Imagine this: an emergency room nurse gives birth to a premature baby. She gets a bill for $898,984 from her employer. She thought she had insurance coverage. Her employer says she didn’t sign up in time for the baby. What is she to do?
This obviously is not an education issue. But it is an issue about what kind of society we are.
“Lauren Bard opened the hospital bill this month and her body went numb. In bold block letters it said, “AMOUNT DUE: $898,984.57.”
“Last fall, Bard’s daughter, Sadie, had arrived about three months prematurely; and as a nurse herself, Bard knew the costs for Sadie’s care would be high. But she’d assumed the bulk would be covered by the organization that owned the hospital where she worked: Dignity Health, whose marketing motto is “Hello humankindness.”
“She would be wrong.
“Bard, 30, had been caught up in an unforgiving trend. As health care costs continue to rise, employers are shifting the expense to their workers — cutting back on what they’ll cover or pumping up premiums and out-of-pocket costs. But a premature baby, delivered with gaspingly high medical claims, creates a sort of benefits bomb, the kind an employer — especially one funding its own benefits — might look for a way to dodge altogether….
“Bard’s saga began, traumatically, when she gave birth to Sadie at just 26 weeks on Sept. 21, 2018, at the University of California, Irvine Medical Center in Southern California. Weighing less than a pound and a half, tiny enough to fit into Bard’s cupped hands, Sadie was rushed to the neonatal intensive care unit. Three days after her birth, Bard called Anthem Blue Cross, which administers her health plan, to start coverage. Anthem and UC Irvine’s billing department assured her that Sadie was covered, Bard said.
”But Dignity’s plan, like many, requires employees to enroll newborns within 31 days through its website, or they won’t be covered — something Bard said she didn’t know at the time.
“Meanwhile, believing that everything with her health benefits was on track, Bard spent nine of those first 31 days recovering in her own hospital bed and then had to return to the emergency room because of a subsequent infection. She spent as much time as she could in the neonatal intensive care unit, where Sadie, in an incubator, attached to tubes and wires, battled a host of critical ailments related to extremely premature birth. At times, doctors gave her a 50-50 chance of survival.
“Right from birth she was a fighter,” Bard said.
“Then, eight days past the 31-day deadline, UC Irvine’s billing department alerted Bard to a problem with Sadie’s coverage. Anthem was saying it could not process the claims for the baby, who was still in the NICU.
“Bard, an emergency room nurse at St. Bernardine Medical Center in San Bernardino, called Dignity’s benefits department and made a sickening discovery. Sadie wasn’t enrolled in its health plan. It was too late, she was told, she could no longer add her baby.
”Dignity bills itself as the fifth-largest health system in the country, with services in 21 states. The massive nonprofit self-funds its benefits, meaning it bears the cost of bills like Sadie’s. And it doesn’t appear to be short on cash. In 2018, the organization reported $6.6 billion in net assets and paid its CEO $11.9 million in reportable compensation, according to tax filings. That same year, more than two dozen Dignity executives earned more than $1 million in compensation, records show.”
Bard was facing bankruptcy when ProPublica found out about her dire situation.
One reason I am posting this story is because I was moved by the injustice of it. Another is because a reader in the South chastised me for writing an appeal on behalf of the Southern Poverty Law Center. He sent me the SPLC 990 form for the IRS, showing that it has nearly $500 million in assets. There are many worthy organizations that need crowd-funding. ProPublica is one of them.
Sickening.
“…the organization reported $6.6 billion in net assets and paid its CEO $11.9 million in reportable compensation, according to tax filings. That same year, more than two dozen Dignity executives earned more than $1 million in compensation…”
This is absolutely sickening. Nobody should be treated this way and yet how many people in the US say they want their employer’s insurance? Costs taken from worker’s pockets is going up, what is being covered is going down as more and more companies don’t want to insure their people. How long can this country survive private insurance companies?
How many people with private insurance are screaming that Medicare for All is going to destroy the US because it is too expensive and is pure socialism at its worst? That is propaganda that insurance and drug companies are pushing because they can’t compete with Medicare for All.
“what is being covered is going down as more and more companies don’t want to insure their people.” My husband and I have observed this trend with his employer-provided plan quite regularly and annually since the early 1990’s – the trend, more accurately, is “what is being covered is going down” simultaneously with “premiums are going up.” There was a prior 6 yrs of hiccups(starting mid-‘80’s), as HMO’s stuck their nose under our tent, immediately offering “deals” like, keep your premium the same by enrolling in HMO, i.e., using only xyz providers and accepting these restrictions/ caps on xyz procedures.
His employer is an international engineering company. The trend is 35 years old in our case.
Are we the stupidest country amongst the wealthy “advanced” countries when it comes to health care? ALL the other wealthy industrialized democracies have universal health care, no one goes bankrupt from medical costs and the medications are much cheaper. Japan, Taiwan, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, Israel, Austria and most of the other western European countries have universal health care, the UK has had it for over 70 years. This is why Bernie is the best, he’s been screaming about this travesty for decades. Warren is good on universal health care but I think Bernie has the edge. The rest of the Democrats are gutless wimps on health care. They say we mustn’t be too rash because supposedly so many Americans love their private insurance. BALONEY! This tragic story of the nurse illustrates the cruelty of USA private insurance. What about the almost 30 millions with NO insurance and the tens of millions more with super high deductible crappy inadequate insurance? Even Clarence Page, a supposed good liberal, was bad mouthing the idea of Medicare for all, he said he loved his private insurance. Makes no sense, the man is old enough to be on Medicare, a government program. Bill Maher, supposedly left leaning (NOT) was also recently bad mouthing the idea of universal health care, saying would you want the government to control your health care? GEEEEEEEZUS, with “liberals” like that who needs the GOP and libertarians. Of course, today’s liberals are really centrist moderates. Only Bernie and Warren are advocating for real universal health care, how sad is that in the richest economy on earth. I am so OUTRAGED, I can’t even breathe, so to speak.
Nobody talks about the people that have died because of our ignorance and refusal to accept the inevitable. People are dying because they cannot afford to pay for insulin because Big Pharma decided to make more money off us. There is no “working with the insurance companies!”
Answer to first sentence: Yes. Yes, we are.
Our current privatized health care system is not sustainable for the future. People are going to have to compromise and accept Medicare for All or at least a public option sooner rather than later.
Even Medicare covers less than it did fifteen years ago so a lot of people have a supplement to cover the gaps. I read that these Medicare Advantage plans are an attempt to lure the elderly into a privatized system. They advertise lots of perks like dental and optical coverage. What they do not mention is they may have very few providers in your area. Also, they are routinely denying claims and fighting over the bills.
Now that my son-in-law has a green card, my daughter is facing sticker shock on the ACA plans in Texas. Her plan this year has a $2,000 deductible, but for next year most of the family plan deductibles are over $6,000. Health care in this country is a patchwork of for-profit providers, sort like the charter schools the government and wealthy keep promoting.
The crux of the problem is that the big money profit vampires (insurance companies, big PhaRma, hospitals, the AMA, the medical-industrial-complex) are vehemently against true universal health care and they will spare no expense, no effort to sabotage and obliterate any attempts to bring us up to the level the other advanced countries. The medical-industrial-complex can throw millions at the politicians to buy their allegiance to profit and millions at the media to mock and swift boat the idea of Medicare for all. Two major candidates have the guts to stand up to the insurance companies, the rest are bought off and compliant. Forget about the GOP, the GOPers scream socialism, communism, Venezuela, the USSR, Stalin, Mao, etc., ad nauseam. If anyone thinks Bloomberg will advocate for M4all, it’s to laugh out loud.
Healthcare in the United States is a variety of organized crime. It’s a racket, and the healthcare companies are RICOs. Our healthcare costs are TWICE as much as the average in the OECD, and our health outcomes are worse. Why? Because healthcare companies here siphon off huge percentages of our healthcare dollar into profits. Those health insurance CEOs have to pay a lot for the personal helipads at their hunting lodges in Montana! And do you have any idea what a Patek Philippe Grand watch costs? How could these execs afford such things if there weren’t lots and lots of Americans whose babies die without proper medical care? whose elderly parents have teeth rotting out of their mouths because they can’t afford a dentist? who pay into their employer plans for decades only to find that when they get really sick, the company won’t cover the treatment?
And even if the US company is nonprofit, it typically pays its execs exorbitantly. “Nonprofit” is an extremely malleable designation here in the New Feudal Order United States!
Consider these stats:
“Thirty-two of the thirty-three developed nations have universal health care, with the Untied States being the lone exception.”
–from Praveen Ghanta, “List of Countries with Universal Healthcare.” True Cost: Analyzing Our Economy, Government Policy, and Society through the Lens of Cost-Benefit, 2013. https://truecostblog.com/2009/08/09/countries-with-universal-healthcare-by-date/.
The US has the highest healthcare costs in the OECD. Healthcare costs in the United States, from National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention:
$10,348 per capita (per person), 2016
Total expenditure, $3.3 trillion, 2016
Healthcare as percent of Gross Domestic Product: 17.9 %
–from “Health Expenditures.” National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2016. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/health-expenditures.htm.
Costs for other countries in the OECD is much lower on average:
Average healthcare cost per capita in the OECD, 2018: $4,069 USD
Average cost of healthcare as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product in the OECD, 2018: 8.9 %
Highest percentages in the OECD: US at 17.2 % of GDP, Switzerland at 12.3 % of GDP, France at 11.5 % of GDP (2018 figures)
–from “Spending on Health: Latest Trends.” OECD, June 2018. http://www.oecd.org/health/health-systems/Health-Spending-Latest-Trends-Brief.pdf.
Despite this, our health outcomes are worse.
Comparing health outcomes, life expectancy:
Life expectancy of the following OECD countries is higher than in the US: Chile, Costa Rica, Portugal, Slovenia, Finland, Germany, Greece, Belgium, Denmark, France, Austria, Korea, United Kingdom, Canada, Ireland, Netherlands, New Zealand, Luxembourg, Australia, Iceland, Span, Sweden, Israel, Norway, Italy, Japan, Switzerland (2017 figures)
–from “Life Expectancy at Birth.” OECD Data, 2017. https://data.oecd.org/healthstat/life-expectancy-at-birth.htm#indicator-chart.
Comparing health outcomes, infant mortality:
Infant morality rates in the following OECD countries are lower than in the US: Iceland, Finland, japan, Slovenia, Norway, Estonia, Sweden, Spain, Czech Republic, Italy, Korea, Ireland, Australia, Austria, Demark, Israel, Belgium, Portugal, Germany, Netherlands, Switzerland, France, Latvia, Luxembourg, United Kingdom, Hungary, Poland, Greece, Lithuania, Canada, Slovak Republic, New Zealand (2017 figures)
–from “Infant Mortality Rates.” OECD Data, 2017. https://data.oecd.org/healthstat/infant-mortality-rates.htm#indicator-chart.
But the Bidens and McConnells will continue to serve these rackets and to deride Medicare for All, despite the existence proofs of its superiority in terms of both costs and outcomes. It seems that in the US you can fool most of the people most of the time.
Nurses and teachers have a lot in common. We both are caregivers for people affected by inequality (as in this post) and seeing the effects firsthand, we go for Bernie Sanders in droves.
Healthcare is a human right.
In the US, it is a right only for the rich.
Lauren Bard opened the hospital bill this month and her body went numb. In bold block letters it said, “AMOUNT DUE: $898,984.57.”
I bet it was the 57 cents that really made her numb.
I’m not exactly sure how it works, but Canada does have private insurance too. Everyone has access to a certain level of care through the government plan, but you can buy coverage beyond it. We need a Canadian to explain it. I’m sure there are other universal plans that provide the same type of option. If “socialism” provides libraries and fire protection and policemen and mail delivery (private business efficiencies be damned) and education and…(need I go on?), I am all for it. No one should be faced with a bill like this nurse faced. Sickening.
It seems at least one major author has noticed how the greedy, power-hungry privitazion of everything from prisons, health care, the military, and education is destroying this country and moving its middle class toward poverty and earlier deaths.
That author is John Grisham and the book is his latest “The Guardians”. I read last night how his main character went to visit a prisoner in a publicly-funded private-sector prison and Grisham clearly pointed out how greed cuts corners everywhere to make the powerful wealthy and even richer.
Why blame the insurance industry or the healthcare providers. Sure enough there is greed and profiteering. But the real villain is the American people who fall prey to the propaganda. Its not healthcare that is the problem it is a problem of taxation. Or more correctly the unwillingness to pay for the “Public Goods” they want.
The neo liberal assault in other countries was accomplished with the power of the gun. In America it has been propelled by the power of envy. And we are envious that those who have little may be getting a little from us. “Why should I pay for your healthcare” says the worker on an employer plan,, as more and more of the costs are transferred back to him each year.
I am simply amazed at all the Politicians and Media talking heads who have become champions of Unions. To protect the benefits that have been negotiated as if all Union workers have Cadillac plans. . Almost as amazed at the number of workers who have no clue that their employers pay nothing for their plans. Benefits are part of a wage package be that for a Union or Non Union worker. The employer is not a philanthropist . He doesn’t care if he pays into your wage or a health-plan. Which is why low wage workers have little or no health insurance.
In my case that employer contribution if I were working still, is now $ 18 an hour. I guarantee 70% of the members of my Union have no clue they are paying for it and fewer still how much.
And speaking of Unions Northam has proved that he is who the progressives said he was, a Republican. So he didn’t just vote for Bush in 2000 and 2004. Didn’t just caucus with the right on economic issues. Now he has come out against repeal of Virginia’s Right to Work Laws. How is that going to workout for all those Teachers and others who voted Democratic to flip the legislature. Try telling working class Americans that both parties are not the same.
It seems Bernie was on the right side of this one too.
“But the real villain is the American people who fall prey to the propaganda.”
Blame the victim much? Why wouldn’t you consider that the people putting out the propaganda are the real villains?
Willful ignorance at best. The discussion has been out there for 25 years.
“But the real villain is the American people who fall prey to the propaganda… the unwillingness to pay for the “Public Goods” they want.” I think this is not quite right. We know that for some decades, wages have remained stagnant while costs have continued to rise. That means a large # of Americans are living more or less hand to mouth, often working more than one job to do it, & that # has been increasing over the yrs. When they say no to increased taxes, it’s because they can’t afford them. In fact polls show something like 70% think teachers should make more, & can or would pay more tax to make it happen. Tax cuts haven’t made them richer, & nobody is asking if they want their public goods cut in exchange for lower taxes, they’re just being cut.
People with employer-provided healthcare over the same wage-stagnating decades have steadily had benefits chipped away as their premiums increase, and they still get stiffed by the insurance companies when big expenses come along. I am not the least surprised by expressions of envy or mistrust, it’s baked into the system we’ve long had: one segment makes so much that health costs are a drop in the bucket for them, another makes so little they’re uninsured & are left to run up unpayable ER bills, & everybody else is paying thro the nose for benefits that may not get them through one serious medical issue.
bethree5
“Support increased when people were told “Medicare-for-all” would guarantee health insurance as a right (71 percent) and eliminate premiums and reduce out-of-pocket costs (67 percent).
But if they were told that a government-run system could lead to delays in getting care or higher taxes, support plunged to 26 percent and 37 percent, respectively.”
Kaiser poll
Proposition 13 was passed in California 1n 1978. Reagan then runs for President on the promise of cutting taxes and shrinking Government. Although adjusted wages had started to stagnate in the 70s. its hard to argue that by 78 before the second oil shock wages were not keeping up with taxes.
Had Obamacare not passed in 2010 with it’s employer mandates the employer provide health care system would probably have collapsed in the great recession. The public would be screaming for M4All
I think Joel is exactly right.
Absolutely unconscionable, and even as we speak Michael Bloomberg is spending millions to keep it that way.
To those that do not know him, Bloomberg’s ads make him appear like a reasonable progressive. He wants to tax the rich and help middle income families. Sure, he’s real man of the people!
Sure he is.
Doctors Group Owned by a Private Equity Firm Repeatedly Sued the Poor
Lawsuits against poor patients began after TeamHealth, a physician staffing firm, was acquired by the Blackstone Group, one of the world’s largest private equity firms.
MEMPHIS, Tenn. — After nine visits to the emergency room at Baptist Memorial Hospital in 2016 and 2017, Jennifer Brooks began receiving bills from an entity she’d never heard of, Southeastern Emergency Physicians. Unsure what the bills were for, Brooks, a stay-at-home mother, said she ignored them until they were sent to collections. She made payment arrangements, but when she was late, she said the collection agency demanded $500, which she didn’t have.
In December, Southeastern sued her for more than $8,500 in unpaid bills — a third of what her husband makes per year as a cook.
The case against Brooks is one of more than 4,800 lawsuits Southeastern has filed against patients in Shelby County General Sessions Court since 2017. In the first six months of this year, Southeastern filed more lawsuits than local hospitals Methodist Le Bonheur Healthcare, Baptist and Regional One combined.
Lawsuits against poor patients over unpaid medical debts have received widespread media attention over the past few years. In almost all cases, the plaintiff has been a hospital system, often a nonprofit…
Check out this article: https://truthout.org/articles/doctors-group-owned-by-a-private-equity-firm-repeatedly-sued-the-poor/?utm_source=sharebuttons&utm_medium=mashshare&utm_campaign=mashshare
and then the media is shocked when some poor, traumatized victim of the powerful and rich goes postal and shoots up the wrong people at a hospital or some other public venue
It’s Our Choice: Medicare for All, or Endless War?
We could easily fund health care for all by ending military boondoggles and fruitless wars.
November 30, 2019
If you’re following the presidential race, you’ve heard plenty of sniping about Medicare for All and whether we can afford it. But when it comes to endless war or endless profits for Pentagon contractors, we’re told we simply must afford it — no questions asked.
According to one study, even if universal health insurance didn’t bring health care prices down — an unlikely worst-case scenario — we’d need an extra $300 billion a year beyond our current spending to provide full insurance for everyone.
Where can we find it? In a giant pot of money that’s already rampant with waste and abuse: the Pentagon…
Check out this article: https://truthout.org/articles/its-our-choice-medicare-for-all-or-endless-war/?utm_source=sharebuttons&utm_medium=mashshare&utm_campaign=mashshare
$900,000 for 3 months care?
That’s $10,000 per day or $416.66 for every hour of those 3 months.
Our health care system is highway robbery.
And the American Medical Association has been a big part of the problem.
Until very recently, they were actively opposing a single payer system because it would mean that doctors can’t continue to ream the public.
SomeDAM Poet: I read recently that the AMA still hasn’t accepted a single payer system. Has that changed?
The AMA doesn’t want research to find cures that heal people. The walking ATM’s [people] wouldn’t be paying money for all types of surgery and drugs if they ever got healed. Can’t have that happen.
You’re right.
They still oppose single payer but just left Partnership for America’s Health Care Future” an organization that has been running ads against Medicare for All.
Probably because there are many doctors who are embarrassed to be associated with such a dirtbag organization.
Healthcare was fully privatized years ago. My guess would be that those running the AMA are NOT physicians, but are slick business persons desiring to make a profit. They likely have a Dr. sitting on a board somewhere because it looks good. Just look at how many folks sitting on State Boards of Ed are actually educators? We are screwed and there is no turning back this machine.
It IS a lot of money, but NICU is really labor intensive. There are a huge number of nurses and doctors on the floor at all times, and the needs are really complex. I’m not saying the costs aren’t high, but let’s not nickel and dime these tiny children. I had a daughter in the NICU (she sadly didn’t make it), so I have seen how much dedicated work these people do.
“It IS a lot of money, but NICU is really labor intensive”
Which is one of many reasons we need single payer national healthcare. Is there any other industry that charges so much and can’t at least estimate the cost and provide an itemized bill for services rendered? I know it is impossible in a situation like the one described to estimate the costs, but did anyone really expect her to be able to pay that bill? All the insurance company cared about was making sure they didn’t have to pay even the far lower rate they would have negotiated.
There are a group of physicians who support a universal national health care system but they don’t get much press or coverage by the media. The PNHP, from their web site: Physicians for a National Health Program is a single issue organization advocating a universal, comprehensive single-payer national health program. PNHP has more than 20,000 members and chapters across the United States. [snip] The answer to our health care crisis is clear. We propose a publicly financed, non-profit single-payer national health program that would fully cover medical care for all Americans. pnhp.org, end quote
Flashback to 2009 and the health “care” hearings chaired by Max Baucus (D), article by John Nichols, 5-13-2009: Senate Finance Committee chairman Max Baucus, the insurance industry-friendly Democrat who is managing show hearings on healthcare reform, has come up with a novel way to express his commitment to care for the almost 50 million Americans who have no healthcare and roughly equal number who have inadequate care.
The senior senator from Montana is ordering the arrest of doctors and nurses.
Medical practitioners who have shown up at Baucus-chaired “roundtable discussions” to demand consideration of a real fix — the single-payer, genuinely-public reform that assures all Americans will have health care while at the same time holding down costs — are being taken into custody and removed from the hearing rooms.
At the first Finance Committee session last week, Dr. Margaret Flowers and seven others were taken into custody when they urged Baucus to include witnesses who support single-payer.
Dr. Flowers discussed her arrest on Ed Schultz’s MSNBC show, explaining that physicians, nurses and reform groups representing more than 20 million Americans had repeatedly asked to be heard by Baucus and his colleagues.
But the answer from Baucus, who has been charged by the Obama administration with shaping a health-care plan, has been to call in the cops.
“They just don’t want to hear from single-payer,” explained Dr. Flowers, a pediatrician from Maryland. “We’ve been trying for months now, meeting with members of Congress, to be included in the hearings at the events that they are holding and they keep excluding us.”
also from pnhp.org
Obama still does’t want to hear about true universal health care, just gradualism so that maybe in the year 2950 we might have universal health care, if we’re good and behave.
Joe Jersey
Trump and Trumpism has rehabilitated the Obama legacy for the left.
Obama is a total sellout to the bankers and insurance industry.
If anyone had any doubts of that, his recent attempts to tamp down the “unruly left” should have put those doubts to bed.
The time and circumstances were ripe for transformative actions, but Obama was interested in appeasing and pleasing (the powerbrokers, who now give him millions for a job well done) rather than transforming.
Yes, I know “But but the Republicans had him hog-tied!”
Ha ha ha.
SomeDAM Poet
It is a good thing they had him hog tied or he would not have had an excuse.
Trump means destruction. He is pure evil.
…………………………
UK National Health Service staff to lead protest against Trump visit amid rising privatization concerns
December 1, 2019
Nurses and doctors from the United Kingdom’s National Health Service are planning to lead a protest against U.S. President Donald Trump next week amid mounting concerns about potential privatization of the U.K.’s decades-old public healthcare system.
The Stop Trump Coalition—which helped organize massive protests against the U.S. president when he visited the U.K. in July 2018—said in a statement Friday that “the health workers’ bloc will tell Trump ‘hands off our NHS,’ as concerns intensify about a trade deal letting U.S. firms muscle in on the health service.”
Trump is scheduled to arrived in the U.K. late Monday, ahead of a two-day summit to mark the 70th anniversary of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO). Demonstrators plan to gather at Trafalgar Square Tuesday evening, then march toward Buckingham Palace, where Trump is set to attend a banquet with the Queen.
Supporters of the demonstration include the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND), Keep Our NHS Public, U.K. Student Climate Network, Palestine Solidarity Campaign, People’s Assembly, Muslim Association of Britain, Kurdish Solidarity Campaign, and Quakers in Britain.
“This week we discovered just how great a threat Donald Trump is to our NHS,” explained Nick Dearden of trade campaign group Global Justice Now, who is set to speak at the upcoming protest. “That’s why Tuesday’s demonstration will be led by nurses and doctors—to symbolize the millions of people who will stand up for our health service against a U.S. president who simply represents the biggest, greediest corporate interests in the world.”…
On Wednesday, as Common Dreams reported, Labour Party Leader Jeremy Corbyn unveiled over 450 pages of leaked government documents on U.S.-U.K. trade negotiations between July 2017 and July 2019—which Corbyn called “evidence that under Boris Johnson the NHS is on the table and will be up for sale” in talks with Trump…
https://www.alternet.org/2019/12/uk-national-health-service-staff-to-lead-protest-against-trump-visit-amid-rising-privatization-concerns/#.XePnlUweQO4.gmail
Health insurance in the United States is a different kind of protection racket, and the companies that offer this insurance are RICOs.