Author Susan Jacoby published a thoughtful article in the New York Times about the Trump administration’s full-scale attack on the “wall of separation” between church and state. The Trump administration is ignorant of the Founders’ efforts to keep religion out of the public sphere, knowing the history of Europe’s religious wars.
Here are highlights.
“Many Americans were shocked when Attorney General Jeff Sessions turned to the Bible — specifically, Paul’s epistle to the Romans — to justify President Trump’s policy of separating migrant children from their parents. This scriptural justification for a political decision should not have surprised anyone, because Mr. Trump’s administration has consistently treated the separation of church and state as a form of heresy rather than a cherished American value.
“Attacks on the wall of separation established by the founders — which the religious right likes to call “a lie of the left” — are nothing new. What has changed under Mr. Trump is the disproportionate political debt he owes to extreme religious conservatives, whose views on church-state issues — ranging from the importance of secular public education to women’s and gay rights — are far removed from the American mainstream.
“The very meaning of the phrases “religious liberty” and “religious freedom”— traditionally understood as referring to the right of Americans to practice whatever faith they wish or no faith at all — is being altered to mean that government should foster a closer relationship with those who want to mix their Christian faith with taxpayer dollars. This usage can be found in numerous executive orders and speeches by Mr. Trump and his cabinet members. Changes in language have consequences, as the religious right’s successful substitution of “pro-life” for “anti-abortion” has long demonstrated.
“Religion-related issues, especially if buried in lengthy government documents, can often seem obscure, but they dominated the news at the end of June, when the Supreme Court upheld Mr. Trump’s travel ban targeting majority-Muslim countries and struck down a California requirement that anti-abortion, state-licensed pregnancy clinics provide notice to their clients that abortion is an option. These significant rulings were immediately overshadowed by the retirement from the court of the frequent swing voter Anthony M. Kennedy, which now gives Mr. Trump the opportunity to nominate a predictable religious conservative who would most likely support the overturning of Roe v. Wade.
“While it is impossible to overstate the long-term importance of the next court appointment, Mr. Sessions and many of his fellow cabinet members offer textbook examples of the everyday perils of entangling religion with politics. Mr. Sessions’s citation of the opening verse of Romans 13, which admonishes that every soul must be “subject unto the higher powers” and that there is “no power but of God,” inflamed an already bitter debate over immigration. the White House press secretary, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, followed up with a reminder that it was “very biblical” to enforce the law. Neither went on to quote Verse 10, which proclaims, “Love worketh no ill to his neighbor; therefore love is the fulfilling of the law.”
“Many pro-immigration religious leaders, including Catholics, Protestants, Jews and Muslims, took umbrage at the biblical justification for a policy that could hardly be described as loving. Their objections, however, were based mainly on the idea that Mr. Sessions had picked the wrong verse.
“It was left to secular organizations to identify all religious rationalizations as the fundamental problem. The Center for Inquiry, a secular think tank, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation, on whose honorary boards I serve, issued strong condemnations — as did the Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Rachel Laser, president of Americans United, put it succinctly: “The separation of church and state means that we don’t base public policy on the Bible or any religious book.”
“And yet Trump administration officials have used fundamentalist biblical interpretations to support everything from environmental deregulation to tax cuts.
“Scott Pruitt, who resigned from his post as the head of the Environmental Protection Agency on Thursday, once asserted in an interview with the Christian Broadcasting Network that Americans who want stricter environmental standards are contradicting the Bible. Mr. Pruitt, a former trustee of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, said, “The biblical worldview with respect to these issues is that we have a responsibility to manage and cultivate, harvest the natural resources that we’ve been blessed with to truly bless our fellow mankind.” The trenchant headline recounting the interview in Baptist News read: “God Wants Humans to Use Natural Gas and Oil, Not ‘Keep It in the Ground,’ says E.P.A. Chief.”
“Many evangelical Christians do not share such theocratic fantasies. These evangelicals, like former President Jimmy Carter, are spiritual descendants of Roger Williams, who was banished from the Puritan theocracy of the Massachusetts Bay Colony and founded the first Baptist congregation in colonial America. Williams is also credited as the first person to use the phrase “wall of separation,” in a 1644 response to the theocratic Puritan clergyman John Cotton. (There should be a “wall of separation between the garden of the church and the wilderness of the world,” he wrote.) Thomas Jefferson used the expression in a famous 1802 letter to a Baptist congregation in Danbury, Conn.
“Williams is an inconvenient figure for today’s religious right, which asserts that the only purpose of the “wall of separation” was to protect religion from government — not government from religion. That was true in early colonial America, but the other side of the equation was well understood by the time the Constitution — which never mentions God and explicitly bars all religious tests for public office — was written. Destructive religious wars in 17th-century Europe, among other factors, had led many Americans to the realization that governments could indeed be threatened by a close identification with religion…
“Ben Carson, the secretary of housing and urban development and a devout Seventh-day Adventist, has described commitment to the separation of church and state as “crap,” prompted by “political correctness.”
“At a December cabinet meeting, Dr. Carson, a retired neurosurgeon, was asked by Mr. Trump to say a prayer thanking God for the recently passed tax cut bill. Mr. Trump also took a jab at the press pool and said, “You need the prayer more than I do, I think.” Speaking to Dr. Carson, he added: “Maybe a good prayer and they’ll be honest, Ben.” Dr. Carson responded by thanking the Almighty for a “courageous” president…
“Last but not least is Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. Ms. DeVos, raised as a strict Calvinist, has devoted much of her life to promoting private and religious schools over public education. She is particularly proud that last year’s tax bill expanded the education savings accounts known as 529s so that they can now be used to pay for private schools, starting from kindergarten.
“In May, Ms. DeVos visited New York City, which has the largest public school system in the country. She did not inspect a single public school. Instead, she stopped by two Orthodox Jewish schools and spoke at a fund-raiser where she was introduced by Cardinal Timothy Michael Dolan. In her speech, she expressed support for tax credits to help pay tuition for private schools.
“While applauding state initiatives to aid these schools, Ms. DeVos opposes any federal program that would create a new bureaucracy. That is not enough for Cardinal Dolan, who wants federal money (presumably because he knows that New York is unlikely to divert more taxpayer dollars to private schools).
“Some states will need more prayers and more action than others to bring about needed changes,” Ms. DeVos acknowledged.
“As someone who believes that the separation of church and state provides equally needed protection for government from religion and for religion from government, I am grateful that laws speak louder than prayers — and take longer to craft on this earthly plane.”

This is nothing new. The Alt-Right Deep State Machine (aka: ALEC and the Koch brothers) have been pushing the country in that direction for decades with their manipulating lies, misinformation and conspiracy theories.
The only difference is the Alt-Right Deep State thinks it has its own stooge as president now even if he is a deliberate out-of-control wild card — even for them.
What they are ignoring as that Trump is a neutron bomb ready to detonate and that bomb will take them down with everyone else it destroys. The arrogance and insanity of the Alt-Right will destroy them too.
LikeLike
Yes, ALEC and Koch Bros. And don’t forget “The Gathering.”
Remember that old speech that surfaced of DeVos saying that she wanted to “advance God’s Kingdom” through public schools? She and her husband said that school choice was a way to reverse the history of public schools displacing the Church as the center of communities. By expanding school choice, she is trying to give churches the chance to reclaim their place as the center of communities. She said all of this in that same speech to “The Gathering,” a shadowy, powerful network of hard-right Christian funders who have led the campaigns to privatize public schools, redefine “religious liberty,” fight same-sex marriage, and fight evolution.
I wrote about it in The Progressive because other members of The Gathering are investing in the California Schools Superintendent race to try to defeat Tony Thurmond, a former school teacher. https://progressive.org/public-school-shakedown/california-school-superintendent-candidate-is-tied-to-anti-g_180208/
LikeLike
Our Dear Leader wants build one wall for political gain while tearing down another built on the foundation of the Constitution. There’s a metaphor in there somewhere. Perhaps it is that we will become Netanyahu’s Israel.
LikeLike
Ironic that this is happening under perhaps the most godless president in US history.
LikeLiked by 1 person
well said
LikeLike
‘The trenchant headline recounting the interview in Baptist News read: “God Wants Humans to Use Natural Gas and Oil, Not ‘Keep It in the Ground,’ says E.P.A. Chief.”
……
God wants gas and oil in the ground, not to be used to pollute the world so that humanity cannot breath and everyone gets ill, even the ultra-wealty. How disgusting. Trump and all of his followers are absolutely crazy. Using the bible and god to justify anything is a disgrace to this country. Shame on the Baptist News that prints propaganda to support the least educated, most ignorant, godless president we have ever had. Amen to a life without Trump’s Tweets blaring everyday.
LikeLike
A flood of conservative judicial appointments may unfortunately lead to taking the wall between church and state down brick by brick, particularly if the left does not provide a counterbalance.
LikeLike
In 2007, George W. Bush started the ball rolling for federal funding of social initiatives. He did so at the “National Prayer Breakfast.” The National Prayer Breakfast dates back to 1953. It was established by Abraham Veride, a Methodist minister and founder of Goodwill Industries. He founded the “prayer movement” in 1935.
In 1942, Veride co-founded the International Christian Leadership Group , an organization that became the Fellowship Foundation and in 1953, originated the Presidential Prayer Breakfast, now know as the National Prayer Breakfast. Wikipedia lists all of the speakers at this event, with a noteworthy appearance twice by Dr. Ben Carson.
The 990 for 2016 says the Fellowship Foundationhas this mission: “Develop and maintain an informal association of people banded together, to go out as “ambassadors of reconciliation,” modeling the principles of Jesus, based on loving god and loving others. To work with the leaders of many nations, and as their hearts are touched, the poor, the oppressed, the widows and the youth of their country will be impacted in a positive manner. Youth groups will be developed under the thoughts of Jesus, including loving others as you want to be loved.”
The form also says that it is doing business as the “The International Foundation.” The 2016 tax return reports about $14 million in revenue, expenses of about $15.4 million, with about $5 million for salaries and compensation, and $14.4 million in program services.
There are three major programs. One is a lay ministry, another is logistics for the National Prayer Breakfast, the third is a real estate operation that hosts and leases facilities for ministries that are part of The International Foundation. International ministries (wrapped into the lay ministry operation) are located in seven geographic regions around the world and received both grants and cash transfers totaling about $4 million.
The National Prayer Breakfast brings in about $1.4 million, seminars and conferences $327,000, room and board reimbursements about $125,000. “Miscellaneous revenue (no detail) is about $236,000.
The Board of this Foundation is led by David M. Coe and 12 of his relatives. This is probably the reason that the Foundation is also widely known as “the Family.” The Family is notorious but a powerful as a presence DC. This is one expose https://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/04/us/politics/04prayer.html
This is Trump at the 2018 prayer breakfast https://www.americanguesthouse.com/blog/2017/10/national-prayer-breakfast-2018.html
You will also find an expose of the teachings within the Fellowship (also called the Family) that should scare the ….out of you. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Family:_The_Secret_Fundamentalism_at_the_Heart_of_American_Power
LikeLike
Yeah, he’s pretty much screwing everything up. This is the real-world version of Chauncey Gardiner, not a meek gardener, but a psycho businessman, Dizzey Thumpinheimer.
He does not walk on water at the end.
LikeLike
This is a good start, but DeVos has gone a lot further than simply promoting religious schools and her reasons are much deeper than just personal preference.
Remember that old speech that surfaced of DeVos saying that she wanted to “advance God’s Kingdom” through public schools? She and her husband said that school choice was a way to reverse the history of public schools displacing the Church as the center of communities. By expanding school choice, she is trying to give churches the chance to reclaim their place as the center of communities. She said all of this in that same speech to “The Gathering,” a shadowy, powerful network of hard-right Christian funders who have led the campaigns to privatize public schools, redefine “religious liberty,” fight same-sex marriage, and fight evolution.
I wrote about it in The Progressive because other members of The Gathering are investing in the California Schools Superintendent race to try to defeat Tony Thurmond, a former school teacher. https://progressive.org/public-school-shakedown/california-school-superintendent-candidate-is-tied-to-anti-g_180208/
LikeLike
Trump alone is not tearing down the wall between church and state. Remember that we are not fighting only Trump; we are fighting the whole institution of Washington D.C. 2018.
The very expression “And may God bless America” should never be used by any politician in any speech. But it is. Let’s not finger point just at Sessions and Trump. We must include so many others, otherwise the fight is ineffective.
All those in Congress and the Senate who choose to say and do nothing are tearing down this critical wall as well, just as strongly, but in silence.
LikeLike
If you (collective) recall, Obama was pressed by critics to say that line.
Not sure things like that are so important, though that pressure was inappropriate in my opinion, inappropriate on many levels.
Citing the Bible regarding law? Sessions should recuse himself for Almighty conflicts.
LikeLike
I agree!
LikeLike
Amen, brother.
It seems likely that our Dear Leader will nominate the most extreme person on his list to be the next SC nominee. Since she will likely be confirmed by a pliant Senate with the support of Dems like Manchin, Heitkamp and Donnelly, ask yourself if this is “centrism.”
https://www.yahoo.com/news/people-praise-supreme-court-contender-amy-barrett-belongs-171538226.html
LikeLike
GregB: So Barretts’ husband is the bearer of God’s will. This sounds like something the Big Orange Ignoramus would appreciate.
LikeLike
The Big Orange Ignoramus would appreciate someone doing his will since the Kremlin’s Agent Orange obviously thinks he is god.
LikeLike
Lloyd: I guess what I meant was God’s job is to control women through the men they marry. God is to enlighten these women.
The Big Orange Ignoramus wants women who know their place, which is to bow to men, especially himself.
The only real use women have is when they are beautiful and Trump can attack. Remember he is drawn to a beautiful woman like a magnet and he can’t help himself.
I’m SO glad that I don’t fit into the extremely beautiful category. I can’t think of much worse than being attacked by the Orange One. I can’t stand to watch him talk.
LikeLike
Even when he doesn’t talk, I can’t stand to look at the arrogant expressions and hate his face displays all the time. The word disgusting doesn’t even describe who he is and what he looks like.
LikeLike
Lloyd,
We may have been separated at birth.
LikeLike
These potential nominees for Supreme Court Justice haven’t said much about Roe vs. Wade but Trump is definitely stating that he is ‘pro-life’. [He wants children to be born and after that they are on their own. Too bad if they are born to immigrants or poor people. It’s a game of blame the fetus if it choose poor parents.]
…………………………………
Video: Trump’s Top Supreme Court Contenders on Abortion
By MAEA LENEI BUHRE and DAVID BOTTI
Judges Amy Coney Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh and Raymond Kethledge are among the frontrunners to replace Justice Anthony Kennedy. Here’s a look at some of their remarks about reproductive rights.
LikeLike
Keep your politics out of my religion and keep your religion out of my politics! And if your not at all religious, you can still be a decent moral person who knows and lives right from wrong.
Let’s vote in more real people like Ocasio Cortez and Innamorato!
LikeLike
Interesting-while they are claiming to be deeply religious perhaps they should heed this verse:
Matthew 25:45 Then the King will answer, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for Me.’
LikeLike
At the very least, this administration is exposing where we have been heading for a long time. At the worst, this administration is accelerating it.
LikeLike