Ron DeSantis has been determined as governor of Florida to privatize the funding of schools, and he has had a compliant legislature to help him achieve his goal of destroying public schools.
Andrew Atterbury of Politico wrote about the fiscal crisis of many public school districts as they lose students to private schools, charter schools, religious schools, and home schools.
Most vouchers are claimed by students already enrolled in private schools—a subsidy for the rich and upper-middle-class—but the public funds are causing serious enrollment declines in some districts. Those districts are now considering closing public schools as tax money flows to unaccountable private schools.
Atterbury writes:
Gov. Ron DeSantis and Florida Republicans have spent years aggressively turning the state into a haven for school choice. They have been wildly successful, with tens of thousands more children enrolling in private or charter schools or homeschooling.
Now as those programs balloon, some of Florida’s largest school districts are facing staggering enrollment declines — and grappling with the possibility of campus closures — as dollars follow the increasing number of parents opting out of traditional public schools.
The emphasis on these programs has been central to DeSantis’ goals of remaking the Florida education system, and they are poised for another year of growth. DeSantis’ school policies are already influencing other GOP-leaning states, many of which have pursued similar voucher programs. But Florida has served as a conservative laboratory for a suite of other policies, ranging from attacking public- and private-sector diversity programs to fighting the Biden administration on immigration.
“We need some big changes throughout the country,” DeSantis said Thursday evening at the Florida Homeschool Convention in Kissimmee. “Florida has shown a blueprint, and we really can be an engine for that as other states work to adopt a lot of the policies that we’ve done.”
Education officials in some of the state’s largest counties are looking to scale back costs by repurposing or outright closing campuses — including in Broward, Duval and Miami-Dade counties. Even as some communities rally to try to save their local public schools, traditional public schools are left with empty seats and budget crunches.
Since 2019-20, when the pandemic upended education, some 53,000 students have left traditional public schools in these counties, a sizable total that is forcing school leaders to consider closing campuses that have been entrenched in local communities for years.
In Broward County, Florida’s second-largest school district, officials have floated plans to close up to 42 campuses over the next few years, moves that would have a ripple effect across Fort Lauderdale and Hollywood.
The district has lost more than 20,000 students over the last five years, a decline that comes as charter schools in particular experienced sizable growth in the area. Enrollment in charters, which are public schools operating under performance contracts freeing them of many state regulations, increased by nearly 27,000 students since 2010, according to Broward school officials.
Broward County Public Schools claims to have more than 49,000 classroom seats sitting empty this year, a number that “closely matches” the 49,833 students attending charter schools in the area, officials noted in an enrollment overview.
These enrollment swings are pressing Broward leaders to combine and condense dozens of schools, efforts that would save the district on major operating costs. So far, some of the ideas are meeting heavy resistance…
Enrollment among charters has increased by more than 68,000 students statewide from 2019-20 to this school year, according to data from the Florida Department of Education. More than a third of that rise happened in Broward, Duval and Miami counties alone.
Private school enrollment across Florida rose by 47,000 students to 445,000 students from 2019-20 to 2022-23, according to the latest data available from the state. Much of that growth is from newly enrolled kindergartners, with only a small fraction of these students having been previously enrolled in public schools, according to Step Up for Students, the preeminent administrator of state-sponsored scholarships in Florida.
A growing number of families also chose to homeschool their children during this span, as this population grew by nearly 50,000 students between 2019-20 and 2022-23, totaling 154,000 students in the latest Florida Department of Education data.
As all of these choice options ascend, enrollment in traditional public schools across the state decreased by 55,000 students from 2019-20 to this year, state data shows. But enrollment isn’t down everywhere. While Duval County has lost thousands of students, enrollment is up by more than 7,700 students at neighboring St. John’s County, the state’s top-ranked school district…
The state’s scholarship program is expected to grow, which could lead to more students leaving traditional public schools. While most new scholarship recipients previously attended private schools already, there is space for 82,000 more statewide — nearly 217,000 total — to attend private school or find a different schooling option on the state’s dime next school year.
Across the state, public schools are facing budget cuts, layoffs. and school closures, all to satisfy Gov. DeSantis’ love of school choice. Over time, billions of public dollars will flow every year to unaccountable private schools that are allowed to discriminate. And the outcomes will be worse, not better, as students flock to low-cost schools whose teachers and principals are uncertified.
It the main win for DeSantis is to subsidize the cost of private schools for parents whose children were already enrolled in private schools.

There’s a big difference between privatizing the funding of schools and publicly funding the privatization of schools.
LikeLike
Actually, there are more CHOICES in Public Schools.
Plus, our students learn about history and democracy as well, not to mention sciences, mathematics, and learning how to live in a pluralistic, democratic society.
The hype around having “choice” is a myth re: charters and vouchers.
LikeLike
Florida is not a blueprint. It is an anomaly. Unlike most states Florida is highly funded by tourists outside the regular tax base. It can afford to shoulder more of DeSantis’ horrible policies than other states that rely heavily on local tax dollars. Florida does not have a state tax. DeSantis and the legislature spend public funds with abandon, and it may eventually catch up to them. Time will tell. At the same time it is the playground of the rich and famous that live in mansions in south Florida so the state is collecting high dollar real estate taxes from them. Some people on fixed incomes are leaving the Florida because their homeowner’s insurance rates have gone up 50 to 100 percent, but they will likely be replaced with more affluent retirees from The North. Florida is an anomaly.
The counties in south Florida that are losing enrollment in the public schools are also among the most diverse counties. Privatization is designed to divide and conquer by sorting young people along color and socioeconomic lines into winners and losers. In privatization schemes it is always the poor and those with little agency that lose. These are the consequences at work in south Florida.
I live in north Florida where there are lots of military bases and new housing developments that are being bought mostly by white retirees and military personnel. The state is less inclined to attack this part of Florida where the military sends its children to school, although we do have a M4L candidate running for school superintendent. Two years ago a new K-8 public school opened here, and two new public high schools will open within the next couple of years as well due to expanding enrollment. Florida is most definitely an anomaly.
LikeLike
Another factor, according to NPR/WAMC news this morning c. 8 am EST: A growing number of children are being kept home to care for preschool siblings because the parent(s) have to work and there’s no day care.
Parents who can find day care are paying 10-20% of their income, where-as the recommended maximum for family “solvency” (such as it may be!) is 7%.
LikeLike
Mark,
That report from NPR that more children are kept home because both parents are working and there’s no day care—makes no sense.
If both parents are at work, how can they homeschool their 6-15 year old children? Who takes care of them? Who teaches them?
LikeLike
Diane– Here is the verbal report I referred to yesterday, regarding children staying home to look after younger siblings while their parents work.
It was on NPR’s “Marketplace Morning Report” for May 29, and starts at 46% on their horizontal time scale, preceded by a report on Exxon-Mobil.
U.S. child care is expensive — and not working for most families – Marketplace
LikeLike
Clarification– The link has eliminated the Exxon-Mobil article, so when you push “play” the lack-of-daycare report will start immediately.
LikeLike
Diane– I was working while listening to this, so will try to find it and report back.
It made perfect sense to me, given the housing shortage, the high rents, and the usual landlord scum. Haven’t you heard about the homeless? Or people –families!–living in their car? Surely you are aware that a decade or two ago NYC schools refused to enroll any kid without a permanent address; then NYS passed a law requiring enrollment.
The poor are doing what the poor have always done–make do. A single parent or both parents are exploited at rip-off, dead-end, minimum wage jobs. It’s all they can do to pay rent and can’t afford to lose a job, so they keep their 8 year old home to watch the 2 year old. If the parent or parents are conscientious, maybe they buy or are given some workbooks or home-school materials.
Day care is expensive, many closed during COVID, and few employers provide daycare. Where would a new provider even find space to open a daycare these days?
LikeLike
Mark,
I may be wrong but I think it’s illegal not to put your child in any kind of school. NYC public schools enroll about 100,000 homeless children. It’s very dangerous for an 8-year-old to stay at home to take of a 1 year-old. And I believe it’s illegal.
LikeLike
Texas is getting ready to do the same. Unfortunately, pro-voucher candidates won in the Texas primary runoffs yesterday, including a former Trump spokesperson.
This is very upsetting.
https://www.texastribune.org/2024/05/28/texas-primary-runoff-school-vouchers-abbott/
LikeLike
Terrible news.
LikeLike
My friends in Texas tell me that the winners of the Republican primaries are so extreme that they might be beaten by their Democratic opponents.
LikeLike
While I do not doubt this reporting, they also must acknowledge that with all the “eVerYoNe iS mOviNg here,” it’s not necessarily younger couples with families. People ages 60-69+ represent the largest share of inbound residents in 2022 followed by 50-59.
So for all the talk of “we opened schools in August 2020,” “no woke in our schools,” “we’re no. 1 in education,” the bulk of people moving here are the typical age of empty nesters or very close to it.
LikeLike
Those older folks moving to Florida don’t have school age children and they don’t want to pay for other people’s children.
LikeLike
<a href=”https://www.facebook.com/JonnyCache/posts/pfbid0kW1ar8QRXkZiGkZug5XGffxkmW2BdPW6rvGPLbqw61qTcaRFPWQWxZKJj1RHMJXAl>May 31, 2016
Parents have always been and will always be free to direct their personal funds to the private schools of their choice, for what they see as the private benefit of their own children.
But private individuals are not entitled by any consideration of the common good to divert public funds for the sake of their private purposes and religious preferences.
People pay taxes to support public schools whether they are parents or not. If only parents have a choice in how the money is spent, then only parents of school-age children should pay school taxes, and based on the number of children in school, not on their property values or how many lottery tickets they buy.
When people start seeing education as a private commodity that parents buy for their own children — just another personal choice, like whether to buy designer duds or that hot new toy — then we are going to see a taxpayer revolt like we have never seen before, and public-funded education will cease to exist.
So watch out for that …
LikeLike
<a href=”https://www.facebook.com/JonnyCache/posts/pfbid0kW1ar8QRXkZiGkZug5XGffxkmW2BdPW6rvGPLbqw61qTcaRFPWQWxZKJj1RHMJXAl”>May 31, 2016
LikeLike
(9) Jonny Cache – Parents have always been and will always be free to… | Facebook
LikeLike