Carol Lerner posted this comment in response to a post about the new $100 million tax credit voucher program in Illinois:
“The article says it is the largest “first-time” tax credit scholarship program. Florida, at nearly $1-billion, has the largest tax credit scholarship program in the nation. And what is particularly horrifying is that it can increase (as stated in legislation) by 25% per year (which it has been doing each year thus far). At that unbelievable rate, in 15 years the spending on these voucher scholarships would exceed the current education budget of $21-billion and in 20 years, it would be almost as large as the entire current $87.2–billion Florida state budget. That is unlikely to happen but it just shows how absurd a 25% growth rate is.
“Florida gets its money for this $1-billion and rising program by diverting corporate income and other taxes to two non profit scholarship-funding organizations (SFOs): Step Up for Children and AAA Scholarship Foundation. Step Up for Children gets the lion-share of the money for which they get a 3% cut. They also actively solicit money from corporations. Step Up for Children was set up by John Kirtley, a close associate of Betsy DeVos.
“Now with the passage on Monday of Florida House Bill 7055, the amount of money diverted to vouchers that should be going into the general treasury is further expanding as is the source of the money. The legislation stipulates that money to fund sending students who are victims of bullying to private schools will come from a consumer sales tax allowing residents to allocate $110 in sales tax when they purchase a car or transfer registration from another state. So now, it is not just corporate taxes but also consumer taxes that are tapped. A recent article indicated that state revenue projects for this year are down and cuts will have to be made. It is no wonder revenue is down despite a supposid booming economy.
“There is a growing backlash to these privatizing maneuvers in Florida and pretty much all but a few Democrats in the State legislature are on the correct side. (Of course, the Republicans far exceed the Democrats, especially in the FL House of Representatives but this might change a bit in November.) Where I live in Sarasota, a group of us set up last summer an organization, Protect Our Public Schools (POPS), to fight school privatization. The impetus for this was the passage of HB 7069 legislation (a big giveaway to charter schools, particularly corporate-managed charters among many other really awful things). From the start we tied fighting privatization to working for a high quality education for all students. Since the Parkland shooting, we decided to expand our mission to include addressing school violence in all its forms. We are attending school board meetings, holding public forums, staffing tables at marches (e.g., The Women’s March, the upcoming March for Our Lives) and getting a great response. I have developed a presentation on school privatization in Florida and have been invited to present to a bunch of Indivisible groups and just the other day was invited to address the local UU Church. So the movement is growing but our enemies are strong and very well funded and are increasingly using dark monies to target and replace pro-public education school board members.
“If anyone knows people from other parts of Florida working on school privatization issues, please let me know. Given the fact that Florida has an increasingly state-run education system, it is important that we all work together.”
I encouraged Carol and other Floridians to contact Carol Burris of the Network for Public Education to learn about other allies in Florida as well as Sue Legg, education director of the Florida League of Women Voters. She has many allies in the state.
Good grief! Florida needs to protect its public schools. If Florida doesn’t protect its public schools that state will be mayhem. Public Schools are for the “Common Good.”
I don’t understand why people are so short-sighted and cannot see the GAMES being played by the deformers.
Why would the deformers want their BAD deeds to be monuments? Is $$$$$, perks, and power worth it? Everything we do has a ripple effect. Karma is the physics of one’s life.
From the book, Wonder:
YOUR DEEDS ARE YOUR MONUMENTS.
Palacio, R. J.. Wonder, Random House Children’s Books.
You said, ‘I don’t understand why people are so short-sighted and cannot see the GAMES being played by the deformers.’
I have watched a number of children fallen out of school, go to jail, get shot and killed, and abandoned any dream their parents might have had for them. Some of these parents have good jobs so don’t think they are deprived of the good things in life. In the neighborhoods where I live not many people will discuss, for any length of time, privatizers or privatizing. So, the privatizers sell them a story they really wish to believe and need to. They, and everyone else wish the best for their kids and they are not seeing that in the schools they have. Their children finish school and they have to pick up a crummy job for life. They simply do not understand that is going on.
The people who know better, spend a great deal of time with their children, reading to them when babies, taking them to libraries when they are old enough. They commit themselves to the education of their young and make the sacrifices they need to. They might end up here reading this. But they already distrust the privatizers and they are only confirming what they felt and extending their knowledge and understanding of what is happening.
Very many people read only when they have to and will not visit a blog of any type, unless it is about music perhaps. Long reading, and god forbid, lengthy reasoning, is not their forte.
The people in the street, want a decent house, car or suv in which to go through life. Many times their children just barely make it through school, and any dreams of becoming a doctor, degreed nurse, psychologist or psychiatrist, is beyond them. They think that is nonsense, for them and their friends to dream of. But they dearly want it for their children, they just do not know how to do it. So they readily buy into what the privatizers sell them.
As for the politicians they can be bought, depending on their desires for their lives.
None of the people I commonly meet discuss Koch, Alec, libertarian, or privatizing of schools, even white teachers. It is an issue indeed but not on the front burners of their minds. The message is not getting around at all; sadly. The people who need to see messages of this type, do not see it. They see the one the privatizers present. A pity.
The saddest truth now that we’re so many years into the test-labeling, neighborhood-dividing, teacher-blaming mess: “…not many people will discuss, for any length of time, privatizers or privatizing. So, the privatizers sell them a story they really wish to believe and need to.”
I believe in Unions BUT Privatization has taken over. In some counties the superintendents are in cahoots with the unions. Many wolves in sheep’s clothing. EX, in Miami: a 22 year teacher makes LESS THAN the mid way mark on the current Min/Max salary scale – 10 years ago, a 22 year teacher was at the top of the pay scale. Now factor in the cost of living and the reduction of retirement pay. This has been long in the making. Tax payers will soon realize- a little too late.
AND, the pubic has been swallowing the “bad” school/teacher/student message for so long, now, and today’s kids (and thus their parents) have heard the testing-as-king mantra from preschool on up: little by little, a fully enacted Institutional Memory Loss offers up less and less chance (especially as older teachers are methodically pushed out the door) of young activists remembering what a well-protected teaching profession looked like.
Institutional Memory Loss …excellent point, and making things more difficult is that an estimated 25% of adults do not have any link to school-age children.
I am not sure I book-marked that source, but it was almost a throw away line in a blog or essay.
the concept of intentionally killing the public school system’s Institutional Memory came to me from a young teacher who had just been pushed out of her teaching job for speaking up against the racism inherent to test-score “reforms” at her school. I remember thinking, after she explained herself: Wow. That’s IT.
This is sickening. As an educator I’ve been following it all. In trying to be forward thinking and knowing about our diminishing population along with the ever changing world of jobs and global economy one wants to support the best choices. The manipulation of information and facts has historically always been with us. The dawn of social media with or without planned manipulation has in its self inherent problems in that people spread false and upsetting information more rapidly and widely than real news. We have a big job ahead of us. Older Americans are the majority. I challenge older people to not sit back and think that high school students alone can fight and win. In in to win.
Privatization has already taken place – I don’t think there is any turning back. Parents, students and most fl. teachers are oblivious. I have been speaking out about this for years – now is too late.
Never too late
Ok – hope? Too many connected individuals. In fla, it is not dem.vs rep. – it is corporate greed against the rest. Writing on the wall. I predict, Charter districts within 2 years with teacher housing.
OnlyinMiami
May your predictive capabilities be as bad and wrong as mine!
Agree ! (fingers crossed) However, I have been researching this for years – it does not look good for public schools in FL. Know the players and track the flow of money.
In conservative northwest Florida there is little news coverage on privatization unless there is an FBI raid on a charter, and there are not too many charter schools here yet. The latest dirty trick to destroy public schools targets areas with large military populations like northwest Florida. The state wants to turn the military impact money into vouchers for students. Scott is also going to run for the Senate as a challenge to Bill Nelson. Jeb Bush and his dystopian views cast a long shadow in the state and the attacks can only be neutralized if enough people are tired of the destruction of public education. Florida is badly in need of change that can only happen if enough people vote blue in November.
Florida may need a brain washing squad in order to flip the state. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/inspired-life/wp/2017/11/22/at-yale-we-conducted-an-experiment-to-turn-conservatives-into-liberals-the-results-say-a-lot-about-our-political-divisions/?utm_term=.178b38d364a8
Hi Ruth and Harold,
I got your birthday message. Thank you and yes, let’s celebrate all we can when we get together. I hear that you’re neck is feeling better too, another joy to celebrate!
Have a read below. I asked to be put in contact. I’ll let you know what I find out.
I’m looking for things to do after I retire so…who knows.
All this hidden manipulation is sickening.
Thank you for adopting me. : )
XO