The editorial board of the Miami Herald knows exactly what Ron DeFascist is up to: He wants to remove local control of public schools and gather complete power over what is taught in the schools. He wants to crush unions. He wants to censor books in school libraries. He wants to make sure that students use the bathroom assigned to the gender on their birth certificate. He wants to control the pronouns that teachers use in their classroom (check every student’s birth certificate so you don’t break the last two laws). He wants to control the state curriculum and tests to be certain that only patriotic history is taught. It’s not at all clear whether Black history can be taught (even though it is mandated) unless it meets his approval. He wants to control school boards, and he doesn’t hesitate to select and endorse candidates who share his views. He is power-mad. And he thinks his authoritarian behavior is a model for the nation! He must have skipped history at Harvard.

The Florida Legislature could de-certify many teacher unions in charge of negotiating salaries and working conditions.
Florida Republicans’ ‘ideology patrol’ is coming to a school near you | OpinionBY THE MIAMI HERALD EDITORIAL BOARD
It’s the biggest irony of a state that calls itself “free.”
A basic tenet of America’s political system — one that conservatives, more than liberals, have staunchly defended — is that the government closest to the people is best. But the Florida Legislature, egged on by Gov. DeSantis, is poised to further constrain locally elected school boards from making decisions about books, what teachers can say in the classroom and even school bathroom rules.
If the Republican-led House and Senate get their way, by the time they are done local education will be a mere arm of state leaders who act like the ideological patrol of Florida’s K-12 system. Meanwhile, there’s not enough talk about real issues like post-pandemic learning losses and the shortage of teachers. In fact, lawmakers might make the latter even worse with a union-busting bill that could de-certify many teacher unions in charge of negotiating salaries and working conditions.
So strong is the Legislature’s desire to turn K-12 into a field of culture battles, they are seeking to turn school board races, which are currently nonpartisan, into partisan contests. This would play right into DeSantis’ hands. He’s said that his goal is to elect candidates of his choosing in 2024 local races, including for the Miami-Dade County School Board.
This move would exclude millions of Floridians who aren’t registered with either major party — and who outnumberRepublican voters in Miami-Dade — from voting for their board member in primaries. The saving grace is that this measure would only go into effect if at least 60% of voters in the state approve it as an amendment to the Florida Constitution.
Another bill would relax residency requirements for school board candidates. They would not have to live in the district they want to represent until taking office. This isn’t unheard of in Florida. The same requirement applies to sheriffs and other constitutional officers. But it would allow any outsider with money and backing from, say, a powerful governor to run to represent communities they have no connection to.
To be fair, there are some sound proposals making their way forward at the Capitol. Lawmakers want shorter, eight-year term limits for school board members, down from 12 years. There’s a bill to require instruction on the effects of social media on young people and to ban the use of a school’s internet for social media, unless it’s for education purposes. Senate Bill 52 is ready for a Senate vote and also would ban cellphones in class.
But lawmakers are too busy fighting gender pronouns, sex education and transgender youth.
SB 1674 would make it a second-degree misdemeanor for adults to use a bathroom or “changing facility” that doesn’t align with their sex assigned at birth. The bill also would require districts to come up with “disciplinary procedures” to deal with students who violate the ban, further stigmatizing trans kids who already are often the target of ridicule.
Republican lawmakers want to prohibit teachers and staff from calling students by pronouns that differ from those given to them at birth, even when a parent is OK with it. SB 1320 expands a law that bans instruction on sexual orientation and gender identity — known by critics as “Don’t say gay” — through the eighth grade.
That same bill would also give outsized power to a single person to, at least temporarily, ban books from schools. Districts would be required to pull books that have been challenged while a complaint is being heard. It allows not just parents, but any county resident, to file an objection, likely resulting in blanket attempts by activists to ban books about LGBTQ issues and race.
SB 1320 also would take away school boards’ power to choose textbooks for sexual and reproductive health classes. Instead, that would be up to the Department of Education, which reports to the governor.
Current law already requires districts to teach that abstinence is the “certain way” to prevent pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases and about “the benefits of monogamous heterosexual marriage.” But lawmakers seem to think we still cannot trust the people we elected to run our schools with basic decisions about curriculum.
We’re not fools. This isn’t simply a traditional power grab by Tallahassee. This is an attempt to ensure only certain voices are allowed in public education. Parents and educators who think differently be damned.
What is the difference between Trump and the Hindenburg?
One is a flaming Nazi gasbag. The other is a dirigible.
What is the difference between Ted Cruz and a carp?
One is a slime-trailing bottom-dweller, and the other is a fish.
What is the difference between Rhonda Santis and the Taliban Morality Police?
Got me there. Don’t see any.
Thanks for a belly laugh!!!
100 points for “Rhonda Santis”!😂
This is an excellent summary of DeSantis’ intentions. He is an inflexible despot. Traditional small government conservatives are not happy about the governor’s overreach, but they helped him win the election with 70% of the vote. They are starting to see that DeSantis’ arrogance outstrips his talent. DeSantis wants power without dissent, but democracy doesn’t work that way. DeSantis aspires to be a dictator, and he practically is one in Florida where the legislature rubber stamps all of his bad policies.
DeSantis gets whatever he wants through the Legislature. He silences and punishes dissent. He has total power. Florida is not a “free” state. He is a dictator. Florida is fascist.
Dangerously Deranged Despot DeSantis is a mirror image of the voters he is seducing, Traitor Trump’s support base of autocratic loving, fascist, racist MAGA RINOs.
Literary, movie, tv, and pop-culture references – and history are often overused to make a point about on current events. Some are overreach. If this is, I’ll join the crowd.
This is a “1984” AND “Fahrenheit 451” Orwell/Bradbury mix!
Florida is Germany and their 1933 new leader’s playbook. Control all “branches” of the government. Scapegoats. Fear mongering. Control the schools (and curriculum). Banning professors from speaking, then firing them. Book burnings. Armed citizens and brown shirts. Brainwash youth.
Too many parallels.
“Woke?” Where and how is the voter wake up call on what is going on now… before the next part of that historical playbook begins?
Unlike the exPres, this guy is may be dumb, but he’s not stupid. He knows exactly what he is doing. Calculated.
We live by a mantra of “Never again!”
Couldn’t happen? Think again.
Well said. DeSantis has been conducting a reign of terror in Florida. He is a threat to democracy and must be kept out of The White House. People across the country need to understand this.
I don’t like anything about DeSantis. His cruelty and bigotry are endless. His hatred for dissent is toxic.
But what I hate most is his distortion of language: calling his fascism “freedom.”
Nothing he does promotes freedom. Except the freedom to hate, the freedom to crush dissent. The freedom to carry a lethal weapon without obtaining a permit. The freedom to persecute gays.
Women do not have the freedom to control their bodies. Teachers and professors do not have the freedom to teach honest history about the cruel treatment of Blacks and other minorities.
DeSantis is creating a fascist state where he alone decides what is allowed.
DeSantis’ version of freedom is not a common right that should apply to everyone. DeSantis and many on the right have turned the concept of freedom on its head. It is the right of an individual to make society do what he intends. Right wing extremists believe they can trample on women, LGBTQ folks, immigrants, people of color and democracy itself in the name of so-called freedom. His version of freedom is narrow and wholly selfish.
Nailed it, Diane
How are they trying to decertify unions? They are removing the ability for union dues to be deducted from paychecks by district payroll. I am in one of the 5 largest districts, and only 8% of membership has converted over to the new direct payments system so far. Members who don’t convert by this fall will lose their union membership. Local unions need 60% membership in order to keep their certification.
Who is exempt from this law? Police and firefighters union’s…
Horrifying.
This law clearly violates the U.S. Constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause as it protects police and firefighter unions while making onerous rules for teacher and clerical unions. Scott Walker’s Act 10 did the same thing.
If we had an impartial U.S. Supreme Court, both Act 10 and DeSantis’ laws would be thrown out in a New York minute.
And therein lies the rub.
Interesting that any rightwing attack on unions excludes police and firefighter unions.
https://www.them.us/story/equality-florida-travel-advisory-de-santis?utm_source=nl&utm_brand=them&utm_mailing=THEM_Weekly_041523&utm_campaign=aud-dev&utm_medium=email&bxid=5c490be624c17c4434347a73&cndid=40532397&hasha=95d1304bfa4647a0a7cf24c1b3945a21&hashb=6ad8ee177c261ccbd3ac2ee09d5010bcb6425bde&hashc=fe902256dd3510b4471f668ee1b8a41613fe438abca27d7e0d964ad83ac854bf&esrc=bounceX&utm_term=THEM_Daily
“lwmakers want shorter, eight-year term limits for school board members, down from 12 years.”
Seems like even 8 years is waay too long.
Why should school board members be elected for 8 years when House Representatives are only elected for 2?
Maybe if school board members only served for one year, billionaires would not deem it worth their while to spend money on their campaigns in places like Miami and LA
Surely, school board is not the type of job that requires a particularly long learning curve.
My guess is a few weeks would probably suffice for most people to come up to speed.
And if it does take a person a long time to come into speed, I’d say they have no business serving on the school board go begin with.
I assume that the terms of school board members are only 2 or 4 years, limited to no more than 8. There are no term limits for members of Congress.
State control. Authoritarian grip on the education system. Indoctrination through propaganda.
Yep, classic old school early Cold War.
Stalin would be proud.
If your public school district relies on Units of Study and/or Fountas & Pinnell materials and you live in California get your child’s reading skills assessed independently.
If there are ongoing issues with reading you need to get your child out of there: switch to a district with a better curriculum, privately tutor, or go to private school.
Systematic change in California is unlikely, which is a shame, because public schools in many districts are captured by people who will not budge on this issue.
Broader issues of literacy equity are very important, but we need all the readers we can in our society. By ensuring your child can read you are helping society.
Do not hesitate to get OUT if necessary to get your kids reading.
What should I do if my kid used that system, learned to love books, and I was glad that instead of spending endless hours doing phonics worksheets and many months bored and learning to hate reading, they loved reading? What if my kid’s very small public school grade had an usually large number of students who were extremely accomplished readers and writers in middle school and later on thanks to that program? Or perhaps because that program didn’t turn them off of reading like phonics would have.
Many parents liked the whole reading approach because they had memories of their own endless phonics lessons they didn’t need and hated.
I wish – just once – that education journalists stopped rewriting press releases and started doing real reporting.
“Phonics” and “Fountas & Pinnell” and “Units of Study” are all DIFFERENT approaches to reading. Just because you have a kid who responds extremely positively to one way and extremely negatively to another way does not give you the right as a parent to demand that the way that worked for your kid be used in the schools.
Good public school teachers with experience know this, which is why even if their school used Lucy Calkins, they always incorporated a little phonics and incorporated MORE phonics only for students who needed that. Or they used a 3rd approach.
Inexperienced teachers (often found in charter schools) are taught that kids who don’t respond to the one way of teaching that works miracles are “bad” or “not trying hard enough”. Private schools can use any approach to teaching and parents whose kids don’t respond simply hire tutors to teach their kids.
How about we all agree that kids aren’t widgets to be made in a factory? Good teachers – especially in the early “learn to read” years – respond to the student and don’t berate, punish or humiliate the student for not responding to a specific curriculum. If your kid is lucky enough to go to a public school with an experienced, good teacher, they will learn to read.
If your kid is unlucky enough to go to a school that tells teachers that students who don’t learn via (phonics/units of study/Fountas & Pinnell) are at fault, I hope that your kid goes to a public school that will have to address your kid’s learning struggles and not a charter or private school that can just counsel them out and tell them it’s their fault for not learning via phonics or whatever the charter or private school uses.
I am so sick of journalists amplifying whatever parent voices are the loudest or supported by the most powerful people and presenting them as if they represent a vast majority of parents.
There should be more than one approach to reading in EVERY school. Whenever I read an article hyping one particular way or bashing another particular way, I know someone has an agenda that does not include caring one iota about the students.
This article should have been profiling teachers who understand this, instead of parents unhappy with one way who believe that some other way that worked for their kid should be imposed on all students.
“Meanwhile, there’s not enough talk about real issues like post-pandemic learning losses. . .
Those supposed learning losses are not a “real issue” as they are based on invalid standardized test scores.