Laura Meckler and Hannah Natanson wrote about Governor Tim Walz’s record on education in Minnesota. In making decisions, Walz relied on his own knowledge as a veteran public school teacher and very likely on research, but The Washington Post misleadingly attributed his views to “the teachers’ union,” the bugbear of the far-right.
The article is saturated with bias against teachers unions and presents the pro-education Walz as a tool of the union, not as a veteran educator who knows the importance of public schools. Walz grew up and taught in small towns. They don’t want or need “choice.” They love their public schools, which are often the central public institution in their community.
The 2019 state budget negotiations in Minnesota were tense, with a deadline looming, when the speaker of the House offered Gov. Tim Walz a suggestion for breaking the impasse.
They both knew that the Republicans’ top priority was to create a school voucher-type program that would direct tax dollars to help families pay for private schools. House Speaker Melissa Hortman, a Democrat, floated an idea: What if they offered the Republicans a pared-down version of the voucher plan, some sort of “fig leaf,” that could help them claim a symbolic victory in trade for big wins on the Democratic side? In the past, on other issues, Walz had been open to that kind of compromise, Hortman said.
This time, it was a “hard no.”
He used his position’s formidable sway over education to push for more funding for schools and backed positions taken by Education Minnesota, the state’s teachers union of which he was once a member. His record on education will probably excite Democrats but provide grist for Republicans who have in recent years gained political ground with complaints about how liberals have managed schools.
Teachers and their unions consistently supported Walz’s Minnesota campaigns with donations, records show. And in the first 24 hours after he was selected as Vice President Kamala Harris’s running mate, teachers were the most common profession in the flood of donations to the Democratic ticket, according to the campaign.
During the chaotic 2020-21 pandemic-rattled school year, Walz took a cautious approach toward school reopening that was largely in line with teachers, who were resisting a return to in-person learning, fearful of contracting covid.
Critics say that as a result, Minnesota schools stayed closed far too long — longer than the typical state — inflicting lasting academic and social emotional damage on students.
As a former teacher, Walz knew that teachers were reluctant to return to the classroom until safety protocols were in place.
Walz also advanced his own robust and liberal education agenda. He fought to increase K-12 education spending in 2019, when he won increases in negotiations with Republicans, and more dramatically in 2023, when he worked with the Democratic majority in the state House and Senate. He won funding to provide free meals to all schoolchildren, regardless of income, and free college tuition for students — including undocumented immigrants — whose families earn less than $80,000 per year. He also called out racial gaps in achievement and discipline in schools and tried to address them…
And as culture war debates raged across the country in recent years, Walz pushed Minnesota to adopt policies in support of LGBTQ+ rights…
In the 2022 elections, Walz was reelected, and Minnesota Democrats took control of the Senate. Democrats now had a “trifecta” — governor, House and Senate — and a $17.6 billion budget surplus.
After taking his oath of office in January 2023, Walz said Minnesota had a historic opportunity to become the best state in the nation for children and families. His proposals included a huge increase in K-12 education spending.
“Now is the time to be bold,” he said.
The final budget agreement in 2023 increased education spending by nearly $2.3 billion, including a significant boost to the per-pupil funding formula that would be tied to inflation, ensuring growth in the coming years. Total formula funding for schools would climb from about $9.9 billion in 2023 to $11.4 billion in 2025, according to North Star Policy Action. The budget also included targeted money for special education, pre-K programs, mental health and community schools.
Walz also signed legislation providing free school meals for all students — a signature achievement — not just those in low-income families who are eligible under the federal program…
In his 2023 State of the State address, Walz drew a pointed contrast between the culture wars raging in states such as Florida and the situation in Minnesota.
“The forces of hatred and bigotry are on the march in states across this country and around the world,” Walz said. “But let me say this now and be very clear about this: That march stops at Minnesota’s borders.”
Through his tenure, he repeatedly took up the causes of LGBTQ+ rights and racial justice.
He signed a measure prohibiting public and school libraries from banning books due to their messages or opinions, and another granting legal protection to children who travel to Minnesota for gender-affirming care.

On a good day I have my hopes the major news outlets will one day return to the job of providing people with the critical information they need to make decisions about what’s good for themselves and their society, both over the short run and the long haul — instead of doing what they do now — disseminating the news of the day like so many Kentucky Derby color commentaries (we all know how that song goes) until the bets are long past off.
But this is not that day …
LikeLike
Where have they been? Did they ever take a U.S. government course? The Vice-President can’t pass ANY laws. Congress—both houses—pass laws. When Money controls the Houses, nothing proposed by a President (or VP) passes without Money support.
LikeLike
Are you still angry about the time you asked why Kamala Harris hasn’t passed any legislation and you were told the Vice President can’t pass legislation?
LikeLike
Walz understands the need to preserve the common good, and it has nothing to do with the teachers union. He demonstrated wisdom and a deep understanding of what a “compromise” on vouchers would mean to his state. In state after state vouchers are a slippery unaccountable fiscal ans social slope that undermines the common good. Waltz understands that DEI, diversity, equity and inclusion, are not attacks on society. They reflect the desire to build a more fair and just society. The privatization of public education has resulted in sorting young people by race and class. Privatization promotes racial discrimination, inequality and exclusionary policies that generally favor affluent white students while simultaneously undermining the schools that bring all of us together to promote mutual respect and understanding.
The media bias in this country worse than ever, The news should not be an editorial. It should attempt to report and inform instead of trying to sway public opinion.
LikeLike
The Washington Post has long been a cheerleader for corporate school “reform”. The paper gave Jay Matthews a forum for years for bashing public schools, so this biased article about Walz is not surprising.
LikeLike
The Post, like The Times, suffers from a mental disorder they share with, which should surprise nobody anymore, donald trump. Their learned scribes state things on the record which, having been uttered,w must be true due to their own infallibility. The first word that comes to my mind is “shameful.” Feel free to offer your own suggestions.
LikeLike
Dang! Those liberal media are killing this country.
LikeLike
Laura Meckler and Hannah Natanson article “was saturated with bias against teachers unions and presents the pro-education Walz as a tool of the union, not as a veteran educator who knows the importance of public schools.”
First, I googled Laura Meckler but could not discover how old she is. I looked at only the first five pages of hits. I hate wasting time. Wiki usually has that information, but I couldn’t find a Wiki page about her.
Her photos look likes she might have been born after 1983 and missed the LIE heard around the world from President Reagan, a lie titled A Nation at Risk.
That lie launched a war against the US Public-schools, public-school teachers, and public-school teacher labor unions. An assault on the foundation of our democracy.
I think Meckler grew up listening to the propaganda from that war and her the foundation of her flawed thinking was built on those lies.
Hannah Natanson looks younger. Still, I also could not find a Wiki page about her.
For two journalists with their alleged reputations based on fools gold, I find that strange.
I don’t think they know that they grew up during the education wars and the only reason they are where they are today is because that have demonstrated that they have been appropriately programmed to think the way the way the fascists want them to think.
I started teaching in 1975, eight years before President Teflon Don Reagan declared war on our public school, a war that has raged for 41 years. I have no doubts that by the time these two graduated from college they had no clue what was going on. Teaching was more rewarding and less stressful before Reagan declared war on OUR public schools. Teachers were treated with more respect. Most students cooperated in doing what it takes to learn what they were taught.
After 1983, that all went downhill fast until teaching was more stressful than being a US Marine in combat and it kept getting worse.
Today, thanks to the fascists and their ditto head stooges like these two, teachers and their unions are blamed for just about everything idiots like them can think of.
LikeLike
Reading your response I’m am struck by how susceptible people from he United States (and probably other countries) have been to mis-dis-information even before the internet. People still talk about Regan as if he were Jesus Christ himself. A clear reading of history would show them how much he, and his acolytes, set into motion that have slowly (and not so slowly) eroded the fabric of our nation. His “I’m from the government,” quip is still presented as some sort of scriptural verse. Meanwhile, out through the backdoor, healthcare, schools, the internet (which was funded by taxpayers) is being sold off to the highest bidder, all with the pronouncement: “Private industry just does things better!” I want to scream “No! Capitalism, and it foot soldier private industry, are about making money. They are not about helping people!” Anand Giridharadas points out that regulating private industry would be as simple as “if you want to do business in this country here these are the rules… They would make less but they would still make massive amounts of money. But he is also quick to point to the mis-information machine that would rev-up it’s engines and drive B.S. into people’s heads non-stop. I started asking this (CONTROVERSIAL) question quietly after the John Kerry swift boat “scandal:” “Where does free speech end, and propaganda begin?” It’s only gotten louder…
LikeLike
“Bugbear…” I think unions are a little more than a “Bugbear…” to them. 😉
LikeLike
Violence against children (a widespread use of physical punishment) has also a negative influence on the peacefulness of countries says peace researcher Franz Jedlicka (“The forgotten Peace Formula”).
Paula
LikeLike