The New Republic published a hypothetical speech by Sidney Blumenthal that Joe Biden might give if were as ruthless as Trump. However, he won’t because he is an institutionalist. He believes in the law and the Constitution. He believes, despite the Roberts Court, that no one is above the law, not even the President.
Here is the hypothetical Biden speech:
Good evening, my fellow Americans. With the close of the current session of the Supreme Court, I want to report to you on my compliance with their decisions, especially in the case involving presidential immunity, United States v. Trump.
When I took the oath of office, I swore that I would “preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.” The Supreme Court has now reinterpreted that document. The court, for all intents and purposes, has also reinterpreted the Declaration of Independence, which proclaimed, “Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed” to replace the “absolute tyranny” of a king.
I have read the court’s majority opinion that an official act of the president is “presumptively” immune from all prosecution during and after his term, and that the president’s motive cannot be questioned. I have read, according to the majority, that a president who orders the Department of Justice and his vice president to commit election fraud is immune. I have read that a president who incites a mob to attempt to assassinate the vice president for failing to follow those instructions is immune. As Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in her dissent, “Orders the Navy’s Seal Team 6 to assassinate a political rival? Immune. Organizes a military coup to hold onto power? Immune. Takes a bribe in exchange for a pardon? Immune. Immune, immune, immune.”
Fellow Americans, I have taken the court’s opinion to heart. I am not one to defy the court. I am, as many have remarked, an institutionalist. I believe with all my soul in our institutions. And now, following the letter and the spirit of the court’s ruling, I have acted swiftly, decisively, and enthusiastically to enforce it. I will not, I cannot, shirk my constitutional duty. As Justice Sotomayor states, “In every use of official power, the president is now a king above the law.”
To begin with, certain “gratuities,” as we shall call them, have been paid to the court majority as a token of appreciation. In their ruling in the case of Snyder v. United States, the majority decided that James Snyder, the former mayor of Portage, Indiana, who cajoled $13,000 from a trucking company after he granted it a city contract, was not liable for bribery. The court stated that it was a “gratuity.” “Gratuities are typically payments made to a public official after an official act as a reward or token of appreciation,” wrote Justice Brett Kavanaugh in the majority opinion.
Payment of “gratuities” to the justices who ruled in the majority in y follows the court’s decision in Snyder. It cannot be considered a bribe because it was not promised beforehand. But I do hope, as Justice Kavanaugh wrote, that there is “appreciation.”
Now, following my strict construction of the court’s ruling on immunity, I can report to the nation that the threat to national security posed by my former political opponent, my late predecessor, has been eliminated. It was an official act. It was, to quote the court, “presumptive.”
The reasons for his removal do not need to be explained. Under the court’s decision, as an official act, it is more than privileged. I hope you understand that I need not disclose the reasons. I must respect the Supreme Court. I can assure the American people that there will be a thorough report that is currently being written by the intelligence community. It is classified. The substance cannot be disclosed—and never can be.
But I do want to tell you that he did have sex with a porn star. She didn’t like it. And he lied about his golf handicap.
Why am I doing this? That’s not admissible. The state of mind of the president, according to the court, is not admissible. My state of mind falls under an official act, so it’s nobody’s business but my own. I am proud of my official acts. I must respect the precedent of keeping secret all my reasons. Otherwise, I would be damaging the presidency for others who might follow in this office.
I regret to inform you that Speaker of the House Mike Johnson has been arrested. A number of other members of the House Republican Conference have been taken into custody. Jim Jordan, unfortunately, attempted to resist arrest. After wrestling with an FBI agent, he met a tragic fate. In the sudden absence of those members, there is a new majority in the House. I look forward to a long and cooperative relationship. I can say proudly, gridlock is at last broken. And we can all give thanks to the Supreme Court.
I further regret to inform you that 10 members of the Republican Senate caucus have been arrested. Again, unfortunately, Josh Hawley attempted to run away and was wounded in the leg. The incident was entirely his fault: if only he had submitted to the authorities. Lindsey Graham was arrested in his office. He has renounced all of his former allegiances, and I have issued him a pardon—a conditional pardon. There will be no more obstruction from filibusters. Again, we can thank the court.
Now, about the court itself, with the present available members of the Congress, I have proposed that the Supreme Court be expanded by 26 justices. I can report that those new justices have already been nominated and approved. Advise and consent is on the fast track. All 26 will be here tomorrow. A longer bench is already under construction.
Tragically, Chief Justice John Roberts has been arrested for his treasonous comment that the president is doing something illegal, based on his very own opinion. I will name a new chief justice after the new 26 members take their posts.
More reform is on the way. The Twenty-Second Amendment prohibiting the president from holding more than two terms will be replaced by the Twenty-Eighth Amendment, which rescinds it. The new amendment has been proposed in the states. I have no doubt that three-quarters of the states, through their legislatures, will be cooperative. In fact, I can promise you that I expect 100 percent cooperation from each and every state legislature on a bipartisan basis. I have alerted FBI offices in every state to assist in our plan to extend democracy.
To that end, I am creating a new Cabinet department, the Department of Official Acts, to coordinate, simplify, and centralize the far-flung activities of the Department of Homeland Security, the Internal Revenue Service, the Department of Defense, and other departments and agencies. I am committed to eliminating waste and abuse in official acts.
Moreover, the vice president will head a new office here at the White House, the Office of Reimagining Official Acts, to spur innovation, creativity, and efficiency, and above all the execution of justice. That office will review all of the acts that I take so that they qualify as official.
The Office of Reimagining Official Acts has already held a Zoom conference this morning with all of the Fortune 500 CEOs. Each and every executive without exception has released a statement in support of my official acts and promised full cooperation, with gusto. By the way, the chairman of the Democratic National Committee will hold a press conference to announce the details of the amazing news that our campaign has just received new contributions of $43 billion and counting.
I can also report that Rupert Murdoch has been arrested for seditious conspiracy, along with his accomplices at Fox News, who have previously been liable for defamation. They have been spewing libels every hour of every day since. That’s as much as I can say. I cannot give another reason without breaking the strictures laid down by the court.
The Supreme Court’s immunity decision has also had a big impact on international relations. I have had a conversation with Vladimir Putin, who told me that he misunderstood me all along, and that after the day’s events here at home, he has decided to withdraw Russian troops from Ukraine. He told me he has the greatest admiration for our form of government now. He said, we can do business, strongman to strongman.
As for the rest of the campaign, when the Republican National Committee decides on its candidate, I would consider a debate with the ground rules that candidates adhere to national security guidelines, which will be presented as needed—before, during, and after such an event, consistent as official acts.
If any reader of this column can show where anything described here would be illegal under the Supreme Court immunity ruling, please turn yourself in to the nearest FBI bureau to avoid yet another tragic result. Thought is mother to the deed. Thought must be included among the potential threats to be countered by presidential official acts. “Presumptive,” as the court stated, must mean presumptive. And the reason? The president does not need to explain.
As we celebrate this Fourth of July, in a fervent prayer that the court’s ruling will work out for the best of all possible worlds, I want to say in conclusion, what goes around comes around.

Good morning Diane and everyone,
Yeah… what will happen when we are not so lucky to have the choice between a despot and a person who believes in the ideals on which this country was founded? Then what?
LikeLike
Wow. Powerful, Mamie. What, indeed!!!!!??????!!!!!
LikeLike
Mamie: similar thinking has crossed my mind. We live in a time when violence comes from those who are seen as “right wing.” It was not so long ago when revolutionary activity rose from the dispossessed, a sort of violence that gave us Emma Goldman and the Haymarket bombing.
A despot is a despot. Someday we might have to choose between two despots.
LikeLike
Way to go, Sidney!
LikeLike
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?id=1039153428&story_fbid=10230612390867004
LikeLike
The thing about Trump, he’s been pulling his signature routine of demented dissing diatribe for so long people just accept it as normal for him — for him, that is.
What we have here, of course, is just another variation on the technique of the BIG LIE — Trump keeps pushing the envelope of Dementia and Disrespect til it gets so big people can no longer see it when it’s staring them in the face.
LikeLike
Trump has normalized the Politics of Rage, Lies, and Insults. The press no longer think it’s worth reporting when he says he won the 2020 election, when he ridicules judges, when he says “most legal scholars” favored overturning Roe v. Wade, when he changes his view of abortion, when he claims that doesn’t know what Project 2025 is or who is associated with it (like members of his administration and the president of the Heritage Foundation).
LikeLike
The media’s going with that Comey Show again this Summer. I’m surprised they didn’t hold it til October, but it makes them feel so powerful … and they get so excited … they couldn’t help being a bit premature.
LikeLike
Joseph Heller, in Catch-22, predicts the coming of Trump:
“It was miraculous. It was almost no trick at all, he saw, to turn vice into virtue and slander into truth, impotence into abstinence, arrogance into humility, plunder into philanthropy, thievery into honor, blasphemy into wisdom, brutality into patriotism, and sadism into justice. Anybody could do it; it required no brains at all. It merely required no character.”
LikeLike
Bob: In a New York Review article, “Like Being Friends with a Hurricane,” the author (Fintan O’Toole) refers to the hard-written set of plans that Chris Christie gave Trump when he was transitioning to president. O’Toole writes:
“Or consider the pitiful fate of Chris Christie. He imagined himself to be not just a political ally of Trump but a close personal friend; as Christie wrote in his hilariously self-pitying memoir, Let Me Finish, ‘He told me he loved me.’
“In return, as governor of New Jersey, Christie became the first senior member of the Republican establishment to endorse Trump for the party’s presidential nomination in 2016–a gesture that marked Trump as a serious contender rather than a mere insurgent outsider. Christie then spent nearly six months leading a team of 140 people to draw up detained plans for this transition to a putative Trump presidency. When Trump was duly elected and Christie arrived at Trump Tower with his thirty binders full of blueprints for the new administration, they were sent straight to the dumpster and Christie was informed by Bannon that ‘we do not want you to be in the building anymore.'”
In another passage, he writes: Trump “is more a black hole than a sun king,” and about having servants’ souls flattened and pressed (from Mantel’s Cromwell) “by the overwhelming density of (Trump’s) self-regard that one has to wonder why others continue to propel themselves into his field of gravity. . . . he gives back only grief and shame” (July 18, 2024, p. 25).
Sane but misguided people can hope they’ll do the same with the 2024 Heritage Foundation document. Who knows? CBK
LikeLike
Exactly so, CBK. Trump cares for and looks after one person only, himself. Those who think they can channel him to their purposes are mistaken. There is an exception to this, of course, and that’s Tsar Vladimir the Defenestrator. He owns Trump because he has the kompromat. So he gets whatever he wants. His lapdog Donnie jumps to.
LikeLike
Trump has one principle by which he governs: does this benefit Trump? He has zero interest in anything else.
LikeLike
That four-word principle can be reduced to one word: ME
LikeLike
DONALD, President of A-ME-RICA
LikeLike
The speech terrifies me because it is likely the speech Donald Trump is going to make if he wins (with names of Dems instead of Republicans)
Does Biden spurn democracy to save democracy? Or does he honor the rule of law and allow democracy to end?
It’s the ethical dilemma with no right answer. Is it ever okay to use torture to stop a nuclear bomb from going off that decimates the entire east coast? Do you take action to divert a trolley to kill one person instead of killing 5? Or 50?
Regardless of who the Democratic nominee is, Trump may win. The end of democracy is actually a possibility – something I never thought possible.
LikeLike
(20+) Facebook
LikeLike
Joe Biden says he will only step down if he receives a message from the Lord Almighty. I have been commissioned by Him to deliver this message to Joe.
Memorandum From: The Almighty, Lord of The Heavens
To: President Joe Biden, President of the United States
Dear Joe,
I rarely have cause to respond personally to any of my supplicants. But I’ll do it for you because that Trump guy really grinds on my nerves. I have heard your prayer. Please go home and enjoy a well earned retirement. You have my blessing. (There. It’s done.)
LikeLike
This would be funny if it weren’t so tragic. For a century, the Reichwingers in the US have sought to a) undo the longterm, historical expansion of federal powers under the commerce clause of the constitution; b) massively cut social services; c) massively cut taxes for the wealthy and replace our tax system with some sort of nonprogressive tax (such as a flat tax or Trump’s tariffs) to shift the tax burden onto the poor and middle class; d) obliterate the regulatory state, and e) clear the way for government by unaccountable strongman.
And this is the Roberts Court agenda. To create a laissez-faire, robber baron, Libertarian, Fascist state.
“America First,” the Trumpanzees yell, echoing Glorious Leader. LITERALLY the name of a mid-twentieth-century American Nazi party.
LikeLike
Agreed, but so sad. They would squeeze democracy out of the fabric of this nation. Elite rule that destroys everything for common people and makes its safe to grind those that that are different or oppositional into the dirt. Our four year election cycle would allow them to consolidate their power even more.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Give the people democracy–the universal franchise. Let them vote for long enough. And eventually they will vote in people who will end the universal franchise. This is a Catch-22 in the whole program. A self-defeating aspect of it. So, the answer to the Halting Problem for democracy is that yes, you can predict beforehand whether its going to end. In other words, Democracy is Defeasible.
LikeLike
Bob: Yes, about the inherent “weakness” in the democratic principle.
However, it’s also our greatest strength–and may we never forget (ha!) the importance of fostering and giving to our children a good political education. Much of the problems with MAGA, as I see it, is their lack of understanding of what they already have could be about to lose.
Our present horrible political situation has lots of threads to it, but the emphasis on STEM . . . not AS STEM, but where it means a LOSS of a humanities education including history, the arts, and the social sciences, for decades now, shares in the blame, along with our fostering a culture of transactionalism and it first child, predatory capitalism (greed) and a loss of anything one might name “community.”
Even our religious institutions, which have for centuries held to Christian practices like, for example, caring for the poor and for the “other,” have succumbed to proud ignorance and a hyper-capitalist, racist mindset, as so many eschew progress that reflects rather than diminishes fully Christian principles. CBK
LikeLiked by 1 person
The terrifying part is that Trump will do exactly this and no one is calling that out. Even the Democrats are silent. Something like 40% of voters have never even heard of Project 2025.
LikeLike
So scary. The ignorance and apathy of our populace will enable Trump or whoever the person is who oversees the transition to Fascism as much as the Supreme Court is doing.
LikeLike
TOW,
I’m
Surprised that 60% have heard of project 2025. I wonder what % know what is in it.
LikeLike
Trump is claiming that Project 2025 has nothing to do with his plans. The man is an opportunistic chameleon.
LikeLike
This reminds me when Bannan crafted a message for Trump based on two ideas: coming down hard on immigration and instituting a massive infrastructure rebuilding program to put blue collar people back to work in lucrative jobs. Trump mouthed the words he was told to mouth. And then he did nothing. No infrastructure program. Almost no wall.
The fundamentalist morons at Hillsdale who thought that they could control The Beast must be weeping into their hymnals.
LikeLike
No, quite the opposite, I should think.
LikeLike
Trump will say whatever it is that he think is going to get him elected. One of his current advisors has probably told him that Project 2025 is getting a LOT of bad press and freaking people out, so he and his former propaganda minister, Stephen Goebbels Miller, are both going all Judas about this. What? Hillsdale? Project 2025? Never heard of them. Abortion? I don’t know. What would you like to hear? That’s where Trump stands. Always has. Just as Oceania has always been at war with East Asia.
LikeLike
The Chefs on the Supreme Court are serving up Fascism. This satire is spot on. The decisions they have been making enable it. They are far, far, far worse than the mainstream press is presenting them as being.
LikeLike
Here is some potentially good news that is NOT being covered:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2024-07-06/biden-narrows-trump-s-election-lead-in-key-states-after-debate-poll
https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4757918-joe-biden-donald-trump-swing-states-bloomberg-morning-consult-survey/
“President Biden, in the wake of a poor debate performance and growing calls for him to step aside, has narrowed Trump’s lead in the key swing states, according to a new survey.
The Bloomberg/Morning Consult poll, published Saturday, showed Biden leading Trump in Michigan and Wisconsin. In Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and North Carolina, the incumbent is now within the margin of error, per the survey.”
Gotta love how good news for Biden always gets that negative spin. “…in the wake of a poor debate performance and growing calls for him to step aside…” Ever see an article that said “Trump, in the wake of a felony conviction and growing calls for Trump to stop inciting violence and getting his supporters to murder cops, gained ground in the latest poll.”
This story will likely be ignored by the NYT. Or presented the way ALL stories like this are presented:
“After the debate, Biden leads or gains ground in the key swing states. Here’s why that’s bad news for Biden.”
(h/t to NYT Pitchbot, who satirizes NYT headlines like this in his twitter feed, and frequently has to post the actual NYT headline that is so anti-Biden it SHOULD be a parody and unfortunately it’s “real news”)
Maybe the voters are starting to realize the “refs” are not fair and balanced at all. Perhaps the elite and arrogant NYT reporters hysterical warning (in 190 articles) that “Biden is demented and unfit” “Biden is a danger! He must step down!” actually doesn’t track with what they saw at the debate with their own eyes.
They saw one old, tired, sitting president with an aging brain who loves his country and is doing a pretty decent job despite the elite media who looks down on regular voters ganging up on Biden.
And they saw the former president – the one who incited an insurrection to overturn the voters’ will after his abysmal presidency – spewing his ugly meaningless yells about how great he is, telling them stuff they KNOW are blatant lies, and making no sense whatsoever.
No doubt this poll will be ignored, or at most mentioned in passing. It won’t cause the twits who believe it is their mission in life to attack Dems (and show they they are fair and balanced to the Trump voters who hate America) to write 190 stories (and counting) about how soon the unfit Trump will leave the race.
“After the debate, Biden gaining ground with voters who prefer Biden to Trump” is a narrative that is banned from all NYT articles.
LikeLike
Yes, I read it this morning! Gre
LikeLike
Unfortunately, this is precisely what Justice Sotomayer warned in her dissent of the Trump immunity case.
LikeLiked by 1 person
https://x.com/chrisdjackson/status/1809590826164514986?s=46&t=vV_4bJ7GuABaalzetJofQA
LikeLike
Amazing.
LikeLike
Apparently the so-called liberal media is already starting work legitimizing the right wing’s anti-Kamala Harris talking point if Biden steps side.
“Did she know about Biden being unfit?” “When did she know about Biden being unfit?” “Did she help cover up Biden being unfit?”
Come to think of it, this Republican talking point will probably be be given 190+ stories in the NYT no matter who the Dem nominee is, if Biden steps down.
LikeLike
I suspect there’s a very simple response to this.
But it requires an appreciation for human loyalty and affection.
So Republicans will never find it acceptable.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great answer. JSR, I wish you had decided to go into politics.
LikeLike
Be grateful every day that I didn’t.
LikeLike
haaa!
LikeLike
BOB: Forgot to post the link to the NYR article:
https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2024/07/18/like-being-friends-with-a-hurricane-fintan-otoole/ CBK
LikeLike
Thanks, CBK. Trump is definitely an eat your young and everything else sort of creature. An opportunistic parasite. Yeah, I know that that’s redundant. But I wanted to point out that part.
LikeLike
Parasitic wasp larvae and Donald Trump differ in size.
LikeLike
One can understand why Biden wants to hang onto this. He believes, and he’s right, that he has done great things for the country and that there is more to do. And this is heady stuff. You wake up in the morning and say to yourself, “Gee, I think I’ll go downstairs and change the course of history.”
LikeLike
The Art of Comparison Exemplified | Bob Shepherd | Bob Shepherd | Praxis (wordpress.com)
LikeLike
Facebook
LikeLike
”Thought is mother to the deed.” 1984 (?)
LikeLike