Peter Greene reports on the status of Oklahoma’s attempt to open the nation’s first openly religious charter school. the State’s Attorney General thinks it’s wrong, so Oklahoma’s State Superintendent Ryan Walter (a MAGA-nut) is relying on outside help. As Peter explains, the rightwingers are flocking to Walters’ side.
He writes:
Earlier this year, Oklahoma State Attorney General Gentner Drummond issued an opinion about the prospect of the state approving a church-run charter school. He was reversing the opinion of his predecessor, saying that previous opinion “misuses the concept of religious liberty by employing it as a means to justify state-funded religion. If allowed to remain in force, I fear the opinion will be used as a basis for taxpayer-funded religious schools.”
In June, the Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board ignored him and approved the St. Isidore of Seville virtual charter, a cyber school that was proposed by the Archdiocese of Oklahoma City in collaboration with the Diocese of Tulsa. It was in anticipation of this application that the virtual charter board asked the previous AG for an opinion in the first place.
As an AP report noted, “Archdiocese officials have been unequivocal that the school will promote the Catholic faith and operate according to church doctrine, including its views on sexual orientation and gender identity.”
And just in case you wonder if the state knew what it was doing, or was trying to preserve any plausible deniability, State Superintendent Ryan Walters supported the decision:
This decision reflects months of hard work, and more importantly, the will of the people of Oklahoma. I encouraged the board to approve this monumental decision, and now the U.S.’s first religious charter school will be welcomed by my administration.
And Governor Stitt hailed it as “a win for religious liberty and education freedom in our great state.”
Meanwhile, AG Drummond called the decision “contrary to Oklahoma law and not in the best interests of taxpayers.” Furthermore, “It’s extremely disappointing that board members violated their oath in order to fund religious schools with our tax dollars. In doing so, these members have exposed themselves and the state to potential legal action that could be costly.”
To the surprise of nobody, that lawsuit was filed before summer’s end with Oklahoma Parent Legislative Action Committee and individual parents as plaintiffs in a case that has already been busy and twisty.
The case has drawn a number of national groups to the case, including for the plaintiffs the ACLU, Americans for Separation of Church and State, and the Education Law Center.
The defendant side is a more interesting array. Drummond, having made it clear that he believes the charter proponents are dead wrong, is not using the attorney general’s office to defend them. So the school board, the state department of education, and Ryan Walters are being defended by private attorneys in Oklahoma and some other hired guns.
Two are part of the usual array of legal shops that work to defund and dismantle public education. There’s the Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian advocacy group that was incorporated in 1993 by six right-wing luminaries, including Larry Burkett, Bill Bright, and James Dobson. They are supported by a host of right-wing foundations, including the Richard and Helen DeVos Foundation. And they oppose abortion, same-sex marriage, most all LGBTQ+ rights. Their track record is sadly successful; these are the Hobby Lobby lawsuit folks. They have a summer legal training program to get Christian law students whipped up for legal careers; Justice Amy Coney Barrett taught at it. They successfully litigated against Vermont, establishing that the state must include Catholic students in its voucher program, a sort of throat-clearing for Carson v. Makin.
There’s First Liberty Institute a Christian conservative firm based in Texas, which co-took Carson v. Makin all the way to SCOTUS, as well as the case of the praying coach.
These are to be expected; getting money away from public education and into church coffers is their thing. But you get a fuller idea of who has a lot riding on this case from the third set of lawyers– the Notre Dame Religious Liberty Clinic….
A Catholic charter in Oklahoma would pretty much erase the difference between charters and vouchers, and the Catholic charter in Oklahoma serves as a proof of legal concept, so this case is a good fit for the church. It is winding through various legal twists and turns (the defendants just moved to have it dismissed), but if it ends up before SCOTUS, it could represent one more reduction of the pile of rubble that now stands where the wall between church and state used to.
Please open the link and finish the article.

The nation is being awakened by headlines like Greene’s and, by Diane’s posting of his article.
Spreading information about the political role played by right wing Catholic jurists on SCOTUS, Catholic universities, the state and diocese Catholic Conferences and sites like Catholic Vote is imperative to preserve American democracy.
LikeLike
This alliance between protestant conservatives and Rightwing Catholics is taking place amid a more pervasive social trend in America. While I find myself not having time to chase down the source for the stats, I recall reading the degree to which the group of people who attend church/mass regularly has declined precipitously since the moral majority began. Back in those days, the problem seemed to some to be the rise of revolution theology in catholicism, and the rise of liberalism in protestant churches. Now the problem, as seen through the lens of the churches, is to get people in the door. I suspect the same thought process leads conservative catholics and protestants to believe that liberalism in politics is the problem. Their solution, conservatism in politics, does not seem to be winning the day. Churches look like ARRP conventions. Congregations average 70 and above in various places. From religion’s point of view, political involvement is not a cure.
LikeLike
How did we come so far from using public funds to pave a playground in a parochial school to Catholic charter schools so quickly? If there is no separation of church and state, when are churches going to start paying taxes?
LikeLike
I look forward to Greene’s follow-up article about the Jones Day law firm’s pro bono cases on topics like contraceptives for Catholic organizations. The prior and current managing partners are Notre Dame alums. One was on the Board of Trustees and the other was on an advisory council for the law school.
Citizens living in Ohio, Florida and Indiana should recognize they live in red Catholic states no different than citizens in Utah living in a Mormon state.
LikeLike
From Law.com (1-20-2017), “12 Jones Day Lawyers Take Key Posts in Trump Administration…Chad Readler, Chairman of the Ohio Alliance of Public Charter Schools.”
LikeLike
You know who really hate being told what to believe? Young people. Keep pushing their buttons, rightwing extremists. Watch what happens.
LikeLike
Democratic Gov. Shapiro is a fool to back a proposal to send $100 mil. to families so that they can attend private schools.
The Republican primary opponents in the 2018 governors race were all in for school choice.
In no surprise at the political opportunism of Jones Day, one of its lawyers, Laura Ellsworth, ran in the primary. In an opinion piece at Penn Live, she was described, “nurtured a Christian school in Pittsburg.” Almost 20 employees of Jones Day, in states throughout the country, contributed to her campaign.
LikeLike