Joel Westheimer has advice for parents who are at home organizing their children’s days.
FORGET THE WORKSHEETS AND TRYING TO REPLICATE SCHOOL
I am really struck by the variety of media inquiries I’ve been getting about the impacts of Covid-19 on education, what parents should be doing at home, and so on. The interest doesn’t surprise me (I am an education columnist on public radio), but the preoccupation with whether kids will “fall behind” or with how they will “catch up” has. I see hundreds of stories, websites, and YouTube videos that aim to help parents create miniature classrooms at home. Maybe some parents have folding chairs they can bring up from the basement and put in rows. Where’s that big blackboard we used to have? Is there a run on chalk at Costco?
Stop worrying about the vague and evidence-less idea of children “falling behind” or “catching up.” This is a world-wide pause in life-as-usual. We’ve spent the last 25 years over-scheduling kids, over-testing kids, putting undue pressure on them to achieve more and more and play less and less. The result? Several generations of children and young adults who are stressed-out, medicated, alienated, and depressed.
This is not a time for worksheets. This is an opportunity (for those of us lucky enough to be at home and not in hospitals or driving buses or keeping our grocery store shelves stocked) to spend meaningful time with our children to the extent it is possible in any given family. Parents shouldn’t be thinking about how to keep their kids caught up with the curriculum or about how they can recreate school at home or how many worksheets they should have their children complete. They should bake a cake together. Make soup. Grow something in the garden. Take up family music playing. And neither school personnel nor parents should be focusing on how quickly or slowly children will return to school because none of us know We should be focusing on ensuring that teachers are afforded the conditions they need to best support their students — now when school is out and later when school is back in.
Remember that ditty about the two Chinese brush-strokes that comprise the word ‘crisis’? One is the character for ‘danger’ and the other the character for ‘opportunity.’ We are more and more aware of the danger. But we’re missing out on the opportunity: to spend time as families (in whatever form that family takes in your household).
This brings me back to the questions I keep getting. What are my recommendations for what to do with your children at home when they are missing so much school? Stop the homework (unless you and your children are enjoying it).Stop the worksheets. Stop trying to turn your kitchen into Jaime Escalante’s A.P. math class. But do help your children structure their day. Help them process what is going on around them. Help them engage in activities that do not take place on a screen. Help them maintain physical activities whether that means running around the block, running up and down the stairs, or running around the kitchen.Help them be creative. Give them — to the extent possible in your household — the gift of time and attention.
And when brick-and-mortar school (hopefully) returns next Fall, let’s give teachers a great deal of latitude in what, how, and when to teach any particular subject matter. Their primary job should be to restore a sense of safety, nurture a sense of possibility, and rebuild the community lost through extended social isolation.
_________
Joel Westheimer is University Research Chair in Democracy and Education at the University of Ottawa and an education columnist for CBC’s Ottawa Morning and Ontario Today shows. His most recent book is “What Kind of Citizen: Educating Our Children for the Common Good.” You can follow him on Twitter: @joelwestheimer.
Very good advice! There’s so much more the kids should be doing.
There should be lots of investigations re: covid19.
Compare how countries dealt with this pandemic.
Collect data about covid19.
Write letters about how to stay sane.
Observe something in nature and record observations.
Read, read, read …. share what’s being read, even newspaper articles.
I could go on.
Thanks, Joel.
schoolfromscratch.com
I was going to write a comment but you nailed down exactly what I want to say, Yvonne. And, you did it in fewer words than I would’ve probably used, LOL.
Yeah, that’s one of the luxuries of being here on this blog. People do such a good job saying what’s going on in my mind.
It was a crazy sort of Corona day. Not me just the world spinning wildly around me, in all sorts of circles, close and far away. Just getting a chance to check in.
And now it’s time to try and reinvent the concept of a weekend.
Take care.
All science curriculum at my kid’s 6-12 is now centered on viruses and epidemiology.
This is the best advice I’ve seen in two weeks.
De acuerdo.
I know some parents are grateful for work that keeps their kids busy.
As a teacher, several of the activities I am encouraging students to do are to help in their community, like picking up trash or baking cookies for a neighbor, write cards to first responders, medical workers and people in care centers, etc. I want the kids to feel useful to their communities right now.
Great ideas
Here is a great resource on why reading multiple choice assessments/worksheets don’t work or tell us much about readers. Feel free to share widely!
https://drive.google.com/file/d/18j-klZ1icehgNV61Lg5PdgjTXa3WzK6f/view?fbclid=IwAR2Ts0zZNsSCSd55OYP-ItC1GE6IRszjWV5nZ5j_P5LVdKtJarNITTo889I
My daughter is essentially finished since she is a Sr and is not taking any AP tests in her classes. She only needs her ELA credit, 4th math credit and a comp/sci intro course to pass. My son is doing online in the morning (1.5 – 2 hrs) and then he is done….but thank goodness I remember Algebra II concepts since Maths don’t transfer well to online learning. We play games in the evening after dinner…..500 Rummy, Yahtzee, Backgammon. It’s pretty chill here in my house. I am enjoying having my kids home….but then again, I didn’t/don’t work and I generally like spending time with my kids anyway. No nagging them to do busy work is a blessing.
Amen. It seems to me that there are so many teachable moments right now that refute the “gotta have textbooks and tests” crowd. COVID provides great reasons to learn about the sciences and math (statistics and geometry!), I encourage everybody to keep a journal or notes because two weeks ago seems like ancient history (writing!), time for music and and art, etc. As for history, I’m reading a short biography on Chester Alan Arthur and it amazes me that there was once a time when a New Yorker for whom nobody had expectations was a quite a good president and the current one is a [what’s a person from Queens called?] is trying to undermine Arthur’s great achievement, the creation of a real civil service.
Love this post, GregB! I’ve often said that one could teach the whole of the high-school math curriculum from the chart table on a sailboat.
This is an absolutely wonderful list of books by Gretchen Rubin. I’ve read many of them and they are great for kids and adults alike. Enjoy!
https://gretchenrubin.com/2016/10/great-books-childrens-young-adult-literature-favorites/
Public schools have been shooting themselves in the foot for quite some time by relying on a mishmash of disparate worksheets and workbooks, now they are frantically trying to distribute them electronically or as weekly paper-based packets, spending time and money on pointless administrative tasks.
Worksheets have always been a poor implement for learning, designed by publishers to sell “consumables” along with textbooks. Over time, worksheets replaced textbooks altogether. They supply information and ask for answers in piecemeal fashion. Unless you diligently file them in a binder, they do not provide historical record of what has been taught and how it has been solved. They discourage skills needed to work with traditional chapter textbooks and other serious literature. They do not foster methodical approach to solving problems.
All one needs, whether studying in a classroom or at home, is a decent textbook, a blank notebook and a pen. Internet is not required.
Shirley U. Jest. “Mom, mom! I’m so excited to read my 800 page history textbook and write notes with my pen in my notebook!”
Said no student ever.
Do you know if any “decent” textbooks?
Read history books. Read great children’s literature.
Most textbooks are garbage, be it history or algebra or science. For algebra, the old 1990s CGP Education textbooks are bearable. Not 200 pages that I would prefer, but neither 1200 pages that most textbooks have, “only” 400 or so pages, this works out to about 3 pages a day 5 days a week, which is doable. The pages are not too busy and have no gaudy full-page photos. Each section contains definitions, explanations, examples, guided practice and independent practice. Just read, absorb and do the exercises in a squared notebook. The major downside for self-learners is that there are no answers in the back, so someone has to check the answers, but presumably parents are high-school graduates and should know this stuff.
For geometry, there are some decent translations, like Kiselev’s two-book set, Planimetry and Stereometry. These books are based on traditional Euclidean proofs, not on rigid transformations.
For American history one can easily use Lies My Teacher Told Me — did you know that Hellen Keller was a socialist and welcomed Russian revolution of 1917? Now a simpler abridged version is available to those who were taught to read using the word method.
Lies My Teacher Told Me– good one! Add The Daughter of Time.
Gotta agree re: worksheets. They sucked when I was a kid, when my kids were kids, and presumably still do. They’re messy to store! So messy, you can’t retrieve them properly as a study aid later. Personally I always preferred ruled 3-hole ppr responses to text exercises, stored in the subject binder. But that was in paper days. I teach PreK age. But judgng from the couple of tutees I’ve had thro midsch & hisch, homework exercises seems to have gone digital a few yrs ago, via publisher-provided programs aligned with their [still hardcover] texts. Those assts get transmitted to teacher online– perhaps corrected/ graded the same way. Hopefully easily retrieved for review.
We are still employed by our school districts, so we need to be giving students schoolwork. Of course, if it were up to us, many teachers would do things differently.
Are they giving you any leeway? it seems like the right time for very short assnts supplemented by extra contact/ feedback.
“Pandemonium”
Rachel’s in the Kitchen
Doing Calc BC
Integrating muffins
Stressed as stressed can be
Gordon’s doing worksheets
Hundreds by the day
Otherwise, he’ll fall behind
And Harvard will say “Nay”
Mom is in the bathroom
Pulling out her hair
Praying to the Lord above
That school will soon be there
!!!!!!!
Words, but unfortunately not punctuation, fail me, SomeDAM.
I like it. Reminds me of a Beatles song.
Laid-off Madonna, children at your feet
Wondering how linear equations meet
Who finds the money when you pay the rent
Will college tuition be heaven sent?
School shutdown arrived without a suitcase
Online worksheets creeping by the ton
Today’s child must spend time in cyberspace
See they don’t run
Laid-off Madonna, baby at your breast
Wonder how you manage to teach the rest?
Laid-off Madonna lying on the bed
Listen to the worries playing in your head
Tuesday afternoon is neverending
Wednesday toilet papers didn’t come
Thursday night your cracked hands needed mending
Test worksheets run
Lady Madonna, children at your feet
Wonder how you manage to make ends meet
Superlative! Kudos.
Wonderful, LeftCoast! This SomeDAM has definitely started something!!!
Great post from a former elementary teacher (10 years) on the need to slow down with the expectations already:
Day 12: We Should Not Be Requiring Parents To Teach Their Children From Home
March 24, 2020 by not your average mom 42 Comments
“Yesterday our school district began distance learning.
Our kids are receiving instruction via Google Classroom.
And yesterday, as I helped my 9-year-old navigate GC for the first time ever, it became apparent that this is not how to handle our current situation.
I appreciate the Herculean effort our administration and elementary school teachers made to get this up and running so our kids can continue to receive instruction while schools are shut down.
But the truth of the matter is that our kids are not receiving instruction.
They are receiving curriculum.
And it is not our job as parents to deliver the instruction of that curriculum.
Our teachers have been placed in an impossible situation.”
https://not-your-average-mom.com/day-12-we-should-not-be-requiring-parents-to-teach-their-children-from-home/
This is where a good textbook saves the day. Quick googling for “algebra textbook pdf free” returns this as the very first link: http://www.wallace.ccfaculty.org/book/Beginning_and_Intermediate_Algebra.pdf I am not saying that this is a great algebra textbook, I see it for the first time, but at least it shows traits of a proper textbook:
it is made of chapters
former chapters serve as a foundation for latter chapters
each chapter has definitions, explanations, examples and then practice questions.
There are answers and solutions at the end of the book.
With a proper textbook, just by orderly following the chapters, reading the intros and solving the exercises, one does not need a mom who knows Algebra or a teacher. In case a question arises, any high school graduate should be able to help with a grade school question, after all this is what official mass schooling is intended for: everyone, who receives high school diploma, should be able to tackle anything presented in elementary, middle and high school.
If parents cannot help their kids with school math or science, it means they did not learn it in school. A handful of parents like this would indicate their personal inability or lack of desire to learn this or that topic. But massive admission of the sort “now my kids will now how stupid I am” indicate that school did not do its job.
This crisis not only highlights the cracks in the school system in relation to present-day students, it shows that these cracks and gaps have been there for a long time. A nation at risk, indeed.
Cx: “will know”, not “will now”.
How many years ago did you teach high school math? How many of your children were able to read and understand the textbook? Was this a successful method for a majority of your students?
Westheimer’s advice should be disseminated by the state Ohio/Fordham Dept. of Ed.
But, Fordham staff would nix that because they are the mouthpiece for their donors and their sole goal is exploitation of the middle class and poor to generate more wealth for the donor class.
Make the 90% perform like rats in a cage, teach it young, and long term control is easier.
“Fordham Institute
On this week’s Education Gadfly Show podcast, @RbnLake, director of @CRPE_UW, joins @MichaelPetrilli and David Griffith to discuss district innovation in the face of country-wide COVID-19 school closures. Listen”
Because who better to ask about public schools than people who don’t 1. use them 2. work in them or 3. support them.
The Professional Public School Critics Association – PPSCA 🙂
Excellent.
Well said
Hear ye! Hear ye! Bring out your dead! And make sure your gerunds worksheets are turned in by Thursday!
In an interview with the great Resistance warrior Leonie Haimson,, posted today by Diane, Randi Weingarten says that now is a time to remember Maslow’s Hierarchy. Yes yes yes. This is a time to be singularly focused on health and safety, basic needs, caring for one another. There is a hole in the hull of the sailboat. It’s not time to be polishing the brightwork.
Forget the “regular school day.”
Bob,
I’m astonished by the deformed who are now pushing for standardized testing in September to see how much ground kids have lost. Grrr! The results will be available in December or January, in time to prep for the spring tests.
My proposal: Anyone who advocates for standardized testing should be required to take the 8th grade math tests and publish their results.
Amen to that, Diane!!!!
I’m hoping that would mean anyone who opposed standardized testing would have right to keep it quiet. Lord knows I wouldn’t want anyone to see my score from a current 8th grade standardized math test! I never figured out how to stop the blinking 12:00 on my old vcr.
Diane: Those who advocate testing in September forget that the tests given in April are never ready to help teachers place kids in August. If you give them in September, you will receive a meaningless grade in November, if you are lucky. Normally, we get meaningless grades about September.
I suggest that we Dickens these people. They should be boiled in their own “standards” and buried with a stake of accountability driven through their heart.
Roy, sounds good to me..
Mike Petrilli of the Fordham Institute for Securing Big Paychecks for Officers of the Fordham institute wrote a piece in the Institute’s Gadfly Droppings newsletter for Ohio calling for standardized testing as soon as kids get back to school so that we can find out “precisely”–his word–what they missed while they were out. Now, the whole steamroller of Deform is based on standardized testing, and what this comment reveals is that Petrilli–one of the leading cheerleaders for high-stakes standardized testing–either has never read one of these tests or had no clue what he was seeing if he did. These tests do not validly measure what they purport to measure in the aggregate, but they CERTAINLY do not provide this kind of fine-grained analysis of what, “precisely,” is known and not known. As you say, months later, teachers get an aggregate score. And that score is about as meaningful as the phrase “Colorless green think tanks sleep furiously.”
Testing in September is another zombie idea from the same usual test and punish zombies. They just can’t wait to troll for “deficiencies.”
Anything to sell more tests and depersonalized test prep software and the notion that public schools are “failing” and need to be privatized. Meretricious, costly to the rest of us, undermining of the quality of life of most folks, stupid, evil, disgusting.
Vlad’s Agent Orange;
IQ45;
Donald (J for Jabba) the Trump;
Teflon Don, the Sequel;
Our Part-time President;
The Great White (Supremacist) Hope;
The Don, Cheeto (“Little Fingers”) Trumpbalone;
Prez Pinocchio;
Trumpty Dumpty;
Don the Con;
The Man with the Plan and the Tan-in-a-Can;
Dog-Whistle Don
President Turnip
Moscow’s Asset Governing America (MAGA)
Donnie Orange and the Trumpteers
Oh, for a Muse of fire! Oh, for the proper invective to be fully reflective of the irredeemable vileness of the man! I picked up “IQ45,” my favorite of these, from some wag on this blog. SomeDAM? GregB? I don’t remember which. Alas, Trumpty Dumpty is not original with me. I saw an editorial cartoon, early in his presidency, that pictured him as Humpty Dumpty, sitting on his wall.
A great short short story (a piece of flash fiction) for this time: Ernest Hemingway, “A Day’s Wait.”
Click to access a_day%E2%80%99s_wait_by_ernest_hemingway.pdf
You are too late. Melissa already cooked this one out of an old anthology of hers for Jos Ellen to read. Or maybe you edited the anthology. Dis you ever work for Harcourt Brace?
What a great story. The surprise of the ending was compounded for me because it was from Hemingway. I had not read it. Thanks.
Yes, I’ve done work for all the major textbook publishers, including Harcourt. I was never a Harcourt employee, but I did some projects for them when I was running a development house.
I don’t remember putting that story into an HBJ anthology.
However, in the incestuous business of courseware publishing, people steal from one another all the time. Example: Once I included Denise Levertov’s “A Tree Telling of Orpheus” into an anthology. The following year, every major lit anthology series had it. A good thing. It’s a GREAT poem.
This is a very good time to tell the online worksheet purveyors at your local school district to go have intimate relations with themselves.
Sing with your kids (Old Dan Tucker Was a Mean Old Man)
Cook stuff together
Build a pillow fort and protect it from marauding coronaviruses
Construct a Durer grid out of a box and some string or clothes hanger wire and use it to draw stuff
Cut out a bunch of shapes (circles, ellipses, rectangles, triangles) and assign kids the task of arranging them into the proximate outlines of things (people, cats, trains). Make a game of guessing what the other person created.
Do improv. Here’s a good one: improvise a pond. One kid is the rain (drumming with fingers on tabletop). Dad is the wind (whoosh!!!). Other kids are frogs (peepers, bullfrogs)
And speaking of frogs: Look up bird songs and frog songs online. Assign each person the task of memorizing and repeating one for everyone else the next day.
Make sock puppets and a proscenium arch/Punch and Judy stage out of a box and enact Romeo and Juliet or Cyrano de Bergerac or Little Red Riding Hood
Arrange some chairs in a row and enact tobogganing down a very steep and scary hill
Erect a tent in the living room and tell ghost stories in it by flashlight at night
Make up Pecos Bill and Paul Bunyan stories
Hold a talent contest for best performance of a song using a comb-and-paper kazoo
And so on.
Tell your kids stories from the oral tradition. Feel free to elaborate the heck out of these. Read to them. Greek and Norse myths. Fairy tales. Tall tales. Fables. Parables. Here’s an example:
Tall Tale: How Pecos Bill Got His Name | Bob Shepherd
From the very beginning, Ma and Pa knew that Pecos Bill was different. For one thing, there was the peculiar circumstance of his birth. Ma and Pa and their thirty-three children were headed west in a Conestoga wagon. Ma was with child (of course), and Pa took great care about her safety. So, he was quite concerned when a big thunderstorm came up and he saw, off in the distance, a tornado poking down out of the clouds. “It’s time,” Ma said, clutching her belly, which was bouncing like two wildcats wrestling in a burlap bag. There wasn’t much else to do. Pa started delivering the baby and prayed that the tornado would pass over.
Well, pretty soon that tornado was right on top of them. The baby was delivered, but the wagon, with all thirty-three older children, Ma, Pa, and the new baby holding onto it, was picked right up into the sky by that tornado. That wagon was whirling round and round and looked sure to crash into the ground. Just then, a twenty-foot rattlesnake whizzed by in the air next to the wagon. The baby wiped his eyes with a passing prairie dog so he could see better, then grabbed the snake and tied it into a lasso. And before you could say hornswoggle or catewampus, he slid down the spout of the tornado, lassoed the wagon hitch, and pulled the wagon down to safety. “That takes care of that,” the baby said. From the beginning, that child was a take-charge kind of fellow. And from the beginning, he could talk — out talk, in fact, any snake oil salesman, carnival worker, or politician who ever lived, even ones from Texas.
A few days later, Ma and Pa and the thirty-four children were camped alongside the Pecos River near the Sangre de Cristo Mountains. Their little boy still didn’t have a name. They just called him Boy. Well, Boy had made himself some boots and chaps and a cowboy hat out of tree bark, and he was entertaining himself skipping stones the size of dinner plates across the river, when along swam a big catfish. Before Ma and Pa could stop him, he had jumped into that river and onto the back of that catfish. He then rode the catfish for 900 miles down to where the Pecos empties into the Rio Grande.
Ma and Pa were heartbroken to lose Boy, what with his sweet personality and his beautiful singing, all lonesome-like. But there wasn’t much to do except to head on west. Meanwhile, Boy took up with a pack of coyotes and learned all about howling at the moon, which he was quite good at. The wind in the trees can’t sing as purty as Boy could howl. Made a person all tingly, hearing that.
After a while though, Boy got lonesome for Ma and Pa, so he jumped up and grabbed the talons of an eagle that happened to be flying overhead. It took a while to figure out how to steer the eagle by leaning left or right, but Boy managed to fly that bird all the way back to Ma and Pa, where he let go and dropped right into Ma’s arms. Boy told Ma all about his experiences on the river, riding that catfish, and she decided right then and there to name him Pecos, which might not be much of a name, but it’s better than Boy.
Time to make, with your kids, a sourdough starter:
https://bobshepherdonline.wordpress.com/2020/03/30/a-starter-is-born-making-your-own-sourdough-starter-from-scratch/
This would be great advice, however, my student is still receiving grades. I cannot ignore his work, no matter how ridiculous. I appreciate the teachers doing their best, I appreciate my district for keeping us informed. But my student is not being taught. End of story.
We are lucky in our house. We have jobs, food, housing, computers and internet, not to mention college degrees so we can explain assignments. Many many students in CA do not have any of that.
If we continue the way we are going, the gap between rich and poor students will only widen in this crisis.
JS, I couldn’t agree more. This crisis will exacerbate already unequal learning opportunities. Parents who cannot devote time to cake-baking or special projects will also be unable to help with worksheets or other curricular materials. Households without a computer or internet access will not be able to easily access online resources.
Rigor! Rigor! Standards-based rigor! Grit! Grit! Test taking grit! You still think or feel during a pandemic?! Nobody gives a David Coleman! No child left behind in the race to the top of the merit-based achievement heap! Tighten up those data gaps! No excuses! Onward with test prep! Compete in the 21st century skills battle royal! Show your competency in the common core! Young people don’t need social safety nets! They need to be students first! Students first! Students first need WiFi! Students need tech! Students need stinking badges! Rigor, I say, rigor! RIGOR!!!!!!! Aaaaaghaaagh!!!!
Badges! Badges! We don’t need no stinking badges!
This may be a new Pink Floyd song in the making?
If I was still teaching, I’d recommend to parents that they do at least one thing and that is set aside an hour or more (preferably more) every day to read books for fun and/or knowledge.
If the child is too young and doesn’t know how to read yet, the parent/guardian reads to them.
If the child reads on their own, then the entire family sets aside family time to read for at least one hour or more every day. The family gathers in the same room and they all read from the same and/or different books.
In fact, to earn time to watch flat screens of any kind, the entire family must read the same amount of time before the flat-screen device is turned on.
For instance:
two hours of reading before two hours of flat-screen time
four hours of reading before four hours of flat-screen time.
et al.
The biggest factor that has been linked to life-long-learners is a love of reading without any tests linked to what they read.
RE: flat screens vs reading.
25 yrs ago, my boys were aged 8, 6, & 4. My younger sis knew them well, having lived upstairs in our Bklyn brownstone when they were little, but at that point we were in NJ, & she hours away in upstate NY. She was then in her 11th yr as a SpEd teacher. So, my first call, when pubsch teachers started rumbling that my eldest was no doubt ADD. [A vast catch-all label in ’90’s elemsch teachers’ minds, which in his case meant highly intelligent, precociously verbose on abstract topics – paired with inability to sit still – alternating w/ hyperfocus/ “in his own world”].
But like I say she knew him well [i.e. hyperfocus applied especially to flat screens]. And knew we 4 were making do sans commuting Dad several nights a week. Diagnostic Q’s N/R.
First thing out of her mouth was an accusatory, “Are you guys still watching TV while you eat dinner?!”
“Yes, but only PBS,” I faltered. “No NICK except Doug Funny.”
From then on we took “the doc’s” advice. I read to them not only before bed as always, but also during dinner. They would choose children’s books on a rotating basis. Middle guy was always picking joke books, which inspired us to save one night for taking turns telling jokes, or “a funny [usually imaginary & ridiculous] thing happened to me on the way to…” or just shared events of the day.
It didn’t “cure” them of ADD or anything else, but established a daily, comforting oasis of camaraderie. Good medicine for plague times.
Bethree, what happened to the son who was labeled ADD?
I have a long time friend going back to high school in the early 1960s. He and his first and only wife had three children together and had a rule that at dinner, they ate as a family with no TV or radio or any other device on. The family ate together and talked together as a family at the same time. My friend and his wife also had a family reading time every day with all the screens and devices off.
Their youngest had leukemia at age five and suffered brain damage from the procedures that saved his life. As an adult, he still lives with his parents because of that damage but he also went to college and earned a degree and earns enough money on his own to live alone if he wanted to.
All of their children are highly literate and have college educations.
Diane, SpEd went completely to bat for him, smoothing his way thro hisch with tiny classes & other supports, especially when bipolar kicked in at 10thgr. “Mania” for him was psychotic break reqg 3wks’ hosp & 3 mos’ recovery. The CST concluded his sryr that he’d never had ADD; his difficulties were caused by a 40-pt spread between IQ & “processing speed.” (Illustration: he could never complete a quadratic equation, but at 13 he could explain in two sentences what they were, how to use them & work them). Computers allowed him to implement ideas swiftly, though. At 15, the synthesizer he played in his rock band had multiple thingies attached he’d programmed w/invented musical effects.
We learned along the way that bipolar in childhood [not yet “believed in” by ’90’s shrinks] looks like ADD. Sadly the meds that bought A’s in midsch played havoc, & full-blown episode hit at 16 [19 is more common]. He’d also suffered lifelong from a rare autoimmune disease that interfered only occasionally– until then. Bp stress kicked it into high gear. He made it halfway thro college, loved his music tech pgm, composed, played gigs, before becoming an invalid. We lost this angel at 23y.o.
Ginny,
I am so sorry. You are a heroic parent. Think of the love you gave and he returned. What a gift he had.
Bethree,
What an odyssey for your family! I am so sorry for the loss of your son.
Friends of mine had a daughter who was diagnosed with bi-polar disorder at the age of nine, after many twists from being described as a willful child, resistant to instruction, ADD and “spoiled”. Her mother felt both relief and vindication with a diagnosis that fortunately responded to medication.
Thank you Diane. He was the gift.
Consider subscribing to the “Curiosity Stream” at only $12/yr.
This is a streaming service that offers hundreds of on-demand nonfiction documentaries and series. Original and acquired content mainly covers topics about science, nature, history, technology, and society.
Recommend your kid tries keeping a journal. One day their grandchild will ask them what it was like during the 2020 pandemic. This is after all history unfolding before our eyes.
It certainly is! Great point, rage!
I am so torn! I am the public school teacher forced to remotely teach, take “attendance,” and grade. I am the human that totally agrees with this viewpoint. Thursday I played guitar, sang, and read a book to the ten students who showed up in my Zoom classroom. Trying to teach math and language arts was laborious and distracting the previous day. The stress of it all for everyone is overwhelming. I wish our district would look at the situation differently, more compassionately, more creatively. Thank you for this prospective.
Eileen,
You are managing this difficult position in such a thoughtful way — and I hear this from many teacher-humans! I’ll bet in 20 years those 10 kids are going to remember you playing guitar more than any lesson pulled from the curriculum and hastily put online.
Best wishes,
Joel
from many teacher-humans. Love that phrase and your post, Joel. Thanks.
Ditto Joel: love this, Eileen!
The final word, from McSweeny’s:
“Dear Teacher,
While I’m sure you’re busy stockpiling food and medicine, protecting your own family, and coping with the impending end of civilization as we know it, I wanted to ask — can you please send my son some more worksheets so that he doesn’t fall behind grade-level standards?…”
https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/can-my-son-get-more-worksheets-before-the-world-ends
😀 😀 Perfect.
What a welcome perspective. Thank you sharing!!
I bask in luxury compared to youse guys. Not bragging, just lucky. My whole post-mama teaching career is lucky: supplemental family income to a well-paid breadwinner, so I was able to develop my own early-language-learning conversational course as an enrichment to regional PreK’s when the opportunity arose. [Been doing this 20 yrs, at most 3/4time (incl driving!); now at post-retirement age, just under 1/2time.]. So I’ve always enjoyed perks unknown to FT (esp FT pubsch) teachers.
PreK itself has built-in perks: no graded student ppwk, no stdzd tests. The bureaucratic recording/ reporting has ballooned for PreK teachers in 10 yrs as K-12 accountability policies trickle down, but N/A for the “specials”– we’re just visitors, w/a different boss whose job is simply to keep the directors/ school staffs happy. & very easy for me to keep students happy: I have to be good, but I’m always a break in their daily routine. FT PreK teachers are a different animal from me: they pace themselves for the long haul [often 10 hrs], have incredible stamina & consummate patience. I am the grasshopper among the ants, I need high energy/ quick-on-the-feet for a couple of hrs at a time (then drive home & collapse/ re-fuel).
So: online ed for the likes of me is very different. Yes, surprisingly, I have to do it. There’s a demand. If private PreK’s (& most are private, small-biz or franchise) just dropped the ball and refunded the last 3 mos of prepaid tuition, they’d all go bankrupt. And many may. Online ed is a stretch for 2.5-5yo’s & unprecedented, but they have to give it a try. At the parents’ end, most are working at home while dealing with little ones at loose ends, & must periodically break from work for kid-focused time. They find it helpful to have some no-prep material already structured & ready to go.
Just gotta report from my teeny niche: it’s a gas. I am very low-tech, & had a horrible week of dragging myself kicking & screaming into 21stC, learning webcam, video/ video-editing, uploading to file, uploading to cloud etc. Lots of extra time reqd to personalize a video for each class so tykes can hear their own names, “greet” classmates etc. But that’s the part I enjoy most, picturing their little faces. The rest is not so different, requiring similar performance skills. It’s kind of like doing your own Shari Lewis/ Lambchop show.
And I’ve noticed a couple of plusses that compensate a bit for the lack of live interaction. PreK kids LOVE repetition, so I know they’ll be returning to these videos again & again, getting needed reps they normally never get from 1 wkly lesson. Also, having a recording of what I did last wk is great for lesson-planning: you can fine-tune that desired wkly “kicking it up a notch” that can get ditched by IRL class interruptions (or you just forget or are having a bad day).
As a 4th grade teacher I wish I could, but in order to earn my pay I have to post “work” for the kids to do. Thankfully for us it is enrichment and not being graded, but I just wish we could stop. I’m dealing with my own trauma through all of this.
I’m sorry. It’s so easy for some to lose sight of the fact that tachers are human beings with families, needs and lives of their own,
Thank you for this post. It’s a real eye-opener. As a public schools teachers for many years, I utilized all the tools at my disposal. Supplementary lessons, ideas, special projects, creative outlets, and more. In some ways, I was probably more like a home school teacher than most others. Where I saw opportunity, I went for it. Had “fun” and creative lessons when the students were done with the curriculum work (i.e. making games, songs, commercials, and what nots…). When a student had a great lesson idea, we considered, and if good, we worked on it. Most times those ideas were golden.
On rare occasions, I met another creative teacher. One like Star Trek. Yes, a trekkie. Another knew the standards inside out, so created lessons to meet them while instructing about historical figures and historical lessons. We compared notes. We thought about this and that. And in our classes, we considered outside the box thinking.
If I were to be a home school teacher, I certainly would have included sports, outings, camping, and lots of writing/reading, but opening the floor of ideas. The other day, walking about out in the woods, I had my compass, but we were also throwing those throwing axes. Much harder than people know. Mel Gibson made it look easy. It’s not. And fishing is never like on the programs. But how many people today learn from the outdoors? And what can we discover away from the home? What can we learn about ourselves and others without putting everything down on paper? Make a dog house? With the roof tiles, outdoor carpeting, using measuring tools? Ventilation?
If we were dropped in the middle of a large forest (And for today’s generation, that means more than several miles from any road or civilization.), with a compass, a knife, and a day’s ration, what would we do? Would we check our smart phones? What if the signal was out? Would we understand terrain, what it means and where there’s water? Would we know which berries are safe? What about creating something to fish or creating a spear? Would we know how to start a fire? To sleep? To keep predators away? And to eat? Then prepare? Would we even know how to walk across rocky plains, avoid snakes, and what would happen if someone was injured? What would we do? Smart phone is out of the question. And while out there, with only trail mix, dried fruits, and water, what would we do if we needed an extra day to get back to civilization? Would we complain or be happy?
Walking along, would we spot land marks so we don’t go around in circles. What about wind and moss? What do they tell us? And if the crickets and other insects and animals stop making noise, what does that tell us. If we see a bear or cougar, how would we react? There so much to learn that is not in books. Then, there are books. What about the classics, which seems to be removed from so many schools and school libraries. As a teacher, I would read some of my students’ books.
Some good. But most bereft of any real education. Of course, they should read things of interest as well, and if they liked Captain Underpants, like I enjoyed Mad magazines, okay. But what about Huckleberry Finn, which more and more are saying we can’t read? Why?
As I got older, and I started thirsting for better quality books, I read the Three Musketeers, even Moby Dick. Socrates? You betcha. The U.S. Constitution? Several times. But the difficulty I had in reading it, understanding certain parts, told me my own education was subpar to some degree. Why wasn’t literature encouraged more in school, even when it was number one in the world, so we would consider things from others’ views. So I wrote. I practiced writing. Really learned grammar, story writing, and essays, to the nth degree. I read more of the classics. And other books. So I would understand and be able to appreciate more of literature. C.S. Lewis anyone. His book about Joy? **The school’s he went to we could all experience more of it. The literature. The challenge to thinking. And as he shared, schools should be open to Christianity, for what foundation are we providing our students.
As I saw school, from the beginning, I wondered why what used to be number one in the world was falling, now down to 17th-25th in the world, and why nations/countries that used to be far lower than us are higher. So, I set out to really teach, through a multiple of media, but also to get them thinking for themselves. And this, home schooling parents have a great opportunity.
You know, when we took a trip to Japan, we talked to a couple about why we didn’t see kids and teens playing outside. They chuckled. They said, kids don’t play outside, at least during the week. After a certain age, they go to school, come home, eat, do their homework, then go back to night school. Now, I think play time is good, but I also understand their perspective. And upon returning to America, I never felt sorry for our students ever. Sad that the “system” seems to be encouraging laziness and complaining, thinking constantly about feelings, and not the real facts of responsibility. You don’t want to do homework? Parents don’t like homework? But a quality education is priceless. But also, a quality education can include the outdoors, cooking, story book writing (including essays), starting small businesses from home, and so much more. And if the education is of great quality, I can almost guarantee the young people will enjoy much of it, and probably find things of interest. All the best.
Great post!