Charles Lane explains one of Trump’s basic character flaw: he lacks decency. One of the ceremonial roles of the President is to show compassion and decency in times of trouble. Think of Reagan when the Challenger Space Shuttle exploded, killing all aboard as the nation watched. Think Bill Clinton after the Oklahoma City terrorist bombing. Think Obama after the Newtown massacre. They mourned with the nation and helped us through the tragedy. One thing Trump has been unable to do is to express empathy for those who suffer. To him, they are losers or statistics. 120,000 people have died during the pandemic, more will die, and he can’t find it in him to express concern or caring.
Charles Lane wrote in the Washington Post:
The coronavirus has rekindled interest in “The Plague,” Albert Camus’s haunting and, now, eerily relevant 1947 novel about a fictional fatal epidemic in what was then a French colony in North Africa.
As thousands die and thousands more suffer deprivation and isolation under quarantine, the book’s protagonist, a doctor, explains why he carries on his work: “There’s no question of heroism in all this. It’s a matter of common decency. That’s an idea which may make some people smile, but the only means of fighting a plague is — common decency.”
Which brings us to President Trump, and his response to the coronavirus, from his initial belated steps to his rambling attacks on the media at White House briefings to his bizarre remark (an attempt at humor, his staff later said) at Saturday’s rally in Tulsa: Increased testing for the virus is “a double-edged sword” — useful for public health but bad for public relations — so “I said to my people, ‘Slow the testing down, please.
In all of it, the missing factor has been decency, which the Cambridge Dictionary defines as “behavior that is good, moral and acceptable in society,” and which, throughout most of previous American political history, presidents have at least pretended to model.
Trump, by contrast, has transgressed his way to the top, tapping — it must be acknowledged — the deep alienation of a swath of society that sees validation for long-ignored grievances in his rule-breaking.
Yet the past three months, since the pandemic disrupted American life and claimed more than 118,000 lives, have shown that Trump’s lack of decency is a matter more of personal character than political calculation. The insults, the self-indulgence, the all-but-explicit racist language — this is just how he rolls.
And now it may be yielding diminishing returns. When the coronavirus hit, the American public, even some who previously opposed him, seemed willing to rally behind Trump in the “war” he announced from his Oval Office desk.
From mid-March through mid-April, polls tended to show relatively high approval for his handling of the virus, including several showing more than 50 percent support.
All he had to do to sustain that was to show real concern; to educate himself on the issues; perhaps to turn the other cheek to a hostile press. Camus’s doctor concluded that common decency “consists in doing my job.” Trump could have, too.
It just wasn’t in him. Instead, at an April 23 White House briefing, he mused crazily about the curative power of sunlight and injected disinfectants, then, when the media called him on it, claimed falsely he was being sarcastic — and his ratings on handling the virus began to fall. Now, 55.3 percent disapprove, according to the RealClearPolitics average.
Common decency, or the lack of it, is also Trump’s Achilles’ heel regarding mass protests against systemic racism that began after George Floyd’s death, for which a former Minneapolis police officer has been charged with murder.
Trump has mouthed healing words scripted by speechwriters — even consoled the Floyd family briefly on the phone. When speaking spontaneously, however, whether on Twitter or at the Tulsa rally, he is venomous and violent, even going so far as to suggest a 75-year-old man who suffered a severe head injury at the hands of Buffalo police may have provoked the assault because he was an anarchist spy.
The American people do not want this. Nearly three-quarters of adults surveyed by YouGov in early June opined that the United States is “out of control.” Sixty-four percent said the solution for this is “bringing people together,” while only 36 percent favored Trump’s approach, “law and order.”
Sixty percent of Americans told the YouGov survey they agree with the words of former defense secretary Jim Mattis, that Trump “does not try to unite the American people — does not even pretend to try. Instead, he tries to divide us.”
This rejection of Trump’s message is especially striking given how uneasy the public was about looting and other violence. Excesses of the new movement such as “cancel culture” also frighten moderate potential allies.
Yet people do not rally to the banner of “law and order” when the man raising it is himself an agent of chaos and conflict.
Even among people who voted for Trump in 2016, almost a quarter agreed that Trump is not even pretending to unite the American people. One-tenth considered him “racist.”
And, of course, only 6,000 supporters showed up for Trump’s Tulsa rally in a 19,000-seat venue, an event that brazenly defied both public health concerns and the sensitivities, still raw since a 1921 massacre of black people in that city, of African Americans.
When it comes to Trump’s character, there’s no realistic prospect of change. For America as a whole, fortunately, there is.

Yes, obviously Trump lacks decency.
But what does that say about all of the sycophants that surround him? What does that say about his supporters?
LikeLike
From the article quoting Camus’ protagonist doctor: “There’s no question of heroism in all this. It’s a matter of common decency. That’s an idea which may make some people smile, but the only means of fighting a plague is — common decency.”
Common decency as action emerges in us from the state of our conscience coupled with a sense of genuineness, and the habits its principles set on course in our lives.
But we can no longer take that ideal, as fuzzy as it might be in us, as a given to those who seek power. Often dictators, like Stalin, spoke about conscience (their own and their followers’) and an adherence to the truth as a weakness, as the enemy, and as the things that we must wash out of our character. There is no guarantee of decency–it’s a human choice, and some choose naught.
Further, for the totalitarian, and as evident in Goebbels’ diary, writing about the role of diplomacy in politics:
*”There is no doubt that one does best if one keeps the diplomats uninformed about the background of politics . . . Genuineness in playing an appeasement role is sometimes the most convincing
argument for their political trustworthiness.” *
So genuineness, conscience, decency are not things to BE but to USE, and to throw away when it doesn’t serve our “higher” purpose.
The reliance on “common” decency is particularly crucial in democracies where the power is (still, and in great part) in the people, . . . unless of course we decide to give it away and rid ourselves of it. This reliance on decency is why so many of us were so “appalled,” “troubled,” etc., etc., etc., . . . when Trump went on a bull-in-a-china-shop crusade AGAINST all-things-decent.
With Trump and his followers in Congress, too many Americans were CARELESS about decency. And most of what we expect of our leaders in terms of decency became a mere projection of what was left of our own. (There is a fictional world now about that also.)
The writer is oh-so-right. The term decency is probably not in our founding documents, but it’s what the soul of democracy is made of. For instance, it’s in our thoughts and we see it every day in our medical workers and those who adhere to their oaths to the U. S. Constitution rather than to a dictator’s whims. (“Deep state, and fake news”?)
Without conscious, genuineness, and decency, and as happened in Russia, Germany, and other dictator states, the LCD is the glittering rule, and truth and good as expressed in the concrete have no champions who will or can speak; so the way is clear for the bloodletting to start. CBK
LikeLike
I just read an article about the revival of Stalin-worship in Russia.
The younger generation learns nothing of his crimes.
LikeLike
Diane Yup. At the core of it, we’re all human.
But if there was ever a call for education (to include history and political philosophy, and humanities in general) . . . .
James Carville (in an interview this week) thought we have a excellent chance to change the tide in November. And there will always be some who will work hard (as with Stalin) to rescind their own conscience and its genuineness (referring to the post on Camus’ Plague). But then that’s why human development (education/culture) is so central to ongoing life as we know it. CBK
LikeLike
Diane: My reply was put in moderation. CBK
LikeLike
Oh my, Diane. Stalin was a monster. Aie yie yie.
LikeLike
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/27/giant-new-russian-cathedral-glorifies-putin-stalin-mosaics
LikeLike
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-47975704
LikeLike
From the American History Chanel, Saturday, June 27, 2020, 2:00 p.m.
(Note the date of the speech in terms of Hitler’s betrayal and invasion of Russia. Also from the video, I cannot tell where Stalin stops quoting Hitler and starts speaking for himself.)
“On November 6, 1941, safe inside Moscow’s subway, Stalin gives a speech to the communist government and communist party leaders. He quotes Hitler, . . . after two decades of terror.”
Stalin says on film (translated from Russian):
“We cannot govern without the help of force. All means are justified. When policy demands it, one must lie, betray and even kill. I emancipate man from the humiliating chimera which is called conscience. A new man . . . the red man.”
. . . some history to keep in mind. CBK
LikeLiked by 1 person
Stalin took enormous pleasure in watching others grovel and plead, and he loved playing games to evoke terror in people around him. He killed with abandon and total lack of conscience. Estimates of the number of deaths he was responsible for vary enormously, but the number was vast. He was a sick, murderous, twisted psychopath.
LikeLike
“With Trump and his followers in Congress, too many Americans were CARELESS about decency. And most of what we expect of our leaders in terms of decency became a mere projection of what was left of our own . (There is a fictional world now about that also.)”
Very astute, re: “a projection of what was left of our own [sense of decency]. Our [American public’s] sense of decency in political dialog has been eroding for some time.
Newt Gingrich arguably started the ball rolling. Sans cites, I reached for wikipedia & found “Political scientists have credited Gingrich with playing a key role in undermining political decorum in the US” — & note that among other breaches he led the charge on impeaching Clinton. That would have been my 2nd cite: an impeachment on the grounds of lying under oath/ obstruction of justice, but based on a minor– unsavory but consensual– sexual incident. Granted, Clinton did the indecency, but transforming it into an impeachment was all about lowering the level of political discourse to the toilet.
Are there any major examples during GWB admin? None strike me. The next were under Obama: (1)SC Rep (-R) Joe Wilson yelling “You lie” during Obama’s 2009 healthcare speech to Congress, and (2) Alito voicing “Not true” during Obama’s 2010 State of the Union address.
In between 2010 & present, social media has fomented to the Nth the spread of indecency/ lack of respect/ political decorum modeled by govt leaders among the populace – via tech encouraging instant, ill-considered reactions (tweets, retweets etc ad naus). DJT stepped into that milieu in 2016 & simply opened the floodgates all the way.
LikeLike
This is a dysfunctional phenomenon that may see some correction at the present moment. I may be a cockeyed optimist, but I think I see a teeny trend.
For example, Floyd’s videoed killing was a call to anyone w/a sense of decency; DJT’s initial silence, then law&order response intensified massive black&white street protest, all shepherded via social media.
The covid phenomenon is also a call for decency: protecting each other w/masks et al social-distancing. DJT response has been indecent, anti-social, but public response – again, organized by social media & buttressed by polls has been to push back, in the name of decency, i.e., protecting lives.
LikeLike
bethree5 Many-threads. And then there was Reagan and his extreme ideas about the nary role of government in the life of a democracy . . . extreme insofar as his neo-liberal ideas were the precursors to the loss of REASONABLE regulations, fair taxes, and the return of self-government for the already-powerful among us, which for some means anything I want. The end-run of THAT extreme is manifest now in Barr’s and Trump’s main logos of a president being “above the law.”
Those of us who think half-way past THAT idea, transferred from Wall Street to the White House recognize it as the philosophical platform for changing “president’ to “dictator.” CBK
LikeLike
Science tells us that a perfect vacuum isn’t, as a practical matter, possible. But there is a perfect vacuum of values. Its name is Donald Trump. He lacks
Trump is a Black Hole of Virtuelessness.
He lacks
A Sense of Humor, Ability, Actual feelings of self-worth, Actual patriotism, Actualization, An editor, Appeal, Applicable experience, Articulateness, Attentiveness, Authenticity, Beauty, Care (except for himself), Charity, Cheerfulness, Civility, Clarity, Concern (except for himself), Constraint, Courage, Courtesy, Creativity, Cultivation, Culture, Decency, Decorum, Democratic values, Detachment, Diligence, Dignity, Eloquence, Equanimity, Ethical principles, Excellence in anything, Fellow-feeling, Finesse, Flexibility, Generosity, Grace, Honesty, Honor, Humility, Imagination, Industriousness, Insight, Integrity, Intelligence, Judgment, Kindness, Knowledge, Learning, Literacy, Loveliness, Loyalty, Maturity, Mindfulness, Moderation, Moral sense, Nobility, Patience, Poise, Principle, Propriety, Prudence, Reflectiveness, Reliability, Sanity, Scruples, Shame, Sharpness, Sincerity, Sophistication, Steadiness, Tact, Temperance, Thoughtfulness, Tolerance, Truthfulness, Understanding, Vision, Wisdom, and Wit.
LikeLike
Oops! I forgot to cut a couple lines!!! Sorry about that!!!
LikeLike
The problem here is, Bob, that for the fascist who rescinds his own conscience, these are stars in his cap. CBK
LikeLiked by 1 person
Spot, CBK. And profound. There are people like Trump and Barr who secretly believe that all that matters is power, who is able to eat whom.
LikeLike
Bob Whether or not Trump is all that you say he is (and he is), it still is a question whether he speaks enough to the unrepentant fascist living in the hearts of his followers, and to the fears of others (especially in a democracy), and whether they’ll keep following him over the cliff, or not.
He’s betting on it because he can bet on nothing else. That (I think) he has painted himself into a smaller and smaller corner, that he cannot get out of without destroying the house, just strikes more fear in most of us; but also, I hope, a determination that transcends his own. CBK
LikeLiked by 1 person
Amen to that, CBK!
LikeLike
Trump has no empathy or decency. He has brought out the worst in our country. This pandemic has only served to divide us more. It has also also an opportunity for those that follow this demagogue to see that the man has no substance or capability to lead. We have an opportunity this November to change history. We must vote out the most deficient, duplicitous and dangerous president in modern history. We must also work to vote out his right wing cronies and sycophants.
LikeLike
There is no doubt that the presidential bully pulpit matters. Would we have as many fools refusing to wear masks and social distance if it weren’t for the examples set by Trump and Pence and the Repugnican gubinatorial Trump Mini Mes? Doubtful. And because of these examples, people are dying. Trump has those tens of thousands of deaths on his tiny hands.
LikeLike
The immediate concern should be all who are enabling this demagogue to stay in office and are plotting to continue their power by voter suppression, aided by the courts he has stacked.
Lawyers who are mentioning out loud that Trump will not leave office unless Biden and has an OVERWHELMING victory, plus Democratic control of the Senate, are fully aware that Trump and his cronies are plotting to make the election results “invalid” unless Trump is reelected.
Trump and his money-hungry family and friends know they face civil and possible criminal liability “on the outside,” even with stacked courts. So far Trump is playing doing his political theater, and the last line in several recent performances have invoked GOD (Christian), as if he has bee handpicked to lead the nation. This appeals to his Evangelical base and allows Trump to pull his God-subroutine into every performance where the media is present.
LikeLike
Trump and God. Oh my Lord. What a laugh.
LikeLike
Charles Koch, the CUA board, William Barr, Leonard Leo and the Knights of Columbus aren’t laughing. Laura identified the problem- Trump’s evangelicals.
LikeLike
Two young men are in the news this week, graduates of a $44,000 a year private school. Reportedly, the colleges they planned to attend rescinded their acceptances based on offensive social media posts by the young men. It appears Mr. Giaquinto and Mr. Panza’s affiliations weren’t with evangelical churches.
Truth, sin of omission and decency. hmmm
LikeLike
RE: Civil & possibly criminal liabilities on the “outside.”
And let’s not forget his financial viability on the outside. His biz is in hotels/ tourism, which has taken a huge hit from covid that will likely have trouble recovering for years. And his biz loans have been since the ’90’s increasingly vested in Russian economy – & DeutscheBank-Russian-$-laundering-connected schemes, all of which was already taking a huge hit pre-covid thanks to bottom dropping out of oil market — now exacerbated by covid-era collapse of oil-consuming transportation industry…
That pusillanimous US prez-salary, buttressed by prez power is probably looking crucial to him right now.
LikeLike
This Should Be Biden’s Bumper Sticker https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/30/opinion/biden-trump-respect.html?campaign_id=2&emc=edit_th_20200701&instance_id=19897&nl=todaysheadlines®i_id=50637717&segment_id=32303&user_id=0b7efaaf843601e54e3ef31aad9169d1
“Respect science, respect nature, respect each other.” Biden should highlight his commitment to all three values in every speech and interview he gives. They draw such a clear, simple and easy to remember contrast with Trump. It summarizes so simply the most important values Americans feel that we’ve lost in recent years and hope to regain from a post-Trump presidency — this impugning of scientific methods, this embrace of conspiracy theories, this undermining of truth and data by our president and vice president — this is not happening in other countries. This is not happening in Germany, France, China, South Korea, Denmark, Canada, Israel or Japan. This is a form of American “exceptionalism” that we never imagined possible.
This is Dark Ages stuff,” remarked Harvey, founder of Energy Innovation. “A prime difference between the Enlightenment and the Dark Ages is respect for knowledge, respect for science. The whole idea of progress requires objectively looking at problems, finding and testing solutions, and then spreading and using the best of them. That’s how we grow, that’s how we learn, that’s how we prosper.”
Start with respecting science. Trump’s obvious disdain for truth-telling is annoying when he exaggerates his crowd sizes, his hand sizes, the size of his bank account or the size of his election victory.
But his disdain for science has become fatal, as we’re seeing in this widening pandemic. Trump has gone from offering quack remedies, like disinfectant, ultraviolet light and hydroxychloroquine, to mocking people, including Biden, for adopting the easiest and most scientifically proven method for limiting the spread of the coronavirus: wearing a face mask.
He not only deserves to lose..he deserves to go to hell!
LikeLike