David Gamberg recently retired as Superintendent of two contiguous school districts on the North Fork of Long Island: the Southold district and the Greenport district. He first was appointed in Southold, where he was beloved for his devotion to the students; he is a child-centered educator, who encouraged the arts, developed a student-run garden (whose produce was used in the school cafeteria), and strengthened the school’s theatre program. When the Greenport schools needed a new superintendent, they invited Gamberg to split his time between the two districts.
Gamberg writes his story:
When I was young I never fully knew what my father did for a living. Eventually learning that he was a truck driver did not dissuade me from following in his footsteps. I never did pursue that line of work. Nor did I ultimately learn about the industry that he worked in throughout his entire life. Therefore I am not one to opine on how the supply chain and the trucking industry’s role in our economy is a major feature of what we are now experiencing in our country and throughout the world.
I was fortunate to grow up in the America of my youth. My father was a truck driver who did not go to college. I consider myself so fortunate. My mom worked as an aide in a nursing home. They worked hard, but I was also the beneficiary of a system that recognized a need to level the playing field for those among us who may not have been born into a privileged position in society.
It never occurred to me that my K-12 public education was ineffective or insufficient to prepare me to lead a fulfilling life. I didn’t go to private school, and the racially diverse schools that I attended were of great benefit to my understanding of the world around me. I resent the attacks on public schools that are playing out today.
At 59 years old I can remember a time when the United States government helped me to get a leg up in life. I went to Head Start, a pre-kindergarten program for children set up for the common good, to give opportunities for young people like me who did not come from wealth, or status in society that paved the way forward. I don’t know where I would have traveled in life if not for this early support, and therefore I can’t imagine why good early childhood education is not something that every American of any political persuasion should support. This was not the only benefit I received as a young citizen of our country.
Yes, I went to college, a public state university, paid in part because of the benefits I derived from my father’s lifelong contributions to the Social Security system. He was of age to receive social security when I went to school in the early 1980s. As a result of the structure of the Social Security benefit program at the time, as long as I was in college I would receive some measure of support to offset the cost of going to school. This and other safety net benefits including state and federal grants afforded me the opportunity for a good education, without having vast amounts of student debt hanging over my head upon graduation.
I raise these issues in the context of my childhood view of work and school, and my growing awareness over the years about the role that good government programs and support played in my life. It is not a matter of government entitlements. Rather, it is about the public trust that we place in our government to support fellow citizens. It is about the importance of a civil society, and how our governing polity should work.
The opportunities that should be afforded to every young American to have the ability to go to post secondary school to pursue their purpose in life if they choose to do so, or to dream of a career and living a life to the fullest should be the norm, and a common reality for all. This should not be dependent upon your station in life, where you were born, or your family situation.

In my experience the truly child-centered, therefore school centered, leader is the most effective. There is significant evidence that this is the exception rather than the rule, so reading about an empathetic leader with a global outlook is refreshing. I can only hope we can get policy makers to follow Dr. Gamberg’s lead.
LikeLike
Education, healthcare, a decent place to live, and a heathy diet are rights not discretionary benefits.
LikeLike
If the GOP has their way, and I think they will, all of those things will be for the wealthy only. Too many millions of people don’t recognize how they are being screwed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
yes,
scary to say: too many millions of people are adamantly buying in to the game which will only horrendously screw them in the end
LikeLike
Thank you, Dr. Gamberg.
My father’s salvation was his public school teachers who learned he was being abused in foster care, collected left over food for him to eat, and called social services. My father ended up living at the Salvation Army Orphanage from the primary grades until he was16.
My father and I graduated from high school in the same year. My father was a great role model for his children and for others. Plus, he never forgot the “good things” his public school teachers did for him when he was an orphan.
One of the things my father learned is the importance of books and reading. He always had a book in his hands wherever we went. Yay for my father’s teachers.
Public Schools MATTER! Too bad Obama’s experiences at Punahou, a private school where the RICH kids go, didn’t help him understand this fact … SAD. It is also SAD that our “so-called” leaders feel it necessary to bash public schools for votes.
LikeLike
Great observations, Yvonne. Your story reminds me of a friend whose father was pulled from the most absolute poverty in the mountains of North Carolina. He got to be an accountant, his daughter attended Davidson College and became a professor.
His rescue was in the hands of a private school, indeed a private religious school, but the result was the same. We can be the difference in people’s lives. Public education has been the rescue for the many.
LikeLike
Wonderful story, Yvonne!
LikeLike
Thank you, Roy and Bob.
Wow, Roy, your father’s story is truly one that shows that teachers are heroes and heroines.
My father’s story (and my mother’s, not told here) are truly ones of survival and hope … hope for a better future and doing the work and having kindness and generosity in order to contribute positive things to society.
I just don’t “get” people who only “BASH teachers” and “promote hate.”
During this time of COVID, I think about all those who survived WWII and the many sacrifices they made. I think about the people of Hawai’i who had to wipe their butts with newspaper and the paper that covered oranges. My mother never got over having to ration toilet paper. If she were still living, she would make sure she had enough rice, eggs, broth, and of course…toilet paper. Can’t forget SPAM … South Pacific Army Meat. I LOVE SPAM.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My father also worked as a truck driver, a long-haul truck driver, and my mother as a home-care nurse. Both physically demanding jobs. He said to me often, when I was a kid, “Bobby, I bust my tail, use my body to earn a living, so you won’t have to, so you’ll be able to earn yours with your brain.” Much honor to, respect for him! Much honor. Much respect.
And yeah, I wouldn’t have been able to go to college without the availability of a subsidized PUBLIC and scholarships provided by taxpayer dollars–investments in our country’s future.
LikeLike
Again, so moving, so well said, Yvonne! Blessings to you and yours!
LikeLike
cx: a subsidized PUBLIC university
LikeLike
I’ll tell a funny story that happened years ago. An English professor at Indiana University told this (speaking out of school as perhaps he shouldn’t have). He said, well, that graduate fellowship came down to two possible recipients, but Bob obviously grew up with all the advantages, so we gave it to the other person.” LOL. My family was as working class as they come, and before my Mom met my stepfather the truck driver, there were many times when we prayed that the bologna would hold out for the week so that we had something to eat. Didn’t seem funny at the time, but I can laugh at it now.
LikeLike
Yvonne: You had me until you got to the Spam. I had a student who loved that stuff. We got back from a camping trip and made a trophy from a spam can and a little plastic soldier glued on top. We called it the Hormel Award (for loving to eat almost anything). I cannot share anyone’s enthusiasum for spam.
LikeLike
Interestingly, this widely reviled product actually contains high-quality cuts of meat. And it was extraordinarily important to the survival of Hawaiians at one point.
LikeLike
Bob: Fascinating. I had no idea. My mother used to cook it up with pineapple, no doubt a Hawaii influence. Still, I am glad my own distant survival story did not include spam. There are, of course, much more vile protein sources in different cultures, not the least of which is souse or pressed meat, a tradition of my area made of the scraps of hog killing, as it is affectionately called by the old folks.
LikeLike
“Yes, I went to college, a public state university, paid in part because of the benefits I derived from my father’s lifelong contributions to the Social Security system. ”
Me too. My father was disabled from the time I was a 10th grader. Without state help, I would not have been able to attend college. I have often considered this when the subject of teacher wages came up. I think I have paid it back. I am glad a generation before me paid it forward.
LikeLike
Amen
LikeLike
Roy, thank you for your statement: “I am glad a generation before me paid it forward.” We must and should “PAY IT FORWARD.”
LikeLike
Thanks to Ronald Reagan, Social Security survivor/children’s benefits for students over 18 who were in college were phased by the early 1980s. Now, anyone who is 18 and isn’t still a high school students gets no social security benefits. (Full disclosure – there is an exception for disabled children allowing them to continue to receive benefits past high school/age 18).
LikeLike
Unfortunately years of neoliberal leadership in the Democratic party has driven many blue collar voters to the party of Trump. Democrats need to work on messaging and policies that will bring these voters back. Build Back Better, even in reduced design, is a step in the right direction. Democrats must follow up with their social plan and voting rights if they want to attract the working class back to the party.
My parents lived through the depression, and they also worked hard throughout their lives. My brother and I attended an affordable commuter college and had more stable careers than my parents who were adamant that my brother and I graduate without debt holding us back. They were very wise and ahead of their time. Our foundation from our diverse public schools made it all possible.
LikeLike
Amen
LikeLike
retired teacher,
Are you suggesting that African American blue collar voters are being driven to the party of Trump? Where is your evidence for that?
WHITE blue collar voters are being driven to the very party that embraces anti-union, anti-worker safety, anti-health care benefits because they are drawn to the white supremacist appeal.
Democrats do not need to work on attracting them. They need to get out their base of working class voters that aren’t white and angry who find the Republican call outs to white supremacy appealing. And the way to do that is to shut down the false narratives that nothing will ever get done if you elect huge majorities of Democrats because when Democrats have a 50-50 Senate they didn’t things done and that proves that Dems are neoliberal.
Note that three supposed “neoliberals” — McAuliffe, Northam and Kaine – spent the last decade keeping ed reformers from taking over in Virginia while the “progressive” that DFER touted as their politician of the month was the one that the progressive movement was fighting to DFER-ize the public schools in Virginia. It wasn’t just Obama — it was progressive politicians embraced by Bernie Sanders himself who were rabid supporters of charters and privatization and weren’t defending public schools.
The way to make this country more progressive is to give Democrats huge majorities, just like they had under LBJ and Truman when two presidents who would be attacked as “neoliberals” today helped enact the progressive legislation we still value.
Send out the message that the more Democrats have huge majorities, the more progressive actions will happen. Because it’s true.
The white working class folks who find the appeals to white supremacy attractive have been infused with the belief that it is normal for white people to vote for the most anti-worker party in history because that anti-worker party wants to “protect their (white) way of life”. They need to change on their own.
LikeLike
No. A number of white blue collar workers have moved to the party of Trump because Trump talks tough, and too many of them believe the lies. My post said nothing about Black people that support Trump.https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/meet-the-press/gop-rapidly-becoming-blue-collar-party-here-s-what-means-n1258468
LikeLike
retired teacher, thanks for the interesting link.
But still don’t understand what Democrats are supposed to do, if those voters believe Republican lies. It doesn’t matter what the Dems do unless they completely fold and let the Republicans simply end Medicare, Social Security and outlaw unions which might bring those voters to their senses. And then it will be too late since there won’t be democracy.
Do you know what I would expect if economic issues mattered? I would expect that blue collar workers – especially white working class voters – would either stop voting at all or vote 3rd party.
But according to this, instead they are drawn to the Republican Party that is doing even worse economic harm to them than the Dems. It would make more sense if college educated whites who earn more money and might benefit from low taxes were switching from Dems to Republicans. But instead it’s blue collar voters – largely white blue collar voters – who find what the Republicans tell them very appealing.
Instead of being turned off of both parties, they are the most rabidly Republican they have ever been — they adore the Republicans. When we figure out why (and I suspect a lot of it is instilling fear of the “other” in white folks), I think it will turn out that many are unreachable because unless Dems start offering allusions to white supremacy to appeal to them – which would turn me off – those voters should simply be ignored.
Dems offered very good policies. That they couldn’t get it done because they don’t have large majorities should be the real message to voters — give them those majorities so they can get this done.
LikeLike
The DNC is launching a campaign across the country to share what Build Back Better will do. Cabinet members will hold meetings various states. Democrats want to share and explain their accomplishments before the midterms. They want to reclaim the rust belt as BBB will create lots of blue collar jobs.
LikeLike
I have some sense of how white rural blue collars in the North vote, as I grew up with them, and am in touch with siblings who’ve stayed among them. To be very broad-brush, these folks are generally not particularly racist (definitely not “white supremacist”), nor particularly religious. As retired teacher’s link suggests, they vote their pocketbook– but not with any nuance or study. So for example, the economy finally eased for them & things started looking up during Trump’s term… but there’s little recognition/ memory that it collapsed during Bush’s 2nd term, & it was Obama’s machinations that rescued us from depression and got the needle pointing steadily in the other direction. So Trump got a free ride, & in fact his trade policies started screwing things up—but covid arrived, so that didn’t get digested.
You see the same kind of thing in the anti-union attitude. For many blue-collar rurals, union work is a long-ago memory— in some rural Northern areas has barely been available for decades. They associate it with far-away cities where people have always been unfairly advantaged [tied in their mind to regs/ taxes that afflict them to the benefit of cities]. The unions “abandoned the working man”—zero memory of how Rep govt policies offshored jobs/ busted unions—all they got was “unions overreached” [USSteel]. With no historical context, it appears unions are just about “govt workers,” i.e. taxes I pay that don’t benefit me.
I see some hope in retired teacher’s link: “Some signs of what this change could mean became visible just after the election when Republican voters aligned with former President Donald Trump called for larger Covid-19 relief payments from the government. A larger cash payout is not a policy choice one would normally associate with Republicans.“ This says blue-collars are an addition to the Trumpian core, and if Reps want to keep them on board, they’re going to have to do something that benefits blue-collar pocketbooks. Which means Dems have an opening.
LikeLike
bethree5,
I also grew up in a blue collar part of the country that is now Trumpland.
But are you really saying they were partisan Democrats before Trump? Doesn’t seem like white working class folks have been reliable democratic voters for a while. Trump got more than other Republicans, but they had been moving toward the party already.
Or perhaps those voters slowly moved away from both parties for a while. And then as the Republicans started making appeals to white supremacy, they made more inroads.
I am going to go out on a limb now and say that if the racist and xenophobic dog whistles a Republican candidate uses don’t bother a voter, that speaks for itself.
I believe that one reason that the college educated voters in affluent suburbs started voting Democrat was that a lot of educated voters were turned off by racist call outs of Republicans. You might say those voters voted against their economic interests for Democrats because of what the Republican party had become. But when voters are voting against their economic interests for the party that is clearly okay with white supremacy, that does suggest that whether they acknowledge it or not, that message has a lot of appeal.
But I do acknowledge that it could be that they also like the “lazy union worker” message of the Republicans. And how do the democrats attract votes if working class white folks respond to the Republicans’ anti-union messaging, and despise the Democrats for being too union-friendly? Because if that is true, I can imagine a whole bunch of overhyped pundits telling Democrats they need to disavow unions to attract their vote and prove they aren’t in their pocket.
LikeLike
AMEN, retired teacher.
Your parents were indeed wise. When you graduated from college, you weren’t hampered with HUGE DEBT.
Huge college debts is another big problem.
I am glad I graduated debt-free.
Tuition for a full-time student at the University of Hawai’i when I attended school cost $116.25 and this included student fees. I know this was a long time ago, but sheez … the cost of higher ed is obscene these DAZE.
I truly FEEL for those facing HUGE student loans when they graduate from college.
LikeLike
College was affordable before states cut funding to public universities.
LikeLike
Graduating debt-free today, for most, is a fantasy—it’s obsolete. We managed it for our kids [2005-2011] only because I had an inheritance from a tightwad engr grandfather with only one child: he had stock options in the 20thc heyday of patriarchal corporations– and saved every penny for his 4 grandchildren. And it still wasn’t a smooth ride: 2008 collapse ate up 40% of it, & we had to refinance house to put youngest through soph-sr yrs. All three attended small modest priv colleges which kept their costs in line with competing state colleges—and one child lived at home/ commuted for two years. Our kids reported they knew no one among college friends in same position.
Among their local [K12] cohort we know precisely three who pulled something like this off. Two attended the local community college on their parents’ dime, then headed for Prague, where they supported themselves as English tutors while learning Czech, & eventually got their bachelor’s degrees there. The third struggled academically in a modestly-priced state college for two years, then traveled to Germany to live with relatives—became an English instructor, finished bachelor’s there.
LikeLike
Maurice Cunningham is quoted in a new article posted at Daily Beast, 11-8-2021, written by Roger Sollenberger. The article highlights how the same wealth-backed groups and individuals who attack public education are driving the CRT backlash. The names that Sollenberger lists are familiar.
LikeLike
Sollenberger explains to readers that there are those who rely on Great Replacement Theory as a casus belli for white nationalism. The N.Z. killer of 51 people justified his actions with the Theory as did the killer in El Paso, 21 deaths.
LikeLike
I am reminded of the plight of truck drivers in America today. They are not making ends meet. Some of the worst jobs are driving containers from the port to a warehouse. The Motor Carrier Act of 1980, passed by President Jimmy Carter, slashed the cost of moving goods by truck.
It also eroded one of America’s great blue-collar jobs: truck driving.
A truck driver’s salary has decreased by as much as half since deregulation.
https://www.businessinsider.com/truck-driver-pay-motor-carrier-act-retail-2020-7
LikeLike
My son-in-law has a class B commercial license. He owns and operates his own dump truck. With the costs for maintenance, insurance, diesel and tires, he makes a living, but not as much as he had hoped. With the supply chain problems he thinks he can do better if he gets his Class A license, and he already has an offer to drive a route between El Paso and Dallas. With the shortage of drivers, the US is also reducing restrictions on drivers from Mexico. His Mexican uncle plans to work with him. Again the expenses are his responsibility. I hope it works out the way he believes it can.
LikeLike
These port truckers — many of them poor immigrants who speak little English — are responsible for moving almost half of the nation’s container imports out of Los Angeles’ ports. They don’t deliver goods to stores. Instead they drive them short distances to warehouses and rail yards, one small step on their journey to a store near you.
A yearlong investigation by the USA TODAY Network found that port trucking companies in southern California have spent the past decade forcing drivers to finance their own trucks by taking on debt they could not afford. Companies then used that debt as leverage to extract forced labor and trap drivers in jobs that left them destitute.
If a driver quit, the company seized his truck and kept everything he had paid towards owning it.
https://www.usatoday.com/pages/interactives/news/rigged-forced-into-debt-worked-past-exhaustion-left-with-nothing/
LikeLike
I can offer zero, but relaying something I heard on the CSPAN a.m. call-in show last week. A caller reported that her husband’s trucking career– involving hauls from CA ports—is at a standstill because of govt regs making it difficult for truckers to qualify for getting into the ports?? She herself is a trucking ‘middleman’/ broker laid off & looking for work, which she says is sparse—because so little is moving… Any idea what all that means?
LikeLike
If capitalism really worked as advertised (it doesn’t), the fact that there is a shortage of truckers should mean that people who can drive a truck can charge of bucketful of money. But from these stories, it doesn’t seem that it works that way.
LikeLike
I had the privilege of working with Dr Gamberg when he was an elementary teacher in our small north fork school and I was his assigned reading specialist. He was an enthusiastic and passionate teacher. His child centered and messy (because kids are messy learners!) classroom was always filled with hands-on projects. We were given full autonomy and respect from our principal to collaborate and design plans on how best to help his struggling readers. I loved working with him and supporting his students in a way that respected his teaching style and curriculum. That, I believe, is the best kind of professional collaboration and our shared students made significant gains. Wonderful memories!
LikeLike
A lovely tribute!
LikeLike
Thank you.
LikeLike
David Gamberg should have an audience with Congress.
LikeLike
Absolutely!
LikeLike
LikeLike
LikeLike
LikeLike