Archives for category: Cruelty

I did not get this essay from Bob Shepherd in time to post it on Columbus Day. Some years ago, I read the book by the priest Bartolomeo de las Casas to which he refers, and it made me so sick with disgust and sorrow that I could not finish it. Some illustrations show the Spanish conquistadores turning people on a spit, as if they were pigs. Too harrowing for me.

A Short Love Letter to Prezidoodle Donnie Trumpty-Dumpty

Re: Chrissie Columbus, by Robert D. Shepherd

We have two national holidays named after people, one for the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., and one for Christopher Columbus.

Columbus thought he had landed near Japan. He wrote a letter back home saying that the natives were so “artless” and “generous” that it would be easy to have whatever he wanted of them. He was, ofc, looking for a quick and easy route to the Far East so that he could trade in spices, silks, gemstones, and so on. When he didn’t find those, he set up a quota for gold to be delivered to him by every native over 14 years of age. When they didn’t meet their quotas, he cut off pieces of their anatomy–fingers, hands, feet. But there was no gold.

Terrified by the prospect of displeasing his sponsors back home, he hit upon enslaving the natives to work in mines and to produce crops that could be traded or sold. He instructed his overseers to pull one of the enslaved natives from the fields every once in a while and slaughter him or her in full view of the others to encourage them to work harder. He wrote a letter back home telling a friend that it was easy to keep his men in line by rationing out to them the native females for sexual purposes. He said, “THOSE FROM NINE TO TEN are now in demand.” He set armored dogs on the indigenous babies and toddlers for sport. He instituted the first European-run slave plantations in the New World AND the first trans-Atlantic slave trading. In a couple decades, he had almost entirely wiped out the Caribbean Arawaks–an estimated quarter of a million of them.

We have a contemporary account of these depredations by a priest named Bartolomeo de las Casas who, horrified, witnessed them first-hand and wrote a book to try to get King Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor and King of Spain, to make it stop. In his book, A Brief Account of the Destruction of the Indies, de las Casas tells how the Spanish celebrated Easter by hanging thirteen Indians from a gibbet–one for each of the apostles and one for Christ–and flaying them alive. And there are bits about how much fun Christopher’s men had cutting open the bellies of living pregnant women and pulling the babies out.

So, Martin Luther King, Jr., and this guy, Columbus, notable for enslavement, genocide, the most ghastly conceivable tortures, and trading in children for unspeakable purposes–the fellow just honored as a “courageous . . . man of faith” in a proclamation by, you guessed it, agent Orange himself, Prezidoodle Donnie Trumpty-Dumpty.

This is a great and pertinent segment of Amy Goodman’s “Democracy Now,” featuring leaders of the fight for Educational Justice in our schools.

The activists on the front lines include Jitu Brown, National Director of Journey for Justice (and a member of the board of the Network for Public Education); Zakiya Sankara-Jabar, the co-founder of Racial Justice NOW! and field organizer for the Dignity in Schools Campaign. And in New York City, we speak with high school teacher and restorative justice coordinator E.M. Eisen-Markowitz and Mark Warren, co-author of “Lift Us Up, Don’t Push Us Out!”

The transcript begins:

AMY GOODMAN: As Brett Kavanaugh objects to being held accountable for his behavior in high school, we look at the criminalization of black and brown students that’s led to what is known as the school-to-prison pipeline. The movement saw a setback on Sunday when California Governor Jerry Brown vetoed a bill that would have expanded a statewide ban on suspensions for students in kindergarten to third grade to include fourth through eighth graders. The ban focused on suspensions for, quote, “disruption and defiance.” A recent UCLA study found black seventh and eighth graders lost nearly four times the number of school days to such suspensions than white students.

Just last week at Oak View Elementary School in Decatur, Georgia, two teachers resigned after students complained they punished them by zip-tying their hands behind their backs like they were under arrest by police. The students were 4 years old. Writer and activist Shaun King tweeted, “This is the (pre) school to prison pipeline.” One of the girls’ mothers spoke to WSB-TV.

MOTHER: This has really shaken me, to the core. … She said that one teacher tied her up and the other cut it loose. And she said, “Mommy, I was scared to tell you, because I thought I was going to get in trouble.” … I want them to pay. I want them to not have any license to teach, because they don’t need to teach. Who would do this? I mean, would they like this to happen to their own kids?

Where do schools get the idea that children should be treated like criminals? Is this an effort to replicate the no-excuses model of punitive discipline?

Reverend Anika Whitfield wrote an open letter to Arkansas’s State Commisioner of Education, its Governor, and the City Superintendent, complaining about the state takeover of the Little Rock School District. This has long been a goal of the Walton family, the richest, most powerful family in the state and in the nation.

She writes:


Superintendent Poore and Commissioner Key (with a copy to Governor Hutchinson),

How are you able to live with what appears to be placing a hit on the lives of over 17,000 innocent students in the LRSD?

What appears to be your willful cooperation with political and philanthropic interest groups to violate the most vulnerable children in our city by closing their schools; selling (without our permission) their community schools to private charter businesses and to governmental programs that are run by officials who have benefited from a prison industrial system that profits off of incarcerating the lives of many of these same students, is unfathomable.

What does it profit you to watch innocent children suffer at your own hands?

What do you gain by taking away resources from children, families, and educators?

How many families and communities must destroyed before you have seen enough?

Are there any valid examples of affluent neighborhoods and communities that you have imposed your power to take over their children and absolve their patriotic rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness?

What wealthy communities have you tried to force, without the will of the people, to accept a subservient educational business model for educators and students while imposing legalized disenfranchisement of their wealthy parents?

What truthful evidence can you provide that school closures, increasing class sizes, creating job losses by merging schools, and re-segregating communities, has proven to be a successful model in strengthening those same communities?

The plans that were laid out today for the LRSD showed ample evidence that your jobs have been, as has been suspected and predicted since your unorthodox appointments, a political and economic bidding to make wealthy investors like the Walton Family Foundation, Stephen’s, Inc. and others, to gain more wealt by privatizatizing public institutions and disenfranchising persons primarily impacted by poverty and systemic racism.

We have attended your previous school forums in large numbers. We have participated with consistent and persistent voices our opinions and desires to regain locally, elected, representation by our peers.

We have made clear our desires to keep all of our schools open, to raise community economic support for all of the schools and, particularly students, in the LRSD so that all students are attending classes and schools that are excellent.

We have provided plans, options and opportunities to work with you to keep schools open, and to improve the overall moral in schools by creating more community support and developing public accountability.

Yet, despite our active participation in your created system of governance, you have repeatedly denied all of our requests.

What will it will take for you to stop disrespecting and disregarding the voices and presence of our LRSD children, their parents, community?

What is the ransom you require to return our district back into the hands of the LRSD community?

Sincerely,
Rev. Anika T. Whitfield

I don’t know all the details of Trump’s executive order but then neither does he. This much is clear. There are no plans to reunite the 2,342 children with their parents who are now incarcerated. They have been sent to various cities. Do you want one? Apparently the administration plans to incarcerate entire families.

One thing is certain: the Trump policy is cruel, incoherent, and unplanned.

The babies in cages may never see their parents again.

We are an international pariah. We are led by a cruel sociopath.

The stories and images of children separated from their families at the border are shocking. If you are not upset by what our government is doing, you have no heart.

There are times in history that call upon us to take action, raise our voices, do whatever we can to stop grave human rights abuses committed in our name. This is one of those times.

Sure, there are worse human rights abuses in other parts of the world. But this is happening here and now. It is happening because the President of the United States has ordered it to happen.

The Washington Post fact-checker reviewed the claims about the causes of the current human rights disaster.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2018/06/19/the-facts-about-trumps-policy-of-separating-families-at-the-border/

Is it the fault of the Democrats? No. Is there a law requiring family separation? No.

Separating families was a choice made by Donald J. Trump.

The government has now opened what is euphemistically called “tender care” facilities for very young children, including toddlers and babies. The babies cry inconsolably and no adult is allowed to console them. Observers say that the older children change the diapers of the babies. When Rachel Maddow began reading a news clip about the “tender care” facilities, she broke down and cried on air. She couldn’t finish the sentence.

Trump said today he would sign an order to stop family separation. What happens next? Will he incarcerate entire families? What will happen to the children already removed from their moms and dads? Will they ever be reunited? Will we keep them as hostages? The local news station in New York City reported that we got a shipment of children from the border. Will they be put in foster care, never to see their families again? Perhaps auctioned off? What will happen to the babies in Trump’s “tender care” facilities whose parents were deported? Don’t be fooled. Pay attention to the details.

Whether you are a Democrat, a Republican, an independent, whatever, please do what you can. Contact your members of Congress. Join a protest. Act with others to amplify your voice. Bear witness.

Make no mistake. This is a defining moment. Decide where you stand and what you care about. Silence is consent.

I do not consent.

Peter Greene offers a useful summary of the disgraceful, disgusting situation at our borders, where families are separated and children torn from their parents. The law doesn’t say so. It is wrong. It is evil. It is contrary to decency. Yes, we have done evil things in the past, but we should not do this evil thing now. Trump could stop it with a wave of his hand. Babies and toddlers are incarcerated. Their parents may never see them again. Some have been shipped hundreds or thousands of miles from their parents. Some are sent to foster homes. This is inhumane. We disgrace our nation in the eyes of the world.

Their parents broke the law. So what. First of all, as noted above, mostly we’re talking misdemeanors which means this is not the same as what happens to someone who was convicted of murder– it’s like taking the kids away from someone who was caught jay-walking.

The bullshit claims that the feds had to do this because evildoers were pouring across the border, because every brownskinned person is a member of an evil gang and a rapist and murder and we must get rid of them all. This is just racist bullshit with no foundation in reality (just like all racist bullshit).

The Bible. A complete non-starter, and the fact that it has even come up is a sign of how far removed from any serious religious or spiritual thought this administration is. Do we really have to point out that the Bible justified the Inquisition, slavery and a lot of other bad stuff. But if you want a religious take on it, here’s what the United Methodist Church (the one that Jeff Sessions nominally belongs to) has to say in condemnation. And here’s a Twitter thread listing the many religious condemnations of this.

This shameful policy is part of a larger initiative– to cut back the number of brown people coming to this country by making this country so unwelcoming, so cruel, so much worse than what they’re trying to escape that coming to America will be unattractive. That’s now our policy, our new unofficial motto– “If you aren’t white, it sucks to be here and you might as well not come.” That’s as stark a betrayal of our national ideals as we’ve ever seen in our long history of not living up to those ideals. And every gutless member of Congress who can’t find the spine to say so needs to face trouble at the polls come the fall. And really, when this is done, all of us who are worked up about it need to ask if there aren’t perhaps other equally huge but less visceral injustices being perpetrated that we should be throwing our energies against.

Call your member of Congress. Now.