Retired teacher Fred Klonsky notes that Arne Duncan endorsed Paul Vallas for mayor of Chicago. This is no surprise since the two previously worked closely together and their views about privatization are very similar. Duncan is best remembered for his failed “Race to the Top” program, which foisted charter schools on almost every state and the horrendous policy of judging teachers by the test scores of their students, as well as the imposition of the Commin Core standards. A decade after RTTT was launched, the national NAEP exams showed that it changed nothing, although it cost the feds $5 billions and the states and districts many more billions. For nothing.
The NAACP and other civil rights groups (the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP); the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund; National Urban League; The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law; National Council on Educating Black Children; Rainbow PUSH Coalition; and The Schott Foundation for Public Education) officially condemned Race to the Top for creating a competition among the states for federal funds, instead of funding the neediest students and districts so they could have experienced teachers, early childhood education, and reduced class sizes. The competition, they agreed, would bypass those who needed funding the most, while implementing harmful policies like school closings.
Klonsky writes:
To the surprise of absolutely nobody Arne Duncan endorsed his former boss at CPS, Paul Vallas, for mayor in an op-ed piece in the Chicago Tribune.
When Vallas was Richard Daley’s (2) CPS CEO, Duncan was his deputy chief of staff.
Duncan then went on to be picked by Barack Obama to run the Department of Education and Vallas went on to post-Hurricane Katrina New Orleans, destroying the public school system there by turning it into the largest privatized nearly entirely charter school system in the country.
If it weren’t for Betsy DeVos, Trump’s Secretary of Education, Duncan would still hold the title of the worst Secretary of Education ever.
Duncan’s notable achievement as Secretary of Education was the creation of Race to the Top.
Duncan’s idea was to pit states against states in a competition for limited federal education dollars.
It was educational cock fighting.
At the last convention of the National Education Association that I attended as an active teacher in 2011, the delegates voted to adopt a resolution condemning Duncan in what became known as 13 Things I Hate About Arne Duncan.
Among the union’s 13 criticisms are Duncan’s failure to adequately address “unrealistic” Adequate Yearly Progress requirements, focusing too closely on charter schools to the detriment of other types of schools, weighing in too heavily on local hiring decisions and failing to see the need for more encompassing change that helps all students and depends on shared responsibility by stakeholders, versus competitive grant programs that the NEA says “spur bad, inappropriate, and short-sighted state policy.”
To say that public school teachers detested the policies of Arne Duncan is an understatement.
Duncan and Vallas have always been brothers from another mother.
They worked hand in hand blowing up CPS.
When Vallas moved from Chicago to head the Recovery School District in New Orleans, Duncan applauded Hurricane Katrina for blowing up New Orleans schools.
Duncan said 2005’s Hurricane Katrina was “the best thing that happened to the education system in New Orleans,” because it led to hiring Paul Vallas.
Vallas completed the job that Hurricane Katrina started.
Last year Duncan hinted that he might enter the race for Chicago Mayor. The voter response was underwhelming.
Now he’s endorsing his doppelgänger.
Open the link to enjoy Fred’s art.
Vallas has a habit of falling upwards. In ‘The Lever’ there is an article that is worth reading. It shows how Vallas helped hedge funds fleece the taxpayers and left the school district with a $1.5 billion dollar debt. This man should not be dog catcher, let alone mayor of a major city. Duncan and Vallas are clueless brothers from different mothers. PS. I enjoyed the art work in the post.https://www.levernews.com/how-vallas-helped-wall-street-loot-chicagos-schools/
Bloomberg and Villaraigosa should be lessons on how relics of a failed, hostile, corporate education “reform” takeover lose elections badly when running on their baggage.
I love the cartoon on Fred’s post, but Duncan should be looking at a wall instead of in a barrel. Arne Duncan doesn’t know his ass from a hole in the wall.
With Duncan passing notes in class about Vallas, it would be a perfect reunion if Michelle Rhee swooped in on her broom and erased Arne’s wrong answers.
If it weren’t for Betsy DeVos, Duncan would still be worst secretary of education ever? Whoa, there! DeVos was a good secretary of education compared to Duncan. No one, NO ONE, not even the brothers Bush, no one destroyed public education like Arne Duncan. That man made us all race to the top of the hole in the wall he thinks is his ass.
Remember when that corporate reporter wished Chicago would have a biblical flood so that all the public schools would be washed away? Terrible. If Vallas is elected, that’s basically what will happen.
LCT,
I agree with you.
Betsy DeVos did not do as much damage as Duncan because most people saw her as a running joke. Whenever she spoke, she said such preposterous things that no one took her seriously.
Duncan on the other hand perpetrated policies that were ruinous. The public assumed he knew what he was doing but he had no clue. He designed Race to the Top as a state competition, and states that wanted to “win” hundreds of millions had to change their laws to satisfy his bad ideas. So almost every state adopted Common Core sight unseen; agreed to expand charter schools, at the expense of public schools (a huge gift to the charter lobby); agreed to evaluate teachers by the test scores of their students; agreed to collect voluminous amounts of data; agreeed to close schools with low scores; etc. Nothing he required made schools better. Nothing he required was based on research and trial. These were the collective “wisdom” of the staff loaned to him by Bill Gates and Eli Broad. He did incalculable damage to American education, yet he is still called upon by the media to opine about the future of US education.
“Race to the Top was educational cock fighting.”
Yes, Diane. Worst of all, Duncan normalized attacking teachers in the Democratic Party.
Yes. He attacked and belittled teachers. He also belittled parents, asserting that parents who opted out of standardized testing were actually running away from learning that their precious child was not so smart after all. He would have fit right into Trump’s administration with his dim view of public schools.
“It was educational cock fighting.”
Nah, cock fighting is a far more humane sport.
This editorial from Canada is illuminating: https://www.levernews.com/email/9fc71107-7471-4168-8204-fd31f7e2417a/
Arne Duncan’s last speech as US Secretary of Education was at St. Sabina Catholic church (Chicago Tribune).
From the DePaul news archives, 6-13-2009, “DePaul University, the largest Catholic University in the U.S., (has 4 faculty), “who have worked closely with Arne Duncan…they can provide first hand knowledge about his…education philosophy.” The news announcement provided the professors’ contact information.
From a webpage at the DePaul College of Education,
“DePaul partners with Chicago Public schools…We also have close ties with the Archdiocese of Chicago (the nation’s largest private school system)…”
What additional power is gained by theocracy (or, Catholic nationalists) in a post-voucher landscape where taxpayers are forced to pay for religious schools?
The damage that Arne Duncan did to U.S. education is incalculably enormous. The dumbing down of U.S. pedagogy and curricula to make it into prep for invalid, useless federally mandated tests based on the puerile Gates/Coleman “standards” bullet list has been extreme, and Duncan, clueless, brainless Arne Duncan, has no idea that this has happened or how nasty have been the consequences. Duncan: Dribble, drivel, dribble, dribble, rinse and repeat.
https://bobshepherdonline.wordpress.com/?s=STDs
Oops. Here’s the link:
https://bobshepherdonline.wordpress.com/2020/03/19/why-we-need-to-end-high-stakes-standardized-testing-now/
A-literate
Duncan, Duncan, drive and dribble,
Drain that data driven drivel!
Dribble balls and dribble spittle,
Duncan, Duncan, drive and dribble!
Shakes Spear
Vallas, Arne Duncan double,
Double, double, toil, trouble,
Foil teaching; make us stumble!
Vallas, Arne Duncan double.
E-man You All
Rahm, Rahm, he’s our man;
If he can’t rob us, Vallas can!
Rahm, Rahm, Chicago klan—
Rahm, Rahm, legacy’s scam.
Dick Durbin just endorsed Valas as well. The Democratic Party will not be coming to the rescue of the public schools any time soon.