Donald Trump somehow imagines that the nation–at least the white portion of the nation–shares his nostalgia for the Confederacy. He is prepared to fight to the bitter end to save statues of Robert E. Lee and others who rebelled against the United States of America and fought a war that cost more than 600,000 lives. He calls this our “great heritage.”
This is the same man who ridiculed Senator John McCain, who spent five years in a Vietnamese prison cell and was brutally beaten, yet refused the chance to go home early because he would not leave until his fellow Americans were freed. Trump said he was a “loser.” But he admires those who fought for states’ rights, dissolution of the union, and white supremacy.
The Boston Globe published this article about Trump’s allegiance to the Confederacy. Does MAGA mean “bring back the Confederacy”?:
WASHINGTON — Mississippi scrubbed the Confederate insignia from its state flag. Top Senate Republicans want to make Juneteenth a federal holiday. And on Wednesday, a crane lifted an enormous statue of Stonewall Jackson off its pedestal in Richmond, Va., the former capital of the Confederacy.
But while America begins to reckon with the racism of its history and its present, President Trump is defiantly defending that past.
As protesters and local governments around the country take down Confederate monuments and rethink the depiction of founding fathers who owned slaves, Trump has appointed himself their protector, tweeting seven times in a 24-hour span beginning Tuesday about attacks on statues and the nation’s “heritage.” He vowed to veto a defense bill if it strips Confederate officers’ names from military bases — a measure authored by Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren but also backed by key Republicans. And on Sunday, he retweeted a video that showed one of his supporters yelling “white power.” He took it down hours later after facing criticism but he did not apologize for the sentiment.
“It’s my hope that President Trump takes a step back and realizes this is 2020, not 1940 or 1950,” said Richmond Mayor Levar Stoney, a Democrat who gave the order to remove the statue of Jackson and another Confederate officer from city property on Wednesday.
But a president who vowed to “Make America Great Again” has again focused his reelection campaign on the past — or at least one version of it. At a moment when the country is wrestling with difficult questions of race, he spent part of the week defending the honoring of Confederate generals and he will end it with an appearance Friday at Mount Rushmore, a monument that critics say has long promoted a sanitized, all-white story of American history.
“This is a battle to save the Heritage, History and Greatness of our country,” Trump tweeted on Tuesday, echoing how he urged the mostly white crowd who came to see him in Tulsa last month to “save that beautiful heritage of ours.”
Trump swept into office in 2017 after a campaign that scapegoated Mexicans and Muslims and won over many white voters. Now, as polls show his support slipping with white people thanks in part to his handling of coronavirus, he’s framing civil rights protests as an “attack” on white Americans and the removal of Confederate symbols and vandalism of other statues as an erasure of their history.
“It appeals to people who believe that America is America because it’s white,” said Michael Steele, the former Republican National Committee chair who was the first Black man to hold that position. “So you talk about erasing ‘our heritage’ — you hear those words, what does that say to you? No one in this country talks like that except for racists.”
Fascism. Wrapped in a flag and carrying a cross.
Trump wrapping himself in the flag is desecrating the flag.
It is indeed.
When will humans grow beyond this stupid tribalism?
Just in “trending” from the Washington Post:
“Trump’s push to amplify racism unnerves Republicans who have long enabled him.
“President Trump has left little doubt through his utterances the past few weeks that he sees himself not only as the Republican standard-bearer but as a leader of a modern grievance movement animated by civic strife and marked by calls for ‘white power.’
“On Capitol Hill, some Republicans fret privately that Trump’s fixation on racial and other cultural issues — crystallized by his fiery denunciation of racial justice protesters Friday night at Mount Rushmore — leaves their party running against the currents of change.”
. . . You think?. . . Why do I sense they don’t give a hoot about any of it. It’s ONLY about getting re-elected? CBK
Sadly, the GOP has become the party of racism. There are no more moderates. No more Eisenhower’s or Rockefellers. No more George Romney’s. Mitt may have to leave the party. Why does Senator Tim Scott, the sole African American, remain?
Diane “Why doesn’t Tim Scott . . . leave?”
I’ll take that the be a rhetorical question, . . . I’ve often asked it myself. Maybe he thinks he is to the R Party what all of those Generals thought they would be to Trump . . . but weren’t. I guess that book hasn’t been written yet. CBK
CBK, I don’t get it. Scott is now part of a party that courts the vote of the KKK.
I can’t think of a good excuse for him. Other than self-loathing.
Diane “Self-loathing.” Well, now, there’s a thought. I know a lot of women who still don’t think much of women. When it’s beat into you and you breath it from birth, it’s difficult to transcend. CBK
Yes, I know such women. They were told that men make all the decisions and they go along.
Diane If we move back to racism (both racism and sexism as kinds of group bias that saturate a culture and so that children are born into it and know no other way to think) we can understand what Toni Morrison meant when she said that white people were involved in a huge national neurosis.
Dr. Morrison, it seems, did not suffer from what W.E.B. du Bois called a “double consciousness”–one for communicating with black people, one for white; a way of thinking that, also, the person who was afflicted by it was not fully aware of it. It was just the way things were, like women thinking that all women, including themselves (self-loathing), were just a bit less real and deserving than men. CBK
Trump is in office because Bannon, Sessions, and Miller looked around for a candidate to carry their anti-immigrant, white supremacist agenda forward. The breathtakingly ugly story of this is told in the outstanding Frontline documentary “Zero Tolerance.” Watch it for free, here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eW4kQ4akZ1A
Trump was always a knee-jerk racist and armchair fascist, but he was never smart enough to cobble together an ideology. The closest he came to an ideology, in the past, was his embrace of incredible simple-minded, mind-blowingly stupid Nazi racist eugenic notions–what he calls his “racehorse theory” of people with and without “good genes.” But this guy, who would have been simply another moron with despicable ideas somewhere off on the fringes was elevated to this position in the now Whiter House by actual fascists with a fascist agenda–Bannon, Sessions, Miller, and, ofc, his handler, Putin.
I’ve made this point before, but I’ll try again. These are not “Heroes,” they are traitors, criminals, perhaps even misanthropes. The words hero or heroes should never, in my strong opinion, be used in this context. May I suggest that this headline should read: Donald Trump Defends Traitors of the so-called confederacy as America’s Great Heritage. I think Abraham Lincoln would have written it thusly. The so-called confederacy should never be put in caps. Would one write, Nazi or Third Reich Heroes? Pol Pot Heroes? Stalinist Heroes? Heroes of apartheid?
You are right.
Not unless you were an authoritarian demagogue,you wouldn’t.
But you have never lived in a place where you lost a war. Try to imagine deciding that your father was all the things you describe above. The cognitive dissonance was too great. The fear of societal catastrophe too intense. Remember, Lincoln had a very forgiving policy of re-unification designed to get the country back to normalcy as quickly as possible. When this was accomplished, it was hard to tell the difference between the South of the peculiar institution and the South without it. Without slavery, the money-making north went back to ignoring the cries of the needy, opting instead to occasionally wring their hands over the stupid rednecks and inferior Africans.
There is plenty of blood for all hands. Let us all repent of our sins instead of worrying about a concrete or bronze confederate, Time to elect someone who will lead repentance.
I was born and spent half my life by the age of 23 in Germany. I played in war ruins as a child. My grandfather, a solider in the German border patrol, was arrested and executed for facilitating the entry and exit of people illegally. My great uncle was one of the few who served in the military from before Hitler took power through the end of WWII. He drew a full pension, was an active Nazi, and lived to ripe old age in comfort. I know a little about having lived in a place that lost a war. It has been the consuming passion of my life.
Oh, and the other place where I spent most of my life until the age of 30 was the Deep South, which is why I would never live there again.
Fascinating, Greg. How do you perceive the differences in Germany (obviously first generation after the war and the Nazi cruelty) and the Deep South (I have never lived in the Deep South)?
I can hear the collective groans of some of my friends out there saying, “now why’d you go and to that?” I just googled Diane Ravitch GregB Germany and some of my pretentious comments on this subject came up should they interest you. I also found this one, although not about the topic here, it’s interesting given the highlight we’ve accumulated.: https://dianeravitch.net/2017/01/26/gregb-what-to-expect-in-the-age-of-trump-and-how-to-resist/
hindsight
US President Donald Trump has ordered the creation of a “National Garden of American Heroes” to defend what he calls “our great national story” against those who vandalize statues.
His executive order gives a new task force 60 days to present plans, including a location, for the garden. He insists the new statues must be lifelike, “not abstract or modernist”.
President Trump has defended Confederate symbols as a part of American heritage. He said America’s national heritage was being threatened – an emotive appeal for patriotism.
The garden – to be in a place of natural beauty near a city – is to be opened by 4 July 2026, Mr. Trump’s executive order says. State authorities and civic organizations are invited to donate statues for it.
President Trump’s choice of historical figures to be commemorated includes Founding Fathers (George Washington and Thomas Jefferson), Davy Crockett, Billy Graham, Ronald Reagan Douglas MacArthur and George Patton, Harriet Tubman , Martin Luther King Jr. The list also includes Christopher Columbus, Junipero Serra, Marquis de Lafayette. Of course, Columbus and the Spanish Catholic missionary Serra are far from heroic for Native Americans, because their “discoveries” led to the enslavement and exploitation of indigenous people by white colonists. There are no Native American or Hispanic individuals on the list, which also includes Republican presidents but no Democrats.
Historians interviewed by the Washington Post criticized the idea, with James Grossman, executive director of the American Historical Association, saying the choices “vary from odd to probably inappropriate to provocative”. See more at
• 5 July 2020
Trump will have a garden near a city for “American Heroes.” You can be sure that he will be among the heroes. It is not clear how this will be financed but there will be no abstract or modernist sculptures in the park. President Trump has defended Confederate symbols as a part of American heritage.
In a speech to mark Independence Day at Mount Rushmore, he condemned the anti-racism protesters who toppled statues. He said America’s national heritage was being threatened.
The garden – to be in a place of natural beauty near a city – is to be opened by 4 July 2026, Mr Trump’s executive order says. State authorities and civic organizations are invited to donate statues for it.
President Trump’s choice of historical figures to be commemorated in the garden is likely to be controversial.
The list of “historically significant” Americans includes Founding Fathers like George Washington and Thomas Jefferson, but also frontiersman Davy Crockett, evangelical Christian preacher Billy Graham, Ronald Reagan and World War Two commanders Douglas MacArthur and George Patton. There will also be statues of African-American abolitionist Harriet Tubman and civil rights campaigner Martin Luther King Jr.
Mr Trump also includes non-Americans who “made substantive historical contributions to the discovery, development, or independence of the future United States”.
So the garden can have statues of Christopher Columbus, Junipero Serra and the Marquis de Lafayette.Columbus and the Spanish Catholic missionary Serra are far from heroic for Native Americans, because their “discoveries” led to the enslavement and exploitation of indigenous people by white colonists.
There are no Native American or Hispanic individuals on the list, which also includes Republican presidents but no Democrats.
Historians interviewed by the Washington Post criticized the idea, with James Grossman, executive director of the American Historical Association, saying the choices “vary from odd to probably inappropriate to provocative”.
Ronald Reagan is the only president from the past 150 years. Antonin Scalia is on the list. Read more at: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53292585
This will be a garden planner nightmare. A list of Trump’s prefeences and then a hodgepodge of “contributions” from states and civic organizations. It is likely to be a perfect mess and large-scale map of his disordered brain and ignorance of history.
National garden of American heroes. Aren’t those called cemeteries? The idea of an American Pantheon–as much as the one in Paris intrigues me–is disgusting and as anti-democratic as it gets.