Have you heard of Horst Wessel? He was a 22-year-old member of the Nazi paramilitary who was assassinated in 1930 by two Comminists. After his death, his name became a propaganda prop for the Nazi party. Lyrics that Wessel had written were turned into the Nazi anthem and called “The Horst Wessel Song.”
I thought of Wessel when I saw how the Trump administration is turning Charlie Kirk into a symbol of leftwing, liberal perfidy that must and will be punished.
Charlie had extremist views about race, immigration, and gender, but he was no Nazi.
I discovered that I was not the only person who was struck by the parallel between Wessel and Kirk, not in what they did, but in how their legacy was used by powerful men. Benjamin Cohen and Hannah Feuer wrote in the Forward, an independent Jewish journal, about the comparison. They interviewed Daniel Siemens, a historian who wrote a book about Wessel. Siemens insisted that the two men should not be compared because Wessel engaged in violence and Kirk did not.
Cohen and Feuer conclude:
The rush to invoke Horst Wessel’s name reflects two realities. On the right, there’s a dangerous willingness among some extremists to valorize Nazi symbols. On the left, a fear that Kirk’s death will be used to erode civil liberties.
It is time to worry about the erosion of civil liberties.
Today, JD Vance became host of “The Charlie Kirk Show.” Among his guests was Stephen Miller, Trump’s Deputy Chief of Staff and Chief ideologue. Miller is known for his hatred of immigrants.
The New York Times just reported that they discussed their plans to crack down on liberal groups, whom they hold responsible for the murder of Charlie Kirk. They believe this even though no evidence has emerged tying the alleged assassin Tyler Robinson to any group, right or left. No one can say whether Tyler moved to the left or to the right of Kirk. The Utah governor said Tyler had a “leftist ideology,” but Kirk had lately been feuding with far-right white nationalist Nick Fuentes, who accused Charlie of being too moderate, a sell-out.
Without any evidence, Vance and his colleagues are forging ahead on the assumption that liberal groups indoctrinated and funded Tyler Robinson.
Katie Rogers and Zolan Kanno Youngs wrote in today’s Times:
Trump administration officials on Monday responded to the activist Charlie Kirk’s assassination by threatening to bring the weight of the federal government down on what they alleged was a left-wing network that funds and incites violence, seizing on the killing to make broad and unsubstantiated claims about their political opponents.
Investigators were still working to identify a motive in Mr. Kirk’s killing, but the Republican governor of Utah, Spencer Cox, has said that the suspect had a “leftist ideology” and that he acted alone.
The White House and President Trump’s allies suggested that he was part of a coordinated movement that was fomenting violence against conservatives — without presenting evidence that such a network existed. America has seen a wave of violence across the political spectrum, targeting Democrats and Republicans.
On Monday, two senior administration officials, who spoke anonymously to describe the internal planning, said that cabinet secretaries and federal department heads were working to identify organizations that funded or supported violence against conservatives. The goal, they said, was to categorize left-wing activity that led to violence as domestic terrorism, an escalation that critics said could lay the groundwork for crushing anti-conservative dissent more broadly.
Open the link to finish reading.
I wonder which groups will be targeted. The ACLU? Marc Elias’s “Democracy Docket”? Bloggers like those at The Contrarian, The Bulwark, Rick Wilson, Paul Krugman, Joyce Vance, Heather Cox Richardson, Mary Trump, Norman Eisen of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), and dozens of others. Will they try again to shut down Act Blue, which many Democrats use as their primary fundraising platform?
Hang on to your hat. Our political system is in for some difficult, challenging times.

I watched a brief clip of Miller baring his teeth like some deranged monkey as he threatened everybody he doesn’t like with arrest, jail, deportation (no distinguishing citizen or not), disappearing….
LikeLike
Stephen Miller is evil. A large brain but no heart or soul.
LikeLike
So the first amendment now only applies to conservatives??
LikeLike
Never before has Thomas Jefferson advice about nourishing the tree of liberty been more accurate or timely.
The tree of liberty… (Quotation) | Monticello
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is an excellent article you have referred Lloyd. Time goes on, and I fear so many of us Americans will be considered “casualties of war” in the history books to come.
LikeLike
The forces of fascism are always looking for excuses to seize control. Whether they engineer them in advance or exploit them after the fact may not matter in the end … but they are impatient … and waiting for chance takes more time …
LikeLike
The worst people ever.
LikeLiked by 2 people
This blog could be a target. You and many contributors have described the Trump administration as “fascist.” If the right decides you’re influential enough, they can flip that critique into a pretext—claiming your use of the word “fascist” is “inciting radicals to violence”—to marginalize this site and chill educator speech. They’ve already started with educators. Scary times were living in.
LikeLike
This Civil War already started with violence on January 6, 2021, and it hasn’t stopped. So far, all the violence has come from members of Trump’s fascist MAGA hate cult.
We are the, so far, peaceful resistance hanging on supporting the US Constitution. Most of the judges (not counting the US Supreme Court) are ruling in our favor. Trump has lost more than 90% of the verdicts so far. I read that last week Trump lost 7 to 1 court cases.
Trump is deplorably ignorant. He wants that civil war without a clue what he’s asking for, and he is trying to egg us on to start it when he already did. What Trump’s klepto-kakistocracy regime is doing now is his attempt to make it look like we are fighting back with violence, while we are not doing it. Yet!
There will still be a resistance, volent or peaceful. Nothing Trump’s fascist regime is going to stop that even after many of the resistance are in his prison camps or dead. If it gets that far.
LikeLiked by 2 people
David,
We must all be strong and brave. I am not afraid. I have nothing to lose.
As Stephen Colbert said at the Emmy awards, you realize how much you love something when you might lose it. He said, “I love this country! God bless America!”
I feel the same way. I love this country and I don’t want it to become a fascist country, where the people who run the government take away our freedoms. I will not stand by in silence.
LikeLiked by 3 people
As offered before, my not being able to understand why these people’s thinking is so pathologically evil frustrates me to no end. I suspect if I could understand why, I could also understand the why of colonialism, the why of slavery, the why of the Trail of Tears, the why of racism and race, the why of the Holocaust, the why of the KKK, the why of Hitler, the why of Woodrow Wilson, the why of Charlie Kirk, and so on.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Human minds are programmed from birth. The toxic minds like Trump and his MAGA hate cult grew up thinking that way because they were willingly programmed through their life choices.
LikeLike
Me too, Ed. Are they stupid, evil, or both?
LikeLike
“We are not Fascists. Stop calling us Fascists, are we will throw you in jail.”’
–The Trump administration
LikeLiked by 1 person
Much like how he handles being tagged a Nazi. He has long had Nazis (and KKK) in his base but that never bothered him, like at the Unite the Right demonstration in Charlottesville VA, where they were protesting the removal of a Robert E Lee statue but they marched at night with tiki torches chanting “Jews will not replace us!” The next day, they clashed with counter protesters and he said there were “very fine people on both sides.”
He has since claimed he is not a Nazi, that Kamala Harris is a fascist, and that he is “the opposite of Hitler.” Are we supposed to believe now that he is Jesus?
LikeLike
ECE, his followers think he is.
LikeLike