Springfield, Ohio, has been in the news lately, and not in a good way. At the debate between Trump and Harris, Trump claimed that Haitian immigrants were stealing pets and eating them. The ABC moderator corrected him and told him it wasn’t true. Trump refused to believe him, insisting that he saw it on television.
The next day, Springfield’s City Hall and other facilities were closed due to bomb threats. Municipal authorities released a statement denying Trump’s claim and expressing appreciation for the Haitians’ contributions to the town’s economy. They are legal immigrants.
A father in Springfield whose 11-year-old son was killed in a collision between a school bus and a minivan driven by a Haitian pleaded with Trump, Vance, and other Republican politicians to stop using his son’s name in their campaigns. He was not murdered, he said; he died in a traffic accident. “Please stop the hate,” he said. “In order to live like Aiden, you need to accept everyone, choose to shine, make the difference, lead the way and be the inspiration…Live like Aiden.”
John Legend stepped in to post an article about Springfield on Facebook that was then published by The Columbus (Ohio) Dispatch. He was born in Springfield.
Editor’s note: Springfield native John Legend, an internationally acclaimed performer, took to social media Sept. 12 to address backlash against Haitian immigrants promoted by Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and his running mate, U.S. Sen. JD Vance of Middletown. His statement is below.
My name is John Legend, and I was born as John. R Stevens from a place called Springfield, Ohio. Springfield, Ohio — you may have heard of Springfield, Ohio, this week.
In fact, if you watch the debate, we were discussed by our presidential candidates, including a very special, interesting man named Donald J. Trump.
Now, Springfield has had a large influx of Haitian immigrants who come to our city.
Now, our city had been shrinking for decades. We didn’t have enough jobs. We didn’t have enough opportunity so people left and went somewhere else.
So, when I was there, we had upwards of 75,000 people and in the last five years we were down to like 60,000 people.
But of late, during the Biden administration, there have been more jobs that opened up. More manufacturing jobs, more plants, factories that needed employees and were ready to hire people.
So, we had a lot of job opportunities, and we didn’t have enough people in our town of 60,000 people to fill those jobs.
And during the same time, there has been upheaval and turmoil in Haiti. The federal government granted visas and immigration status to a certain number of Haitian immigrants so they could come to our country legally.
Our demand in Springfield for additional labor met up with the supply of additional Haitian immigrants and here we are.
We had about 15,000 or so immigrants move to my town of 60,000.You might say, wow, that’s a lot of people for a town that only had 60,000 before. That’s a 25% increase.
That is correct.
So you might imagine there are some challenges with integrating a new population.
New language, new culture, new dietary preferences. All kinds of reasons why there might be growing pains.
Making sure there are enough services to accommodate the new, larger population that might need bilingual service providers, etc. etc.
So, there are plenty of reasons why this might be a challenge for my hometown.
But the bottom line is these people came to Springfield because there were jobs for them and they were willing to work.
They wanted to live the American dream, just like your German ancestors, your Irish ancestors, your Italian ancestors, your Jewish ancestors. Your Jamaican ancestors, your Polish ancestors – all these ancestors who moved to this country.
Maybe not speaking the language that everyone else spoke.
Maybe not eating the same foods.
Maybe having to adjust.
Maybe having to integrate.
But all coming because they saw opportunity for themselves and their families in the American dream.
And they came here to do that.

(10) Facebook
LikeLike
(10) Facebook
LikeLike
Good afternoon Diane and everyone,
Just imagine if I went into my workplace (where there are people of Haitian descent) and said that all the Haitian immigrants were running around stealing pets and eating them. What would happen to me at my workplace? What would happen to any of us living in the real world? Our butts would be bounced out into the street and rightly so. Yet this is the crap we have to put up with from a former president and someone who wants to sit in the oval office. It never ceases to amaze me. Time for half this country to look deep inside and figure out what they are projecting onto this guy and get working on that in themselves pretty quickly.
LikeLike
And didn’t we have a version of this in the 70’s with Asian people stealing family pets to use in their restaurants? It was untrue then and it’s untrue now! Same lie, different nationality.
LikeLike
Its the 21st century version of an angry mob carrying torches and pitchforks and going after the town “witch.”
LikeLike
Mamie, so true!
LikeLike
Lisa: that was my first thought when I heard this
LikeLike
But in the 1970s, the lie wasn’t being told by the LEADERS OF ONE OF THE MAJOR POLITICAL PARTIES!
It’s true that these kinds of false rumors and attacks on various ethnic groups were out there. But it wasn’t Richard Nixon or Jimmy Carter or Gerald Ford saying them.
That’s why scholars of fascism have been saying we are at def com 1000 or whatever it is.
This is NOT NORMAL. But it was certainly “normal” in Nazi Germany when it was the leadership of a major political party spewing these lies about Jews.
The first stage of genocide is dehumanizing other groups.
LikeLike
Haitians are easy targets for bullies like Trump and Vance. They come from a very poor, troubled island, and they are generally poor and don’t speak the language. They are perfect scapegoats for racist politicians. When AIDS arrived in the 1980s there was a claim that Haitians were spreading it. “Catgate” is another attempt to attack those that cannot defend themselves.
I worked as an ESL teacher in a school district with a large Haitian community for more than three and half decades. I remain in touch with several of my former Haitian students, and they know exactly what Trump and Vance are doing. As John Legend mentions, Haitians simply want to work to be able to support their children. Most of them are hard working, law abiding people, and they do not eat people’s cats.
What Springfield is experiencing is a bit of cultural friction that is often the case when many newcomers arrive in large numbers into an established community. If given a chance, Haitians generally acculturate well into American society as they are Christian. Many Haitian families value education, and many of my former Haitian students are two and four year graduates of institutions of higher education.
LikeLike
I relate to your post, rt. When I moved from Manhattan to Park Slope Brooklyn in 1980, it was to an area which had been settled by Haitian immigrants in the 1960’s after a period when that area was poor & chaotic. The Haitians helped it become a middle class enclave. (They were mostly gone by 1980, on to bigger & better things).
Another chord this rings with me: my grandparents loved sailing, and spent much of their adult life vacations sailing in the Caribbean. My grandfather was of Irish/German working class parentage [born 1907], and a real racist, especially toward blacks. But his travels mellowed him to an extent: he would always tell me– Martinique was a smart island: no matter how poor, locals could live off the fruits of the island, where a large portion of land near shore was free and fertile. And then he would start on the Haitians: THE most productive and ambitious folks he’d met in his Caribbean travels.
LikeLike
Often those that are accustomed to scarcity become very resourceful.
LikeLike
I recently read that Traitor Trump’s grandfather was an immigrant like that.
What I read said Frederick Trump saw opportunities after he reached the United States as an immigrant, but wasn’t succesful at first, until he failed at one opportunity and saw another one in Alaska during the gold rush there.
“Born and raised in Kallstadt in what was then the Kingdom of Bavaria, (Friedrich) Trump immigrated to the United States in 1885. In 1891, he began speculating in real estate in Seattle. During the Klondike Gold Rush, he moved to the Yukon and made his fortune by operating a restaurant and a brothel for miners in Whitehorse.” SOURCE: Wiki
Donald Trump’s father, Fred Trump, was arrested on two occasions. One involved a Ku Klux Klan rally…
LikeLike
Every new immigrant group has had to face a barrage of lies about them, starting with the Irish in the 1840s.
LikeLike
Here’s another false whopper coming from Breaking Christian News [BCN]. The far R doesn’t give up.
…………………………………………………….
Story from breakingchristiannews.com
HAITIAN VOTER FRAUD UNCOVERED IN SPRINGFIELD, OHIO
Paula Bolyard : Sep 13, 2024
“…This is fraud, outright fraudulent behavior … It’s plain and obvious to me when you get this many registration cards with the very same handwriting that someone is trying to defraud the elections process in Hamilton County.” -Alex Trianfaflou, a Hamilton County Board of Elections member and chairman of the Ohio Republican Party
[PJMedia.com] Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose warned election boards to be extra vigilant in the weeks before the November election after an investigation uncovered illegal voter registration forms circulating in Clark County. (Image: Pexels)
In a media advisory, the secretary of state’s office noted, “The office’s Election Integrity Unit recently concluded an investigation into the origins of an illegal voter registration form translated into the Haitian Creole language. The Clark County Board of Elections reported this form to our office after rejecting its submission by a local applicant.”
In a memo to election officials, Hun Yi, director of investigations for the Secretary of State’s Public Integrity Division, said, “The Board confirmed they’ve only received one of these unauthorized forms, but they rightly recognized it as illegal and worked with my team to track down its source with the help of a county government assistance office.”
“The form was erroneously included among others outsourced to a foreign language translation service. It garnered national attention considering the high number of Haitian refugees that have recently migrated to the Springfield area, and it serves as an important reminder that boards and designated voter registration agencies should be vigilant about the use of forms submitted to their office,” Yi added.
Clark County is home to Springfield, Ohio, where as many as 30,000 Haitians have unexpectedly migrated—most of them semi-legally after the Biden-Harris administration extended Temporary Protected Status to 300,000 Haitian migrants in June.
The mass migration to Springfield has taxed hospitals, schools, and social services as the population went from around 60,000 to more than 80,000 overnight.
LaRose’s press release noted an ongoing investigation into “evidence of a pattern of fraudulent voter registration activity in multiple counties under the paid employment of a group called Black Fork Strategies.”…
LikeLike
Love this from John Legend. Sent from Elaine Barnett’s iPhone
LikeLike
The Republican candidates surely are, going, ALL OUT, first, they’d disrepected the, veterans, and now, they’d, lied at the face of the facts, to fuek their anti-immigrations belief, just how LOW can a, political party, go??? And yet, they still have, this, huge a crowd, following them…
LikeLike
John Legend does not have all the facts. He sits in his million dollar home and does nothing except spout his opinion. The Hatians have the right to persue the American way of life but they should not ruin Springfield. The Hatians put garbage down the street water drain pipes. They do not understand the gas or water pipes. If John Legend wanted to help he would spend his millions to go there and help the Hatians in Springfield to understand and adapt to American values instead of their Hatian way of life which was very poor.
LikeLike
The newly arrived Haitians need a liaison to help them navigate living the US and the technology. I recall when the Hmong arrived from Vietnam they were setting fires in apartments because they did not understand central heat. Haitians need a guide. They need a little help and patience in order to adjust. It is unlikely they are doing inappropriate things deliberately; it is more likely they are are not familiar with the culture, climate, food and language.
LikeLike
It’s not surprising that groups of hateful people are spreading lies about immigrants in Springfield.
What is UNPRECEDENTED (at least in recent history) is that all the leaders from one of the two major political parties are doing it.
As much as I despise Rudy Giuliani and George W. Bush, the one decent thing both of them did was that within hours of knowing who the hijackers were, they shut down the anti-Muslim rhetoric. There was still plenty of it being spewed, but it wasn’t being spewed by the leaders of a major political party so it lacked the same power and credibility.
I remember how tense it was living in NYC in the immediate days following 9/11. I can only imagine what it would have been like if Rudy and Bush had been spewing conspiracy theories that they heard “someone on tv” saying. Would there have been violence? Very likely.
If I recall correctly, Trump was spewing conspiracy theories back then! But since at the time, Trump was not the leader of a political party where every elected official was attesting to Trump’s honesty and credibility, Trump’s lies and hate did NOT have the power they have now.
I can’t believe the media is still working overtime to present Trump as credible.
LikeLike