Archives for category: Ravitch, Diane

In November, New Yorkers will elect a new mayor.

It matters a lot for the future of public education in the city.

The mayor has complete control of the city school system.

The mayor appoints 8 of 13 members of the city school board, who serve at his pleasure. If one of his appointees dares to disagree with him, the mayor may fire him or her on the spot.

Mayor Bloomberg has closed more than 100 schools and opened hundreds more. He has closed some of the schools that he opened. What matters most to the mayor is test scores. He grades students, schools, teachers, and principals by test scores.

The scores went up and up until 2010, when the State Education Department admitted the tests got easier every year. Overnight the “Néw York City miracle” disappeared.

Recently, the mayor embraced the Common Core standards. When the test results came out, the scores of 2012 collapsed, the achievement gaps grew larger, and the mayor said all this was “very good news.”

The mayor is devoted to charter schools. Although he is responsible for the public schools, he prefers privately managed charters and plans to open four of his own, as soon as he leaves office. His DOE is already setting aside the free space for these schools that will be created by billionaires Bloomberg and George Soros.

The results of Bloomberg’s “reforms” are unimpressive. Despite boasts to the contrary, he did not close the achievement gaps.

A recent study by the Economic Policy Institute found that the three “market-reform” districts–NYC, DC, and Chicago–got worse results than other urban districts.

The public is fed up with the Bloomberg era of imperial, autocratic “reform.” The latest polls show that only 22% want the next mayor to continue Bloomberg’s school reforms.

What’s next?

I fear that most of the candidates are trapped in Bloomberg’s cramped data-driven vision of schooling.

I want the next mayor to think about how to improve education, not how to raise test scores.

I want the next mayor to stop closing public schools. I want him or her to abandon Bloomberg’s obsession with testing and measurement. I want the mayor to stop giving absurd letter grades to schools. We learned from the Tony Bennett scandal just how malleable and how meaningless the A-F letter grades are.

I want the next mayor to take responsibility for the 95% of the students in the city’s public schools, not act as a cheerleader for the charter sector that enrolls 5% and kicks out or excludes low-scoring students.

I want a mayor who has a different vision.

I want a mayor who believes that it is his or her responsibility to provide a good school in every neighborhood. I want a mayor who is devoted to strengthening the schools, not closing them or privatizing them. I want a mayor who understands that improving the lives of children, families, and communities will improve schools. I want a mayor committed to early childhood education, to class size reduction, and to the arts in every school.

I want a mayor determined to make sure that every school has a full curriculum, experienced teachers, daily physical education, foreign languages, and adequate resources to help children who are learning English and children with disabilities.

I have an even more radical idea: Here is an interview I did recently on NY1, the local news station. Watch to hear what I propose. If the mayor acted on my proposal, he or she would become a national figure and an instant hero to millions of parents, students, and teachers.

I received this comment after writing that Moses had to take his people into the desert for 40 years because a new generation had to be born who would think as free men, not slaves.

Kathy wrote this:

Dear Diane: Learning how to think like free people/educators and not slaves really is the central message. I am hoping you have a slew of press appearances when the September book debuts. I know that will be physically taxing so please, everybody send Diane the required energy because we desperately need you to broadcast loud and clear. This may be our collective last chance to really get the word out. The corporate culture of NCLB and the advent of Common Core are the new Jim Crow but this incarnation is attacking the growth and development of every USA child. Crippled citizens won’t take this nation forward and neither will an oligarchy nurtured in a wave of not very good, (segregated by color and class) private and charter schools. This is a democracy where we receive our possibilities from one another, a gift and a responsibility. Kathy

Kathy, I need your good wishes, and even your prayers. Given my age, I need all the energy you can send my way.

There will be many speaking engagements, many opportunities to explain to the public what we should be doing instead of demonizing teachers and public education.

Hopefully, even some TV time, though I don’t know about that yet. Until now, the privatizers have commanded the air waves.

I promise I will stand up for you, I will fight for you.

I can’t do it alone.

I need you.

I need all the Badass Teachers.

I need everyone to speak up, act up, act out, in defense of children’s right to a childhood; in defense of a noble profession, which is being destroyed by heedless politicians; in defense of public education, which is an essential institution in a democratic society.

You may find this hard to believe, Kathy, but I think the tide is turning.

I think the whole ed reform project is collapsing in slow motion.

Not only is the public awakening to the damage the “reformers” are doing, but every one of their ill-founded ideas has failed.

Thus far, they have “succeeded” only in demoralizing teachers and principals, closing public schools by the dozens, and turning education into nothing more than testing and test prep.

We will win, because we are on the right side of children and of education and of democracy.

I have never debated Michelle Rhee.

I am ready and willing whenever she is.

At a panel discussion convened by Henry Louis Gates Jr. at Martha’s Vineyard in 2011, Michelle and I were on the same panel.

I arrived a day early, knowing how beautiful Edgartown is. Michelle arrived literally one minute before the panel started. She flew in from Florida, after speaking to an event on behalf of the for-profit charter operator Charter Schools USA. Although there was a lovely reception afterwards, she did not stay for it, so we had no time to talk.

You may recognize some other members of the panel. It was moderated by Charlayne Hunter-Gault. Dr. James Comer was there, as was Dr. Laurence Bobo of Harvard and Dr. Angel Harris of Princeton. If you have time, you should watch the whole panel discussion. It was outstanding.

Michelle and I had only a few direct exchanges, but you will get a sense of our differences on this Youtube video, which someone unknown to me edited and forwarded.

I mentioned a few days ago that I will have a regular Monday conversation with Pete Dominick on Sirius-XM at 7:35 am EST or thereabouts. At the time I did not know which channel the show is on.

It is 104.

Last week we talked about testing. Pete takes callers, so call in.

Pete Dominick has a regular show on Sirius-XM called “Stand Up! with Pete Dominick.” He invited me to discuss the state of education every Monday morning at 7:35 am EST.

This was our first conversation, this morning.

Pete has children in public school and is very concerned about over-testing. He is right.

Today, this blog passed the three million page view marks.

That represents the number of times someone has read a post here.

The blog started April 24, 2012.

Thank you, readers.

We will continue to learn from one another.

We will continue to stand strong for a high-quality education for all.

We will continue to advocate equality of opportunity.

Thank you!

Thank you for reading the blog.

Thank you for joining what must surely be the liveliest discussion about education issues anywhere on the Web.

I did not know how this blog would evolve when I started it on April 26 last year. Since then, it has had more than 2.7 million page views. So I know it meets a need for a place that welcomes candid exchanges about the issues that concern us all.

This is an unusual platform. It is a place where the voices of educators, parents, and students get a full hearing. It is a place where those who exhibit unusual courage on behalf of public education and freedom of expression are honored. It is a place for the candid exchange of ideas.

I want to share a few thoughts.

Some bloggers post once or twice a week. I post anywhere from six to twenty times every single day.

In other words, I work very hard to provide you with information and discussion from all parts of the nation–and occasionally from other nations as well.

And I expect a lot from you. You get lots of posts from me every day. Some people don’t like that. They have a right not to like it, and if they don’t want all that information they should not subscribe. No one is compelled to read here. You have freedom of choice to stay or go.

I also count on you to correct any errors I make. Sometimes I forget to add the link. A few times I have posted without the title. Sometimes I make typos. You help me by pointing out my errors so I can fix them.

I don’t have all the answers. I often turn to you to get your thoughts. I lean on you for your knowledge. I respect your experience as teachers, students, administrators, parents, and school board members. If we put our heads together, if we listen to one another, if we learn from one another, we can move forward. I believe we are having a national impact. Some posts from this blog have been quoted in the national press.

Because I respect your views and want to hear them, because we need a space to share our ideas, I take offense when people use the comment section to behave in a rude and uncivil manner. I won’t permit it. I also won’t permit anyone to ride a hobbyhorse and bash teachers or any other group. There is unlimited space on the blog for disagreement, but not for prejudice and bile..

Sometimes people ask me how I get so much information from districts across the nation. The short answer is that I depend on the kindness of strangers. Readers send me clippings from their local and state media. I don’t post everything I get but I try to share what I find interesting. And I frequently post your comments. If you sign your name, I include it. If you don’t, then I reprint your words without your name. I understand why many people–especially educators–need anonymity in a time when dissent is not welcome.

Sometimes I get guest posts, and I share them with you.

As I have pointed out in the past, I am the sole moderator of the comments. I read them all. The only ones I block are those that contain obscenities; those that insult me personally (sorry, it’s my space); and those that go on a rant about how Newtown never happened or 9/11 was a U.S. government plot or other nutty themes. I believe in freedom of speech, but I have my limits. This is my living room, and I don’t want rude, uncivil people to dominate the conversation or to insult the host.

This is a site to discuss better education for all. It is a conversation. I thank you for joining the conversation and making it a place where the voices of parents, students, and educators are welcomed with respect.

Let me know what you think. My goal is to let you know you have allies in our shared vision for better education for all. My goal is to provide a forum where we can figure out how to survive the deluge of misguided reforms that are overwhelming our schools. My goal is to support those who are doing the work of society by educating children. My goal is to give you a realistic picture of where we are, what is happening, and why we must continue to work for real change.

I believe that good sense and good ideas will eventually prevail so long as we work together and demonstrate courage on behalf of what’s right, not what’s demanded or imposed by higher powers.

We are everywhere.

Diane

As readers may recall, I started a new book last June.

I finished it and turned it over to the editor on January 15.

The manuscript was nearly 600 pages.

In print form, it should be about half that length.

If you have been reading the blog all along, you know what is in the book.

Now it’s time to catch a break.

I am taking a one-week vacation starting January 31.

The blog will still be here every day, as I will have some pieces in the pipeline and I have invited some of my favorite bloggers to write guest posts.

This will be the year that the public begins to see who the corporate reformers are and the havoc they are wreaking on schools and communities.

Diane

Someone I do not know sent me a surprising gift: a memory of what I said, who I was.

Memory plays tricks on us, and sometimes I learn things about myself from people I met or knew many years ago. And I wonder, “did I do that? Did I say that?”

Here is my gift from Nathaniel Smith:

“A bit of history about Diane: In a post “Diane Ravitch on and since 1/11/88″ at http://politicswestchesterview.wordpress.com/, I wrote up my notes on a talk she gave 25 years ago to the day at Franklin and Marshall College on 1/11/88. I tended to agree with her then, and i agree with her even more now!”

Faithful readers of the blog may recall that I started a new book last June.

I am pleased to announce that it will be published next fall by Knopf, the finest publishing house in the United States.

The title is under wraps for now.

If you have been reading the blog, you know what it’s about.