This speech by French Senator Claude Malhuret went viral. It has been translated and reproduced at least 1 million times. I personally have received several copies of his speech from friends and family. Recently, it has been translated and published in The Atlantic. Senator Malhuret expresses the shock and dismay that many of us feel about Trump’s decision to abandon Ukraine and Europe and to align the United States with Russia. Please read what he said. This is not normal.
Senator Malhuret said:
Europe is at a crucial juncture of its history. The American shield is slipping away, Ukraine risks being abandoned, and Russia is being strengthened. Washington has become the court of Nero: an incendiary emperor, submissive courtiers, and a buffoon on ketamine tasked with purging the civil service.
This is a tragedy for the free world, but it’s first and foremost a tragedy for the United States. [President Donald] Trump’s message is that being his ally serves no purpose, because he will not defend you, he will impose more tariffs on you than on his enemies, and he will threaten to seize your territories, while supporting the dictators who invade you.
The king of the deal is showing that the art of the deal is lying prostrate. He thinks he will intimidate China by capitulating to Russian President Vladimir Putin, but China’s President Xi Jinping, faced with such wreckage, is undoubtedly accelerating his plans to invade Taiwan.
Never in history has a president of the United States surrendered to the enemy. Never has one supported an aggressor against an ally, issued so many illegal decrees, and sacked so many military leaders in one go. Never has one trampled on the American Constitution, while threatening to disregard judges who stand in his way, weaken countervailing powers, and take control of social media.
This is not a drift to illiberalism; this is the beginning of the seizure of democracy. Let us remember that it only took one month, three weeks, and two days to bring down the Weimar Republic and its constitution.
I have confidence in the solidity of American democracy, and the country is already protesting. But in one month, Trump has done more harm to America than in the four years of his last presidency. We were at war with a dictator; now we are fighting against a dictator supported by a traitor.
Eight days ago, at the very moment when Trump was patting French President Emmanuel Macron on the back at the White House, the United States voted at the United Nations with Russia and North Korea against the Europeans demanding the withdrawal of Russian troops.
Two days later, in the Oval Office, the draft-dodger was giving moral and strategic lessons to the Ukrainian president and war hero, Volodymyr Zelensky, before dismissing him like a stable boy, ordering him to submit or resign.
That night, he took another step into disgrace by halting the delivery of promised weapons. What should we do in the face of such betrayal? The answer is simple: Stand firm.
And above all: make no mistake. The defeat of Ukraine would be the defeat of Europe. The Baltic states, Georgia, and Moldova are already on the list. Putin’s goal is to return to the Yalta Agreement, where half the continent was ceded to Stalin.
The countries of the global South are waiting for the outcome of the conflict to decide whether they should continue to respect Europe, or whether they are now free to trample it.
What Putin wants is the end of the world order the United States and its allies established 80 years ago, in which the first principle was the prohibition of acquiring territory by force.
This idea is at the very foundation of the UN, where today Americans vote in favor of the aggressor and against the aggressed, because the Trumpian vision coincides with Putin’s: a return to spheres of influence, where great powers dictate the fate of small nations.
Greenland, Panama, and Canada are mine. Ukraine, the Baltics, and Eastern Europe are yours. Taiwan and the South China Sea are his.
At the Mar-a-Lago dinner parties of golf-playing oligarchs, this is called “diplomatic realism.”
We are therefore alone. But the narrative that Putin cannot be resisted is false. Contrary to Kremlin propaganda, Russia is doing poorly. In three years, the so-called second army in the world has managed to grab only crumbs from a country with about a quarter its population.
With interest rates at 21 percent, the collapse of foreign currency and gold reserves, and a demographic crisis, Russia is on the brink. The American lifeline to Putin is the biggest strategic mistake ever made during a war.
The shock is violent, but it has one virtue. The Europeans are coming out of denial. They understood in a single day in Munich that the survival of Ukraine and the future of Europe are in their hands, and that they have three imperatives.
Accelerate military aid to Ukraine to compensate for the American abandonment, so that Ukraine can hang on, and of course to secure its and Europe’s place at the negotiating table.
This will be costly. It will require ending the taboo on using Russia’s frozen assets. It will require bypassing Moscow’s accomplices within Europe itself through a coalition that includes only willing countries, and the United Kingdom of course.
Second, demand that any agreement include the return of kidnapped children and prisoners, as well as absolute security guarantees. After Budapest, Georgia, and Minsk, we know what Putin’s agreements are worth. These guarantees require sufficient military force to prevent a new invasion.
Finally, and most urgently because it will take the longest, we must build that neglected European defense, which has relied on the American security umbrella since 1945 and which was shut down after the fall of the Berlin Wall. The task is Herculean, but history books will judge the leaders of today’s democratic Europe by its success or failure.
Friedrich Merz has just declared that Europe needs its own military alliance. This is a recognition that France has been right for decades in advocating for strategic autonomy.
Now it must be built. This will require massive investment to replenish the European Defense Fund beyond the Maastricht debt criteria, harmonize weapons and munitions systems, accelerate European Union membership for Ukraine, which now has the leading army in Europe, rethink the role and conditions of nuclear deterrence based on French and British capabilities, and relaunch missile-shield and satellite programs.
Europe can become a military power again only by becoming an industrial power again. But the real rearmament of Europe is its moral rearmament.
We must convince public opinion in the face of war weariness and fear, and above all in the face of Putin’s collaborators on the far right and far left.
They say they want peace. What neither they nor Trump says is that their peace is capitulation, the peace of defeat, the replacement of a de Gaullian Zelensky by a Ukrainian Pétain under Putin’s thumb. The peace of collaborators who, for three years, have refused to support the Ukrainians in any way.
Is this the end of the Atlantic alliance? The risk is great. But in recent days, Zelensky’s public humiliation and all the crazy decisions taken over the past month have finally stirred Americans into action. Poll numbers are plummeting. Republican elected officials are greeted by hostile crowds in their constituencies. Even Fox News is becoming critical.
The Trumpists are no longer at the height of glory. They control the executive branch, Congress, the Supreme Court, and social media. But in American history, the supporters of freedom have always won. They are starting to raise their heads.
The fate of Ukraine will be decided in the trenches, but it also depends on those who defend democracy in the United States, and here, on our ability to unite Europeans and find the means for our common defense, to make Europe the power it once was and hesitates to become again.
Our parents defeated fascism and communism at the cost of great sacrifice. The task of our generation is to defeat the totalitarianisms of the 21st century. Long live free Ukraine, long live democratic Europe.

My old friend Earl, who was wounded on Omaha Beach, was never so proud of anything as the letter he got on the 50th anniversary of D-Day from France, thanking him for his wading onto shore (Earl made it to the beach but barely, and was too wounded to continue in the war).
Had strong American opposition to Hitler occurred earlier, the Cold War might have been fought between Germany and the West.
LikeLike
This is an explicit, insightful speech from Claude Malhuret. The French have a strong tradition of philosophy and rhetoric, which involves analyzing texts and examining the logic of any material. Students in this country would benefit from such exposure, IMO. The key is reading, reflecting and expressing the ideas presented. When I studied French literature as an undergraduate French major, I learned how to apply the “explication de texte” method of deconstructing information and text, which is taught in French schools. I think it contributes to developing logical thinking skills, which, perhaps if more Americans learned, may have helped to avoid our current political quagmire. Anything we can do to make our people become more logical thinkers and enables them to question disinformation would be helpful. Reading leads to thinking, and our people need to do more of it. Why are the right wing extremists attacking libraries and public schools?
LikeLiked by 2 people
His speech was perfect truth!
How fast did FDR turn the US manufacturing sector into a war machine after Pearl Harbor?
“Following Pearl Harbor, FDR swiftly transformed the US manufacturing sector into a war machine, setting ambitious production goals and mobilizing industry to produce vast quantities of military equipment, with automakers shifting from civilian production to war materials within months. “
The EU already has the third largest manufacturing sector in the world behind China and the US. And it is the biggest export market for around 80 countries. The UK is in twelfth place. Russia seventh.
If they do what FDR did, it won’t take long to shift gears. There are already countries in Europe that make their own weapons, including fighter aircraft, bombers, Navy ships, missiles, tanks, et al.
Europe has Volkswagen group, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Renault, Peugeot, Volvo, Hyundai and Ferrari factories turning out cars and trucks. This is the short list. There are other auto makers with factories in the EU like Toyota.
Japan will probably ally itself with the EU and the UK. Maybe South Korea, too. The UK also has the commonwealth nations that were once all part of the British Empire.
56 independent and equal countries with shared goals like development, democracy and peace.
This is how the world may divide up into new alliance.
What’s going to happen in the US is a mystery? How many people in the US are willing to risk their lives to fight the Traitorous Felon and his fascist MAGA cult?
I’ll turn 80 in August. Still, I’m willing to do what I can to fight back. Even at 80, I can still pull a trigger or work to supply younger troops fighting in the front lines with the supplies they need. In war, for every fighting person in the front lines, there are about 7 in uniform supporting them behind the lines.
LikeLike
He is absolutely correct. After Trump’s delusional speech from the DOJ, crying about being persecuted more than the “late, great Alphonse Capone”, I realigned my jaw after it dropped, while trying to process his crazy speech. He wrongly thinks that the Justice Department is HIS to use as he likes. Someone please sit him down and read him the Constitution, which is obvious that he never has read nor understood. Really, Republicans?!?! I think it’s time for the three living presidents to step forward, go to the Capitol, and call out Trump and his acolyte Republicans on their trashing of our beloved Constitution. They should bring along with them as many other constitutional judges & scholars as they can. Maybe even an actual patriotic Republican or two with a spine will join them. Presidents Clinton, Bush and Obama–it’s time to come forward and enlighten the world on what’s really going on here in the “late, great USA”. Your coming out will get more attention than any Congressperson or Senator could get by tweeting or standing on the Capitol steps recording a TikTok video.
LikeLike
Loved2Teach,
I had the same reaction to “the late great Alphonse Capone.” What kind of brain does this man have? Like the late great Hannibal Lecter.
I too have dreamed about a bipartisan coalition of eminent leaders stepping forward to confront Trump.
I can’t get rid of the thought that he’s working for Putin. What else explains the attack on every agency and Departnent?
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s been my understanding that he likes to reference “Alphonse Capone” because he thinks knowing Capone’s full first name shows how smart he is. Ugh.
LikeLike
“The late great Alphonse Capone”…. like “the late great Hannibal Lecter.”
LikeLike
We are in the grips of puppets and insane people. And we have no real leadership standing against it. We are in for some troubled times.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry, I have been speechless. Horrified. Shell shocked. And this is just the beginning. It’s gonna get really bad before this is over. Dark, dark times.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bob, even though we all knew & predicted that Trump aspired to become an authoritarian, if not an all out Fascist, the fact that it actually seems to be happening is nevertheless incredulous and mind numbing for us all to process. Dark times, for sure.
LikeLike
He nails it. Trump is a threat to the planet. He mentioned “Manifest Destiny” at his inauguration and then threw in planting a flag on Mars. Got my radar up, though. I’ve been thinking he’s a Russian asset for years, Diane.
Europe needs to unite, politically and militarily. I agree with Lloyd: they’re waaay more than capable of doing just that, as long as there’s a common will.
As horrific as all these insane actions are, there are three things that I think will stop him:
I tend to go with a positive approach. But I’m not naive. I’ll continue to speak out and resist. It’s just very important that we don’t cave. The overload is designed to achieve just that from the public. We can’t give in.
LikeLike
First time I’ve had a numbered list function option here on WP. Wonder why it makes the font smaller. Won’t use it again.
LikeLike