Archives for the month of: April, 2018

The Network for Public Education needs your help NOW to stop Betsy DeVos’ latest effort to introduce federal vouchers.

DeVos and some Republican members of Congress have introduced legislation to convert a federal $1 billion program called Impact Aid into vouchers for military families. Impact Aid was designed to reimburse public schools that educate the children of military families and also to compensate public school districts because of the loss of federal revenues due to large federal facilities that don’t pay taxes.

HR 5199 and S. 2517 were introduced in the House and the Senate about a month ago. Carol Burris, executive director of NPE, wrote about this effort here. 

Military families have made clear that they don’t want vouchers. They want good public schools.

The Heritage Foundation is lobbying the House and Senate Armed Services Committees to get the voucher bill tucked into the National Defense Authorization Act (the annual budget for the Department of Defense), and that DeVos herself is lobbying Secretary of Defense James Mattis to get his support.

Please open the link, which makes it easy to contact  your representatives.

Don’t let the privatizers pull a fast one. Read this appeal, which contains resources as well as an easy way to reach out to your representatives. 

Stop DeVos now!

 

Tom Ultican writes that the board of LAUSD is nearing the time of making a decision about who will be the next superintendent of the Los Angeles public schools.

The former publisher of the Los Angeles Times, Austin Beutner, a billionaire and a buddy of Eli Broad, wants to be chosen. He has no education experience, although he does seem to have ties to Betsy DeVos.

The superintendent of the Indianapolis public schools, notorious as a fan of privatization, has taken his hat out of the ring.

That leaves Andres Alonso, who was superintendent in very low-performing Baltimore City, and veteran Los Angeles educator, Vivian Ekchian. The NAEP scores for Baltimore City are significantly below those of the Los Angeles district.

Ms. Ekchian has worked in the LAUSD for 32 years. She has had every possible role in the schools and is now acting superintendent. An Armenian-American who was born in Iran, she has natural empathy for the many immigrant students in the public schools.

The LAUSD board should choose a consensus candidate, not ram through a candidate chosen by a temporary majority.

If the swing vote, Ref Rodriguez, should be convicted of the felonies on which has has been indicted, the board will be 3-3. The superintendent must be in a position to work for and with the board, in the best interests of the students. That will be impossible if the next leader is chosen in a divisive 4-3 vote.

 

 

Stephen Dyer says there is now little or no question that crimes were committed by ECOT (the late, unlamented Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow).

Someone knowingly inflated enrollment to collect millions from the state.

Who done it?

“Because it now appears that we have a smoking gun indicating that officials at the Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow formed the necessary mens rea to be charged with crimes.

“According to an Associated Press story today (which ran all over the place, but I’ll link to my former employer’s version), people at ECOT — at one point the largest single school in the nation — were ordered to deliberately inflate enrollment so the school could keep getting paid $100 million plus to “educate” children, even if those children weren’t actually at ECOT.

“ECOT infamously did a remarkably poor job of educating those who were, by the way. How poor? Only 109 of 3,794 ECOT graduates from 2010 earned a college degree within 6 years of graduating.”

B

Jessica Marks, Teacher of the Year in Arizona, wrote a guest post for Tim Slekar’s blog “Busted Pencils.” She recounts her journey from being fired at KIPP as a terrible teacher to winning accolades on Arizona. And now, on the verge of walking out, she wonders what she should say to the public.

“On Friday, April 27, I will be giving a speech to a ballroom crowded with 300 people, explaining what it meant to have spent the last year as 2017’s Yavapai County Overall Teacher of the Year.

“”It’s been quite an honor. A flag was waved over the nation’s Capitol in my honor. A declaration about my contribution to education was read on the floor of Congress. I was showered with free vacations, free tuition, and thousands of dollars in prize money. People recognize me at the grocery store.

“And only about four years ago, I was fired from a teaching job. My principal then told me that, on a scale between one and four, I was a 1.5.

“I wonder if he realizes his great loss.

“I wonder, what do you put in a speech that will be published in the paper the next day, read by everyone in your small town, and put under a microscope by everyone who wants to squash the Arizona walk-out movement?

“I have a lot to say and, for the first time, I’m in a place in my life where I am not afraid to say it out loud and sign my name to every hurtful word.

I wonder where I should begin?

“I could talk about how far I’ve come. I mean, after I was fired, I wanted to give up teaching altogether and water plants at Home Depot . . . but Home Depot wouldn’t hire me. I was too broken. Too worn out, exhausted after months of 16 – 20 hour days at KIPP Austin: Academy of Arts & Letters. I’d suffered relentlessly, both at the hands of the students and at the hands of the administration. The kids stole from me, destroyed my things, and threatened me. The administration had pointed video cameras at me all day long to document and criticize everything from my handwriting on the board to my clothing. I was trying to teach messages about endurance and foster a love of learning in students that hated school and couldn’t read or write in English. I failed miserably. KIPP discarded me.

“I came home to Arizona after being fired at the pleading of my family and my left-behind boyfriend. I felt lucky that anyone would want me at all, me being so tarnished and useless. My friend told me to apply at a local middle school because “they would hire anyone.” They hired me.

“I gave every bit of my heart and energy and determination to those students. Now, just a few years later, I’m recognized as one of the best educators in the entire state…

“I could use my few minutes on the stage as a platform to speak up for the deplorable conditions of Arizona’s education system. My textbooks are 25 years old. I don’t have one desk that is not mutilated or broken. Every Post-It, pen, or pencil that I use in the classroom has been provided by myself or the generosity of my students’ families. At the beginning of the year, my classes were packed with 36 – 40 students in each one.

“I have had two students try to kill themselves this year. Two of my students have moms who were murdered. I have students living in their cars and motels. My students have withdrawn from school so they can go to prison. We don’t have a social worker on campus. We DO have a school psychologist (though she is TERRIBLY overwhelmed, diagnosing learning disabilities all day and writing IEPs) and three school counselors – but their job is to make sure every student can graduate on time – not give private therapy about traumatic events. But we are having success! I build lessons and create learning with no budget and no help! My students trust me, even though I was a failure before. We rise.”

 

The highest court in Massachusetts ruled unanimously that the cap on charter schools is constitutional. 

It tossed out an effort by charter advocates to win in the judicial system what they lost at the polls in a state referendum in 2016, when the public voted against expanding the number of charter schools.

In an opinion issued Tuesday, Massachusetts’ Supreme Judicial Court dismissed a complaint that the cap on the number of charter schools allowed to operate in state violates students’ rights under the state’s constitution.

The unanimous opinion, authored by Justice Kimberly Budd, affirmed a lower-court decision made in October 2016. It holds that even when public schools under-serve their students, that doesn’t mean state actors are failing in their constitutional duties — or that opening more charter schools is the only way to make it right.

The decision represents a third and possibly decisive setback for the proposal to lift the longstanding cap. In 2015, legislators decided against advancing Gov. Charlie Baker’s bill for more charter schools, instead leaving the choice to voters — who then voted it down by a 24-point margin in 2016.

It’s cause for disappointment and frustration among supporters of those schools, and for students and families who hoped to get in off their wait lists.

“Watching your own children have to suffer in a school that’s underperforming — and knowing that it’s the result of a political turf war… it’s crushing. It’s devastating.”

Keri Rodrigues

 Keri Rodrigues is one of those people. She’s an education activist who supported Question 2 in 2016. Now, she runs Massachusetts Parents United — an advocacy group supported in part by the pro-charter Walton Foundation. She has two sons who have tried and failed to get seats in a charter school. “Watching your own children have to suffer in a school that’s underperforming — and knowing that it’s the result of a political turf war… it’s crushing. It’s devastating…”

The plaintiffs argued that missed opportunity amounted to a violation of their shared right to an adequate public education, or to equal protection under the laws, as laid out in the state constitution.

The SJC opinion accepts the plaintiffs’ arguments that, under Massachusetts’ constitution, state leaders must provide all students with an “adequate education,” and that “the education provided at their schools is, at the moment, inadequate” based on testing data.

But the court rejected the plaintiffs’ conclusions. The opinion holds that state officials and lawmakers must be allowed to work to improve poorly-performing schools, and that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that the state’s current approach — including oversight and takeover of chronically underperforming schools — couldn’t jump-start progress “over a reasonable period of time.”

Rodrigues wasn’t persuaded. “Over what period of time are we talking about? Because parents get roughly 12 years to get their kids an adequate education,” she said. “So are we just supposed to roll the dice and hope the commonwealth is able to figure this out?”

But the SJC opinion goes further. It argues that even if students’ constitutional rights were definitively being violated, it still wouldn’t mean the charter program must be expanded. The opinion states, “There is no constitutional entitlement to attend charter school,” and further, that the court is barred from enforcing any “fundamentally political” remedy of that kind.

The decision, in short, says that the state has an affirmative duty to improve low-performing schools, not an affirmative duty to open privately managed charter schools.

Rodrigues was state director for the now-defunct Families for Excellent Schools (also Walton-funded), which bundled millions of dollars for the failed “Yes on 2” charter expansion referendum; she is now executive director of Massachusetts Parents United, another astroturf group created by Walton and other charter advocacy organizations.

Unlike most parent organizations, Massachusetts Parents United started its life with $1.5 million in projected income and more on the way from the Waltons and other friends. 

The decision affirmed that the charter advocacy groups cannot rely upon the judicial system to overturn the 2016 referendum that said NO to more charter schools.

 

Gary Rubinstein was taken aback when he saw an article in Rupert Murdoch’s tabloid “The New York Post” claiming that the girls’ chess team at Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy had defeated the chess powerhouse at Stuyvesant High School, one of the city’s elite high schools. (Murdoch has personally donated millions of dollars to Success Academy.)

Gary checked the tournament report and found that no student from SA had defeated either of the Stuyvesant contestants at the tournament. The highly-ranked Stuy team sent two players to the tournament, whose combined score was less than the combined scores of the three-person SA team.

What was so disturbing was that SA twisted this narrative into a “glorious victory” for SA. Even Chalkbeat posted a link to the fake news.

Well, what’s the point of having a public relations team if they can’t turn every piece of news into a triumph over a public school with a daunting reputation? Nothing yet from the PR team about SA’s high school graduation rate of 17% (if you start with the 100 students who entered kindergarten at SA). Or, how the carefully culled 32 graduates of 8th grade turned into 17 high school graduates. That’s a graduation rate of 53%, below the grad rate of the city public schools.

 

Nancy Bailey writes here that one of the sources of reading failure is the disappearance of libraries and librarians. 

Ironically, I just learned that New York State adopted the edTPAassessment for librarians, and it is not liked by those in the field. Excellent would-be librarians, I hear, are not likely to pass it, while it favors those who give scripted responses. Is the goal to create s shortage of librarians? Ask the state commissioner.

Bailey writes:

Poor students attend poor schools where they miss out on the arts, a whole curriculum, even qualified, well prepared teachers. Students might end up in “no excuses” charter schools with only digital learning.

But, next to hunger and healthcare, one of the worst losses for children in poor schools is the loss of a school library with a real librarian.

Stephen Krashen, a well-known reading researcher and advocate for children, provided a study he and his co-authors did as proof why school libraries help children be better readers. He is adamant that children need access to books, and he believes good school libraries are “the cure.” We often hear that getting books into the hands of very young children is important. It’s also critical to ensure that children who are in fourth grade and beyond have access to books!

Many poor schools have closed their school libraries, citing a lack of funding. Oakland, California lost thirty percent of their school libraries. Cities from Los Angeles to New York report library closures.

Chicago has lost school libraries. Some there blame the teachers union who pushed not to replace the librarian at one elementary school with volunteers. But good school libraries require good librarians.

School districts in many places keep school libraries open, but they let go of their certified librarians. This is a loss for children.

In 2013, when I started this blog and website, I listed under “Reading” a link showing a map of all the schools in the country that no longer have certified school librarians. That link began in 2010, and sadly the list has grown!…..

From FairTest:

In addition to lots of other testing news, several states that contract with Questar, a for-profit subsidiary of the Educational Testing Service, recently experienced significant disruptions of their computerized standardized exams. In three — New York, Ohio and Tennessee — the entire assessment system crashed. The latest failures add to the evidence that corporate and ideological forces rushed these technologies into the marketplace before they were ready for prime time. See FairTest’s chronology of computer testing problems at:
http://fairtest.org/computerized-testing-problems-chronology

Florida State Seeks to Delay Stricter Grad Test Rules
http://www.orlandosentinel.com/features/education/school-zone/os-florida-graduation-test-scores-20180416-story.html

Georgia District Tells Opt-Out Parents to Keep Kids Home for Two Weeks
http://www.13wmaz.com/article/news/local/what-to-do-if-you-opt-your-child-out-of-milestones-testing-dont-go-to-school/85-542620645
Georgia Top State Court Refuses to Hear Educators Test Cheating Appeal
https://www.myajc.com/news/local-education/highest-georgia-court-won-hear-aps-educators-appeals/zmXkAVaS38EYWLg02FJlZK/

Maryland Computer Testing Is Another Challenge for Low-Income Students
http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/education/k-12/bs-md-online-parcc-test-20180402-story.html

Massachusetts Student and Her Mother Blog About Problems with State Testing
https://lesstestingmorelearning.tumblr.com/post/173095664989/stories-12-and-13-from-a-daughter-and-her

Michigan Standardized Tests Dull Learning
https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/2018/04/17/standardized-tests-dull/33935993/

Minnesota Legislature’s Test-Driven School Ranking System Needs Overhaul
http://www.startribune.com/proposed-system-for-ranking-minnesota-schools-needs-work/480423733/

Mississippi Technical Problems Interrupt State Computerized Test
http://www.heraldcourier.com/news/technical-problem-briefly-interrupts-mississippi-state-tests/article_2066e3fd-859e-52fb-b636-387279e56309.html
Mississippi State Renews $10 Million Testing Contract Despite Recent Exam Administration Disruption
https://www.clarionledger.com/story/news/2018/04/20/mississippi-renews-questar-testing-contract-more-than-10-m/536735002/
Mississippi What’s a Test For?
https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/politics-government/national-politics/article209485029.html

New Jersey PARCC’s Long Goodbye
http://nj1015.com/parccs-long-goodbye-wont-end-standardized-tests-in-new-jersey/

New Mexico Legislators Push Back Against Governor’s Test-Based Retention Plan
http://www.santafenewmexican.com/news/education/secretary-s-school-retention-plan-riles-new-mexico-lawmakers/article_b042ef13-990b-5846-bf30-aec990e296df.html

New York After Epic Fail of State Testing, Parents Seek Removal of Education Commissioner
https://nycpublicschoolparents.blogspot.com/2018/04/epic-fail-of-last-weeks-state-testing.html

North Dakota New Education Dashboard Goes Beyond Test Scores, Includes Student Engagement
http://www.valleynewslive.com/content/news/New-tool-launched-to-Provide-More-Transparency-in-School-Performance—480534231.html

Ohio Statewide Computer Testing System Crashes
https://www.daytondailynews.com/news/online-state-testing-system-down-some-schools-cancel-tests-for-day/3aV1Z4YyJdEp9SdhxJrsON/
Ohio School Grades Are Not Understandable
http://www.norwalkreflector.com/Education/2018/04/20/School-supers-want-simplified-fair-state-report-cards.html

Oregon Latino Students, Standardized Testing and Opting Out
https://www.eugeneweekly.com/2018/04/19/latino-students-what-matters/

Pennsylvania Opt-Out Numbers Growing
https://lancasteronline.com/news/local/nearly-lancaster-county-students-have-opted-out-of-pssas-this/article_2ec60700-44da-11e8-8e1b-3b18d5e8c81f.html
Pennsylvania Teacher Writes Anti-Test Poetry While Proctoring Exams
http://www.philly.com/philly/education/i-had-test-itis-while-kids-are-taking-pssas-this-teacher-might-be-writing-subversive-poetry-20180418.html
Pennsylvania “Kiss My Assessment,” More High-Stakes Poetry
https://gadflyonthewallblog.wordpress.com/2018/04/18/kiss-my-assessment-a-high-stakes-testing-poem/

Tennessee Statewide Computerized Testing System Fails for Third Year in a Row
https://www.commercialappeal.com/story/opinion/editorials/2018/04/20/tnready-testing-testing-testing-and-failing/529442002/
Tennessee Parents Pull Children Out of Testing
https://www.wbir.com/article/news/local/parents-pull-children-from-tnready-testing/51-542961098
Tennessee Legislators Drop Consequences From This Year’s Flawed Tests
https://chalkbeat.org/posts/tn/2018/04/19/breaking-tennessee-lawmakers-take-matters-into-their-own-hands-on-tnready-testing-problems/

Texas High Time for State Testing Burnout
https://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2018/04/18/high-time-staar-test-burn
Texas Why Do They Test?
https://www.mystatesman.com/news/opinion/commentary-let-test-then-you-and/1VVhNP556rJE6RjHiwDpDK/

Washington New System for Evaluating Schools Is Being Implemented
http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2018/apr/18/washington-implementing-new-system-for-judging-sch/#/0
Washington Time to Opt Out
http://saveseattleschools.blogspot.com/2018/04/its-testing-time-opting-out.html

University Admissions SAT Documentary “The Test and the Art of Thinking” Opens Across the U.S.
https://www.thetestdoc.org/

International Why British Parents Will Boycott School Tests
https://www.theguardian.com/education/2018/apr/22/parents-boycott-sats-tests

Worth Reading Why Can’t We Assess Like We Were Assessed?
https://www.educationdive.com/news/we-cant-assess-like-we-were-assessed/521257/
Worth Reading I Lied to My Students Today
http://www.lovewhatmatters.com/i-lied-to-my-students-today/

Bob Schaeffer, Public Education Director
FairTest: National Center for Fair & Open Testing
office- (239) 395-6773 fax- (239) 395-6779
mobile- (239) 699-0468
web- http://www.fairtest.org

 

Eva Moskowitz just received a gift of $15 million from billionaire Dan Loeb, chair of the board of Eva’s Success Academy. Just last year, Loeb received negative public attention for comments widely regarded as racist after he chastised the leading Democrat in the State Senate—who is African American, saying she did more damage to children of color than anyone who ever wore a hood because of her criticism of charter schools.

Many people denounced Loeb’s remarks and called on him to resign, but Eva stood by him. Her forbearance was rewarded with his $15 million to her high school, which just graduated 17 students (of a class that started in kindergarten as 100). Loeb said he hoped that Eva could make her model “scalable.”

How a school with a shedding/dropout/attrition rate of 83% becomes “scalable” is mysterious.

The charter chain plans to open eight new high schools by 2033.

Here is the curious math.

Only 17 students were members of Success Academy’s first graduating class. All 17 are going to college. These are the students that survived the original 100 that enrolled in kindergarten.

That is many many millions of dollars invested to produce 17 graduates who are college bound.

Of the 32 students who graduated from eighth grade at Success charters, nine attended other high schools before going to Success Academy’s High School of the Liberal Arts. Five left before graduating.

Honestly, I don’t understand the math. I can’t figure out how this adds up to 17 graduates, but maybe someone else will and can explain it in a comment.

PS:

Eliza Shapiro explained the math of SA graduation rate to me.

“Basically 32 kids started their 8th grade year together at Success
9 left after 8th grade to go to other high schools and never enrolled/matriculated/entered SA HS
5 other kids enrolled at SA HS and left between the start of their freshman year to the present
That’s all I know! :)”

17 graduated. One may have been held back. Unaccounted for.

 

toñ hhc

We always knew that Campbell Brown’s anti-union, anti-teacher news site (The 74) would find a way to blame the growing wave of teachers’ strikes on those”evil unions.”

Peter Greene finds the quintessential non sequitur article on The 74, written by a choice zealot.

Teachers are walking out in “right to work” states, it seems, because they are robots who do what their unions order them to do. Teachers never think for themselves.

Lest we forget, the 74 is funded in part by Betsy DeVos.

Critical thinking is not the selling point of The 74. Propaganda is.