The Tampa Bay Business Journal reported that Florida will withdraw $2 billion in investment funds from BlackRock because the firm abides by standards against racism and for environmental awareness. This sort of ethical investing is repulsive to Governor Ron DeSantis and the extremists in his government. Republicans usually represent and celebrate big corporations. But in the past decade, many Republicans have turned against the same corporations for what they call “woke capitalism.” That is, a number of big corporations have sought to placate their Black employees and customers, their LGBT+ employees and customers, and socially aware young people.
When corporations take stands on sensitive issues which make their employees and customers angry, hat’s “woke capitalism.” When they oppose hate laws and work to promote diversity and equity, that’s “woke capitalism.” The more they step up to support minority causes, the more they enrage reactionary Republicans like DeSantis.
Here is an example of Governor Ron DeSantis acting boldly to crush “woke capitalism.”
Florida will pull $2 billion from the largest asset-management firm in the world over ideological differences.
State Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronisannounced Thursday that Florida will immediately freeze about $1.43 billion in long-term securities and about $600 million in short-term overnight investments managed by BlackRock because of the firm’s use of “Environmental, Social, and Governance” standards — known as ESG.
Patronis in a prepared statement said he doesn’t “trust BlackRock’s ability to deliver” and “BlackRock CEO Larry Fink is on a campaign to change the world.”
“Whether stakeholder capitalism, or ESG standards, are being pushed by BlackRock for ideological reasons, or to develop social credit ratings, the effect is to avoid dealing with the messiness of democracy,” Patronis said.
Republican leaders in Florida and across the country have targeted ESG ratings, which can involve considering a wide range of issues in investments, such as companies’ climate-change vulnerabilities; carbon emissions; racial inequality; product safety; supply-chain labor standards; privacy and data security; and executive compensation.
Patronis said the state Department of Financial Services oversees about $60 billion and that the money with BlackRock will be moved “elsewhere.”
“I think it’s undemocratic of major asset managers to use their power to influence societal outcomes,” Patronis said. “If Larry (Fink), or his friends on Wall Street, want to change the world — run for office. Start a non-profit. Donate to the causes you care about. Using our cash, however, to fund BlackRock’s social-engineering project isn’t something Florida ever signed up for.”
Fink is a leading proponent of ESG metrics. In a letter this year to corporate executives, Fink said companies using the standards are “performing better than their peers.”
“Stakeholder capitalism is not about politics,” Fink wrote. “It is not a social or ideological agenda. It is not ‘woke.’ It is capitalism, driven by mutually beneficial relationships between you and the employees, customers, suppliers, and communities your company relies on to prosper.”
BlackRock manages over $8 trillion in assets. They are unlikely to miss Florida’s $2 billion.
The very idea of BlackRock being too woke is kind of hilarious. You’d think that it’s massive investment in fossil fuel industries would counterbalance its great concern about racism. 🙃
To clarify: would counterbalance DeSantis’s opposition to its concern about racism.
They’ll have to change the name to WokeRock
Giggle.
It is indeed — darkly — hilarious that Florida has BlackRockaphobia. BlackRock and the like are trying to be woke in an attempt to profit from self-preservation. “Win-win”, wink-wink. They’re investing in climate crisis “solutions”, part of which is solving the disparity of who is affected by global warming, hence the wokeness domestically. Mixed feelings about green/woke capitalism aside, Florida’s fear of even attempting self-preservation with capitalism is laughable, laughable and cry-able.
Wow, you really are afraid of Ron DeSantis. Woke capitalism violates fiduciary rules that require investment managers to maximize returns while complying with all laws. It’s virtue-signaling by affluent people so they can show off to their peers at the trendiest cocktail and dinner parties. By all means invest teacher pension funds with those wokesters – the returns will be less than they would be otherwise. You will, of course, then insist that taxpayers make up any shortfalls in monthly payments to retired teachers.
BlackRock a “wokester” company with risky investments?! It is THE LARGEST investment firm in the world with over $8 trillion in assets! Following your logic, DeSantis should insist on investing in BlackRock given its success and disregard the company’s “virtue-signaling”. But virtue-signaling – in his case “anti-wokeness” – is the only thing that matters to him.
I think if I read made up terms like “wokesters” and “virtue signaling” one more time, I’m gonna puke.
It’s like listening to a bunch of goddamned parrots.
Kinda makes a point loud and clear, doesn’t it, that what these rapacious cretins think of as Capitalism is doing whatever might turn a little more profit, do matter the consequences. Slave child labor in Africa or India or Indonesia? No prob. Climate disaster? Great, we love it. Poisoning the communities of people of color to avoid paying for cleanup? Wonderful.
What can one possibly say about people who think like that? They are freaking psychopaths.
It’s really corporatism.
Corporatism operates on the principle that what generates the most profit for the corporation is what should be done in all cases.
If that requires murdering indigenous people in the Amazon rain forest who are opposing oil drilling or enslaving children to work in lithium mines for batteries , so be it.
It’s not an accident that the Supreme Court has granted corporations personhood, with all the benefits but none of the responsibilities.
It renders the “government by and vor the People” the “government buy and for the corporations”
The Supreme Court Justice(s) who figured out that they could subvert the entire US Constitution simply by granting corporations personhood was (were) genius(es).
Or maybe that was what the Founding Fathers intended from the beginning?
The day is quickly approaching in which all “human” considerations will be moot, when the bots control everything and have no need for humans and their silly physical and spiritual needs and desires.
The hilarious thing is that we are knowingly and willingly bringing it upon ourselves — even celebrating it.
The bots won’t care
The bots won’t care
If laws are “fair”
The bots won’t feel
When humans squeal
The bots won’t hear
The human fear
The bots won’t cry
When humans die
The thing inducing
All the bots
Is reproducing —
Lots and lots
Some history from the Holocaust Encyclopedia- In 1933, the Nazi leadership staged an economic boycott targeting Jewish businesses. It was the beginning of a campaign. The provocation for the Nazi action was the success that various groups e.g. the press were having in damaging Nazi Germany’s reputation.
“…Fink said companies using the standards are “performing better than their peers.”
Did you miss that? Hard to convince corporate executives of the truth of that statement without the metrics to support it.
There are those who believe that investment managers should be concerned exclusively with maximizing returns within the law. The idea is that such managers should simply ignore what economists call “negative externalities.” This is an extreme view that even Friedrich Hayek, the libertarian forefather, rejected.
There is a term, of course, for ignoring, not being concerned about, the negative effects on people of one’s actions. That term is PSYCHOPATHY.
Bob, when the shareholders and investment clients demand results e.g. Blackrock and Apple (production in China), where is the locus of psychopathy?
After the 2007 collapse of the subprime market, Blackrock came into Tampa and bought 1.5 billion dollars’ worth of foreclosed houses. It now rents those to people who used to be homeowners.
Thanks, Obama, Geitner, Summers, and the rest of the Wall Street Rip Off the Common Person Gang.
I remember how, for years, there was an Apple cult. People thought of Microsoft and Apple as the light and dark sides of the Force, respectively. Uh, no. Tell that to the families of all those Apple supplier workers in China who committed suicide because of their horrific working conditions.
Economists are themselves negative externalities — like pollution.
LOL
Just read your Bots won’t care poem, someDAM.
WOW. That’s freaking really, really good.
Bob,
In general economists argue that people in general ignore both positive and negative externalities when making decisions. Economists also argue that people should not ignore externalities and have suggested policies to get decision makers to internalize those externalities. As a group we have been calling for a price on carbon emissions for decades, for example.
I talk with my students about this. They typically use electricity to wash and dry their clothing, very problematic as coal is the single largest source of electricity locally, rather than taking the responsible step of washing their clothing by hand. They often use the university run shuttle bus service rather then walk between destinations. They ignore the impacts of their own choices on climate change.
Living on campus in self-erected yurts, as opposed to university housing, is also a great idea.
Wouldn’t you agree?
And they could study by candlelight to save on electricity for lighting.
Wood campfires for heat would be very good for energy savings too.
The students could have climate kumbaya singalongs every night by the fire to attract new students to the cause.
Great thinking, SomeDAM!
Oh and fetch water every day from the university cement pond. That would save on water pumping energy.
They could also wash their clothes in the cement pond, but that might present a bit of a problem if they were also getting their drinking water from there.
But maybe they could wash at one end of the cement pond and fetch water at the other end.
The solution to pollution is dilution, right?
On second thought, maybe whale oil burning lamps would be better for lighting.
Better yet, hemp oil, since most students already have that lying around .
And if they got short on the oil, they could burn the buds for light and heat and cooking — which they already wastefully burn anyway.
Hemp oil! Now you’re really putting on the ole thinkin’ cap, SD!
And, at any rate, they wouldn’t much care. Herodotus says that the ancient Scythians used to make great bonfires of hemp and have a glorious time at these. LOL.
And if the students all lived in yurts universities could make the dorms into greenhouses for marijuana, which could then be burned for heating, lighting and cooking, and generally improving test scores and attitude.
And of course, it would all be carbon neutral.
Problem solved.
Good thing we have economists to figure all of this out.
A common Republican argument- unless a solution that corrects all facets associated with a problem can be found, nothing should be done.
What aboutism
It was all inspired by your yurtiversity idea, Bob.
Which was inspired by TEs suggestion that students wash clothes by hand.
TE likes to try to jerk chains.
I think you have found your retirement gig
President of Shepherd Yurtiversity
Dean Bobkis Khan!
The course possibilities are endless:
Pot Growing for Poets
Pot growing for Potters
Pot Growing for Engineers
Pot Growing for Scientists
Pot Growing for Economists
The History of Pot
The Politics of Pot
And so on
And of course,
“How to make a yurt”
“How to live off the grid in a hurt”
How to milk a yak”
“How to make yak cheese and yak butter”
And everything else yurty
Make that
Yakherd Yurtiversity
If TE declines, I’d like to be considered for the job of Director of Yurtiversity Development.
Cuz I already have lots of ideas.
I have already been in contact with the Mongolian Embassy and they are interested in giving some seed money. (For seeds)
Clearly! Been microdosing a lot I guess.
Seed money!!!! HAAAAAAA!!!!
I am already working on the Kumis curriculum!
Fermented yak milk
And they have said they can put me in touch with many Yurtonomists (although maybe TE also has expertise in that area)
Economists are experts in everything. Something the theologians missed is that God herself is an economist. That explains a lot, doesn’t it?
I already came up with a Yurtiversity motto
“Yakherd Yurtiversity: Where circles are not just math but a way of life”
Well, after all God did say “Let there be economists and all was Light”
And on the seventh day, God was arrested (for good reason)
Amen (and a few women)
Genesis” (from the Raj Chetty
version of the Bible)
In the beginning God created the Heaven
and the earth.
And the earth was without VAM, and
void; and darkness was upon the face of
the deep. And the Spirit of God moved
upon the face of the waters.
And God said, Let there be economists:
and there was light.
And God saw the Light, that it was good:
and God divided the good teachers from
the bad ones
And God called the light VAM, and the
darkness he called “Traditional Teacher
evaluations”
And on the eighth day, Diane started this blog and all Hell broke loose…
That’s from Genesis in the Raj Chetty version of the Bible.
But in all seriousness
“How to milk a yak” would be far more environmentally, socially and economically appropriate than the courses currently offered by economics departments and business schools that deal with “How to milk a public”
Bob,
I think many of the things mentioned here would would significantly reduce the carbon footprint of my students, but apparently the students are ignoring and unconcerned about the negative effects their actions on others.
My clothes washing example was a reference to this classic TED talk by Han’s Rosling. You, and others, might enjoy watching it: https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_the_magic_washing_machine?language=en
Apparently TEs students have good enough sense not to listen to what he says.
Given the newer energy- and water-saving washing machines, hand washing of clothes would actually waste water while saving relatively small amounts of electricity. Most washing machines draw significantly less current than a hair blow dryer, which students use far more often (albeit for somewhat shorter time)
And while on the subject of water and energy conservation, hot showers consume far more energy and water than clothes washing machines.
And walking instead of taking the shuttle bus while the Yurtiversity shuttle bus continues to drive around with fewer or even no students onboard is an an energy-“saving” tactic that only TE could dream up.
While some students can walk to class, riding public transportation (instead of driving) in general is a carbon reducing strategy that commuter students and others can take. And getting folks in the habit of taking public transport is good in itself.
Deranged Governor DeSanctimonious should invest that $2 billion with Traitor Trump.
DeSantis could not tolerate The Disney Corpration’s criticism of the culture wars. He signed a bill stripping Disney World of its status as an “independent special district,” fulfilling his request to punish the Disney company for its stances on social and education issues. DeSantis’ tantrum will dramatically shift the tax burden to the two counties in which the theme park is located. Talk about biting the hand of the number one employer in the state, but DeSantis requires Putinesque loyalty from anyone doing business in the state.
The Disney Company dared to be critical of DeSantis’ anti-mask laws and treatment of LGBTQ folks. DeSantis repeatedly told Floridians that “masks don’t work,” propaganda that has been refuted by science. The “free state” of Florida has the highest death rates for Covid among the elderly, but I doubt this statistic will be highlighted in any DeSantis’ commercials. BTW, I am not condoning Disney’s labor practices, nor am I a fan of the company. DeSantis constantly accuses Democrats of overreach, but he is blind and immune to his own. DeSantis expects mob boss fealty from those that work in the “fiefdom of Florida,” or suffer the consequences.
If they ain’t gonna miss it the. What’s the problem? Stay woke
At what point will the people of Florida understand that their culture warrior governor is costing them taxpayer dollars? Oh yeah, I forgot this is Florida we’re talking about…
I can’t stop laughing. Death DeSatan has the gall to talk about racism when he went after Disney world for for sticking up for the gay rights, disenfranchising black votes. Where does that 2B go for DeSatan 2024 campaign. The DOJ better keep an eye on him and his FL legislators.
In the climate today, we should consider the possibility that right wing politicians lie about their motives. Targeted Wall Street firm(s) may have leaders with different demographics than the financial firms that don’t get hassled or denied business. Christian nationalists have their prejudices?
Maybe, they want to steer business to people they feel an affinity for.
From the Intercept, Twitter allows Russian officials (Russian Embassy Account) to post anti-Semitic cartoon of Zelensky (11-22-2022).
Members of a Republican administration moving money out of investments on a point of some skewed principal?
Gosh, that’s not the USA I have been observing since 1960s.😲
It’s quite the betrayal of conservatism.
Don’t forget the basics Gov. DeSantis…
🎵’Money makes the world go round…
The world go round…..’🎶
Is it coincidence that DeSantis picked fights with Disney and Blackrock? The right wing, in the past few years, has been fixated on Christian nationalism.
WaPo, “DeSantis is following Trump’s White Supremacy Playbook” (2-1-2022).
The NY Post wrote on June 29, 2022, “Anti Semitic Flyers Attacking Disney Found on Lawns of Fla. Homes.” At the time that DeSantis targeted Disney, Bob Chapek was leading the company.
Btw -Walt Disney who died a long time ago had a “complicated” history on the subject.
DeSantis is actually more open about the White supremacy (His anti-woke schtick in a nutshell.)
As I noted below, what Trump called MAGA has basically morphed into MASA with DeSantis
MASA: Make America Supremacist Again
I chose to view MASA in the context of the poem below, as a contraction of the southern plantation owner’s Master.
Indeed he did Linda. Classic early 20th century self-made fellow obsessed with Communism taking over the USA (laughable), questionable on race and religious bigotry.
These are more dangerous breed. These are people who have not read their history and where these toxic beliefs lead.
PS: Suggestion, if you encounter anyone who suggests they are speaking well of Hitler and National Socialism. Just phrase ‘Malmedy December 1944’.
These are not true patriots of the USA, these creatures of MAGA.
Determined-
In today’s climate, the Malmedy Massacre during which Nazis targeted American soldiers/POW’s should provoke us to examine what ratio in the American military today are on the side of fascism. The Freedom from Religion Foundation posted in 2005 about fears related to right wing religious evangelism at the Air Force Academy (Colorado Springs). The Air Force has the reputation as the branch with the most intelligent and professional forces. If that branch can become a source of activism for the right wing’s agenda, it may reflect, game over.
On Jan. 6, we saw the delayed reaction/inaction from the military and law enforcement. Some warn us to question if the delay was deliberate and premeditated. Media reported that Gen. Flynn’s brother was in one of the rooms where the military discussed the riots as they were happening. A prior memo from Chris Miller has been mentioned in the context of Jan. 6. Subsequent reporting hasn’t provided clarity.
The U.S. population was willing to face off against Hitler. Hitler targeted homosexuals, Jews, the Roma race, etc.
In the U.S. at the time, women and Black people were 2nd class to the White men in the military. Today, White GOP men see themselves as losing their dominance over Blacks and women. “Modernism”, when it threatens power, creates instability. Right wing religion stands as a front for the dominant ruling class.
When we join in, in Pat Buchanan’s framing, “culture war”, we wrongly distance what is going on from conservative Taliban-like religion and we distract from the truth that the subject is modernism.
I do not support DeSantis in any way, however, Black Rock is a despicable corporation.
…………
BlackRock: The Secret Company that Owns the World
Why You Should Be Scared of BlackRock
Founded by Larry Fink in 1988, BlackRock is the most powerful Wall Street fund in the world with $9 trillion worth of assets under management. That’s larger than the gross domestic product (GDP) of every single country around the globe, with the exception of China and the United States.
If you were to make $1 every second, you would be worth as much as BlackRock in about 240,000 years…
BlackRock’s absurd liquidity means that if you look at just about every major publicly traded company in the world you’ll find that BlackRock is its first, second or third-largest shareholder. ..
What BlackRock Does is Terrifying
If you put the big three asset management firms together being BlackRock, Vanguard and StateStreet, they control a collective of $15 trillion dollars. That’s roughly 70% of the United State’s GDP…
What made all of this worse is that BlackRock held significant shares in the exact institutions they were helping bailout. In finance we call this “circular ownership.” I just call it horse shit economics.
BlackRock also owns part of CNN and FOX, meaning they can unilaterally influence bipartisan information flow.
Oh, and they manipulate what we buy, sell, consume, and even where we decide to live. They also own our politicians…
View at Medium.com
Well, that’s pretty scarry.
Carol,
I agree the rich have outsized influence in the selection of politicians e.g. Hakeem Jeffries. And, I agree that through investment firms, clients insulate themselves from reprehensible moral situations e.g. Apple manufacturing in China.
The following comment does not address your view about Blackrock. It provides info. from a, 4-20-2022, Reuters’ fact check of a video that claimed Blackrock and Vanguard own all of the biggest corporations. The main point was the company’s control is a function of how large a voting share it has in each firm owned and what type of a firm’s decisions, Blackrock supports or rejects.
The very little I know about anti-trust suggests to me that investment firms like Blackrock don’t fit the traditional model of monopolies. It’s possible that laws should be updated.
IMO, the problem is that there are more investment firms than there are firms that produce products. There are a lot of dollars chasing money-taking opportunities. It’s estimated that Wall Street is a 2% drag on the economy. If men like Bill Gates cared about the economic future of the nation, he would turn his skills (such as they are) to fixing the large problem, not focusing on the drummed up issue of public schools. Public schools are under the guillotine’s knife for two reasons (and, they are likely connected). First, the theft of community assets is a goal of money managers and
secondly, right wing religion wants to perpetuate a ruling system that discriminates in favor White straight men.
“It’s possible that laws should be updated.”
But it’s not possible that laws willbe updated.
Not when, as Senator Dick Durbin noted,” Frankly, they [the banisters] own the place” [the government]
Banksters”
“A + Charter School Secures $11.3 mil. Bond Through Blackrock” (2020 in Maricopa). Blackrock’s clients will earn interest on deals like this. It’s clients, living remote from Maricopa, will be paid from local tax dollars intended for community students. The diversion of funds also harms communities because it denies them the benefit of the economic multiplier effect. That’s the kind of man Bill Gates is. His legacy is an ugly one.
Hopefully, this link will work.
View at Medium.com
BlackRock held significant shares in the exact institutions they were helping bailout. In finance we call this “circular ownership.” I just call it horse shit economics.
It’s just “economics”
The horseshit modifier is redundant.
Carol,
“I do not support DeSantis in any way, however, Black Rock is a despicable corporation.“
That was essentially my point (up above). DeSantis is pulling money from BlackRock because it claims that
“At BlackRock, diversity, equity and inclusion is more than a strategy, it is a mindset embedded at the heart of everything we do”
but not in any way because of the harm it causes with the power of its investments. DeSantis deserves zero ethical credit for this decision.
DSantis cut up his ethical credit card long ago.
Now he is operating purely on ethical debit.
There should not be billionaires, but having companies like BlackRock and Vanguard is a necessary evil with capitalism. I want my pension fund invested in those ruthless firms. An unnecessary and unintelligent evil was the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act.
BlackRock: The Company that Owns the World
Jake Tran
Make America Sleep Again (MASA)
Make America Sleep Again
The motto of the master
Make America how it’s been
MAGA changed to MASA
DeSantis: Make America Sleep Again!
Republicans: Yes, MASA
Good line, MAGA changed to MASSA’
The Florida Plantation
DeSantis is the Master
The mansion is his home
Presiding over MASA
Like Caesar did in Rome
MASA also stands for Make Americans Slaves Again
Make America Supremacist Again” also works
Make America Slaves Again (MASA)
Make America Slaves Again
The motto of the master
Make America how it’s been
MAGA changed to MASA
Make Americans Slaves Again (MASA)
Make Americans Slaves Again
The motto of the Master
Make America how it’s been
MAGA changed to MASA
“Yes. MASA. We’ll get on the plane, MASA!”
DeSantis holds the whip
And tells his slaves to “Move!”
He sends them on a trip*
Cuz Ron has things to prove.
*To Martha’s Vineyard