution.

He is a prolific father who considers it his duty to spread his sperm and help rebuild the white population. In the many videos of his workplaces, I don’t recall seeing a Black person, other than those who were losing their job.

Musk’s purchase of Twitter led to the immediate firing of most of its employees. While he calls himself a champion of free speech, he turned the platform into a sewer of hate speech. One of his first acts after taking control of Twitter was to fire everyone who moderated content for vile speech, like Alex Jones, who defamed the parents of the Sandy Hook massacre–claiming that the mass murder of their children was a hoax– and was sued for over $1 billion. The parents won in court.

Musk’s leadership of DOGE was a fiasco. He brought a team of mostly young people to downsize the federal government. The goal was to cut the government’s operating expenses by $2 trillion, but they failed. They fired thousands of highly skilled and experienced civil servants; they offered buyouts that encouraged the retirement of top talent who could make more money in the private sector.

DOGE closed AID, which Musk considered a scam. Aid for food and medicine was immediately canceled in the world’s neediest nations, especially in Africa. Even when people were standing in line, and supplies were available, the distribution was halted and supplies of food and medicine were burned. Hundreds of thousands of people, mainly children, died because of Musk’s closedown of AID.

DOGE did not meet any of its targets. It did not reduce government spending, although more than 200,000 federal employees were laid off. It damaged several major agencies, including Health and Human Services, by killing vital research. Government spending did not decline; in fact, government spending increased, largely due to a ballooning military budget.

Elon Musk’s business success has been facilitated by some $38 billion in federal contracts, according to an investigation by The Washington Post.

Today, the world is circled by 10,000 or more space satellites launched by Musk. The satellites are called Starlink. At one point in the Ukrainian war, someone to decided to shut down Starlink and prevented Ukraine from winning a crucial battle. The system has provided vital information for Ukraine to defend against Russian missiles. Recently, Starlink has been shut down and allowed deadly Russian missiles to destroy major targets in Kiev and raise the death toll.

In response to Musk’s power over life and death, the EU has decided to launch its own competing satellite system in space.

A good deal of time in the film is devoted to Musk’s personal life. One of his children by his first wife was a twin named Xavier. Xavier transitioned became a female named Vivian Jenna Wilson, taking her mother’s last name. She disowned him as her father, and he disowned her. It’s been a bitter relationship and has deepened his contempt for what he calls “the woke mind virus.”

The film covers many important angles of Musk’s meteoric rise. I didn’t even go into the time devoted to showing videos of “self/driving” Teslas that crashed and killed their occupants or others.

Elon Musk today seems to be as powerful as a nation-state. What’s wrong with this picture?

During the 12 years when billionaire Michael Bloomberg was Mayor of New York City, he was in near-total control of the city’s public school system. He campaigned in 2000 claiming that he could “fix” the schools. After he won, he asked the state legislature to give him control of the schools, and the legislature complied by abolishing the city’s independent Board of Education and replacing with a toothless board dominated by Bloomberg appointees. In addition to controlling a majority of the school system’s school board, Bloomberg gained the power to select a chancellor to lead the system.

In 12 years of Bloomberg’s rule, the city school system was reorganized four times. Innovations came and went with warp speed. Test scores and accountability were king. Charter schools proliferated. The Mayor’s powerful public relations team regularly issued press releases and encouraged the mainstream media to believe in the miraculous transformation of the schools under Bloomberg’s control.

The Mayor especially loved charter schools. This was ironic because they were not under his control. They proliferated during his time in office.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/13/nyregion/bloomberg-charter-schools-super-pac.html?unlocked_article_code=1.QFE.1AWD.4u2kkGCWmebP&smid=nytcore-ios-share

As of the 2026–27 school year, New York City has 286 charter schools operating across approximately 424 campuses in the five boroughs.

They serve approximately 152,000 students, or more than 16% of NYC’s public-school enrollment.

The first charter school law in 1998 allowed the creation of 100 charters; in 2010, the State Legislature raised the cap to 460. Over the past decades, charter school enrollment statewide has grown to 190,000 students across about 355 schools, a small fraction of the state’s roughly 2.4 million public schoolchildren.

Breakdown by borough (campuses):

149 Bx

133 Bklyn

77 Manhattan

50 Queens

10 Staten Island

The figures are from the NYC Charter School Center’s 2026–27 data.

One important distinction: 286 is the number of charter schools; 424 is the approximate number of physical campuses. Some charter organizations operate multiple campuses.

John Thompson, retired teacher and historian in Oklahoma, is happy to report that there is growing attention to the acquisition of knowledge, but frustrated to report that Oklahoma just elected a governor with retrograde, simplistic ideas about education.

He writes:

The Oklahoma Center for Education Policy (OCEP) 2026 conference, “Building Knowledge, Building Opportunity,” was awesome. This will focus on the research of the nationally respected literacy expert, Natalie Wexler.

But it also featured Adam Tyner, the OCEP Executive Director, former Education Department director, Daniel Hamlin, who is now Dean of Education at the University of Texas; legislators, and education department leaders; school district superintendents, and charter school leaders; journalists; educators, and my friend and opponent, Mike Petrilli of the Fordham Institute.

I was pleasantly surprised to learn that, recently, when Petrilli introduced research by Adam Tyner, he made a recommendation that went to the heart of the question whether Oklahoma’s new Strong Readers Act will benefit students. This is important because too many business and political leaders have drunk the Kool-Aid on the so-called “Mississippi Miracle,” because they believe that more phonics, test-driven accountability, and “high expectations” can produce  long-lasting gains in reading comprehension.

This ideology has taken time away from history, science, and other approaches for building background knowledge. So, it is important because Petrilli and Tyner agreed:

Elementary schools should consider making more room for high-quality instruction in history, civics, geography, and the other knowledge-rich—and engaging—subjects that comprise social studies. Our youngest generation of readers will be all the stronger for it.

That is consistent with Wexler’s message that:

The federal No Child Left Behind (NCLB) legislation contributed to the trend away from whole books by attaching high stakes to standardized reading tests. Those tests present students with brief passages or excerpts followed by comprehension questions. In an effort to equip students for success on the tests, many schools have adopted that approach for reading instruction as well, despite the lack of evidence that it increases test scores—or comprehension.

Wexler’s The Knowledge Gap: The Hidden Cause of America’s Broken Education System and How To Fix It, made the case that the education establishment  wasn’t serious enough in explaining how phonics should be scaled up, and was ineffective in implementing it. But, Wexler has also explained that “we don’t need more phonics, but more effective phonics.” And we need a “focus on content with an instructional method that fully exploits the potential of writing to build knowledge and critical thinking abilities for every child.”

Her recent writings, like Beyond the Science of Reading: Connecting Literacy Instruction to the Science of Learning, further explains why teachers pushed back against the so-called “Science of Reading.” They had seen the negative effects of NCLB, the Race to the Top (RttT), and Common Core testing. They witnessed the effects of early reading instruction that encouraged the use of “brief passages and skills-focused comprehension instruction in K–12 [that] may also lead to a ‘check the box’ approach to reading.”

Wexler has cited the admired journalist, Dana Goldstein, who explained that corporate reforms, during the era known as the “Teachers Wars,” were based on “the hope that collecting more test scores will raise student achievement,” was “like the hope that buying a scale will result in losing weight.”

Moreover, accountability-driven reforms were driven by the idea that higher data-driven metrics would increase student learning is refuted by Daniel Hamlin’s research that found “No Relationship between Rising Standards and Test Score Growth.” I would add that educators have long known that when the NCLB set the impossible target of 100% Proficiency in 12 years, the predictable result was “jukin’ the stats. 

Wexler acknowledges that a quarter of a century of data-driven accountability, which unleashed more and more test prep, wasn’t the only thing that produced today’s “shrinking attention spans.” But the way it helped undermine the practice of reading books, combined with digital technology and A.I., is especially disturbing. She cited a 2023 survey where “83 percent of teachers said their students’ reading stamina had decreased since 2019, including 53 percent who said it had decreased “a lot.”

I believe the rise of social media created other problems that, along with standardized testing, undermined the reading of books. But focus on test prep distracted us from what should have been our priority – providing the holistic learning students need for the 21st century.  

Yes, she says, “we do need some reasonably objective way of determining whether schools are serving all students,” but “there are alternatives that don’t cause the same damaging consequence as the system we have now.”

So, Wexler “would advocate abolishing any other so-called reading, English Language Arts, or literacy tests, and substitute tests that openly state they are assessing knowledge of topics in history or social studies, science, and literature.”

I hope that legislators will read her recent publication, as to why, “test-based accountability will probably never significantly boost reading outcomes … at least, not under the current testing regime.” Wexler then explains, “That’s because holding schools accountable for scores on state reading comprehension tests distorts teaching in ways that have their most negative impact on students at the lower end of the socioeconomic spectrum, the same students who typically score low on tests.”

They should also listen to her research that explains why that happens:

Phonics-focused reforms can boost state test scores in the elementary grades, but those gains fade out by middle school. 

Finally, Oklahoma just elected a rightwing governor, Mike Mazzei, who wants to kill the income tax, and cut property taxes that support schools. His website doesn’t mention social studies or history, but it focuses on metrics-driven accountability, performance pay and third grade retentions.  

Mazzei has prioritized the hiring of a statewide literacy director. He hasn’t announced who is on his shortlist of people he could hire. Mazzei said Mississippi’s education model inspired him to hire a literacy director. He wants to hire someone for this role who supports the “Mississippi Miracle.” 

So, now it is even more important for education supporters to come together, bury our differences as much as possible, and support the “Science of Learning,” as opposed to the simplistic “Science of Reading” shortcut

Bruce Lesley looked at the blue tsunami of 2026 with a different perspective. The winning campaigns, he discovered, ran on a pro-child agenda. By focusing on child care, child health, good public schools, and other issues that directly affect the well-being of children, he discovered, Democrats won.

Bruce goes through the election results state-by-state and finds that in most states, the candidates with a pro-child agenda won. While Democrats were seeking investment in children’s well-being, Republicans leaned into anti-trans advertisements. Democrats mostly won, Republicans mostly lost.

Message for the future: Put children first.

Lesley writes:

Although children could not vote on November 3, their schools, health care, food, safety, and family budgets were at the center of consequential choices on election day.

Candidates who made affirmative commitments to children won in markedly different states, and voters approved substantial direct investments in the future of children in last week’s elections.

The stakes for children were substantial. Across the country, millions of families are facing threats to health coverage, nutrition assistance, public education, and the services their children depend on.

The Threats Children Have Been Facing

The Trump Administration and Congress have enacted over $1 trillion in Medicaid and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) cuts through the so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill” (OBBB), and children’s enrollment in these programs has declined by millions since then, even before the cuts were fully implemented.

The Administration, through Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., has repeatedly promoted vaccine hesitancy. Consequently, parents confront headlines announcing the return of record levels of measles cases and brain bleeds in babies due to rejection of Vitamin K shots for newborns. Despite saying they wanted more babies, the Administration has also proposed abolishing the Healthy Start program, which President George H.W. Bush created to reduce infant and maternal mortality. Families deserve policies that protect babies and support their healthy development rather than increased threats.

Despite running on an expanded Child Tax Credit (Vice President JD Vance talked about a $5,000 Child Tax Credit) and funding for child care, which are both critically important affordability issues for families with children, the enacted law increased the Child Tax Credit by just $200, far share of the $3,000 increase Vance proposed, while the Administration repeatedly sought cuts to early childhood programs.

The President has also done everything he can to abolish the Department of Education.

And in partnership with a number of governors, Trump has threatened the nation’s commitment to public schools. At both the federal level and in a number of states, political leaders have emphasized support for private schools and education vouchers over public schools. Consequently, for the vast majority of parents with children in public schools, including rural families who live where there are few or no private schools, education has become an increasingly powerful electoral issue.

For young families with children who rely upon and love Head Start, the President’s proposals to slash funding and then to gut the program’s requirements through a massive and unpopular regulatory proposal just weeks before the election, landed as a direct threat.

Under the direction of now Chief of Staff Stephen Miller, the Administration has also engaged in an agenda of separation of the children of immigrants from their parents (so much for family values), the jailing of thousands of children (epitomized by the story of Liam Ramos), mass deportation of kids, and repeated attacks on babies through efforts to gut the Fourteenth Amendment’s birthright citizenship clause that had to be overturned by the Supreme Court.

Taken together, these choices gave candidates a clear opportunity to offer families a vastly different agenda, including one that makes needed investments in children and their future.

Unfortunately, Republican candidates doubled down on culture wars and, as a result, spent an estimated $183 million on anti-transgender-themed TV ads, more than the $151 million spent at the same point in 2024. This included an estimated $58 million in over 50,000 airings in Texas alone (my bet is these numbers are understated).

This agenda stands in sharp contrast to the agenda that Democrats emphasized in this campaign. They talked about supporting public schools, protecting children’s health care coverage and child nutrition, addressing the need for affordable child care, and adopting an affordability agenda that included helping families trying to keep up with the cost of raising kids.

For children and parents in this election, the contrasting agenda promoted by Democrats was deemed to be the better choice.

A political agenda that prioritized and focused on supporting the needs and well-being of all children is a powerful one that, at least in this case, defeated an agenda of abandonment and division that has targeted certain types of children (e.g., low-income, immigrant, LGBTQ, the children of single parents, and children of color) for cuts and exclusion….

We should hold every one of our political leaders to a simple standard: “Is it good for the children?”

The test leads to concrete answers: protect and restore health coverage and nutrition assistance, include all children in the Child Tax Credit, deliver investments in public schools and child care, protect children facing exclusion, and give children sustained attention in their work. 

We should measure success by improvements in children’s lives and well-being.

Voters have given these leaders an opening. Children should not have to wait for them to use it.

Kids can’t wait.

Heather Cix Richardson raises

The extraordinary Nvidia scandal encapsulates the nation’s economic and political system in 2026. On October 29, 2026, the New York Times reported that Jensen Huang, the chief executive officer of chipmaker Nvidia and the major voice shaping the Trump administration’s AI policy, had an extramarital affair with Huang Le, or Alice Huang, suspected of being a Chinese spy. Huang worked for the Singaporean company Megaspeed, which appears to have been a pass-through for AI technology, including AI chips, to get to China. Since those chips can be used in military applications including weapons, the U.S. has since 2022 prohibited the export of advanced chips on the grounds of national security.

As Jonathan V. Last put it in The Bulwarktoday: “By all indications, Alice Huang was a Chinese spy working as the head of a Chinese-backed shell company that was routing banned chips to China. She was not duping or coercing Huang into breaking the law. She was helping him.”

Huang has made it clear that he thinks Nvidia should be able to sell advanced AI chips to everyone, including China, with the argument that such sales will make the rest of the world dependent on American technology. As Last noted, such a stance is also the policy that would make the most money for Nvidia…and Huang himself.

In that stance, Huang appears to have had the support of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, who has refused to crack down on sales of Nvidia chips to data brokers like Megaspeed, which take advantage of a loophole in the law that prohibits sales of the chips but does not stop Chinese firms from renting the chips from data centers in Malaysia, Indonesia, and Thailand. The Biden administration tried to close that loophole, but Trump revoked those rules, saying they stifled innovation.

Ana Swanson, Aaron Krolik, and Paul Mozur of the New York Times reported yesterday that Cantor Fitzgerald, the financial firm formerly headed by Lutnick and now run by his sons, is invested in those data centers in Southeast Asia that serve Chinese customers.

Trump has also sided with Huang. Meryl Kornfield and Steve Thompson of the Washington Post reported today that Trump’s stake in Nvidia rose at least as high as $62 million before the scandal broke.

Ian Duncan, Zach Dorfman, and Warren P. Strobel of the Washington Post reported that Huang, Lutnick, and Trump opposed “a bipartisan group of government officials, lawmakers and think tank analysts,” who “view Nvidia’s chips as a vital asset in the rivalry between the two nations and one that the U.S. should strictly control.”

That faction is backed by U.S. laws.

On Friday, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent blamed Lutnick for slow-walking the restrictions on Megaspeed that would have closed the loophole that enabled it to send Nvidia’s chips to China. But, as former U.S. ambassador to NATO Ivo Daalder noted in his newsletter The Diplomatic Cable, “[b]laming Lutnick suits everyone except Lutnick. It spares the president who set the policy, the adviser who sold it, and the principals who stayed silent until a sex-and-spies scandal made silence costly.”

When they broke the story of the scandal in the New York Times on October 29, Jonathan Swan, Maggie Haberman, Ana Swanson, Paul Mozur, Tripp Mickle, and Julian E. Barnes reported that U.S. intelligence agencies had informed Trump about Huang’s entanglement about a year ago and he had chosen not to distance himself from the Nvidia leader. Huang continued to meet and travel with Trump, and in March 2026, Trump asked him to serve on the “President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology” to offer advice on AI policy.

Members of the Trump administration appear to have been covering for Nvidia’s work with Megaspeed. According to Ana Swanson and Devlin Barrett of the New York Times, Commerce Department investigators were looking at Megaspeed last year, suspecting it was smuggling Nvidia’s chips into China, when Jeff Kessler, a Trump appointee who reports to Lutnick, apparently tipped off Nvidia about the investigation. The case was transferred to the Justice Department, where it appears to have stalled.

When voters elected Democrats to the majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate on November 3, the ability of the Trump administration to hide this apparent extraordinary disregard for the law and for U.S. national security came under threat. The Nvidia board launched an investigation, and Huang stepped down on November 12.

But Nvidia was not just any company. It was central to the AI buildout. It has been referred to as the “central bank of AI” because under Huang, it partnered with six major financial institutions to launch a $500 billion financing platform to support AI startups and specialized cloud providers. That AI buildout was central to the performance of the stock market in Trump’s second term.

Today Matt Egan of CNN reported that when taken along with the popular hatred for data centers, Huang’s downfall points to the bursting of the AI bubble and a hit on the U.S. economy. Gary Gensler, who led the Securities and Exchange Commission from 2021 until 2025, told Egan that the “the only question is if it’s a soft recession or something more dramatic.” Today the Nasdaq Composite index of tech stocks fell for a third day, losing more than 2%.

Anxiety over what will happen at Nvidia and in AI without Huang at its head has led nearly 180,000 tech executives, workers, and shareholders, including billionaire Elon Musk, to sign a petition calling for Huang’s reinstatement. Trump, too, backed the idea of Huang’s return, saying: “I think he learned a big lesson.” He continued: “I guess maybe one lesson more important than another, but I would certainly not mind seeing that.”

Trump downplayed the severity of the case. He suggested that Alice Huang might not have been a spy, and that our national security “was not put at risk, and, uh, our country is now stronger than ever before. And you know, China plays games with us so we play games with China.”

But this afternoon, a source speaking for Nvidia’s board of directors told reporters that the board is not considering reinstating Huang. The Bulwark’s Last noted that the exposure from the scandal has “almost certainly spread to other high-level Nvidia executives” and notes that the “statute of limitations for criminal violations of the Export Control Reform Act, which governs technology diversion, is five years.” A conviction can lead to up to twenty years in prison. 

As Robert Johnson and Walt Hickey wrote in Business Insider in 2012, it is not uncommon for companies to sell military equipment illegally to other countries because the practice is “extremely lucrative.” But if indeed members of the administration were in on it, we are in entirely new territory, with the lust for profits overriding national security at the top of our government. In that—the idea that selling out the people of the country for profit is acceptable all the way to the Oval Office—the scandal seems to represent this moment.

Today the Treasury Department and the National Security Council overruled the Commerce Department to issue a new rule restricting the export of chips to countries deemed likely to supply chips or computing power to countries that are subject to U.S. arms restrictions. The new rule applies to Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand.

I don’t know about you, but I was unable to piece together all the moving parts of the Nvidia scandal. It involved the CEO Jensen Huang, Trump, Lutnick and others. The stories about who did what came out every day but I couldn’t put them all together.

Happily, Dan Rather has put all the pieces together and explained who did what and why it matters.

Thanks, Dan.

He writes:

Word of more grift continues to seep out of the cesspool of corruption known as the Trump administration.

The president, it was revealed on Monday, owns as much as $62 million in stock in the AI giant Nvidia, according to financial disclosures obtained by The Washington Post. That’s the same company at the center of the latest Trump imbroglio, which sounds like the plot of a new James Bond thriller:

An American billionaire tech CEO is caught in a honey trap with a Chinese spy who is selling AI chips to Beijing through a Malaysian front. Meanwhile, that same CEO has the ear of the most corrupt American president in history. That president ignores warnings about the affair because of the effects it could have on his personal wealth and on the U.S. stock market.

Nah, no one would buy it. But they don’t have to, because a story along those lines is now playing out in real time as the country navigates a truth-is-stranger-than-fiction scandal.

At the heart of it is an alleged spy who has yet to come in from the cold.

The CEO, Jensen Huang, co-founded Nvidia with two fellow electrical engineers in 1993 with the goal of improving gaming hardware for personal computers. Over the ensuing three decades, the company grew into one of the largest in the world, shifting its focus to artificial intelligence hardware, specifically chip manufacturing. Huang has become a billionaire and a leader of America’s AI dominance.

Last Wednesday, Huang resigned after the story of his affair with the alleged spy, Alice Huang (no relation), broke in The New York Times. The CEO also reportedly had affairs with two other women, both Nvidia subordinates.

In the two weeks between the Times piece and the resignation, Donald Trump publicly backed Huang, calling him “an honorable guy,” and telling him to fight for his job. This was after it was reported that Trump was twice told about Huang’s affair with the woman suspected of being a spy; the first time more than a year ago and again in May, on the same day he invited the tech executive to join his trip to China to meet with President Xi Jinping.

Trump never acted on the information about the spy investigation and has since denied knowing anything at all.

Trump’s relationship with Huang has been fast and furious. The two met for the first time in January 2025. Within months, Huang became the administration’s de facto AI adviser, one with extraordinary access.

Because we have all seen this play out before, it is no surprise that Huang has become an unabashed supporter of the president, donating millions to Trump’s pet projects, including $25 million for the ballroom, as well as pledging a $500 billion investment in U.S. manufacturing.

Huang’s approach to the business of AI differs from that of many in the sector. A growing number of AI executives have warned of the existential dangers of the technology, calling for regulation, while Huang remains mum.

Others, including members of the Trump administration, have sought to restrict AI hardware sales to China because of Trump’s desire for American “AI primacy.” But Huang’s focus is on selling more chips. Rather than more restrictions, he advocated for more sales to China. He argues that this makes China more reliant on U.S. technology. He seems to have brought the president around to his way of thinking.

In April 2025, Trump was still of a mind to limit chip sales to China. By July, seven months into his relationship with Huang, he had eased some of the sale restrictions. By December, he OK’d the sale of a more powerful Nvidia AI chip, with the caveat that the U.S. government receive 25% of the revenue. Some might describe that as a shakedown. Ultimately, China chose not to buy the chips.

On January 6, just a month after making that deal, Trump added to his cache of Nvidia stock by buying a million dollars more, financial disclosure forms reveal. Because of Nvidia’s inclusion in the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average, most 401(k)s, retirement funds, and mutual funds hold the stock as well. Trump is acutely aware of how important the company’s financial health is to the U.S. economy and how that reflects on him.

Trump is not the only person in the administration who has a financial stake in Nvidia. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has even stronger ties. First, a little background.

Prior to joining the second Trump administration, Lutnick, a billionaire, ran Cantor Fitzgerald, a private global financial services firm. When he accepted the White House job, Lutnick turned over control and his substantial stake in the company in trust to his sons. Cantor Fitzgerald holds 1.8 million shares of Nvidia, among other connections to the chip giant.

An intra-administration fight over government regulation of AI has been brewing, with Lutnick leading the effort to restrict oversight. He did not add Alice Huang’s company, Megaspeed, to the U.S. trade entity blacklist, which would have kept it from acquiring Nvidia’s chips. On the other side is Scott Bessent, the Treasury secretary, who publicly blamed Lutnick for failing to stop Nvidia’s chips from finding their way to China.

“Treasury, War, USTR [U.S. Trade Representative] and State were in favor of putting Megaspeed on the entity list for months. But Commerce has the pen,” Bessent said on CNBC on Sunday. Meaning, Commerce is the Cabinet department that draws up the list.

Even after all that has come out, the president still thinks Huang should be at the helm of Nvidia. On his way to the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit in Shenzhen, China, today a reporter asked if Trump was open to Huang’s return to Nvidia. “I would not mind that…. [The country] was not put at risk, and our country is now stronger than ever before,” he said.

If this burgeoning scandal, which has the potential to bring down more than just Huang, were a made-for-TV movie, how would it play out? The new Democratic Congress, elected in part to curb Trump & Co.’s corruption, will have a hand in crafting the ending.

But beyond politics, one has to ask: Why are we making it easier for our most advanced technology to be sold to our biggest adversary? And if Trump knew it was being sold (through a spy) and did nothing about it, even encouraged it, that behavior will sound to many like treason. Arguments are already being made that Trump betrayed his country, sold us out, for the almighty dollar. His dollars. His ballroom. His stocks. He has monetized the presidency for personal gain to such a degree that the true cost may never be known.

Stephen Dyer is a former legislator and current watchdog over Ohio spending on education. Dyer is skilled at reading the state budget. He reports that the vast majority of new funds for charter schools was spent on administrators’ salaries. Does the public know this?

Dyer reports:

The state released yet one more data point highlighting the need to greatly slim down Ohio’s bloated Charter School Program — last school year’s spending numbers for Ohio’s public and charter schools. 

And while for the first time in a few years, Ohio’s Charter Schools spent less per pupil, on average, than Ohio’s traditional public schools, it wasn’t by a lot. The average brick and mortar Ohio Charter School spent $17,291 per pupil last school year. Ohio’s traditional public schools spent $17,644 — about 2 percent more. 

Per Pupil expenditures for the 2025-2026 school year by school type

Remember that this is how much districts and charters spend in total, including all state, local and federal money. Only a handful of Ohio Charter Schools collect local revenue. So their expenditures are almost exclusively state sourced, with about the same percentage of federal funding that districts get. So the fact that charters and districts are in the same ballpark on relative spending is a remarkable testament to how generous the state had been to charters, especially in relation to the kids in local public school districts.

What’s most striking about these data, though, is how much of the overall spending in Charter Schools is on administrative, non-instructional costs. While not unusual (I’ve been writing about charters’ addiction to administrative expenses for years), what is amazing is how much more per pupil Charter Schools spend on administrators.

Brick and mortar charters spend nearly double the amount districts do and online schools spend a staggering $6,654 per pupil on administrators — more than 3 times the amount districts do. 

By way of comparison, Ohio’s online charters spend more per pupil on administrators than 293 Ohio public school districts receive in total per pupil state aid, according to the latest funding report. There are 613 Ohio public school districts.

More outrage?

Since 2023-2024, 98 percent of all online charter school spending growth has gone to administrative costs.

That’s right. Online charters cut their spending on instruction and staff support so that they could spend 98 percent of their $1,462 per pupil increase on administrators. The remaining $99 went to pupil support.

While online schools reveal the starkest change, brick and mortar charters ain’t much different.

Their increase for administrators is actually more than double their overall spending increase. How is that? Because they drastically cut operations and staff support funding. So while their overall spending only went up $116 per pupil, their administrative cost jumped $263.

Can you imagine the outcry if school districts spent their money this way?

Can you understand why I’ve always called bullshit on Ohio school choice advocates’ insistence on “putting more money into the classroom?” 

Because charters were sold as being a more efficient way to deliver more resources directly into the classroom — avoiding the school district administrative “bloat”. 

Instead, they are remarkably worse at delivering resources into classrooms than traditional public schools.

One more thing to chew on: If charters spent the same share of their funding on administrators that school districts did, it would save state taxpayers about $215 million. 

That’s just about what the state’s school funding formula calculates it costs for all traditional school district guidance counselors and staff professional development.

In all districts.

Like … combined.

Yet that’s how much more Ohio Charter Schools spend on administrators than they would if they just spent the same percentage of their money on administrators that Ohio’s public school districts do.

And what’s been the result? One in 3 charters ending up on the state’s worst-performing schools list, among other things.

Yeah. Trim that fat.

Woo Pig Sooie!

Laura Baker and Elizabeth Heubeck wrote in Education Week about the value of reading short pieces of text versus long form texts like novels.

The Common Core State Standards discounted fiction and literature, expressing a distinct preference for “informational text.” Long-form reading was despatched to the dust-bin, as compared to snippets of informational text. Snippets, after all, were perfect preparation for standardized tests, where students were presented with short passages that had no context. Novels had little or no value in the regime of test-prep.

How tweens and teens consume the written word is quickly evolving. They used to routinely devour long-form reading—chapter books, mysteries, young adult series. Now, that may be the rarity rather than the norm.

Instead, much of this demographic’s pleasure reading tends to consist of a combination of receiving and sending quick snippets of text, like DM’s and Snaps, while simultaneously scrolling through social media and videos laden with short text blurbs.

What happens when students move quickly across the written word, ping-ponging between multiple threads of surface content? And how does that compare to the act of immersing oneself in a long-form text that reveals a dynamic setting, complex characters, and an evolving plot—sometimes over hundreds of pages?

We asked experts in literacy, cognition, and child development to weigh in. Here’s what they shared.

What happens when we give the brain more time?

Maryanne Wolf, a renowned cognitive neuroscientist, literacy scholar, and director of the Center for Dyslexia, Diverse Learners, and Social Justice at the University of California Los Angeles, thinks a lot about the process of reading.

“Everything [in reading] is about how the circuit for the reading brain is used or not used,” Wolf said. Long form reading requires our brain’s time, attention, and effort, she explains. Reading long-form fiction, she says, takes us down an even deeper path.

“Reading fiction inspires us to leave our own perspective behind, and take on the thoughts and feelings of others,” Wolf said. “You are enriching your capacity for empathy, and your capacity to take on the experience, the life, the epoch, the culture of others.”

The same can’t be said for reading snippets of text, Wolf observes, whether it’s a brief reading passage on a standardized reading assessment or the captions on a short-from video.

“They’re just getting at the surface of the word, rather than the subterranean life that gives meaning and beauty, and further thought,” Wolf said.

Long- and short-form reading both require executive functioning skills: working memory, cognitive flexibility, (response) inhibition, and to a lesser degree, attention and processing speed, says Baltimore-based psychologist Danielle Wexler. But short-form reading places less demand overall on the reader, she adds.

“The demands for those executive functioning skills when you’re reading a longer text are substantially higher than if you’re reading a short text or quick message,” said Wexler, who works with patients and conducts research at the Center for Neuropsychological and Psychological Assessment at Kennedy Krieger, a world-renowned institute for treating pediatric disabilities.

“ The demands for … executive functioning skills when you’re reading a longer text are substantially higher than if you’re reading a short text or quick message.

If long-form reading conveys benefits, does short-form reading carry other, different ones?

“I think in some ways short-form reading helps teens learn how to shift between tasks more easily,” Wexler said. “But then the question then becomes: Can they apply that to something that’s less preferred; for example, their homework?”

Effective multi-tasking is particularly challenging for kids with attention issues, like attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Wexler observes. “If you’re a child with ADHD, sometimes multitasking goes terribly wrong,” she said. “You might have 20 different tabs open on your computer, but you never finish any of the related tasks.”

Wolf concedes that interacting with the constant stream of pithy verbal messages bombarding adolescents on social media may help them learn how to manage large quantities of information. But she offers this caveat: “As long as you use it as a sieve to find what you really want to, that’s a skill. But if you just use it as your basic modus operandi, it’s a detriment.

“It’s just getting at the surface of the world, rather than the subterranean life that gives meaning and beauty, and further thought,” Wolf said.

“You have the ability that a lot of people did not have previously, which is how to handle massive amounts of information. Your skill mode is actually quite useful when you have that kind of information—as long as you use it as a sieve to find what you really want to.NameTitle

For educators, the relevant question might be: Long-form reading is challenging, and something students are much less likely to do on their own. So what can schools do to require rich texts, support students through them, and encourage them to read on their own?

EdWeek’s latest special report, on engagement and motivation in reading, has some ideas—both inside and outside of classrooms. 

Wolf, for her part, calls on teachers to protect it. 

Teachers, Wolf says, should continue to set expectations high for students; for example, assigning whole texts as opposed to summaries for proficient readers. 

“God forbid that George Eliot is never read by the next generation,” Wolf said. “But it’s possible.”

The Trump administration claims it is “making American healthy again,” under the leadership of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Hahaha. RFK has discouraged vaccines, and the U.S. is experiencing a resurgence of measles. This is not a sign of improving health. It’s a result of ignorance.

CNN) — Thanks to widespread vaccination, measles had been considered “eliminated” as a continually transmitting illness in the United States since 2000 – but not anymore.

An independent commission of experts that reports to the director of the Pan American Health Organization determined that the US no longer qualified as having eliminated measles, a source close to the process told CNN on Friday.

The news was first reported by The Wall Street Journal.

The decision was widely expected after years of falling vaccination levels and surging case counts, but it’s still a black mark on the nation’s public health policy….

“Measles elimination is a vital sign for our public health system. It shows cracks in our foundation. Losing elimination status means that we are less prepared as a nation to address infectious and noninfectious disease challenges,” said Dr. Demetre Daskalakis, former director of the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.