Far-right extremists concocted a cascading series of so-called culture wars that have no basis in fact or reality. Their purpose is to undermine public trust in teachers and public schools, paving the way for divisive “school choice,” which defunds public schools.
Teachers are intimidated, fearful that they might violate the law by teaching factual history about race and racism. Students are deprived of honesty in their history and social studies classes. Schools are slandered by extremists. Needless divisions are created by the lies propagated by zealots whose goal is to privatize public funding for schools.
First came the furor over “critical race theory,” which is not taught in K-12 schools. CRT is a law school course of study that examines systemic racism. The claim that it permeates K-12 schools was created as a menace threatening the children of America by rightwing ideologue Chris Rufo, who shamelessly smeared the teachers of America as purveyors of race hatred that humiliated white children. Rufo made clear in a speech at Hillsdale College that the only path forward was school choice. The entire point of Rufo’s gambit was the destruction of public trust in public schools.
Then came a manufactured brouhaha over transgender students who wanted to use a bathroom aligned with their sexual identity. The number of transgender students is minuscule, probably 1%. And yet again there was a furor that could have easily been resolved with a gender-neutral bathroom. Ron DeSantis made a campaign ad with a female swimmer who complained that she competed against a trans woman. What she didn’t mention was that the trans woman was beaten, as was she, by three other female swimmers.
And then came the nutty claim that teachers were “grooming” students to be gay. Another smear. No evidence whatever. Reading books about gay characters would turn students gay, said the critics; but would reading about elephants make students want to be elephants?
Simultaneously, extremists raised loud alarms about books that introduced students to dangerous ideas about sexuality and racism. If they read books with gay characters, students would turn gay. If they read about racism, they would “hate America.” So school libraries had to be purged; even public libraries had to be purged. One almost expected public book burnings. So much power attributed to books, as if the Internet doesn’t exist, as if kids can’t watch porn of all kinds, as if public television does not regularly run shows about American’s shameful history of racism.
As citizens and parents, we must stand up for truth and sanity. We must defend our schools and teachers against libelous claims. We must oppose those who would ban books.
Of course, parents should meet with their children’s teachers. They should partner with them to help their children. They should ask questions about the curriculum. They should share their concerns. Learning benefits when parents, teachers, students, and communities work together.
Sadly progressives have their hands tied in the Culture wars. Attacking the hypocrisy on the Right at the same level as the right demonizes progressive issues, can not be done without demonizing some of the issues.
Joel, wish you would elaborate on this opening note. Where is the left going wrong, attacking the right at their same level? I might agree, just would like some particulars.
bethree5
So here are a few examples:
If Hershel Walker and Republicans call Abortion murder then the effective way to attack him is as a serial murderer not a hypocrite. You can not do that without validating their argument.
Matt Schlapp the head of the American Conservative Union / CPAC would be on the front page of every paper in the Country if he was a star for Democrats and the left. Republicans would be demonizing him not just for unwanted
groping but as a sexual deviant. Again that can not be done without demonizing Homosexuality.
The Virginia school bathroom case involved consensual sex followed by none consensual sex later in the day. Is there any doubt in your mind how Republicans would have reacted had it not involved a boy with mixed sexual identity.
They have been excusing rape on college campuses victimizing women as asking for it right up to SCOTUS appointments.
Now perhaps I am too old but there is a difference between under the bleachers after school and the school bathroom during school. Had the shoe been on the other foot this girl and her father would be ridiculed to no end.
Perhaps the greatest injustice of all of this sound and fury for nothing, is that few of the individuals who are the most outspoken concerning cultural disinformation have set foot in a school in the last decade, much less observed or engaged in classroom instruction. Most of the right wing celebrities who profit from all of this noise send their children to private schools. Well intentioned policy makers and Washington politicians also opt for private schools when they are available. It is my experience that when school officials open their doors the reception from the public is very positive. I was principal of an elementary school where my predecessors actually barred members of the community from the building. There was a metal pull down door at the front of the office that was always closed by 4:00 pm. The neighborhood perception of the school was bad because there were no relationships between the school and community. When I got there, I stopped using the metal door and invited the real estate developers to come and see what we were doing. The overall outlook toward the school from all constituencies, including the staff, improved dramatically. I took similar steps at my previous school, invited the “difficult” parents in, and increased afternoon activities to accentuate the positive. According to Gallup (August 2022) 76% of parents are satisfied with their child’s public school (Compare that to 22% for Congress), it was 82% before the pandemic. My experience has taught me that if we are open to parents being in the schools and participating in activities, the dissatisfaction reduces significantly. Yes, it is well documented on this blog and through other media outlets that there are nefarious actors pushing a destructive agenda, but it is important that we fight their lies with the good that takes place in schools. The knee jerk firing and isolation of teachers who teach about diversity is one example of the the defensive posture taken by district and state leaders. Part of the reason, certainly not all, that the right wing disinformation campaigns take root is because school officials too often take cover and act to separate schools from the greater community. We simply don’t know one another. Our best weapon against false opaque charges of indoctrination is to open our doors, invite the community in, and get the positive out.
These are good points. Recent school shootings have led to a lockdown atmosphere in many schools that never existed years ago. After school is over, doors locked tight and halls vacant give the impression of a fortress. This makes the silly tale of schools separated from their communities by left-wing zealots unneeded oxygen. By contrast, ten years ago our halls were filled with students passing in and out who were involved in extra-curriculars like sports and dramatics. The locked door serve only to give some paranoid parents the misguided notion that their children are safe behind a locked glass door. This is foolish. No safety is gained by locking doors. Anyone with a piece of iron can enter the school at will. Anyone with evil intent can compromise security like this faster than the authorities can possibly respond. So what purpose does all this bunker mentality achieve? Only to further the narrative that schools are places of forbidden entry.
When I was a principal in Alabama the district hired a security consultant to present effective safety practices to schools. He stated that the schools that face the least amount of violence and community threat tend to be those that invest in inviting aesthetics, such as murals, that promote a welcoming environment. The district obviously refused to listen to this advice as they paid hundreds of thousands to build “security bubbles” with bullet proof class around the main lobbies and offices of most of the schools. My last school was from the “open concept era” where every classroom has an exterior door. The focus on front office protection is a good indicator of misplaced priorities.
Paul, so agree. There needs to be a way for public to see what goes on in their district classrooms in order to dispel this sort of distrust. I’m not sure it is necessary in regions like mine where most local districts are relatively small, and Bd of Ed meetings are highly attended [& broadcast on local cable], in a state where the hand of state BdofEd is relatively light [“guidance only”] & bows to local druthers. But there is an increasingly large # of states where state aid provides 50% of funding & uses that as a cudgel to dictate curriculum & even micromanage what can be discussed in the classroom. Those are he places that need to actually see into the classroom to understand what goes on there.
Most sane conservative leaning parents with children in public schools are not buying the propaganda either. They are also content that their schools are doing a good job. They know that the vast majority of teachers are not “groomers” or woke zealots. They support their public schools and do not feel that libraries are dangerous places. However, even these insights will not prevent them from continuing to vote for right wing provocateurs like Matt Gaetz or fraudsters like George Santos.
But it’s the few who make lives of teachers miserable. All it takes is one parent to destroy a teacher’s reputation and career. I’m watching that happen to a colleague right now. Universally loved and admired by students and staff alike. One parent calls the teacher a “groomer” and now that teacher is ruined.
And those “most sane conservatives” vote for right wing culture warriors like DeSantis. Of course many of those sane conservatives have not had Children in a school this century.
And no doubt many Germans who voted for Hitler did not believe the lies about the Jews. Those Germans had no problem with Jews — they also had no problem with Jews being demonized, their property confiscated, and they had no problem with Jews disappearing.
And no doubt those Germans called themselves “sane” Germans who may not have supported what the Nazis did to Jews and others, but who would continue to support Nazis because IT DID NOT BOTHER THEM ONE IOTA that the people they empowered hurt other people.
To me, it’s almost worse that a “sane conservative-leaning parent” will continue to empower those who hurt students and teachers. At least the right wing parents who aren’t “sane” actually believe that the harm they do to teachers is because those evil people deserve it. The supposedly “sane” ones apparently believe that the harm done to teachers who don’t deserve it is a just the cost of getting something of value for themselves.
Needless divisions are created
by the lies of
INSTITUTIONAL THINKING,
the embedded paterns of
perception and interpretations,
the social constructions
of reality, that lead
people to make decisions
that seem rational,
from their POV-thus
protecting their
status quo, their
bubble, their
paradigm.
Show me your papers!
Institutional bias,
the cornerstone of
hierarchies which
maintain themselves by
debasing and marginalizing
“others”.
Institutional thinking:
“A more perfect formula
for social dissolution
has rarely been
conceived. Focusing on
social divisions, rather
than solidarity, is a gift
to the ruling class.”
It is not a gift. The ruling class paid a lot of cash to create those divisions and distractions.
Whatever they paid, it was nowhere near enough.
SomeDAM Poet
True: Sadly a huge portion of the American people come with a bargain basement price tag.
But we could STILL send them a bill.
It’s never too late.
Some organization needs to start bringing class action suits on behalf of teachers against the politicians and others who are making the libelous claims about teachers — eg, of “grooming”
And the obvious organization would be a teachers union.
If people like DeSantis want to make libelous claims to further their careers, they should be forced by the courts to pay a personal — preferably financial — price for the lies.
Nail these politicians — not the states they represent, but the individuals — even a few times with a multimillion dollar lawsuit and I’d bet they will sit up and take note
In doubt that most of the politicians behind the “culture war” even believe their own BS. In fact, people like DeSantis probably laugh in private about what saps their voters are for falling for the stuff.
Trump has marveled at the stupidity of his supporters on more than one occasion and there is no reason to believe that DeSantis does not do the same.
The primary difference is that DeSantis is smart enough to do it privately.
Although, it obviously doesn’t matter that it is private.
Well said. Teachers and unions need to be more proactive in addressing these libelous claims. DeSantis gets away with slander because he knows public schools and teachers are easy targets. When allegations go unanswered, it will spawn more spurious claims and snowball into a larger false narrative. That’s how fascism operates.
Problem is, if they address the issues, they lose their jobs. My district is full of lemming and scared teachers like this. That’s also how fascism works! It changes behavior before it changes laws.
I think that’s what teachers thought in the case of VAM. That they would simply be fired.
But when teachers (even individual teachers like Sheri Lederman ) actually challenged it, they won.
The Houston Federation of Teachers filed a lawsuit in 2014 on behalf of nine teachers who said VAM violated their rights and a they won the suit.
I think if National teacher unions had done the same, VAM would have been thrown out very early on because what the few suits that were actually brought showed was that VAM was an opaque “take our word for it” method with no mechanism for challenge or even inspection that clearly violated teachers rights to due process.
The Venezuelan migrants (or probably their lawyer) had the right idea when they filed a class action suit against DeSantis personally over his Martha’s Vineyard stunt.
Even if they don’t eventually win, it puts DeSantis on the defensive and if the state of Florida has to spend money to defend him, some Florida residents probably will be none too happy.
People that support DeSantis including almost 70% of the voters have their heads in the Florida sand. This guy is a propaganda spewing, dangerous fascist that cannot be trusted.
Well, maybe some independents outside Florida will learn something from the law suits filed against him so that he won’t get their vote when he runs for prez.
We can always hope.
For example, some Libertarians don’t like it when politicians spend their money on clearly self serving things.
DeSantis did not spend Covid money to make schools safer. He hoarded the federal funds to underwrite his culture war. If anything, DeSantis’ reckless anti-vaxx and anti-mask messaging cost lives and increased infection rates, and he has been trying to keep this fact from the public. https://wusfnews.wusf.usf.edu/health-news-florida/2023-01-10/florida-reports-another-uptick-in-covid-19-cases-as-deaths-pass-84-000
It puts Desantis on the defensive only if the press reports it. So far media simply jumps to the next shiny object leaving justice and political accountability behind.
Far-right theofascist extremists concocting a cascading series of BIG LIES is what these people do, and once they hold all the power, if that happens (hopefully it won’t happen), they’ll start a program like the Nazi’s Final Solution to get rid of anyone that dares to challenge them, like what RasPutin the Terrible is doing in Russia to anyone that criticizes him.
People falling out of twenty story windows that don’t open. Families executed with bullets to the back of their heads.
Thank you for this powerful and passionate defense of public education.
Great post, Diane, & love to hear you cutting to the chase as you always do– like a knife through the butter of all the miscellaneous articles on these issues.