As one of its final actions of this session, the Florida legislature passed a law restricting public bathrooms according to biological gender identity. Violators May be criminally prosecuted. The purpose obviously is to prevent trans people to use the bathroom aligned with their chosen gender. This is yet another performance by Ron DeSantis to go to the right of every other GOP figure by showing his hatred for LGBT.
A small number of Republicans joined their Democratic colleagues in opposing House Bill 1521, which applies to schools, government buildings, prisons and detention centers. It now heads to the desk of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R), who is expected to sign it into law. DeSantis — who has privately indicated that he intends to seek the 2024 GOP presidential nomination — has tacked to the hard right on social issues such as abortion, as he courts primary voters by showing off his conservative vision for the state and pitches Florida as a “blueprint” for the rest of the country.
The bill that passed was more limited than earlier drafts, which would have extended the ban to facilities in many private businesses. It is opposed by LGBTQ and civil liberties activists, who say that it criminalizes transgender people for ordinary behavior. “Our state government should be focused on solving pressing issues, not terrorizing people who are simply trying to use the restroom and exist in public,” said Jon Harris Maurer, public policy director at Equality Florida, an LGBTQ advocacy group.
One important question is how the bill will be enforced. Will people be reqhired to show their genitalia whenever they enter a public bathroom? Will they carry a copy of their birth certificate with them, to be produced on demand?
Who will do the genital check? Will the state hire new employees to check birth certificates?
Oh, how the tables have turned. In 2016, the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) of the NCAA moved its football championship from Charlotte, North Carolina to Orlando, Florida in protest of North Carolina’s then transgender bathroom bill.
https://www.cbsnews.com/detroit/news/acc-moves-football-championship-game-to-orlando/
It was actually a sacrificial move for the ACC because the competing teams ended up being Clemson (South Carolina) and Virginia Tech. They were literally giving tickets away to try to fill the stadium.
Even if the transgender bathroom issue didn’t exist, there is a huge need for more single stall family bathrooms. When my mother was in a wheelchair and unable to get out or in the wheelchair herself, my husband had to do the lifting. We could only go places that we knew had a family bathroom, since I could not take care of her by myself.
Good point.
Imagine that. A sane solution that doesn’t need to be politicized. Forgot what that was all about.
Well observed, Ms. Fan!
I’m in favor of European-style single stall bathrooms for all kinds of reasons, but the reality is that’s not currently what we have and transgender people have to go to the bathroom now, so their choices are the men’s room or the women’s room. The simple fact is that trans women are women and should be able to use the women’s room without hassle. Likewise for trans men. If you’re worried about the genitals of the person in the stall next to you, you’re the problem.
I agree. I have never been in a ladies’ bathroom that did not have closed stalls with locks on them. What’s the deal?
Most interesting is the enforcement of these laws. Will there be someone at every public bathroom to check your birth certificate?
D77: you are more than correct. We had a child late in life, and family bathrooms were a very welcome sight. You would think the political party which champions the family would understand spacious and private facilities.
Unfortunately, the Republicans are empowered – they know the current Supreme Court is no longer a barrier to them legislating whatever anti-trans bills (or other right wing bills) they want, and legislating their way into keeping power by any means (as in North Carolina). So this bathroom bill is only the beginning of what trans people (and many others who aren’t white or Christian or cisgender or conservative) will suffer.
I note that none of this targeting of trans people seems to be happening in states where Dems control the legislature and judiciary. hmmm…..
The issues are different so the result may not be the same, but remember that Justice Gorsuch wrote the majority opinion in Bostock, holding that discrimination against someone based on gender identity is illegal under the Civil Rights Act.
Gorsuch ruled on very specific textual grounds about employment. I’m fairly certain that Gorsuch won’t find textual reference to bathrooms in the Civil Rights’ legislation. And let’s face it, Gorsuch believes that any “precedent” is the”anchor of the law” which to him means that a Supreme Court Justice should “start” by considering precedent (for an hour, a minute, or a second) and then may overturn it as they wish, as Gorsuch did with Roe.
Lucky for the trans-haters that Alito, Thomas and Kavanaugh who dissented from Bostock are still there, and Gorsuch will certainly be reminded that he doesn’t have to worry about his “textual” requirement to join his friends.
I wonder what Greenberg Traurig’s position was on Bostock? Maybe the guy who bought the property owned by Gorsuch (and others) that no one else wanted for so much money had strong feelings against firing gay people at will. I just don’t think the folks who believe that it’s wrong for trans people to be discriminated against can make the kind of “friendly gesture” that Harlan and his federalist society pals can.
Like I said, the issue are different so the result may be different, but Bostok shows that anyone who thinks SCOTUS will allow any and all anti-trans actions or laws to stand is wrong.
My two favorite bathroom sign experiences. On a military golf course: Pointers, Setters. In a restaurant: The Beautiful Ones, The Necessary Ones
This just in: Flor-uh-duh legislature passes out of committee a bill outlawing walking around Woke.
Is it OK to roller blade while Woke?
Thank goodness we have Republican watchdogs to stop CRT from spraying Woke Juice into the heating and air conditioning systems of our nation’s schools!
Is that anything like walking around money?
Does the Florida legislature ever pass any bills that help people?
All the time! It just depends on the flexible definition of “the people.” They are designed to benefit some and ostracize the other.
•I recently learned that some Paterson, NJ primary grade teachers keep cat litter & containers in classroom closet—in case of live shooter lockdown & kids can’t go to restroom. Lawmakers should be working to eliminate the gun violence problem that affects more than the very small %age who are trans.
• Senator R Warnock, GA had an eloquent talk on Senate floor re gun violence and our lack of action.