Sarah Longwell is publisher of The Bulwark, executive director of Republican Voters Against Trump, and host of “The Focus Group” podcast.
In this article, she appeals to fellow Republicans to stand up and speak out about Trump. I hope her article is read by George W. Bush, Mitt Romney, and Lamar Alexander. They know how dangerous Trump is. They know he is destroying the Republican Party.
She writes:
I HAVE A QUESTION FOR FORMER Trump administration officials, Republican electeds (and former electeds), business leaders, and conservative writers and pundits who recognize Donald Trump for the threat he is. Actually, it’s a question for anyone on the right who knows what Trump’s re-election could mean for the country, for liberal democracy, and for the world—and, who, in the face of this threat, has decided to maintain either a posture of silence or both-sides-are-bad neutrality.
My question is this:
How are you going to feel if Trump wins on Tuesday by an extremely narrow margin?
I suspect you’ll spend the next four years holding your breath.
Because if Donald Trump does a tenth of what he has promised—pulls the United States out of NATO, abandons Ukraine and sides with Vladimir Putin, puts RFK Jr. and Elon Musk in charge of serious parts of the American government, rounds up 15 million undocumented immigrants into camps and deports them, seeks political retribution against those who opposed his candidacy—I suspect you’ll come to regret your silence when you could have made a difference.
I can see you holding up your hands to show us how clean they are. Saying, “But I said Donald Trump was a threat! I said I wouldn’t vote for him! What more do you want from me?”
And I get that. I do. The problem is that this moment demands more from all of us.
It demands clarity. And it demands your leadership.
Over the course of your career you’ve asked people to trust you. Either by voting for you, or listening to your advice, or relying on your judgment and analysis.
So why is it suddenly a bridge too far for you to tell everyone what you really believe?
I understand that this moment is hard. Trump could win. Even if he doesn’t win, coming off the sidelines could alienate you from career networks, business opportunities, or even friends and family.
But being a leader means standing up and telling the truth even when it’s hard, or costly, or scary. Especially when it’s hard, or costly, or scary.
It’s still not too late. Every day, more people are speaking out—people with reputations, and reservations, but whose consciences won’t let them sit this one out.
You shouldn’t sit this one out, either. You should not decide, after a career in leadership, that this time you’d rather just be a spectator.
Maybe you think that adding your voice wouldn’t matter to voters. After all, so few things seem to move the needle. Well, I’m here to tell you that it matters. It all matters. Every little bit. You do not know who’s listening as the moment approaches to cast their vote. You do not know who you might persuade at the eleventh hour. And you do not know what the margin will be. If this election is decided by 9,000 votes in Pennsylvania—which is absolutely a real thing that could happen—then every single input could be the tipping point.
We’re almost there. Stay with us! The Bulwark is a reader-supported publication. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
I can’t see the future. I don’t know if your endorsement would be the difference maker. Just like I don’t know what price you would pay for speaking out more clearly.
What I do know is this: If you abdicate the obligations of leadership in this moment and the thing you fear comes to pass, you will regret having stood down when the country needed you to stand up. You will regret it for all of your days.
MAYBE YOU ARE A RETIRED FOUR-STAR GENERAL, or cabinet secretary, or someone who took a job as a political appointee in the Trump administration and saw things that shocked your conscience. And maybe you’ve told reporters about what you saw, or written about it in a book. That’s not enough because books have a relatively small reach, and your words are mediated through paper. What’s needed is for you to look voters in the eye and give them a direct warning about what a second Trump term might mean. Especially now that you won’t be on the inside to try to protect the country from him.
Maybe you’re a former Republican president or presidential nominee. Maybe you were once the leader of the party Donald Trump has destroyed. I am sorry, but the unpleasant fact is that you cannot preserve your influence for some future GOP. This is actually the last moment in which you have a chance to influence it. Your party, every bit as much as your country, needs you. Right now.
Maybe you’ve led venerable conservative publications. You’ve acted as a thought leader. Someone shaping our political culture. But today you want to keep your hands clean by writing in Edmund Burke on your ballot or some other nonsense protest candidate—as a sign that youkept your purity. I understand this impulse. But it’s wrong. You know that if yours was the single deciding vote, you’d vote for Harris. So just say so. This isn’t an academic exercise, and it’s not about you.
Maybe you’re a billionaire to whom this country has given everything. Your wealth insulates you from the consequences of the worst-case Trump scenarios. And yet, you see Trump’s transactional nature, his willingness to provide favor if you provide obedience, and instead of standing up to Trump, you cower. This might seem like wisdom, but it’s not actual safety. There will be more demands. The only way to actually protect your business is for the rule of law to be victorious and democracy to be stable.
FOR MONTHS, YOUR COUNTRYMEN have been waiting for you to tell them the full, unvarnished truth about the danger you believe Donald Trump presents. To tell everyday Americans the same words you say in green rooms, at dinners, and in off-the-record conversations. You haven’t gotten there yet, but you still can. Before you make your final decision, think about Liz Cheney’s warning that some day Donald Trump will be gone, but the choices we make today will be with us forever.
Choose honor. It’s the choice you’ve made again and again in your professional lives. It would be a sin to stop choosing it because of a mountebank like Donald Trump.
I want to tell you about some Republicans who are already putting themselves on the line for democracy. They don’t have security details, or staff, or budgets. They’re just regular people who voted for Trump before, but refuse to support him again. They joined Republican Voters Against Trump to get the word out to their friends and neighbors. A few of them have lost jobs. Some of them have lost family. All of them have lost friends. None of them regrets it.
They’ve put their faces on billboards across the country. They’ve appeared in millions of dollars’ worth of paid ads running in their own communities. They’ve taken part in text campaigns, spoken to the media, knocked on doors, and traveled to swing states in the hopes of making a difference.
If Kyle from Alabama, or Jackie from Michigan, or Robert from Pennsylvania, or Jim from Wyomingcan speak out, then so can the generals, politicians, and thought leaders.
THE REASON I BELIEVE THAT every little bit counts is because conservative-leaning voters say that to me all the time.
In Republican focus groups, one thing I hear again and again is that voters are open to hearing from the leaders who served under Trump, who were in the room with him. The messenger is as important as the message, and these people are ready to believe the words of a lifelong Republican or flag officer much more readily than they’ll believe a Democrat telling them the same things.
So if you’re one of the small number of people who can make a difference in this moment, the question is: What are you going to do?
Courage is contagious. And I have one last piece of advice: No one ever regrets doing the right thing.
You won’t regret it, either. So stand up and join us. It’s our last chance.

BTW phone banking again for Kamala in a few moments and they want us to spread the word. I hate phones, banking, Zoom etc…. but it’s simply GOT TO BE DONE. A chance to talk to all sort of people all of Pennsylvania including some GOPers.
https://bit.ly/virtual-phbank2
LikeLike
I have been zoom phone banking daily and from when I started (70 volunteers in a session) to the past 10 days (sometimes 800+ volunteers a session!) the determination to win this election is evident. I really hope it is a sign that people are VERY MOTIVATED to vote and defeat Trump. And I hope that a lot of the people who want Trump to win don’t want it enough to go vote.
LikeLike
Way to go , Jon!
LikeLike
I don’t think I’m that good at phone calling, Roy. But it’s the way the Harris campaign has played out. Phone banks….canvassing… and, of course, a veritable blizzard of TV ads on the Pennsylvania station we watch.
I’d love to stand out with signs by the Viewmont Mall in Scranton, PA (a short drive from here) and just show some actual, physical, in person support for Kamala and Co.
Joe Biden was going to come to Scranton tomorrow, at least that was the plan a few days ago. Have to wonder if the flak over his comments regarding garbage derailed that visit? Nothing about him visiting now…
Yeah, the AP has a big story parsing the punctuation in Biden’s off-hand garbage comment. Meanwhile, the Republican candidate for POTUS talks about the shooting of Liz Cheney and how he knows best for all women. WTF???
LikeLike
The media made a huge deal out of Biden’s use of the word garbage; Trump says it frequently and it’s no big deal. He said yesterday that Liz Cheney should face a firing squad. Is that as bad as using the word garbage?
LikeLike
Republicans should remember that voting for Harris will not cause them to melt or lose their identity. They should define themselves by the courage of their convictions, not a grand old party that has so lost its way that it is not even recognizable. Anyone that values democracy, supports the US and its alliances and defends the rule of law should vote for Harris as she is the only reasonable, sane candidate that will defend our American values and move our nation forward. It is time to put country over party.
LikeLike
Voters should also consider that Trump is a “bad hombre.” Why would anyone with any sense of right and wrong vote for a convicted rapist with over thirty felony convictions?
LikeLike
Exactly.
And this goes for folks on the left, too.
The vote isn’t an endorsement of Kamala’s policies. It is a endorsement of keeping our country a democracy where people who don’t like Kamala’s policies can fight to change them without being in fear for their family’s lives, which is the way fake democracy works in Russia.
LikeLike
Good afternoon Diane and everyone,
One of my favorite quotes is from Auden’s The Age of Anxiety (a propos now in its own right):
We would rather be ruined than changed
We would rather die in our dread than climb the cross
of the moment and let our illusions die.
The illusion (or I would say “delusion”) is that the current GOP is Reagan’s Republican Party. That no longer exists. It’s completely gone and will probably never come back. Let your attachment to it die so that something new can be born. Liz Cheney and the “Republicans” who have come out for Harris know this. Why would anyone choose to lose his or her individual voice by following any party especially when it has been hollowed out by fascism, racism, xenophobia, misogyny, cruelty, hypocrisy, hatred, crassness, demagoguery and incitement to violence???
LikeLike
oops… Reagan. Sorry for the misspelling.
LikeLike
P.S. liked the line at the end of the piece: “Courage is contagious”
Could apply to the people here on Diane’s blog, too!
LikeLike
Being a Tennessean, I always followed the career of Republican Lamar Alexander. When I was a young adult working in the sewers, our company had a job in Jackson, TN. I worked in the streets near a sign that announced the cancellation of a speech to be given by governor-elect Alexander. Seems the guy who was the governor, Ray Blanton, was suspected of selling pardons to convicted felons. To stop this, the two parties got together and ended his position as governor before he could do this.
Twice Alexander had a chance to help keep Trump from doing roughly the same thing (think pardon for Roger Stone). He never even came up to the plate. The point is that he will not speak out against Trump. Even though he had experienced this level of corruption in his own life, he voted not to convict. Was he threatened? Loyal? Has he always been cynical? I think I voted for him that year.
Romney and others have spoken out. A retired guy like Alexander should too. But he is silent.
LikeLike
Roy,
I worked for Lamar Alexander when he was Secretary of Education. I admired him for his integrity.
After Trump was elected, I asked him privately if Trump could be stopped. He assured me that Republicans would control him.
As you wrote, he might have swung votes to impeach him. He didn’t.
Right now, he could speak out. It would cost him nothing. Silence.
I am disappointed but no longer surprised.
LikeLike
Meanwhile on the dirtbag left:
https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2024/11/01/2024-elections-live-coverage-updates-analysis/rashida-tlaib-kamala-harris-skips-endorsement-00186901
LikeLike
What a shame,but does she think the Palestinians will fare better under a Trump dictatorship? I am a mutt, so I have no strong ties to any nation other than the USA. However, most of my heritage, if not all, tends to be northern European. My family by marriage is more diverse, but I cannot claim to fully understand the pain of someone who is watching their people slaughtered. I take some comfort in the fact that we are working with several Arab nations to bring some semblance of resolution to this conflict. I imagine that is not much comfort to Rashida Tlaib.
LikeLike