Archives for category: Betsy DeVos

Politico discusses the state plans to implement the Every Student Succeeds Act and raises the question:

Why are these uninformed, distant, unqualified people allowed to tell schools what to do?

Betsy DeVos and everyone she has appointed hates public schools. Why should they be trusted to give them instructions? Left to her own devices, DeVos would cripple public schools with regulations and mandates intended to drive students to unregulated charters and religious schools. Nothing qualifies this woman for the position she holds. She knows nothing about public schools, nothing about instruction, nothing about teaching. She was put there by Trump and Pence to destroy our public schools.

“HOUSE TACKLES ESSA IMPLEMENTATION TODAY: The House Education and the Workforce Committee this morning will hear from federal, state and local officials on their efforts to carry out the Every Student Succeeds Act. “Given the monumental shift in education policy represented by ESSA, it is important that we hear how implementation is progressing,” Chairwoman Virginia Foxx is expected to say . “We know the law will not fully take effect until the coming school year, and we will need time to assess its impact on schools and students. However, I look forward to hearing from today’s witnesses about the progress states, school districts, and the Department of Education are making.”

– While the hearing will primarily focus on state and local implementation of the law, Foxx is also expected to say that the committee will be watching the Education Department for any signs of overreach. The hearing comes as Secretary Betsy DeVos’ agency is under fire for its feedback on state ESSA plans. Some advocates and state education chiefs believe federal officials haven’t been consistent in their feedback or they’ve been reading the law too strictly, limiting the flexibility that was promised to states since ESSA’s passage in 2015. Senate HELP Committee Chairman Lamar Alexander said last week that Jason Botel, acting assistant secretary for elementary and secondary education, “hasn’t read the law carefully.” Botel should nix the back-and-forth with states over their plans, Alexander said.

– GAO will release a report in conjunction with the hearing, called, “Early Observations on State Changes to Accountability Systems.” Jacqueline Nowicki, director of K-12 education policy at GAO, is expected to say that some states are using the law’s flexibility “to significantly change their accountability systems while others are making more limited changes,” according to prepared testimony obtained by POLITICO. The Education Department is also trying to determine “whether there is a need for additional guidance to states on aspects of ESSA implementation,” Nowicki will say. Democrats and some advocates believe additional guidance is sorely needed, since Republicans earlier this year scrapped the Obama administration’s ESSA accountability regulations.

– A lack of “clear regulations” has presented “challenges,” Phillip Lovell, vice president of policy and government relations for the advocacy group Alliance for Excellent Education is expected to say . The Education Department’s feedback to states on their plans has proven “confusing” and “insufficient.” This isn’t good because “the quality of ESSA state plans is uneven,” Lovell will say, stressing that the department should play a stronger and more consistent oversight role. “There are certainly some strengths” in state plans, he’ll say, “but there are missed opportunities and many weaknesses, including proposals that are inconsistent with the law.”

Betsy DeVos will be the keynote speaker at the ALEC annual meeting in Denver this week. Protestors will be there to greet her, although the U.S. Department of Education is keeping silent about which day she will appear.

ALEC has been promoting deregulation and privatization since the early 1970s. It is funded by major corporations and has nearly 2,000 members who are state legislators. It writes model legislation, which its members bring home and introduce in their own state. ALEC promotes charters and vouchers. It wants to eliminate unions, tenure, and seniority.

The linked Chalkbeat article says,

“ALEC is best known for crafting “model” legislation advancing conservative principles on issues ranging from tax limitations to gun safety and the environment.”

That’s not quite right. ALEC wants to eliminate all environmental regulations and gun controls.

Colorado’s Senator Michael Bennett wants to show DeVos a Denver “public school.” He is the most fervent supporter of charter schools among Senate Democrats, so he will most likely show her a Denver charter school. It is embarrassing for a Democrat like Bennett to admit that he and a radical extremist like DeVos agree about school choice, so he will try to find some way to pretend that charters are the good way to privatize schools, but vouchers are the bad way.

DeVos will not be convinced.

Here is the agenda for the ALEC meeting. It doesn’t show when DeVos is speaking, apparently a state secret.

To learn more about ALEC, its corporate sponsors, and its legislative members, check out the website ALEC Exposed.

A group of Democratic Senators wrote a letter to Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos to express their concern that she was abandoning civil rights enforcement.

DeVos wrote back to say that she was “returning” the Office for Civil Rights to its role as a “neutral” investigative agency.

It is at a time like this that DeVos’s ignorance of education policy and history becomes embarrassing. OCR is the Office FOR Civil Rights. It was never a “neutral” agency. It led the way in the 1960s in forcing the integration of Southern schools. It didn’t just investigate. It threatened Southern districts that did not produce hard data about students and faculty integration. No integration, no federal funding.

One can’t be “neutral” about civil rights. The Office for Civil Rights is meant to enforce the law and protect the vulnerable–not to feign indifference.

Jennifer Berkshire writes about Betsy DeVos’s radical agenda, which she cloaks in platitudes.

She has become the mistress of not speaking to the press. When invited to address the annual meeting of the Education Writers Association in D.C., she skipped out, claiming she was too busy.

She briefly appeared on a network news show, speaking about the only subject she cares about: choice. When asked about a charter school which avoids children wupith disabilities and English language learners, she turned the subject upside down and said the school was great for those enrolled. Berkshire notes that she has often praised schools that have no students with disabilities. Inclusion and diversity are not in her vocabulary.

Berkshire writes:

“Her substance-free performances are all the more remarkable given the fierce urgency with which DeVos has pursued her agenda since arriving in Washington. Sidelining federal civil rights enforcement, rolling back protections for students who have been defrauded by shady for-profit colleges, meeting with a steady stream of “edupreneurs” and flogging school choice at every turn—these have been busy days for the Secretary.

“The NBC interview was actually a trio of softballs thrown by reporter Craig Melvin as part of a segment on Philadelphia’s charter school wars. Melvin met up with DeVos at Boys Latin of Philadelphia Charter school. You can read their entire exchange yourself:

“Melvin: You go to a lot of schools like this, I would imagine.

DeVos: I do.

“Melvin: Critics have said the success of schools like Boys Latin has come at the expense of neighborhood schools. Are you OK with that?

DeVos: Actually, I think schools like this are a really great example of schools that are meeting the needs of kids that haven’t fit in elsewhere.

“Melvin: But if there’s only one pot of money, aren’t traditional public schools always end up getting shortchanged to some extent?

DeVos: Great public schools are going to continue to do a great job for the students that they’re serving. I think instead of talking about schools and school buildings we should be talking about funding students and investing in individual students.”

That’s vintage DeVos. Every person for himself or herself. No concern for those left behind. Just kick them to the curb.

Berkshire writes:

“New York City requires a massive infusion of cash in order to repair its train woes, but by DeVosian logic we should be talking about funding and investing in individual commuters instead.”

Everyone on their own. Ride in a limo if you have one. If you don’t, you can ride a bike. Or walk. Problem solved.

Senator Lamar Alexander took great pride in the Every Student Succeeds Act, passed at the end of 2015 to replace the failed and rancid No Child Left Behind law of 2002. ESSA explicitly prohibits the Secretary of Education from telling states what to do to meet their obligations under ESSA. SAlexander was taken aback when he read in the New York Times that Betsy DeVos’ aide Jason Botel had warned Delaware that it was not “ambitious” enough in setting goals. Alexander wondered whether Botel or anyone else at the Department had read the law.

We know that he chastised John King for over-reaching when he was Secretary. We know that Congress wanted to be sure that no Secretary in the future would act as aggressively as Arne Duncan by intervening in the states’ education plans.

Watch to see if he reins in Betsy DeVos.

I am willing to bet $100 that DeVos has never read ESSA. No one would take that bet. She thinks that God has given her a divine mission to put an end to government schools. Why read the law?

Dora Taylor writes in “The Progressive” about the disadvantages of tax credit, aka vouchers.

1. Education tax credits deplete state budgets, diverting money from public schools to private and religious schools.

2. Education tax credit programs benefit the rich.

3. Education tax credit programs are risky for students because the private and religious schools are not covered by federal civil rights laws.

4. Education tax credits underwrite religious indoctrination.

Is this what Americans want? No public referendum has ever supported vouchers.

Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos invested in a military technology company owned by her son-in-law. Her brother Erik Prince is advising the Trump administration on military strategy.

I naively assumed that once appointed to the Cabinet, all outside business dealings were suspended.

CBS News aired a great segment on the importance of rural public schools. They are the heart of the community. CBS News went to an impoverished community in Appalachia and interviewed students and the principal, who is also the school bus driver. The small rural public school in Letcher County doesn’t need competition. Most of its students live below the poverty line, yet the school is one of the best in the state.

Nine million children across the nation attend rural schools.

Why does Betsy DeVos want to destroy them?

Hello, Senator Mitch McConnell. These are your constituents!

Ed Berger, a retired teacher who lives in Arizona and is active in the struggle to save public schools, has written a powerful post about the billionaire-funded movement to destroy our democracy.

It begins like this. I urge you to read it all:

“Within the core of our freedoms, lie the avenues powerful individuals use to take away the rights of citizens and the controls of government designed and evolved to serve all. Americans are now aware of the reality that subversive forces have made excessive headway in destroying our rights.

“What has been allowed is the incursion of an Oligarchy: The few exploiting the many. We are witnessing the theft of human rights through the infiltration of what were meant to be representative systems within a constitutionally defined government.

“My first introduction to those who want absolute power was through studies of The Robber Barons in America in the 19th Century, and then in the 20th Century, the way Adolph Hitler and Joseph Stalin took total control of their countries. I learned of an American, Fred Koch, who became wealthy via Russian and German contracts and worked with Stalin and then Hitler as WWII began. He was convinced that absolute dictators were necessary to create strong nations. He came home to change the U.S government into a mechanism which would allow him to acquire power and wealth by any means. His tenets were: Destroy public education. Destroy any kind of worker representation. Control the prison system. Destroy the democratic process by distancing or removing undesirable citizen involvement in decision-making. End government interference in the rights of individuals like himself to create his own empire.

“Koch’s ideology was embedded in the goals of the John Birch Society, founded in the late 50s by Fred and ten others. It was one of many organizations spawned or infiltrated by Koch. Be aware of subversive groups founded by Koch and his sons and other powerful billionaires. Groups like the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) which writes legislation supporting Koch’s political and economic agendas. Know the goals of think tank groups established and funded to carry out Fred’s vision, these include: The Freedom School, the CATO Institute, and Americans For Prosperity among others. Be aware of how Foundations and not-for-profit tax avoidance mechanisms allowed the billionaires to finance their think thanks and other subversive organizations.

“The Koch machine gained the support of other libertarian arch conservatives. Richard Mellon Scaife, Harry and Lynda Bradley, John M. Olin, the Coors brewing family, and the DeVos family, to name some of the big supporters recruited by the Fred Koch and his sons David and Charles. All had acquired vast fortunes from activities that exploited citizens and nature. All were against any type of government that limited their rip, rape, and run business philosophies.

“In the last few years, add the names Bezos, Broad, Cohen, Singer, Schwarzman, Adelson, Hendricks, Mercer, and perhaps the worst of the lot, the Waltons. The Koch ideology also appeals to radical splinter groups of the Christian conservative right which is obsessed with the takeover of the US Government and the dismantling of the government. Understanding this unholy marriage explains why so many Tea Party extremists support Koch and the coup.”

Every day I get fund-raising appeals from Democratic and progressive national organizations. They usually include a list of critical issues and ask me which one I care most about. They never include K-12 schooling, which is now being battered and assaulted by DeVos and the Red state governors.

Here is a list I got today from the DCCC (I think that’s the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee). Here is its list:

WHAT ISSUES MATTER THE MOST TO YOU? (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY)
Fully funding climate change research

A health care plan that takes the burden off families

Continued funding for Medicare and Social Security

Student loan forgiveness

Making tuition affordable for all

A $15 minimum wage

Protecting immigrants and immigration reform

Fully funding women’s health centers

Fighting economic inequality

Creating new jobs

Preserving President Obama’s Medicaid expansion

Gun violence prevention

Protecting voting rights

The form had a box for other. I wrote: STOP PRIVATIZATION OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

And made no contribution.

No money until they acknowledge the threat posed by charters and vouchers.