The Indiana legislature is considering a bill that would empower parents to censor books they find objectionable and to criminalize librarians who allow such books in libraries. The story was originally reported on WYFI, the NPR station in Indiana.
Chalkbeat reported:
The House Education Committee heard hours of testimony Wednesday from school employees, librarians, and others across Indiana who expressed opposition to a proposed amendment to a bill that would strip these employees of a legal defense against charges they distributed material harmful to minors.
The hearing was the latest evolution in a months-long legislative process driven by concerns among some parents that pornography is rampant in schools. While lawmakers have drafted legislation to address these concerns, they’ve presented little evidence to suggest it’s a widespread problem. The latest iteration of the legislation also targets public libraries.
Rep. Becky Cash (R-Zionsville), who crafted the amendment, said she’s heard from “thousands” of parents who have lodged complaints with their schools over books they believed were objectionable.
“Parents have testified in school board meetings and come to me, and many members of this committee and assembly many, many times over the last couple of years saying that the system did not work for them,” Cash said.
She explained that the amendment mandates schools and public libraries lay out a transparent process for parents and residents to lodge complaints.
But several Democratic members of the committee expressed concern that the bill would empower some parents and disempower others by creating a system in which some parents could control access to books for all children. They also expressed opposition to a portion of the amendment that strips librarians and school employees from a legal defense.
“We are not the court of appeals from parents who are unhappy with school board decisions,” said Rep. Ed DeLaney (D-Indianapolis). “But if we were the Court of Appeals, we would want evidence. What parent? What school? What book? What hearing? What process? Not this vague discontent.”
These attacks on librarians and on the freedom to read are despicable. The red states are empowering ignorant censors who want to impose their values on people who don’t share them.
And that would be, how these, younger generations of children, become less and, less, educated than the generations, before…and the parents still don’t have a clue, that they are, the ones, causing their own young to get, dumber than they, are. This is truly, sad…
You mean like home schooling. Purposeful replication of ignorance.
exactly
Indiana…. Just another state being added to the growing number of states with a Fascist leaning.
An internet site identifies the religion of Republican Rep. Becky Cash, who crafted the amendment, as Catholic. She is for school choice and anti-abortion.
Recommended reading, “error has no rights,” at Wikipedia.
Good morning Diane and everyone,
Wouldn’t it just be easier to forbid your child from going into the school library than to fire librarians, pass laws, etc. etc? No, they don’t just want to forbid their children from certain books. They want to forbid everyone from looking at them. That’s not right. Reminds me of an old Buddhist story. Something about if you want to protect your feet, it’s easier to wrap your feet in leather than to cover the entire world in leather….
It is exactly the case that they want to cover the world. This is all about forcing others to toe their line.
Mamie, you hit the nail on the head, as usual. The parents involved in censorship want to control not just what their own child reads, but what all children read. Other parents with different views are denied their parental rights.
https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/book-burning
Book banning is un-American.
It is!!! Fundamentally so.
What do you mean?
I thought a historian would be aware of the first incidence of censorship in the Americas by the Iroquois Council:
“We hereby ban ‘How to build a birchbark canoe.’ That book is filthy and disrespects women, with it’s talk of ‘stripping birches’ .. and besides , the shape of canoes is clearly suggestive of a body part that shall not be mentioned.”
Also, who can forget the banning of “Teepee Life” and it’s description of babies being born in the presence of young children.
“error has no rights”
Rep. Becky Cash is identified on the internet as a Republican Catholic. Her anti-abortion and pro school choice advocacy makes her a conservative catholic.
That segment doesn’t value democracy as we understand it.
FYI-info on Indiana-thought it may be of interest
FL is a disaster as well
I think these fascists want to insure that extreme right white people like MTG retain all power by turning the calendar back to at least 1900, if not further, when 40 percent of the population lived in extreme poverty, only 7% of young adults graduated from high school and 3% from college.
These fascists want to reverse the US as a developed nation, and return our country to undeveloped status.