John Thompson, retired teacher and historian in Oklahoma, is happy to report that there is growing attention to the acquisition of knowledge, but frustrated to report that Oklahoma just elected a governor with retrograde, simplistic ideas about education.
He writes:
The Oklahoma Center for Education Policy (OCEP) 2026 conference, “Building Knowledge, Building Opportunity,” was awesome. This will focus on the research of the nationally respected literacy expert, Natalie Wexler.
But it also featured Adam Tyner, the OCEP Executive Director, former Education Department director, Daniel Hamlin, who is now Dean of Education at the University of Texas; legislators, and education department leaders; school district superintendents, and charter school leaders; journalists; educators, and my friend and opponent, Mike Petrilli of the Fordham Institute.
I was pleasantly surprised to learn that, recently, when Petrilli introduced research by Adam Tyner, he made a recommendation that went to the heart of the question whether Oklahoma’s new Strong Readers Act will benefit students. This is important because too many business and political leaders have drunk the Kool-Aid on the so-called “Mississippi Miracle,” because they believe that more phonics, test-driven accountability, and “high expectations” can produce long-lasting gains in reading comprehension.
This ideology has taken time away from history, science, and other approaches for building background knowledge. So, it is important because Petrilli and Tyner agreed:
Elementary schools should consider making more room for high-quality instruction in history, civics, geography, and the other knowledge-rich—and engaging—subjects that comprise social studies. Our youngest generation of readers will be all the stronger for it.
That is consistent with Wexler’s message that:
The federal No Child Left Behind (NCLB) legislation contributed to the trend away from whole books by attaching high stakes to standardized reading tests. Those tests present students with brief passages or excerpts followed by comprehension questions. In an effort to equip students for success on the tests, many schools have adopted that approach for reading instruction as well, despite the lack of evidence that it increases test scores—or comprehension.
Wexler’s The Knowledge Gap: The Hidden Cause of America’s Broken Education System and How To Fix It, made the case that the education establishment wasn’t serious enough in explaining how phonics should be scaled up, and was ineffective in implementing it. But, Wexler has also explained that “we don’t need more phonics, but more effective phonics.” And we need a “focus on content with an instructional method that fully exploits the potential of writing to build knowledge and critical thinking abilities for every child.”
Her recent writings, like Beyond the Science of Reading: Connecting Literacy Instruction to the Science of Learning, further explains why teachers pushed back against the so-called “Science of Reading.” They had seen the negative effects of NCLB, the Race to the Top (RttT), and Common Core testing. They witnessed the effects of early reading instruction that encouraged the use of “brief passages and skills-focused comprehension instruction in K–12 [that] may also lead to a ‘check the box’ approach to reading.”
Wexler has cited the admired journalist, Dana Goldstein, who explained that corporate reforms, during the era known as the “Teachers Wars,” were based on “the hope that collecting more test scores will raise student achievement,” was “like the hope that buying a scale will result in losing weight.”
Moreover, accountability-driven reforms were driven by the idea that higher data-driven metrics would increase student learning is refuted by Daniel Hamlin’s research that found “No Relationship between Rising Standards and Test Score Growth.” I would add that educators have long known that when the NCLB set the impossible target of 100% Proficiency in 12 years, the predictable result was “jukin’ the stats.
Wexler acknowledges that a quarter of a century of data-driven accountability, which unleashed more and more test prep, wasn’t the only thing that produced today’s “shrinking attention spans.” But the way it helped undermine the practice of reading books, combined with digital technology and A.I., is especially disturbing. She cited a 2023 survey where “83 percent of teachers said their students’ reading stamina had decreased since 2019, including 53 percent who said it had decreased “a lot.”
I believe the rise of social media created other problems that, along with standardized testing, undermined the reading of books. But focus on test prep distracted us from what should have been our priority – providing the holistic learning students need for the 21st century.
Yes, she says, “we do need some reasonably objective way of determining whether schools are serving all students,” but “there are alternatives that don’t cause the same damaging consequence as the system we have now.”
So, Wexler “would advocate abolishing any other so-called reading, English Language Arts, or literacy tests, and substitute tests that openly state they are assessing knowledge of topics in history or social studies, science, and literature.”
I hope that legislators will read her recent publication, as to why, “test-based accountability will probably never significantly boost reading outcomes … at least, not under the current testing regime.” Wexler then explains, “That’s because holding schools accountable for scores on state reading comprehension tests distorts teaching in ways that have their most negative impact on students at the lower end of the socioeconomic spectrum, the same students who typically score low on tests.”
They should also listen to her research that explains why that happens:
Phonics-focused reforms can boost state test scores in the elementary grades, but those gains fade out by middle school.
Finally, Oklahoma just elected a rightwing governor, Mike Mazzei, who wants to kill the income tax, and cut property taxes that support schools. His website doesn’t mention social studies or history, but it focuses on metrics-driven accountability, performance pay and third grade retentions.
Mazzei has prioritized the hiring of a statewide literacy director. He hasn’t announced who is on his shortlist of people he could hire. Mazzei said Mississippi’s education model inspired him to hire a literacy director. He wants to hire someone for this role who supports the “Mississippi Miracle.”
So, now it is even more important for education supporters to come together, bury our differences as much as possible, and support the “Science of Learning,” as opposed to the simplistic “Science of Reading” shortcut
