Politico reports that there was no sweep for partisans of the culture war issues. We can expect to see more attacks on teachers, students, and school boards in the next election, based on hyped-up falsehoods about race and gender. Support from rightwing conservative foundations—the usual suspects—will keep alive the battles and the fake organizations leading them. (Expect a special report soon from the Network for Public Education on these front groups attacking school boards, written by an authority on Dark Money).
Juan Perez Jr. of Politico writes:
THE DIVIDED CLASSROOM — In case you missed it amid the advertising noise and campaign spending avalanche of November’s midterms, 2022 proved to be an incredibly busy — and contentious — year for education elections.
Fifteen states and the District of Columbia held state school board or education superintendent races this year. Roughly 1,800 local board seats across some 560 districts in 26 states were also up for grabs on Nov. 8, according to the nonpartisan nonprofit Ballotpedia.
Who came out on top? Nobody. Neither Democrats nor Republicans managed a clean sweep.
This means the state of education in the United States remains divided sharply along partisan lines — and the education wars are likely to continue unabated in 2023 and beyond.
The bitter differences between the two sides and lack of consensus between the poles of both parties — over everything from teaching about slavery and gender identity to childhood vaccinations – offer little incentive for either side to back down.
“We are stopping Critical Race Theory from being taught, stopping access to obscene pornography in our schools, and ending the tenure of radicalism and indoctrination of our kids because the left is waging a civil war in our classrooms,” newly-elected Oklahoma State Superintendent Ryan Walters recently wrote in the Daily Caller.
Candidates who supported having race and sex-related curricula or Covid-19 safety requirements in schools won about 40 percent of the roughly 1,800 local board elections tallied by Ballotpedia this year, and tended to win in counties President Joe Biden carried in the 2020 election. Candidates with opposing views won about 30 percent of their elections, often doing so in counties held by former President Donald Trump.
Nearly one-third of incumbent school board members also lost to their challengers on Nov. 8.
“People didn’t feel listened to. Parents felt they lost agency and power over their kids’ education,” Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers labor union, recently told Nightly. “My concern is that we can’t have two countries. This is one United States of America, and we have an obligation to help kids — regardless of whether they’re in South Carolina, Tennessee, New York or California — to learn how to critically think.”
As they turn toward 2023, Democrats take solace in battleground state victories for governor, successful education-related ballot measures and local school board races where moderate incumbents defeated far-right challengers in Louisville, Ky., the suburbs of Austin, Texas, and other places.
Sure, conservatives lost plenty of races. But they won more than enough to show their brand of culture-based education politics thrives in areas controlled by the party faithful. Trump seems to have this on his mind, too. The former president promised schools would lose their federal funding if they don’t get rid of critical race theory, and what he described as “radical civics and gender insanity,” when he announced his reelection bid.
No state school boards with elections this year flipped partisan control, according to the National Association of State Boards of Education. But majority parties did expand their influence on boards in Colorado, Kansas and Utah while conservative incumbents often lost primary challenges.
Candidates endorsed by two upstart GOP-aligned political committees also won roughly half of their midterm elections.
Candidates backed by Moms for Liberty, a group formed by a former Florida school board member to fight school Covid-19 mask requirements and controversial library books, won about half of their 2022 elections, according to the organization. The 1776 Project PAC, a group opposed to the critical race theory academic framework that examines how race and racism have become ingrained in American institutions, saw a similar win-loss ratio.
Open the link to read more.
The Democratic “celebration” over the midterms — that they they didn’t lose both houses — was just ridiculous.
Is that’s the Democratic leadership’s definition of z “win”, I’d say there is no hope for them.
Even in the Senate, there was no real win.The Ddmocrat’s so called “majority” is fake, since Manchin and Sinema both vote Republican on critical issues and would never vote to get rid of the filibuster, at any rate. And Sinema is no longer registered as ai Democrat, what a surprise she never was one anyway.
But Biden and Democratic leadership are STILL trying to ram through Manchin’s giveaways to the fossil fuel industry that Schumer and probably Biden promised him, despite the fact that it has been rejected 3 times now.
Hey, I know.
..but Trump would be worse.
Ha ha ha
My sentiments exactly. I didn’t get the relieved optimism from the beginning. A one vote republican majority can be just as, if not more so, destructive as a hundred vote majority.
It’s very simple. They did not win, but they did not not win because they did not lose, so they won not losing. That was not not a loss and not not a win. One can see how the Democrats do not not winning, by not not losing. Bill Gates wins. It’s not not inspiring.
We had our department meeting yesterday and our district is, basically, armed and ready to go and has our back. We have a MFL group that meets in our community but is trying to cause havoc in other districts that don’t even enroll their own kids. Trying to force others views/values on others, trying to control people for their own ends, is the most UnAmerican Activity that should be banned. In my classroom, I have the First, Fourth, Fifth, and Fourteenth Amendments above my Banned Books corner of the room and arm my students with the rhetorical/intellectual tools to counter the assertions of these nutjobs which are nothing shy of absurd.
Thanks for that. Success to you all!
Thanks to Citizens United our nation allows astroturf groups funded by billionaires and dark money to gang up on public schools and teachers armed with propaganda and lies. Other than unions and the power of the pen, there are few ways to defend against the assault. A democratic institution is a sitting duck against these “nutjobs.” The very nature of democracy gives them access and a right to be heard. Public institutions have no budgets for publicity, advertising or self-promotion so it is easy for them to be public punching bags. The only thing teachers can do is support each other and act collectively.
I can’t wait for the report from NPE about Dark Money. Koch and the other libertarian billionaires surely pulled a fast one in 2022. I want details.
cx: and the paid performers are armed with propaganda and lies.
You dropped part of the quotation, didn’t you?
We PURITANICAL, BRAIN-DEAD, RIGHTWING EXTREMIST MORONS are stopping Critical Race Theory from being taught, stopping access to obscene pornography in our schools, and ending the tenure of radicalism and indoctrination of our kids because the left is waging a civil war in our classrooms,” newly-elected Oklahoma State Superintendent Ryan Walters recently wrote in the Daily Caller.
Good that they are on the case of tracking down “obscene pornography,” as opposed to the other kinds. lol
Oops. My bad. He didn’t need to say those added parts because they are implicit in what he did say.
Great to see the committee’s referrals, yesterday. I was particularly pleased to see that they had added insurrection. I made the argument here that Trump had committed treason because he aided and abetted groups attempting to overthrow the elected government before it even took office.
The extreme right may be losing ground, at least at the state level.
In 2016 the Republican Party controlled 30 states: state legislatures and the governors. The Democrats had about 16 states.
After the 2022 midterms, the Republicans has lost about 8 states and the Democrats gained about 5, up to about 21.
I’m writing this from memory, but, out of curiosity, I did check yesterday from primary sources.
I have also read that the Repulibican Party has been working long term goals for decades to end up controlling enough states to pull of a rewrite of the U.S. Constitution and ratify it, changing the Constitution to support extreme right goals, rewriting the laws to support a theofascist autocratic government where the few tell the many how they can live their lives. Sort of what the majority of conservative justices on the U.S. Supreme Court are doing now.
“. . . to pull of a rewrite of the U.S. Constitution and ratify it, changing the Constitution to support extreme right goals, rewriting the laws to support AN XTIAN theofascist autocratic government. . . .”
It’s all about the xtians taking over and as been since the 70s.
I think I want to start a public education and learning advocacy group called Dad’s for Dendrites. What do you think?