Journalist Todd Smekens in Indiana blogged about the struggle by Glenda Ritz to stop Governor Mike Pence from destroying her position, to which she was elected by the people of Indiana. This is a battle for democracy, not for an individual.
Smekens sees the struggle as part of a national attack on public education. He tied it to Sue Peters’ upset victory in Seattle, where the zillionaires put together what they thought was a big enough campaign fund to crush her.
Smekens recognizes that Pence is trying not only to usurp democracy but to make Indiana a friendly home for “free market capitalists.” Pence wants to protect Indiana as a zone where entrepreneurs can make a profit by feeding off the public schools with false promises.
He writes:
The free market capitalists are bankrolling school board seats to expand charter programs or advancing the privatization of our school system.
The same billionaire free marketers who are driving to eliminate unions, cut government regulation, strip workers of their rights, etc. are also behind Common Core standardized testing. You saw how important it was to Tony Bennett – he had to increase grades from a C to an A so they could keep pushing their privatization agenda – it cost him his job in Florida.
However what most journalists in Indiana are missing is the underlying fact that charters do not outperform public schools. Even with all the hype, new equipment, the opportunity to screen students, etc., they still don’t outperform public schools. The hundreds of millions of dollars thrown at “fixing the education system” by corporations, foundations, and non-educator politicians, the bottom line is they make decisions based on profit schemes versus the needs of teachers-students-parents.
So, if you think Gov. Mike Pence is simply playing politics with the formation of the CECI to usurp State Education Superintendent, Glenda Ritz, you’re only scratching the surface. Gov. Pence hired all the education reform players who worked with the former superintendent Tony Bennett. Who also worked with Mitch Daniels, the Gates Foundation, and reformers like Jeb Bush to privatize Indiana’s schools. They have a financial stake in Indiana, so they will not give up until Glenda Ritz is removed from the equation.
These billionaire free market capitalists could care less about our democratic process in this country – they’ve now shown their hands from the billion dollar Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) trade agreement being negotiated behind closed doors, the dysfunction in shutting down our government in Washington, the dysfunction in our statehouses and gerrymandering districts to prevent competition, and all the way down to simple school board seats in our community.
If you think these free market libertarian billionaires and their Tea Party cowboys are about “freedom of choice”, you’ve been badly misguided by corporate media spin owned by the same people.

Off-topic, but a bit humorous: So Much for Asian PISA Scores:
http://gizmodo.com/5304233/entire-new-13+story-building-tips-over-in-shanghai/
LikeLike
The really scarey thing is that we are letting it happen. How much is living in a democratic society worth to us? Too many of us have been totally demoralized or worn out. Some of us are just trying to hang on to what we can. Some time (soon, I hope, I think) we are going to reach a tipping point. Free market capitalism makes a lousy form of government. I hope I still have the will and the energy to stand for democracy. The battle over public education is only a skirmish in a much larger war.
LikeLike
Examine this thought.
If the way to improve something is to “run it like a business;” then ask for whom does that improve the outcome. In business, the goals are profit and monopoly. So, running things like a business, isn’t good for employees, isn’t good for customers, and isn’t good for the public. It is good for the CEOs and CFOs.
Examine any industry, cell phones, airlines. As the industry is deregulated that allows corporations to buy each other. With less competition the costs of products and services rise, it also forces down wages and benefits. Meanwhile instead of a 12:1 or 20:1 (1965) ratio between CEO and average worker, last year it was 273:1.
Running things like a business is good for the person running the business.
http://www.epi.org/publication/the-ceo-to-worker-compensation-ratio-in-2012-of-273/
LikeLike
The Education Revolution. A remake of the American Revolution. As one of my students claimed, I am a Rebel as we explore what led up to the Am. Rev. Let us Patriots gather in solidarity. The Time is Now…
LikeLike
how about a compromise for those big corporations that want to take over public education? Why not make the law be that they only get paid if so many students pass a state test at minimum levels. Otherwise they do not get paid at all. I wonder how many new corporate charter schools would actually be started, and how many existing corporate charter schools would instantly pull up their stakes and leave the state.
LikeLike
Great idea, except, the testing company: CTBS is in bed with the same folks. Scores can be manipulated in many ways to make your buddy’s school look good. Just ask Tony Bennett!
LikeLike
I wonder why there has been no one in the legislature to speak up and challenge the Governor on this takeover. How has the Governor silenced the remaining few legislators who might really see the dark side of this move.
LikeLike
Phillip Harris, there is a super-majority of Republicans in both houses of the legislature in Indiana. They blindly follow the Governor wherever he leads them. Meanwhile, those who DO oppose him, speak out publicly against what the governor is doing, but don’t have the numbers to actually do anything about him.
LikeLike
I am one of the many in Indiana who voted for both Pence and Ritz. I am so disappointed in Gov. Pence and his behind the scenes antics. Our state legislators are staying as quiet as possible. They see the potential political fallout.
LikeLike
I’m sorry, I guess I’m being rude, but what the hell did you expect from Pence? How could you support both him and Ritz? They’re diametrically opposed. I mean, I know his competition wasn’t much, but, geez, Pence???
LikeLike
There are many of us in Indiana that subscribe to smaller government but still strongly support public education. I believed that Mr. Pence fit that description. Sadly, he has not proven to be doing a good job at either. Also, Candidate Pence was very cagey regarding his education viewpoints. In fact, his comments during the campaign were extremely misleading. His wife is a teacher by the way. This may have given some of us a false sense of security regarding his views on education reform. In the beginning, Glenda Ritz appeared to have high hopes of being able to work with Pence. The shadow education agency put an end to that.
LikeLike
Like ‘Unhappy Hoosier’, I too voted for both Pence and Ritz. Dienne, there are always factors to consider at the polls–like the alternative candidate, for instance. Bennett was a disaster for public education in Indiana; many Republicans voted for Ritz, but felt Pence would do a good job bringing businesses and employment to Indiana. Sadly, not happening–at least not in NW Indiana. Until teachers are again permitted to teach and are not overwhelmed with bureaucratic red tape paperwork involving the word de jour (i.e. ‘teamwork,’ ‘diversity,’ ‘cooperation,’) and federal mandates, and given some autonomy in their classrooms, nothing is going to change.
LikeLike
Cord, I live in the district that Pence represented in the U.S. Congress, and he did absolutely NOTHNG for our district for the entire time he represented us. He didn’t believe that the federal government should “provide” for his constituents if it wasn’t necessary, even though we all paid for its services through taxes. He is doing the same as governor. I assumed that would be the case, which is the reason I did NOT vote for him.
LikeLike
Ritz will be the next governor of Indiana.
LikeLike
Mike Pence & the Republican dominated Indiana General Assembly take their marching orders from ALEC. When people say they believe in “smaller government” which the Koch brothers & their followers extoll, what that really means is the privatization of any & all public services. Before you vote, ask for explanations. I’d rather have the DOE in Indiana working for public schools instead of Claire Fiddian-Green, who is not an educator, working to privatize schools. Thats why we elected Glenda Ritz.
If you listened to Mike Pence while he was in the House, you would have known exactly what he would do to public schools & public school teachers when elected as governor.
LikeLike
I disagree that the term smaller government means privatization of all public services. That is not my interpretation. I am a supporter of Glenda Ritz. Glad that some of you have all the answers. Some of us are still searching but are respectful on our postings.
LikeLike
Thank you Diane for posting our article on your blog. Like much of the south, Indiana has a large contingency of Tea Partiers who wrongly believe government is the problem. We also have Gannett owned newspapers who open up their pages to the free market libertarians who write as if their opinions are fact. The fundamental belief of the free market class is the poor are lazy and support democrats because they get free stuff.
Considering the government has been acquired by monied interests over the past three decades, and Citizen United helped finalize the merger of the public sector into the private sector, our only ability to fight back is through our vote. A voter who has been misinformed or misled is voting against their own self interests.
The billionaire backed free market libertarians are winning the battle against education like they are winning many of the other battles in this country. They can spend billions buying ads on TVs, newspaper outlets, and academic shills who will write articles for money. They’ve invested a lot money on making sure things go their way.
Moderate republicans with a conscience are changing to over to the democrat party since they cannot stand what has become of the republican party. Education is not about politics, but unfortunately, Wall Street wants to extract wealth from our communities by viewing our kids as commodities with cash flow attached them. They’ll use whoever they have to guarantee it happens.
Throw out all your old beliefs regarding politics and the “value systems” they stood for since the Oligarchs own both parties and use them to divide and conquer.
You have to be cynical and skeptical and start using those rusty old critical thinking skills which the Oligarchs don’t want you to use – all these tests our students are taking eliminate building critical thinking skills. Former Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels wanted Howard Zinn banned in Indiana – called Zinn’s view of history “liberal excrement”.
There has been a nationwide push to read Zinn’s books by many people who had never heard of Howard Zinn. They want to know why a state governor was so threatened by a history book writer.
Here are a few quotes from Howard Zinn which might explain why:
“I’m worried that students will take their obedient place in society and look to become successful cogs in the wheel – let the wheel spin them around as it wants without taking a look at what they’re doing. I’m concerned that students not become passive acceptors of the official doctrine that’s handed down to them from the White House, the media, textbooks, teachers and preachers.”
and –
“Civil disobedience is not our problem. Our problem is civil obedience. Our problem is that people all over the world have obeyed the dictates of leaders…and millions have been killed because of this obedience…Our problem is that people are obedient allover the world in the face of poverty and starvation and stupidity, and war, and cruelty. Our problem is that people are obedient while the jails are full of petty thieves… (and) the grand thieves are running the country. That’s our problem.”
LikeLike
Received from Brad Oliver, member of Indiana State Board of Instruction:
“There is an agenda item for tomorrow’s public meeting at 9:00am that involves revisions to existing Board Operating Procedures that Supt. Ritz has been actively involved with as an outgrowth of our work with a NASBE consultant. Every effort is being taken to ensure there is consensus on the proposed changes. I have seen nothing to suggest anyone is trying to strip the Superintendent of her role as Chair of the State Board.
Respectfully,
Brad Oliver”
LikeLike