Carol Burris is the executive director for of the Network for Public Education. in this post, which she wrote exclusively for the blog, she reveals the details of Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders’ plan to defund and destroy the public schools in her state.
Burris writes:
Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the daughter of Baptist minister and former Governor Mike Huckabee, missed learning the 9th commandment that prohibits telling a lie. As press secretary to Donald Trump, her distortions of the truth resulted in the editor of Forbes warning corporations against hiring Sanders and other Trump “propagandists,” writing, “Forbes will assume that everything your company or firm talks about is a lie.”
Now she is the Governor of Arkansas. On her first day in office and in her response to Biden’s State of the Union, she parroted the old “education is the civil rights issue of our time” line that has been used to justify horrible policies from school closures to charter schools and vouchers. However, the disconnect between what she says and what she does quickly became apparent. On her first day in office, she issued an executive order prohibiting “indoctrination and critical race theory in schools” and another banning the term “Latinx” from being used in state documents. State authorities are investigating AP African American Studies at Little Rock Central High School, where the majority of students are Black.
If we need further proof that this self-proclaimed champion of Civil Rights is more aptly described as a champion of Civil Wrongs, look at her recently leaked ed reform plan.
Here are its features:
The Privatization of Public Education:
· Her voucher plan is a universal ESA—the plan now favored by the far-right. These plans have few rules and no family eligibility requirements. They have become Entitlement Spending Accounts–cash going into the pockets of private school families regardless of income. The leaked plan does not say how taxpayers will pay for it. But everyone will be eligible by 2025. It includes Voucher funding for homeschools. The only restrictions will apply to vendors, so those who enroll their children in those recently uncovered Neo-Nazi homeschools can find ways to cash in.
· Increased tax credits for contributions to an existing voucher program.
· Local School Boards can contract with an open-enrollment charter school or private company to run a school campus at risk of state takeover due to low performance—and if they do, they get a financial incentive.
· Establishment of a charter-school construction fund for new charters and expansion.
· Elimination of the cap on charters.
· Charter school applications no longer need to be reviewed and approved by the local school district board of directors.
· All students attending a public school can take courses and earn credit for classes not offered in their school. By the beginning of the 2025-2026 school year, students attending a public school that receives a letter grade of “C”, “D”, or “P” from the Arkansas School and District Accountability System may take their required courses (i.e. math, English, etc.) through the course choice program. Bet your bottom dollar that these courses will be online, with vendors like Stride K12 making a fortune.
Censoring and Controlling Curriculum
· K-3 literacy evaluation will be aligned with the “science of reading.”
· Before grade 5, teachers cannot provide classroom instruction on the following topics: sexually explicit materials, sexual reproduction, sexual intercourse, gender identity, and sexual orientation.
· School districts must implement an age-appropriate child sexual prevention program for grades K-12, allowing parents to preview materials and exempt their children from instruction. (I have no idea what a child sexual prevention program even is.)
· The Secretary of Education will review the Department of Education regulations, policies, materials, and communications to ensure they do not indoctrinate students with ideologies that conflict with the principle of equal protection under the law.
· No school employee or student must attend training on prohibited indoctrination or Critical Race Theory.
Harmful Policies for Students
· 3rd-grade retention based on deficits in reading proficiency.
· An accountability system for pre-school education that includes student data.
· Literacy testing three times a year for all students in K-3.
· Curriculum tracking in Grade 8.
· Community service requirements, which may, for some students, be challenging to meet.
· Mandated cops on campus.
· Career-ready pathways in partnership with local business and industry leaders” translate workforce training programs to track students into low-paying and middle-wage jobs.
Punitive Policies for Teachers
· Elimination of due process in dismissals.
· Base salaries will no longer increase by years of experience or for Master’s degrees.
· Bonuses based on VAM.
There are a few likable initiatives in her plan, such as paid maternity leave for teachers, but if she makes districts fund them even as she drains their funding with charter schools and voucher expansion, a good initiative will be one more financial pressure on already underfunded schools.
Sarah Huckabee Sanders’ education plan is a hodgepodge of all the awful and ineffective ideas proposed since No Child Left Behind. The fingerprints of JEB! and the Walton family are over the leaked legislation.
Despite its hodgepodge nature, one thing is clear—its ultimate intent is to destroy public education in the state by slamming a fist down on students, public schools, and their teachers while propping up a wild and largely unaccountable privatized system.
Maybe it should be “education is the civil war of our time”? or worse…”Education is the civil riots of our time?”
Haaa. Yes.
It seems clear that there is a coordinated national effort to implement similar plans, particularly in red states. Has anyone investigated the use of consultants in these processes? Although they appear to be independently contracted with a variety of districts, it is curious that their methods and proposals so closely mirror one another. In my district, they sloppily left the name of another city on their initial presentation. It is also interesting that they were hired almost simultaneously in urban school districts. I suspect that this was a broad initiative of The Heritage Foundation or some other privatization advocacy group and that the “consultants” were politically connected and given a script. New austerity proposals dovetail far too well with the predictable outcomes of these studies. I would love to see some investigative journalism on this point.
I bet you are right about this!
I’d like to see investigative journalism about Harvard and school privatization. The reporter could start background info. with a review of Prof. Martin West’s curriculum vitae.
West lists Co-PI for the Charles Koch-funded ($2,650,000), 2020-2024, “Accelerating the Pace of Ed Reform.”
Other grants listed as associated with West are from the Walton Family Foundation (since 2014, close to $3.7 mil.) and, for 2022-23, from (John) Arnold Ventures, $63,689. The Gates Foundation is listed, also.
The reporter could get more info. from West’s bio listed at the Federalist Society site.
In 2009, West wrote a paper about the following subject, “Catholic resistance to state run schooling in many countries in the 1900’s helped create institutional configurations that continue to spur student achievement.”
A speech given about the paper had the title, “Every Catholic in a Catholic School.” The paper is on-line at res.org.uk, with the title, “Competition from private schools boosts achievement for both private and state schools.”
The reporter could, then, review Theocracy Watch i.e. the training manual of the Koch-funded Paul Weyrich (conservative Catholic) who was co-founder of the religious right, ALEC and the Heritage Foundation (Ginny Thomas, wife of Clarence, took home more than $600,00 while working there).
Another avenue of reporting could be the almost 50 state Catholic Conferences, the bishops’ political arm, and their. involvement in school choice in states like Kentucky and Indiana. The journalist could also report about the state Catholic Conferences that co-host school choice rallies with the Koch’s AFP.
An insightful addition to the article could focus on Harvard Law Professor, Adrian Vermuele, who thinks Catholic immigrants should get preference in the queue for the U.S. Vermuele has been described as the nation’s most dangerous critic of liberalism.
Martin West is on the Mass. State Board of Education.
Yes and, he is a non-resident senior fellow at Brookings and he has a position at Education Next. From 2015-2016, he was a research fellow at Hoover Institute.
His current projects include studies of public opinion on education policy and influence of relative pay in teacher quality, among others.
West, editor-in-chief of The Journal at Education Next, co-wrote a winter 2023 article. Readers can look at it and make their own decisions about objectivity.
Arkansas schools are already near the bottom of the barrel. I think she is going for the “We are number 50!” plaque.
Bingo
“I love the uneducated.”
–Her boss, Glorious Leader Who Shines More Orange Than Does the Sun
Of course, his boss is Putin. It’s cads all the way down.
Spelling correction:
That’s Que Sera Slanders Huckster-bee
Base salaries will no longer increase by years of experience or for Master’s degrees.
This is based upon the “findings” of The Gates Foundation for Royally Screwing up American Education that having advanced degrees or more experience doesn’t correlate with dramatic improvements on the completely unscientific and invalid state standardized mismeasurements that Billy Boy so dearly loves.
Mike Huckabee, “humble pastor,” bought a mansion on the Gulf of Mexico in the Florida Panhandle. He tried to privatize the beach in front of his home despite neighbors’ objections, and the neighbors sued him and won. Florida has a public beach law in the state, fortunately.
I relate this because it exemplifies a lot of thinking of right wing extremists. They are obsessed with their own sense of self importance. They have little regard for civic responsibility. Only their beliefs and experiences matter, and they have no problem imposing their biased beliefs on others. Sarah Huckabee Sanders is cut from the same cloth so undermining the common good is part of her sense of natural order of things.
“. . . another banning the term “Latinx” from being used in state documents.”
At least she got one thing right. All of the latinos with whom I’ve spoken do not like “Latinx” finding it to be an American absurdity.
I didn’t ever think about this because I never used it. But I think we agree, the nuance that you see and I have been enlightened about has absolutely nothing to do with her decision. Her’s is a third way, which I think we also agree, that is much, much more sinister intent. Built on a whole different type of classification that neither side argues.
Up here in the NE corner of the country, highly saturated as we are with students and academics, “Latinx” has gained some currency, especially among younger speakers. Not pronounced as Latin-X, though!
In Spain and in the parts of South America which are fond of their ties to the continent “Latine”, closer to the linguistic origin, shows up, again with younger speakers having a higher usage.
But how Spanish heritage language users speak and write is none of the Huckster’s business and such a regulation, which requires public servants to remove the word from all government publications retroactively are nothing more than a performative waste of time and money.
Duane,
That’s what people used to say about “Ms.” They said: “all the ladies I know find Ms. to be a feminist absurdity”. It still astonishes me that Ms. became so common that no one even associates the women using it as being a “fem-nazi” anymore. But there was a time when they did.
I don’t really have an opinion on Latinx — I defer to those who are Latinx. But I have a very strong opinion about those who insist that the term is an “absurdity”. Because I remember when good people said the same about “Ms”.
I know. But the fact that was the first place she went speaks volumes.
exactly
Arkansas: The Ej-u-ka-tian State
Arkansas: Working for Walmart
It’s impressive that C. Burris wrote this post exclusively for Dr Ravitch’s blog, but it deserves national exposure as a Letter to Editor or OpEd.
I wish that too. But it’s not so easy to get published in one of the big papers.
It is indeed.
There’s Huckabee and fellow GOP’er Janel Brandtjen of Wisconsin who is a die hard Trump supporter. At the Brandtjen campaign site she lists receipt of an award from the Wisconsin Catholic Conference. She tweeted the name of a large insurance company with the claim that its, “charitable” donation to City Forward was a “scathing rebuke of MSP and teachers unions.”
With Walmart just down the road, she has plenty of support for destroying public education.