We saw this coming. The GOP candidates for President have decided, for now, to focus their campaigns against “critical race theory,” Black history, the threat posed by transgender students, and any teaching about race, sex, and gender.
Juan Perez of Politico reports:
CULTURE CLASH — Once upon a time, back when people used fax machines, education policy — test scores, spending, school choice and the like — were a notable feature of Republican presidential campaigns.
Former President George W. Bush’s support for education spending and the transformative No Child Left Behind Act was enshrined in the party’s 2004 platform. Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee railed that a general lack of concern about education in the 2008 presidential field “frustrates the fire out of me.” Bush’s brother, Jeb, invoked Martin Luther King Jr.in 2016 when he proposed a detailed education platform before his campaign fizzled.
This year, education is re-emerging as a prominent issue for the budding 2024 GOP field. But America is poised to witness a presidential contest where the debate over school policy sounds dramatically different — with discussions over academic standards and the stunning, once-in-a-generation hitto test scores taking a back seat to issues with a more distinct culture war bent.
Former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley is salting a back-to-basics education mantra with brimstone, targeting school lessons on race and sexuality. Former Vice President Mike Pence has put a small Iowa school system’s gender identity policy in the national spotlight. And Former President Donald Trump is stirring up concerns about “pink-haired communists teaching our kids.”
Haley’s campaign launch last week offered a sign of the heightened role the education wars are about to play in the GOP primary.
“They’re talking about critical race theory, where if you send a five year old kindergartner into school — if she’s white, you’re telling her she’s bad, and if she’s brown or Black you’re telling her she’s never going to be good enough and she’s always going to be a victim,” Haley said of the academic practice to a New Hampshire crowd last week. “That’s abusive.”
She added that a Florida ban on sexual orientation and gender identity lessons for young students — championed by rival Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis and dubbed by critics as the “Don’t Say Gay” law — “didn’t go far enough.”
“When I was growing up, we didn’t have sex ed until seventh grade,” Haley said to applause in New Hampshire. “That’s the kind of stuff you do at home, you don’t do that at school. That’s the kind of thing parents do.”
For his part, Pence has focused attention on an Iowa dispute, in which the conservative Parents Defending Education organization is suing the Linn-Mar Community School District to stop it from enforcing a policy that directs educators to protect their students’ gender identities on campus.
The court case has garnered supportive briefs from the Pence-backed Advancing American Freedom organization plus a coalition of Christian groups and Republican state attorneys general. The legal battle is also the focus of a Pence political initiative— funded with an initial budget of $1 million — that will advocate for “parental rights” policies embraced by conservatives.
“We’re told that we must not only tolerate the left’s obsessions with race and sex and gender but we must earnestly and enthusiastically participate or face severe consequences,” Pence told supporters last week. “Nowhere is the problem more severe, or the need for leadership more urgent, than in our public school classrooms,” he said.
Trump’s education plan, unveiled last month, calls for cutting federal funding for any school or program that includes “critical race theory, gender ideology, or other inappropriate racial, sexual, or political content onto our children.”
Trump would also open civil rights investigations into any school district that has engaged in race-based discrimination, particularly against Asian American students. He also called to “keep men out of women’s sports,” make significant cuts to school administrative personnel, elect school principals and end teacher tenure.
“As the saying goes, personnel is policy and at the end of the day if we have pink-haired communists teaching our kids we have a major problem,” Trump said.
Sen. Tim Scott, who is testing the waters on a potential presidential bid, is taking a less combative approach. Speaking at a GOP Black History Month event in Charleston last week, the South Carolina senator said “the story of America is not defined by our original sin, the story of America is defined by our redemption” and urged Republicans to “be the party of parents.”
Scott and others are responding to the GOP grassroots energy surrounding issues at the intersection of race, gender, culture and education — which Virginia GOP Gov. Glenn Youngkin successfully harnessed in his 2021 blue-state victory.
The sharp-edged rhetoric might get sanded down for the general election. But for now, not getting outflanked on education controversies that currently animate the right appears to be the first order of business for the 2024 field.
More likely that Trump will be campaigning against Critical Indictment Theory
The theory that the wealthy and influential should be prosecuted for crimes just like everyone else.
Lard knows, it’s a crackpot, unAmerican theory.
We should certainly not make the wealthy and influential pay or even feel guilty for the crimes they commit.
Touche’
Silly rabbit! Lawmaking, interpretation, and execution on the “just like everyone else” principle is so yesterday. Trix ain’t just a cereal anymore. It’s a legal doctrine.
But that Critical Indictment Theory could make wealthy children feel bad about themselves . . .
You need to copyright that one, booklady. Beautiful! Going to steal it regardless. Sue me.
Glad you are back with witty comments and rhymes.
YES!!!
Hundreds of Omaha Nebraska High School Students walked out of class Friday 3/31.They are not buying the Crazy Hate Filled Culture War being waged all around them. Everyone carried colorful placards, sang songs, read poems and denounced the demented politicians legislating lawlessness.
The kids were joined by parents and community members.
And these protests were happening all over the USA on 3/31!
https://omaha.com/news/local/education/omaha-central-high-students-walk-out-of-class-to-protest-trans-youth-bills/article_8bf68ec2-cca7-11ed-bb89-37246454e48b.html#tncms-source=login
Thank you for sharing. Finally started the day with some optimism for a change!
Everywhere the GOP tries to sell its false narrative they should be met by protesters that value public education and function it serves in our society.
The GOP doesn’t have a platform that they can talk about because it would lose them votes. We know they are targeting seniors’ benefits. Instead of talking about a losing proposition, they will run their campaign on the bogus culture wars that will rile up the extremist faction in their party and cause a ruckus and get a lot of free media attention.
yes, yes, yes
Democrats would do well to study of SPD candidate Olaf Scholz’s winning campaign in Germany two summers ago. I was there for a while and the messaging of the campaign was disciplined, simple, and spoke volumes
about the irrelevance of most of the opposition’s policy proposals to average
people. Probably the best campaign I have ever witnesses in my life. It had three basic taglines that were featured in campaign posters (they do not do bumper stickers) all around cities and towns. They didn’t get into a tit-for-tat debate on what the opposition wanted to do, they focused on what was important to the daily lives of average people.
Chancellor for Germany (Kanzler für Deutschland) – they would not be
drawn into irrelevant debates about non- or contrived political issues, they
intended to govern for all Germans.
Respect for You (Respekt für dich) – cuts right to heart of issues meant to divide
Competence for Germany (Komptenz für Deutschland) – Biden’s got that and needs to tout it, not defend it against lies
One of the most effective party slogans of the local Berlin SPD: More than 100 Languages. One one vote against the right. (Über 100 Sprachen. Und eine Stimme gegen Rechts.)
And one vote against the right.
“Competence for Germany (Komptenz für Deutschland) – Biden’s got that and needs to tout it”
Most Americans won’t care if Biden has “competence for Germany.” And they shouldn’t.
Sadly, Duane, you seem not to be an abstract thinker on this topic. You can’t see the forest for your cherished, selected stereotypes. Let’s try this. Democrats should consider building campaigns around these three themes as a complete package for the 2024 campaign and coordinate with all federal and state office races:
President For the United States of America
Respect For You (Hopefully don’t need to interpret that for you)
Competence for America
How’s that?
Sarcasm, Greg, Sarcasm!
Biden has tried to avoid tit for tat with insane GOP like McCarthy, Greene, Boebert, etc.
He has tried to show leadership, vision, future-oriented. They bite at his heels.
I would only add that Biden HAS shown leadership in addition to trying, decisive at that, with the great exception of education. His three minute improvisation at the SOTU may have been the greatest political moment I have ever witnessed live in my life.
Here’s an ad I would run if I were a PAC supporting the Democratic Party:
Narrator: (As numerous images of schools, students, and teachers engaged in learning are shown across the screen) “In the early twentieth century the United States of America reinforced a universal commitment to Public Schools. This resulted in an economic powerhouse that generated more wealth than at any time in the history of the world. The alumni of these schools led Democratic governments in the defeat of tyranny in World War II and resulted in the establishment of universities that are the envy of the world. Industry and finance thrived. Yes, the public schools did this.”
(Pan to politicians advocating privatization and attacking teachers) “Today, there are those who would like to pretend that the public schools have been a failure. That government efforts to educate our children could never produce the work force that would result from subsidies for private efforts. They are wrong!”
(Show closed charter buildings and parents seeking help for their children) “Any implementation of vouchers has resulted in subsidies for those who already attend private schools, charters have not outperformed public schools academically, and closing public schools with unfulfilled promises of better results has resulted in decimated communities.”
(Pan to schools and parents who are engaged with their public schools in the myriad of ways this happens every day). The only way to improve educational opportunity in America is to vigorously fund our Public Schools. To support teachers through greater resources, district support, and higher pay. To provide facilities that are equally great in all communities. America has thrived through our support of public schools. We as citizens, need to recommit to Public Schools with our purse and our fervor.”
Nice “commercial”!
But what makes you think that the Dims have the capability to properly disseminate that message?
I can only hope…
Here’s a recommended soundbite to accompany: We live in the wealthiest, most powerful nation in the history of the world and more than 95% percent of the people who accomplished it went to public schools. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.
Absolutely!
Excellent, Paul!!
Magnificent, Paul!
I think the cultural war the MAGARINO Party is waging is relying on all those surviving Republican voters that refused to wear masks and be vaccinated to protect them from COVID that are now living with Long COVID and brain fog.
“Nearly half of patients report either poor memory or brain fog, according to a JAMA Network Open study on long COVID symptoms. And it doesn’t just afflict patients who were sick enough to need a ventilator or hospital care—it can affect anyone who has been infected with SARS-CoV-2.”
Since MAGARINO voters were already mentally challenged before COVID, the ones living with Long COVID today now have brain damage on top of the inability to think critically.
“Covid death rates are higher among Republicans than Democrats, mounting evidence shows — Lower vaccination rates among Republicans could explain the partisan gap, but some researchers say mask use and social distancing were bigger factors.”