Legislators in Florida have introduced a bill that would require bloggers who write about Ron DeSantis or his cabinet or legislators to register with the state. This is rich because gun buyers don’t have to register at all.
Apparently, the bill covers only paid bloggers, and Republicans consider them to be no different from lobbyists.
A Republican state senator in Florida has introduced a bill that, if passed, would require bloggers who write about Gov. Ron DeSantis, his Cabinet or state legislators to register with the state.
Sen. Jason Brodeur’s bill, titled “Information Dissemination,” would also require bloggers to disclose who’s paying them for their posts about certain elected officials and how much.
“If a blogger posts to a blog about an elected state officer and receives, or will receive, compensation for that post, the blogger must register” with the appropriate office within five days of the post, the legislation says.
I’m in the clear because no one pays me to blog. I do hope there is a court case testing this among many other pieces of legislation intended to cement DeSantis’ control over everything in Florida.
More worrisome is the legislation that challenges the New York Times v. Sullivan case, which would allow DeSantis to sue his critics for defamation. Justice Thomas and Justice Gorsuch want to overturn that precedent too.
The New York Times published an editorial this morning critical of Florida’s effort to restrict free speech and press freedom.
It said:
A homeowner gets angry at a county commission over a zoning dispute and writes a Facebook post accusing a local buildings official of being in the pocket of developers.
A right-wing broadcaster criticizing border policies accuses the secretary of homeland security of being a traitor.
A parent upset about the removal of a gay-themed book from library shelves goes to a school board meeting and calls the board chair a bigot and a homophobe.
All three are examples of Americans engaging in clamorous but perfectly legal speech about public figures that is broadly protected by the Constitution. The Supreme Court, in a case that dates back nearly 60 years, ruled that even if that speech might be damaging or include errors, it should generally be protected against claims of libel and slander. All three would lose that protection — and be subject to ruinous defamation lawsuits — under a bill that is moving through the Florida House and is based on longstanding goals of Gov. Ron DeSantis.
Even a tweet or a comment in Facebook would trigger a lawsuit.
In a direct attack on a key aspect of free expression, it says that whenever someone is accused of discriminating against others on the basis of race, gender or sexual orientation, that accusation is automatically considered enough to sue for defamation. Any person accused of bigotry based on sexual orientation or gender identity could file a defamation lawsuit and be virtually guaranteed of winning by saying the discrimination was based on personal religious or scientific beliefs. The penalty for calling someone a bigot would be a minimum of $35,000.
Bloggers could no longer call DeSantis names like DeSatan or DeFascist. What a fragile ego he has. How will he survive Trump’s insults?
“would also require bloggers to disclose who’s paying them for their posts about certain elected officials and how much.
Tells you what they really want. . . .
They (DeSantis and those backing the bill) want the names of the money people so that they can coerce the money people into giving them the money
@diane — off topic, but the other day I got a weird “blog message” from you that just had numbers. Then it took me to an Apple web site. Was this you?
Yes. What you got was a notice that I mistakenly posted something on the wrong date, before I finished writing it. That happened last night, when I accidentally posted the Trump COAC report before I had finished writing it. It happened a couple of weeks ago because I posted “Feb 8” when I meant to post March 8.
@dianne — Thanks. Hope all is well.
All DeSantis has done is invite every blogger on the planet to write about Dangerously Deranged DeSantis. Most of the planet doesn’t censor the internet like China, North Korea, Iran, and Russia does. To censor them, DDD would have to set up the “orange” curtain in Florida to block the internet outside of Florida from getting in.
Traitor Trump blobs (sorry, couldn’t help myself — blogs) from Florida.
I want to sit back and watch how DDD is going to force Traitor Trump and all those bloggers spread out around the world, living in other states and countries, to obey him. What a fool?
To many bloggers, that like a challenge to a duel you can’t ignore.
Vanity, thy name is DeSanity.
lol
Have you put in your request for paperwork?
Most First Amendment attorneys believe this would be impossible to enforce. DeSantis knows what he is doing. He is shoring up his “strong man” image for his base.
Any publicity is good publicity for politicians of DeSantis’ ilk.
This is insane.
If Orson Wells and Charlie Chaplin were alive I would believe it if you said this sick man’s daily decrees came from one of their radio shows and silent movies, respectively.
Don’t say gay… separate state police (with brown shirts most likely)… “owning” college presidents… negotiating history with Academics and the (uggh) College Board… book burning – er, banning… erasing the presence of individuals who are LGBTorQ… media censorship and silencing critics… What’s his endgame? Bring on the colored stars and ribbons and chain link fences?
Fannie Lou Hamer said: “I’m sick and tired of being and tired of being sick and tired” Aren’t we? But no…
blah, blah, blah
…when will Disney, NFL, NBA, MLB, cruise industry, and other power brokers step up, speak up, and act up?
…when will every college president, superintendent, and minister show up at the Capitol together?
…when will NCTE, NCSS, NTSA, NMEA, AAHPERD and (blue) States STOP SPENDING money in Florida. Not spending a penny on association travel, conference participation, conference attendance, sports participation…
We’re all sick and tired of SAYING we’re sick and tired of being sick and tired…
So now what?
Any other time I’d say the courts will strike it down at the first challenge.
But we don’t live in any other time.
This is a man who intends to govern outside the law. He is a clear and present danger. But I’m sure Alito will find some unknown 12th century friar who will assure us the First Amendment is invalid, because Jesus Christ hated it.
20 years ago, if a governor in this country allowed such a law, he’d never be able to live it down. He/she certainly wouldn’t stand a chance for reelection. Now it’s just a challenge to RWNJs to think of something even MORE fascistic.
Floridians, how much does it take to get the public there to wake up?
Well said, theta. But don’t hold your breath waiting for Floridians to awaken. Flor-uh-duh is where sanity and the Constitution go to die.
That sucks.
As it happens, every state I’ve lived in has been a Democratic stronghold.
The whole purpose of this bill is to get it before the Supreme Court in order to change defamation precedent. What I don’t think they are considering is that right wing defamation practices would be subject to this change as well. The Curren Fox v. Dominion case requires proof of malice. If that is taken off, the courts will be busy from all sides.
Most people in remote provinces like Flor-uh-duh are too freaking dumb to be able to figure out just how backward, how behind the rest of the country and the civilized world they are. And there is a HUGE gulf, a chasm, between how they actually behave and what they profess. In this, the governor reflects those whom he governs. So, for example, Floridians hew to medieval Christian morality about sexual matters and about abortion but have among the highest teenage pregnancy rates and have high abortion rates. It’s a state in which every other building is EITHER a megachurch or a mega-strip club. LOL. Don’t try to make any sense of this. It doesn’t make sense. Is there lead in the drinking water here? How does one account for this degree of ignorance, self-contradiction, and stupidity? For a governor who gets behind a podium proclaiming the importance of freedom to announce new limitations that he intends to place on people’s freedoms?
It just gets weirder and weirder here.
Flor-uh-duh IS on the march toward progress and freedom and tolerance and equity and democracy, but IN THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION.
And DeSantis is the tin soldier leading this backward march.
Backward. As in, not of the 21st century, not reflecting where people in civilization are now.
People in civilization look at the stuff being done in Flor-uh-duh and respond as they do to the latest pronouncement by Marjorie Taylor Green. They think. These people are wacko. Cuckoo. Nuts. Backward. Hillbillies, minus the hills.
Same thing in Texas, where they put tight restrictions on abortion but have one of the highest rates of rape in the country. Governor Abbott promised to reduce the number of rapes but did not say how. And of course he did nothing.
I am hoping that what this means is that the country as a whole will reject Flor-uh-duh as a model for the nation, that DeSantis and his toadies will find that the country as a whole don’t buy what’s selling on the Floridian carnival midway.
I would hate to see DeSantis as the GOP nominee as I think he has no respect for the Constitution and would purge people and institutions he can’t control.
But if DeS gets the nomination, Trump is likely to run a third party and split the GOP.
That would be wonderful.
YES!!!!
So, the smart money in the GOP needs Trump out of the picture, period. If Trump runs as the nominee, they lose. If DeSantis is the nominee, Trump runs on a third-party ticket, and they lose. Either way, if Trump is in the picture, they haven’t a chance. So, they need to awaken Garland and other prosecutors and get Trump imprisoned ASAP for one of his many, many quite serious crimes. That clears the way for DeSatan AND they can blame the Democrats for persecuting the rehabilitated Trump as Reaganesque icon/mythical father figure.
If I were advising DeSantis, that’s exactly the argument that I would have him secretly floating among Repugnican donors, movers, and shakers (like Rupert Murdoch, Peter Thiel, etc).
I don’t think he’s exactly catching fire beyond Florida. He’s had some fawning RWNJ press, and he’s generated a lot of attention.
But there are some huge deficits: Trump at the moment is drawing attention as the primary elections loom for both parties, so he”s in the air as well. And DeSantis has all the charm of steel wool – he is uncomfortable with people (he doesn’t like them is why) and he has the oratory of a vice principal announcing a fire drill.
The best thing he can hope for is for Trump to be indicted. If that happens, it will greatly complicate his dreams of retribution and vindication. He’s the king of delay, and he will do anything to prolong the pretrial process. He believes running for president means DOJ “can’t” put him on trial if he’s a candidate.
I think DeSantis GREATLY overestimates how popular his ideas are outside of Florida. I expect that a lot of what he’s doing will be stopped by the courts. And the courts will be brutal, unless it’s Trumpalo judges these cases will be tried by.
“he has the oratory of a vice principal announcing a fire drill”
ROFLMAO!
DeSantis is polling well nationally.
But most voters don’t know much about him.
That’s only because the greater public doesn’t know him.
I’ve come to believe that being the new media obsession is the kiss of death. History is full of “bright, new mover to watch out for”. And most of them flame out early.
…news flash! Newsweek
“Former GOP House Speaker Newt Gingrich slammed a Florida Republican lawmaker for introducing legislation that would require political bloggers to register with the state.”
“The idea that bloggers criticizing a politician should register with the government is insane. it is an embarrassment that it is a Republican state legislator in Florida who introduced a bill to that effect. He should withdraw it immediately,” he tweeted.
Wow. When Newt Gingrich is the only person in the GOP talking sense, earth is totally off its axis.
Newt’s problem, aside from being relentlessly obnoxious, is that he doesn’t deal in good faith on anything. He’s not stupid though.