Everyone knows how to end the pandemic: mandate vaccinations for everyone over the age of 2. When vaccines are available for children under 2, vaccinate them too. Almost everyone is vaccinated against other infectious diseases, like smallpox, mumps, and measles. Many schools will not admit new students who are unvaccinated. Why make an exception for the deadly coronavirus?
But for purely political reasons, this will not happen. Libertarians, Trumpers, and others will refuse to be vaccinated, insisting that the government can’t force them to protect themselves and the lives of their families, friends, and communities. Conspiracy theorists would spin crazy ideas about secret plots, and those opposed would go to court to prevent being vaccinated involuntarily.
And this resistance to life-saving vaccines will make it impossible to end the pandemic. At this point, most new cases and deaths occur among the unvaccinated. The anti-vaxxers will not accept direction. And they might be convinced if members of their families die. But there are ways to persuade them, like barring them from public transportation, federal jobs, and federal benefits
NYC Mayor De Blasio just approved a regulation requiring all 300,000 municipal workers, including teachers and police, to be vaccinated or to take a weekly test to prove they are not infected. WhY not require them all to be vaccinated?
Dr. Leana Wen wrote this opinion article for the Washington Post. She is a public health specialist.
With coronavirus infections climbing throughout the country and the pandemic worsening once more, the Biden administration needs to strongly urge a return of covid-19 restrictions.
The United States is on a very different trajectory now than it was back in May, when the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued guidance that fully vaccinated people no longer needed to wear masks. Even then, when cases were trending downward, many of us in public health were alarmed that the CDC’s recommendations would herald the precipitous and premature end of indoor mask mandates.
We were right. The CDC’s honor system didn’t work. The unvaccinated took off their masks, too; not enough people were vaccinated to be a backstop against further surges; and infections began to soar.
Compared with two weeks ago, daily coronavirus infections in the United States have climbed 145 percent. The most contagious form of SARS-CoV-2 yet, the delta variant, accounts for the majority of new infections. Vaccinated people are still well-protected from becoming severely ill, but reports abound of breakthrough infections. Because the CDC has inexplicably stopped tracking mild infections among the vaccinated, however, we don’t know how frequently these occur. In addition, because those infected with the delta variant appear to have a viral load that’s 1,000 times higher than that of those infected with the original strains, it’s an open question as to whether vaccinated people who contract the variant can infect their unvaccinated close contacts.
It’s time for the CDC to issue new guidance that takes into account these emerging concerns. It can reiterate that vaccination is safe and effective by stating that the vaccinated are safe around others who are also fully vaccinated. In settings where everyone is known to have immunity, no additional restrictions are needed.
However, if vaccinated individuals are around those who remain unvaccinated, the unvaccinated could pose a risk to the vaccinated, particularly those who live at home with young children or immunocompromised family members. So the CDC needs to state, as it should have in May, that unless there is a way to distinguish between the vaccinated and unvaccinated, indoor mask requirements should be reinstated. Los Angeles County has issued such a mandate. The federal government should urge other jurisdictions to follow suit.
This is particularly urgent in areas with escalating outbreaks. Covid-19 hospitalizations in southwest Missouri have already surpassed the winter peak there. Multiple hospitals in Arkansas are full, with doctors treating younger, and sicker, patients, including tweens. In these low-vaccination areas, the pre-vaccine tools of masks, distancing and avoiding indoor gatherings need to be deployed again to stem the surge.
Unfortunately, the areas with the lowest vaccination rates are also the ones least likely to implement mask mandates. Still, leadership from the Biden administration can make a difference. There are many businesses and local jurisdictions that look to the federal government for direction. Those that dropped mask mandates after the CDC’s change in tone could be convinced to reinstitute them.
The federal government could also use this opportunity to — finally — incentivize vaccination. It could say that areas with high vaccine uptake do not need to reimplement mask mandates, and mandate vaccination on planes and trains and in federal buildings. And it can finally get behind a vaccine verification system that would allow restaurants, gyms, workplaces and universities to create safe, maskless environments where everyone is vaccinated.
Lack of strong federal leadership impedes the ability of local jurisdictions to implement policies that protect their residents. In Los Angeles County, the sheriff stated that he would not enforce the new mask mandate, calling the order “not backed by science” because it conflicted with the CDC guidelines. This is a clear demonstration of how local health departments rely on the political cover provided by the CDC to enact unpopular but necessary actions.
A more cautious approach from the CDC would also realign the entity with leading health-care organizations. On Monday, the American Academy of Pediatrics issued new recommendations for schools that emphasized universal masking for everyone 2 and older. Notably, and in direct contradiction to the CDC, it stated that even vaccinated individuals should be masked in the classroom. These pediatricians recognize the reality on the ground: Without proof of vaccination, the unvaccinated have been behaving as if they were vaccinated, which has disincentivized them from getting inoculated and contributed to the surges we are now seeing.
The Biden administration has done many things right during the pandemic, but it made a grave error with its premature return to normalcy. It must hit reset and issue new guidance that addresses the escalating infections, waning interest in vaccination and unknowns of the delta variant. If it doesn’t, we could well be on our way to another national surge — and one that was entirely foreseen and entirely preventable.
Too bad that they can’t spray areas with an inhalable vaccine like they do when they want to get rid of an outbreak of insects like mosquitoes.
Then the anti-vaxxers would have to buy hazmat suits and live inside of them 2/47 to avoid the spray.
You have an ally on this issue from a prominent writer for National Review. That publication doesn’t fit the stereotype that this blog paints of it. NR is definitely conservative, but they print dissenting opinions among their writers and there is no rigid orthodoxy that is enforced; several of their writers refused to support Trump in 2020, and the ones who did only did so to oppose the hard Left turn of the Democrats. The New Republic in its best days took a similar approach,but TNR unfortunately is now purely partisan Left.
https://www.nationalreview.com/the-tuesday/vaccination-agitation/
“the ones who did only did so to oppose the hard Left turn of the Democrats”
Nothing proves how far right you are than your view that Joe Biden is “far left” because what you just demonstrated is that you consider FDR,Truman, and LBJ as “far left” while you believes that the National Review writers who reject FDR/Truman style policies because they prefer the John Birch Society Republicans are justified. William F. Buckley would have been cast out of the today’s John Birch Society Republicans for pointing out that a naked Trump was not wearing fabulous clothes as all Republicans are now required to do as good little “John Birchers”. Given that a requirement for being a Republican is now a willingness to lie and say whatever Trump says is the gospel truth – including fighting to end democracy – it’s hard to take you seriously.
The fact that some writers at the National Review realized that their loved ones’ chances of dying are greatly increasing because the Republican party is more focused on politicizing and lying about the pandemic than actually trying to fight it has no relation to whether those National Review writers embrace the John Birch Society Republicans or not.
I realize that the National Review did try desperately to prevent Medicare and Social Security because they believed that providing health insurance for senior citizens was a “hard left turn”. That is certainly the belief that the National Review was founded on — Medicare and Social Security are evil and “hard left” and they must be ended. You should go post and tell people how if they vote Republican, they can end those “far left” policies you and the National Review hate so much.
Love this line from NR piece: “The Right, which has embraced theatrical self-harm as a kind of weird performative political ritual” 😀 There’s some very good reasoning in there about the inconsistency of libertarian & conservative position on this v-a-v history & their own principles. And some of them might just listen, since it’s in the NR.
There are so many people out there who believe that the plague is a hoax or that it is exaggerated. They don’t want their supposed “freedoms” impinged upon in any way, shape or form. Is driving on the right side of the road and obeying traffic signs and signals an assault on your freedom? According to the logic of some of these plague-deniers, we should be able to drive anywhere, anytime at what ever speed we want, total freedom? The same folks won’t get vaccinated because they don’t trust the vaccines’ efficacy or they think it’s some kind of big government plot. It’s a case of Rand Paulism on steroids.
I was so happy to see Dr. Fauci stand up in Congress to irrational bully, Rand Paul. Dr. Fauci’s family have been targeted by the radical right. Enough of tolerating the irrational and lethal right! Their lies have killed enough people. Conservatives should stop conflating politics with public health. i was pleased to see Gov. Ivey urging Alabamans to get the vaccine. We won’t see DeSantis making a plea like that.
I poste a link to this at OEN. https://www.opednews.com/Quicklink/How-to-End-the-Pandemic-b-in-Best_Web_OpEds-Anti-vaxxers_Conspiracy_Coronavirus_Death-210727-835.html
I added this comment. Each theme in the comment has embedded links if you go there.
The three themes What helps move people from vaccine skeptical to vaccinated? The Kaiser polls point to three main themes.(The themes apply to both the 23 percent of people who said they would not get a shot, as well as to the 28 percent who described their attitude in January as “wait and see.” About half of the “wait and see” group has since gotten a shot.)
Seeing that millions of other Americans have been safely vaccinated .A poll of vaccine skeptics by Echelon Insights, a Republican firm, points to a similar conclusion. One of the most persuasive messages, the skeptics said, was hearing that people have been getting the vaccine for months and it is “working very well without any major issues.”
Hearing pro-vaccine messages from doctors, friends and relatives. For many people who got vaccinated, messages from politicians, national experts and the mass media were persuasive. But many other Americans especially those without a college degree don’t trust mainstream institutions. For them, hearing directly from people they know can have a bigger impact.
“Hearing from experts,” as Mollyann Brodie, who oversees the Kaiser polls, told me, “isn’t the same as watching those around you or in your house actually go through the vaccination process.”
Learning that not being vaccinated will prevent people from doing some things. There is now a roiling debate over vaccine mandates, with some hospitals, colleges, cruise-ship companies and others implementing them and some state legislators trying to ban mandates. The Kaiser poll suggests that these requirements can influence a meaningful number of skeptics to get shots, sometimes just for logistical reasons.
“Libertarians, Trumpers, and others will refuse to be vaccinated. . .”
I simply call them freedumbshitheads.
Uh, children under 12 are not yet eligible for the vaccine. How about if we finish clinical trials before we decide that the vaccine is safe for them?
Of the 600,000-plus people in the U.S. who have died from or with coronavirus since the start of the pandemic, about 340 have been under the age of 17.
Yeah, I see. Who cares if 340 children die unnecessarily.
I didn’t say nobody should care, Bob, so that’s not an honest counter-argument. More children died from the flu in the 2018-2019 flu season. That’s too many, which is why (FDA approved) flu vaccines for children are worthwhile, just like (FDA approved) Covid vaccines for children will be worthwhile. But it’s not a crisis for children.
Children are vectors of the disease. This is a significant issue.
This is a more honest argument, although I think it’s overstated given that every adult who wants to be vaccinated can be vaccinated now.
Yeah, Darwin Awards for those who aren’t.
FLERP!,
Have you read how many hundreds of children have died in Indonesia recently because of COVID? It’s not the flu.
The reason that “only” 600,000 plus people and 340 children died in this country is the efforts by some Americans to not spread it so that our health care system does not become overwhelmed.
People who have no medical reason not to get the vaccine should be last in line for ventilators, oxygen, and hospital beds, and sent from hospitals as soon as any child gets sick.
Covid fatalities among people under age 18 have been extremely rare from the get-go. That has always been clear from the data, even from the months when the CDC and WHO were recommending that people not wear masks, even in areas that never shut down and where masking was not widely adopted. I wouldn’t touch anecdotal accounts of Indonesian child fatalities in news stories with a ten-foot pole. If you have official data on child fatalities from Covid from Indonesia, just post it.
FLERP!
A few months back you had a concern about having your child complete the vaccine because of the inflammatory heart side effects. Several studies have shown that the disease in asymptomatic younger patients caused vascular inflammation in numbers far in excess to the vaccine.
What are the long term effects on a young seemingly asymptomatic child .
I don’t know, Joel. We went ahead with the second dose, despite my concern. I was not happy that the main reason we went forward with the second dose was that it would simplify his life administratively, rather than a clear sense of safety.
It’s not just deaths. It’s the long Covid. I have 2 sixteen year old former students, both (now former) runners, who got Covid in January. They are both still suffering from such bad symptoms that they can’t go upstairs without inhalers and can no longer run. And there are other young people (including young children) who have all sorts of long Covid problems that may impact their entire lives. We need to be thinking about kids who can’t be vaccinated. We NEED TO GET VACCINATED AND KERP WEARING MASKS.
Flu has long-term impacts for many people, too.
FLERP
Flu has long term impacts and kills people . Seriously !
Yes it does but I am betting you know no one who either died of the flu or had long term impacts . Or at least I don’t and I wont burden you with the list of 9 people I know(4) or know of (5)who died of covid . Or the 2 long haulers.
By the way don’t look for the headline in the tabloids murder down 67 % vs 20 in NYC. last week. Down 46% the last 28 days. Down 8 weeks out of the last 9 since the City opened up in May. .
Willie Horton is alive and well.
I just posted the total U.S. fatalities under age 18 for Covid. It’s in the range for a bad flu year. The data are what they are, everybody knows it by now, and there’s no need to belabor it. As for long Covid, I’m not aware of any generally accepted statistics comparing its incidence in children to that of other respiratory illnesses.
Also, yes, the homicide data is encouraging citywide for the last month or so. Hopefully it sticks and the city doesn’t shut down again.
FLERP!,
You keep posting all kinds of reasons why COVID isn’t dangerous for kids, every time people talk about masking or vaccine requirements.
Are you anti ALL vaccine mandates for children to attend school (how many children died of measles this year, FLERP!?) or do you pick and choose?
Which vaccine mandates (if any) for children to attend school do you support, FLERP!?
How many unvaccinated Orthodox Jewish school aged children died in the last measles outbreak? What number is “too low” which means vaccines should no longer be mandated for school children?
Mandating vaccinations here in the US will do nothing for the billions in the world who are not lucky enough to live in the countries with widespread vaccine availability. There are still places where very few (if any) people have received a vaccination, not because they are anti bad, but because there are NO vaccinations available to them.
It’s a cliche, but until everyone is safe, no one is safe.
And people like German “leader” Angela Merkel who are standing in the way of temporary patent waivers that would allow perfectly capable pharmaceutical companies in developing nations to produce the vaccines should be told in no uncertain terms to get the hell out of the way. Merkel is looking more like Trump every day that she continues her adamant opposition, which is almost certainly based on monetary concerns rather than human ones.
Not just my opinion. Among others, the group Doctors without Borders just called for an end to opposition to patent waivers by countries like Germany, Canada and UK
SomeDAM Poet
Dean Baker has been screaming for open source research in medicine for years . Since March of 2020 Baker was calling for patent protection to be dropped. Especially for a publicly financed Vaccine Platform
https://www.salon.com/2020/03/07/patents-are-slowing-the-development-of-a-coronavirus-vaccine_partner/
The US government already owns the patent (10,960,070) on a key element of both the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA vaccines: spike protein technology that was developed by Graham et al at NIH
Pfizer has obtained a license from the US government, but Moderna has not and is currently in violation of the US government patent, which means legally, they could potentially be on the hook for all the profits that they have made and might make in the future off the vaccine.
The US government is currently holding all the high cards and if Biden wanted to he could tell Moderna that either they share the recipe for producing the vaccine with pharmaceutical companies in Africa and elsewhere that could make the vaccines for their own populations OR, that Moderna face the prospect that they will not make a single dime on their vaccine.
Researchers at NYU have proposed that the US government “use the threat of litigation of the ‘070 patent to bring Moderna back to the negotiation table and convince Moderna to share its own patents, trade secrets, and other intellectual property on [its vaccine] with the U.S. government and with vaccine manufacturers around the world.”
The US public effectively owns the rights to the Moderna vaccine at this point and Biden should make that clear to the CEO and members of the board of Moderna.
Antivax” not ” anti bad”
That was a correction to autocorrect “correction” in a comment that went into moderation.
People who refuse to get vaccinated do not put only themselves at risk. They prolong the period in which this disease is rampant and is mutating. These mutations might very well result in variants that are resistant to current vaccines. So, those people are putting us ALL at risk.
This fact means that we have every right to require that they be vaccinating a) before returning to our colleges, high schools, and middle schools; before they go back to workplaces; and so on.
And given that kids can be asymptomatic vectors for this disease, it’s important, if they are all going to be forced to go back to in-person school, that they all be required to wear N95 or equivalent masks.
Utah has banned mask mandates for schools. The only ones that can change that are the Legislature. Not even health departments. It’s disgusting, and I know that Utah isn’t the only state being so stupid.
How is Utah doing relative to other states in terms of Covid deaths?
Ohio. Flor-uh-duh under Trump Mini-Me DeSatan, ofc.
Your first sentence is more pertinent then you think. Last night Fauci explained that vaccinated break through patients have high levels of virus in their Nasopharynx. The vaccine causing immune responses that prevent the virus from migrating to the lungs and causing severe illness . Infected asymptomatic children share that dynamic with breakthrough patients . They are “vectors for disease . ”
As for an N95 mask I was hoping to pack them away by now.
The CDC used to e a respected scientific organization. For several years now, it has conducted science by asking whatever public official is in charge, first, what he wants the science to say.
Toadying is not science.
Yes, toadying is the correct term.
I expected it from #45’s CDC; Mr. Biden’s CDC has been equally disappointing, especially in their rush to bring back full-time, in-school instruction. The mask mandate was lifted too soon. In my backwater county, vaccination rates hover around 35 percent; mask-wearing hovers around 5 percent.
Politics and the pressure to push people back into profit generation over public health will only delay the day we can say COVID is conquered (or corralled). I think the CDC downplayed human nature and the resistance to public health measures. The “honor system” is not working.
What would have been far better, IMHO, was using COVID relief funds to upgrade HVAC systems in schools. That, and not summer school, should have been the priority so that we could reduce transmission of COVID and other pathogens.
yup
“vaccination rates hover around 35 percent; mask-wearing hovers around 5 percent.”
Mirrors my community, I fear. The good news? A lot of these folks do not get out much. Maybe that will help suppress the disease a bit. We can always hope.
I hope they stay indoors nonstop.
Unvaccinated 8-year-olds, too.
The CDC just changed their mask recommendation again, claiming “new science” : that people who are vaccinated can contract and spread the delta variant.
This new science is worrisome and unfortunately warrants an update to our recommendation. It is concerning enough that we feel like we have to act.”
—Dr. Rochelle Walensky, CDC
Only it’s not “new science” by a long shot.
Israel has been reporting relatively low effectiveness of the Pfizer vaccine against simply contracting the delta variant for over a month now. They were saying 64% effectiveness and are now (just this week) saying only 39% effectiveness.
In fact, Fauci was asked a couple weeks ago specifically about the Israeli studies and immediately changed the subject to the effectiveness of the vaccine against more severe illness and hospitalization.
If people are losing faith in the CDC, there is good reason. Playing the red light/green light game with masks is not the way you inspire confidence. And to make it even worse, they are pretending that they are responding to “new science”.
Gee, Mr. President. What would you like for the CDC to be saying today. Oh. OK. Well, then I guess that’s what “the new science says.” Wink wink. Nudge nudge.
Should rename themselves the “Centers for Displease Control” or maybe just add a hyphen
the “Centers for Dis-ease Control”
Centers for Dis-ease Control
The Centers for Dis-ease Control
Are serving presidents
Their penchant to appease them all
Is setting precedents
On a completely different note, a messages to Simone Biles:
Ms. Biles, you are freaking awesome. You are a great hero. Thank you for taking care and stepping back when you needed to. Blessings on you. This reduces not at all your status in all our minds. Rather, it increases it. Strength, perseverance, grace, AND intelligence. Wow. Much love to you and yours.
By stepping back when you need to, you provide, again, a role model to other young women.
Biles also had to deal with that pervert of a doctor some years ago. She might be a good candidate to become a teacher. At least she would already be used to the hassle factor.
High-level gymastics is probably the most punishing and predatory of all youth sports.
Dr. Ravitch, it’s interesting how you can articulate on the “secret plot” of billionaires and those with “old money” ties when it comes to subverting democracy, human rights and ethics but can’t make the same connection when it comes to vaccines and mainstream medicine. I understand that as an elderly person there are fears with covid-19 but the truth is vaccinations have always been controversial because they involve adding foreign substances to the body, which has a potency to kill and maim such as aluminum, mercury and fetal bovine serum—all used to enhance the immune response and act as a growth medium for virus parts…
The same corporate criminals that you denounce in your critique of the current educational landscape are the same folks investing in vaccines and modern medicine. If these companies, think-tanks, and individuals corrupted the American education system what makes you think they have not done the same to the American healthcare industry?? And these characters are sadistic—they have no apathy, no regard for human life and are increasingly showing their angst towards religion…
Pfizer and Moderna for instance, have paid out billions of dollars for marketing fraud—bribing doctors and lying about what’s in their products… J&J was found guilty for knowingly adding a carcinogen to their powder, which women used on their bodies—even their private parts and ended up getting ovarian cancer… Afterwards, J&J lawyers blamed the victims and assumed no responsibility for their death or suffering… Bill Gates administered vaccines to women overseas who subsequently developed conditions with their reproductive system and there is much, much more to reveal… If we’re going to speak on the corrupt individuals devaluing our education system, we ought to also highlight the same individuals that are destroying other aspects of society such as healthcare and the environment.
Rob, I had two shots of the Moderna vaccine. If a booster is needed, I’ll be first in line to take it. Today, most of those who are hospitalized and those who are dying are unvaccinated. My shots were free, by the way.
Dr. Ravitch- that’s your personal choice and I don’t shame or intimidate you because of it. Neither should the unvaccinated be shamed, intimidated, coerced or forced because of their choice not to take the vaccine… I should point out as well that in the 1980s the Supreme Court ruled that vaccines are “unavoidably unsafe” and vaccine companies hold the peculiar distinction of not being legally liable if someone dies or get injured from their product… Anyone gets sick or die from a vaccine and it is almost impossible to seek compensation or justice…
We know that mainstream media content today is very narrowly focused and shortsighted with all the mega-mergers and only a handful of transnational corporations controlling what we hear and see… I’d like to look into the research for myself and what statistical measures are being used to assert that those who are dying and hospitalized are mostly the vaccinated. There are an increasingly number of news stories coming out of folks who got the 2 vaccines and still got covid– some died, some suffered terrible side effects. I’ll submit these resources but I have more:
https://www.greenmedinfo.com/blog/how-accurate-claim-nearly-all-covid-deaths-are-among-unvaccinated
https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/hooman-noorchashm-immunologist-wsj-editorial-board-retract-lie-covid-immunity/
https://odysee.com/@sayerji:7/Genome-Variant-Pres-7-14-21:9
meant to say “when it comes to subverting democracy, human rights and ethics in education…”
“Everyone knows how to end the pandemic: mandate vaccinations for everyone over the age of 2. When vaccines are available for children under 2, vaccinate them too. Almost everyone is vaccinated against other infectious diseases, like smallpox, mumps, and measles. Many schools will not admit new students who are unvaccinated. Why make an exception for the deadly coronavirus?”
Diane, you’re arguing here in effect that every student below the age of 12 (not to mention all unvaccinated students over 12) should have remote school. Do you really believe that?
I want children in face-to-face contact with teachers, and I want everyone to be vaccinated.
Wanting things is the easiest thing I’m aware of. But everyone will not not be vaccinated this fall. Should unvaccinated children be allowed to attend school?
If proof of vaccination is required to enter school as routinely as proof of same for other contagious diseases, every parent will make sure their child is vaccinated.
I believe you’re very wrong about that. And in the meantime, remember that vaccinations are not available for children under 12. So the position that unvaccinated students should not attend school is in effect a position that young children should not attend school until vaccines are available.
Children over 2 will have vaccines by November, maybe sooner.
FLERP!,
Should unvaccinated students 12 and over be allowed in school?
Don’t schools have vaccination requirements already? There are health and religious exemptions, but unless I missed something, certain vaccinations have always been required and some haven’t.
Should the COVID vaccine be required for 12 and over or not required?
I remember people being pretty angry at de Blasio for not acting sooner when Orthodox Jewish communities were vectors for measles and (earlier) mumps because they were anti-vac.
What was your opinion on that, FLERP!?
Back in 2019 there was a big measles outbreak. In Rockland County, city officials barred all children under 18 who weren’t vaccinated for measles from public places for 30 days.
Back in the day this wasn’t politicized the way it is now. And that politicization is entirely the fault of the Republicans. Entirely.
In my district, which thanks to the strong teachers union has been the safest in the country, students and teachers can either get vaccinated once, or tested every week.
I take that back. Due to changing conditions, everyone in L.A. will have to be tested weekly, vaccinated or not.
There is no reset button. If I were to tell my students in September that we would have daily pizza parties instead of writing essays, simply “being careful” about how we eat the pizza, I would not be able to get the kids back to work in October. I would simply lose the class. The unvaccinated have shown themselves to be unreachable, and now the vaccinated are unwilling to give up their new freedoms too. We’re lost.
What if your students stayed at home for an entire year, logging onto Zoom when they felt like it or when they were able to?
It would not be possible to return to normal with a snap of my fingers in the spring. Fortunately for all the students, education actually does have a reset button called summer vacation. We get a fresh start every fall. The first day of school is always exciting, a little frightening but exciting, especially this year. Unfortunately, the virus didn’t take a vacation like schools did.
It makes me think. Every student who comes to my class on the first day of school carries a satchel of past experiences that affects how they interact with my class. Most often, my students have parents and have previously had teachers who used carrots and sticks to make the students conform in an assimilationist manner. It takes some time for them to understand that my classroom is a place where they have more agency, that it’s all carrots and no sticks, that they are allowed to be critical thinkers, and that they can enjoy reading and writing in their own style and use some creativity. Students who failed English in 7th grade sometimes earn ‘A’s in my 8th grade English class.
It’s important to remember that education is not a race, and the past does not completely dictate your future. If a student missed a year of school because of a pandemic, illness, injury, family death, divorce, or other traumatic experience, the student’s academic growth and development was paused, not stopped.
Maybe you’re right, but this feels like a rationalization to me.
It is a firmly held belief of mine, that when I am teaching, I am opening some doors for my students, but not placing them on a set life trajectory. That’s the problem with the NCLB/ESSA and especially VAM. So-called outcomes do not predict futures. Getting straight As though 9th grade didn’t mean I was going to get an A in 10th grade honors chemistry. We have strengths and weaknesses, ups and downs. Success in life takes, yes, skill and effort, but also timing and good fortune.
And masks and jabs, for now.
We are going about this all wrong . Unfortunately there are several different cohorts of un vaccinated. The Trumpanzee is the easiest to deal with. Their motivation is owning the libs. Democrats could go on air thanking them for neutralizing voter disenfranchisement and watch them line up in mass at the CVS or Walmart for a shot .
Or call the shot the Trump Vaccine. Which it is.
dianeravitch
Contrary to the Morning Joe crowd; the Pfizer Vaccine applied for testing approval in Germany on April 5 . The first shots went into arms in Germany April 29th and I believe the US on May 5th. Operation Warp Speed was announced on May 15 . So the vaccine, the product of near 2 decades of NIH funding that Republicans seek to cut, was in arms before Warp Speed. Moderna built on the same Platform.
The biggest impediment to vaccine research is the lack of the virus and volunteers willing to take a vaccine. Covid was very cooperative on both counts. Plenty of infections and volunteers. Warp speed did guarantee the purchase of produced vaccine after the preliminary results were in. Taking the risk out of producing vaccine before approval. Germany gave 500million to build production facilities in Germany.
Reblogged this on What's Gneiss for Education.
The dark forces of disinformation online and on Facebook and Twitter are so influential and it’s almost brainwashing a segment of the population. They are now paying influencers to spread false information about vaccines:
Important to watch:
https://www.msnbc.com/morning-joe/watch/why-disinformation-online-is-easy-to-produce-and-tough-to-regulate-117459525522
Trolling as a service is lucrative.
Trolling For Dollars
Trolling as a service
Pays a pretty penny
Underneath the surface
Trolling is aplenty
Trolls, certain politicians and media personalities
cater to the 1 percent.
By stirring the pot
the fortunes of the rich
they help augment.
Who cares about democracy
When you are paid
to support a plutocracy.
Stopping by blogs on a trolly Evening” (with apologies to Robert Frost)
Whose trolls these are
I think I know
His house is in Medina though
He will not see me lurking here
To watch his trolls control the show
His comment whores would think it queer
To write without a dollar near
Between the shimmer and the sheen
The propaganda’s thick round here
His trolls are worst we’ve ever seen
And rude and crude and really mean
They only ever act like creep
The biggest creep that’s ever been
The trolls are ugly, dark and deep
And they have promi$e$ to keep
And blogs to troll before they sleep
And blogs to troll before they sleep
I laughed out loud when I saw the Robert Frost title in my email. This is one of my fav’s. Bravo SDP!!
I think the tricky part is how to reconcile mask mandate with vaccination. Vaccines are now universally available, and roughly 1 out of 2 people are fully vaccinated(although it varies from states to states). I believe the Biden administration has so far done a decent job to provide vaccines to mitigate covid spikes and flatten the curve, and I don’t doubt the CDC’s ability to provide sound directions and advice to American people for this purpose. However, I am also worried about the way the medical authorities communicate their message–some of those coming from CDC director are rather confusing that it could mislead the public(such as unfounded fears about covid variants, side effects of vaccination).
Right now, people around the world are once again getting infected and reinfected due to the rise of delta covid variant (and possibly Lambda variant, in the near future?). With incoming reports of people who got tested positive again after vaccination(including those who got two shots), the CDC chimed in. That’s when the things have got complicated.
What does it mean by “getting normalized by vaccination?” If the vaccination is the means to getting back to normal life, then, what’s the point in urging people who get fully vaccinated to wear masks for open-ended period? How can we see the line between the two? How can the CDC’s guidance convince us which area/district is safe for us to travel without masks, and which are/district is not? These are the questions that need to be addressed and scrutinized. Unlike Asia, many people in the west don’t have a custom of wearing masks in particular season–such as flu, you know.
I know there are always anti-vaccinators and conspiracists who love to spread misinformation and fear for fun, but the mainstream media are also responsible for having created a chaotic situation about the covid updates.