John Merrow’s title is sarcastic. Of course he wants you to read banned books, and he is deeply concerned about the large number of eligible voters—especially young people—who don’t bother to vote.
When someone on Twitter posted a list of 25 popular books that Florida Governor Ron DeSantis had supposedly banned from the state’s public schools, people went crazy. The list included Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird,” Alice Walker’s “The Color Purple” and Madeleine L’Engle’s “A Wrinkle in Time.”
Below is a screenshot of the list. How many of these books have you read? Have your children read most of them? What on earth is going on in Florida?
People familiar with DeSantis’s efforts to restrict classroom discussion of controversial topics had no trouble believing that he would try to prevent young people from reading controversial or challenging books. If DeSantis did draw up a list, these books might well be on it.
But the list is a fake, a clever satire.
Many people were fooled, including teacher union President Randi Weingarten and “Star Wars” actor Mark Hamill. Hamill’s screenshot of the list amassed more than 100,000 likes and 24,000 retweets.
(Add my name to the list of those who were taken in.)
Like all good satire, that fake list of banned books is rooted in truth, because book banning is real and growing. Florida school districts have banned around 200 books, according to a report published by PEN America, a nonprofit that tracks book banning in the U.S. Pen America ranks Florida third among US states for banning books, trailing only Texas and Pennsylvania.
We are in the midst of a pandemic of book banning, so it’s hard to imagine any title that would never be banned by some zealous or timid school board or ignorant legislator.
One way to stop this outbreak of censorship is to get active, vote, attend school board meetings, run for school board. Passivity and complaining is a losing strategy.
Time to turn back the rising tide of incipient fascism.
Something we read suggested that Charlotte’s Web had been banned somewhere. Like you say, it was believable. When it is hard to separate satire from reality, something is wrong.
I figure they might have objected to Wilbur being “Some Pig.”
My wife read it was in Kansas about ten years ago that Charlotte got thrown off the shelf for some reason
this just in …
https://www.bridgemi.com/talent-education/romance-author-nora-roberts-helps-save-mi-library-defunded-over-lgbtq-books?utm_source=Bridge+Michigan&utm_campaign=b5cd4c4694-Bridge+Newsletter+08%2F30%2F2022&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_c64a28dd5a-b5cd4c4694-78794473
What a travesty. I wonder where the outrage was when Mathew Shepard was tied to a fence and tortured
Point is made but obviously not a real list because it does not include Fahrenheit 451 (an excellent way to teach irony and a really good West Wing episode).
This book thing is out of control which is exactly the ploy. The right-wing playbook is very good at taking hot button issues to the local level so everyday (?) people go to microphones to complain about the liberals – and it gets front page coverage in local papers across the country.
and…
The first question out of every person conducting the public meeting should be
1) was this book actually assigned to your kid or on the library shelf?
2) did you complain to the teacher or librarian?
3) then did you complain to the principal?
4) then did you complain to the superintendent’s office?
5) did you read the district policy about parent rights to complain about materials (and sex education)?
or did you just show up to scream about ideology?
Another example why Diane’s column and Billy Townsend’s blog the other day about “focus on the right’s and crank’s behaviors, not ideas” – that is what gets moderates and independents to shy away from joining the ranks and voting for the crazies.
Add to your list: did you read the book before complaint about it?
One of the Burbank parents who filed a complaint in 2020 about Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry admitted in her complaint that she had never read it. Even so, it was removed from instruction.
Interesting that Pennsylvania, a state with many respected colleges and universities, would rank 2nd in book banning.