I wrote about Emily Hanford’s “Sold a Story 2” last week. Her first season (“Sold a Story”) was devoted to the assertion that reading teachers have been deceived and have failed to learn that phonics is the one best way to teach reading. I am a proponent of phonics but firmly believe that states should not mandate how to teach. I do not believe in a “science of reading” or a science of any other subject. There are many ways to be a good teacher, not a single method.
In season 2, Hanford discovers “Direct Instruction” and again asserts that teachers have been deceived by the education establishment, which (she says) prefers unscripted, loosey-goosey, “discovery” methods.
Hanford shows her hand in Episode 6 of the second season. She chooses to highlight the use of Direct Instruction at Baker Mitchell’s four-school charter chain in North Carolina. More than a decade ago, I wrote about Baker Mitchell and his charter chain (Roger Bacon Academy) as a prime example of profiteering and conflict of interest in charter world. It’s a strange choice for an exemplar.
Baker Mitchell operates his charters for profit and has collected millions of dollars from them. He is paid 16% of their revenues to manage them. He owns a separate for-profit company (Coastal Habitat Conservancy) to collect rent on land and buildings and sell supplies to the schools. Another Mitchell company sells school uniforms. He is an entrepreneur, not an educator. When the Tea Party won control of North Carolina in 2010, the hard-right Republicans in the state legislature passed a charter law in June 2011, and Baker Mitchell saw a business opportunity.
But! Hanford admired the fact that these charters used DI.
At this point, I am going to post part of the online discussion between Trevor Aleo and Nick Covington about “Sold a Story 2.”
They begin by writing: “‘Obedient and Loyal to Those in Authority”: The Charter Network Hanford Hoped You Wouldn’t Google.'”
I hope you are intrigued enough to read their commentary in full.
I am posting only the beginning.
Nick: I think I’ve been even-handed in my criticism of this season, so I ask forgiveness for the heel turn I’m about to make: Emily Hanford is lying to you and thinks you’re gullible. That’s my takeaway from Episode 6 after the most cursory Google search for Baker Mitchell, the charter school founder at the center of this week’s narrative. I can’t focus on anything else. The way Hanford frames Baker Mitchell and his charter school network—and what she omits to make it work in her favor—is the story, and all of my energy today has gone into bringing that to our readers.
Trevor: This was definitely the mask off episode of the season. I noted in our previous episode that Hanford at least attempted to hide the ideological underpinnings guiding the Sold A Story project, but this week we went from subtext to text in a fairly jarring manner. This episode was basically a really bad infomercial about charter schools from 2008. I joked last week that Hanford’s arguments were so recycled that it seems like she spent the last 20 years in a cryogenic chamber. After this week, I’m actually concerned it’s true. Maybe the American Enterprise Institute keeps her on ice when she isn’t podcasting on their behalf?
What Hanford Doesn’t Tell You About Baker Mitchell
Nick: Episode 6 opens innocuously enough, “Baker Mitchell is an engineer. He loves science. He was hoping his children would too,” followed by an interview clip of Mitchell talking about instilling a love of science for his own children, all of which led him to found a school. “That one school has become four,” Hanford says, “A group of charter schools in and around the city of Wilmington, North Carolina named for Roger Bacon, the 13th century scholar who helped develop the scientific method.” Much of the episode focuses on the experience of teachers, students, and parents at Roger Bacon Academy schools, emphasizing the call-and-response aspect of Direct Instruction.
About halfway through the episode, though, Hanford pauses, “A note: there has been controversy surrounding the Roger Bacon schools for reasons that have nothing to do with Direct Instruction — including a high-profile lawsuit about their dress code by the ACLU,” before picking the thread right back up, “We visited the Roger Bacon schools because Direct Instruction has lasted for 26 years…” Hold up. Controversy, dress code, and the ACLU? I wonder what’s going on there that Hanford felt it needed mention withoutelaboration? How has Direct Instruction survived for so long here where it hasn’t elsewhere? Here’s where a Google search undoes the narrative.
Baker Mitchell was an engineer, but he was also an entrepreneur. According to his CV, Mitchell built a successful computer software company and sold it off in 1989. He then spent the next decade writing courses and volunteer teaching before moving to North Carolina and opening The Roger Bacon Academy in 1999. Today there is no single school of Mitchell’s called Roger Bacon Academy. What Hanford describes as “a group of [four] charter schools in and around the city of Wilmington” are actually branded Classical Charter Schools of America and managed by Mitchell’s for-profit Roger Bacon Academy, Inc. Yet neither the classical charter brand nor the for-profit status show up anywhere in the episode.
In 2014, ProPublica investigated how Mitchell’s operation works. The schools themselves may be non-profits, but the non-profit school board hired the for-profit Roger Bacon Academy to manage them, with Baker Mitchell on both sides of the transaction. In other words, Mitchell hired himself, an arrangement ProPublica points out “is illegal in many other states.” He then sold or leased the schools nearly everything they needed—from desks, computers, and teacher training to the land and buildings themselves—with no competitive bidding. As early as 2001, the IRS denied the group’s application for tax-exemption and documented what they called “a clear conflict of interest” in Mitchell controlling the management company and the schools buying its services. That didn’t prevent him from taking $20 million in management fees and rent from just the first six years of his first two schools. None of Mitchell’s apparent self-dealing appears in the episode.
Trevor: But, Nick! Can you really put a price on children’s ability to retrieve knowledge from their long term memory? Caring about rampant self dealing, fraud, and corruption is so education establishment coded. Who taught you to care about that stuff? John Dewey? Jean-Jacques Rousseau? Good teaching isn’t political!
Nick: Funny you mention that, Trevor—Mitchell was also a political activist, putting his thumb on the scale of state policy in his favor. In 2011, the North Carolina state legislature raised the cap on charter schools and put Mitchell on the Charter School Advisory Council, whose job it was to review new charter applications. As the ProPublica piece documents, Mitchell’s schools suddenly benefitted from a number of “unusual” exemptions and exceptions. In 2013, Mitchell used his influence to push for new charter school regulations that loosened teacher certification rules and gave property managers like himself tax-breaks for leasing to charter schools. He eventually resigned from the state’s Charter School Advisory Board in 2014 after being dogged by questions about his impartiality and conflicts of interest. That Mitchell saw his education work as deeply political is mentioned nowhere in the episode, and that’s before we even get to the curriculum.
Classical Charter Schools

Nick: If you’re curious about the bit in the episode with middle-schoolers naming Roman emperors and taking Latin, that comes from the classical charter school angle, which “teaches a classical curriculum espousing the values of traditional western civilization.” That’s left out of the episode, along with the School Pledge taken directly from the 2026-2027 Parent and Student Handbook, which includes vows to guard against “the stains of falsehood from the fascination with experts…and the over-reliance on rational argument.” Bit of tension there for a podcast series about evidence-based practices, so I can understand not leading the episode with it, but the School Pledge then closes with this stanza:
I pledge to be obedient and loyal to those in authority
in my family,
in my school, and
in my community and country,
So long as I shall live.
Trevor: It feels like Hanford is making us speed run every bad right-wing education/policy fad from the last 15 years. In addition to all the issues with this particular charter school system, there are so many issues with the broader classical school movement that I feel like I have to start in the historical weeds and work my way back from there.
First of all, the idea that “the West” is an unbroken chain stretching from ancient Greece through Western Europe and ultimately culminating in a Disneyfied version of American exceptionalism is utter pish. The Western tradition is not some sacred heirloom of Christendom. The idea that Europe can “claim” Greece’s intellectual legacy as its property attempts to project modern borders onto ancient history as though they are timeless and static cultural boundaries. What these classical charter schools call “the Western tradition” was shaped by centuries of intellectual exchange across Europe, North Africa, and the Arabic-speaking world—not within a self-contained cultural space called “the West.” In fact, much of the Greek philosophy that helped transform medieval Europe, including the Trivium referenced in the CCSA materials above, reached Latin readers through Arabic-language scholarship and translation networks linking the Islamic world with Iberia and Siciliy. The Muslim and Jewish cultures and scholars (not just the Christian ones!) who kept this knowledge alive did not simply pass along an untouched Athenian inheritance; they translated, interpreted, challenged, extended, and generally enriched it.
This is not a purely pedantic point about historical accuracy. It proves that people like Mitchell know nothing of the history that they seek to venerate. They are either wholly cynical, treating the good, beautiful, and true as marketing buzzwords for CCSA promotional materials, or they are embarrassingly dim, eschewing the complex texture of history for smooth brained fairytales to reinforce their political priors. Either way, their celebration of “the West” is not born out of intellectual curiosity, a desire to live a more fully examined life, or even a belief students should engage with powerful ideas from the past. The entire project is just reactionary politics cosplaying the life of the mind. Nevermind the fact that it’s hard to take grandiose claims of value-based education seriously when, as you’ve already detailed, these schools basically become cash cows for entrepreneurial grifters seeking to better monetize their own liberal arts educations.
Please open the link and finish reading.
