Archives for the month of: April, 2018

 

Tomorrow and Saturday, the Kentucky General Assembly 2018 will end its 60 day budget session. Thousands of parents, teachers, students, staff, small business owners, taxpayers, constituents and voters from across Kentucky will be joining together to fight to not only save public education, but more importantly the democratic process in Frankfort.

There are a number of harmful bills still in play. Please help us #OccupyFrankfort and tell our ALEC funded legislators understand their tactics will not be tolerated! We will #HoldTheLine against the corruption, lack of transparency, swindling, privatizing and hijacking of our democracy.

The teachers have held the line. It’s time for the rest of us to jump in and carry the torch. We need to fill the rotunda and Capitol grounds. Save Our Schools KY Coalition is planning 2 full days of speakers, music, and advocacy opportunities. Please join us.

Here are the goals:

1. STOP BAD LEGISLATION – There is still some bad legislation that can get sneaked in at the last minute. HB169 would harm students, especially our gap students, because it will target poor youth in minority neighborhoods. There is also the proposed harmful “scholarship tax credit” legislation, and any other number of bills that may have made it out of committee that could be passed during the final two days.

2. PUT LEGISLATORS ON NOTICE – We want to let them know exactly what we think about their terrible legislation. There will be candidates speaking throughout the two days who want to do better for Kentucky. #WeWillRememberInNovember

3. GIVE COALITION GROUPS A CHANCE TO BE HEARD – From right to work, to charters, health service, to pensions, to higher ed cuts, many, many groups have been hurt by the past two years of legislation. We need to lift up each others’ voices and work together to move Kentucky forward.

Before You Head Out

Take the action below from Forward Kentucky.

1. Shoepolish Your Car Windows. Get some shoe polish or window markers to decorate your car windows (not the paint)! Be creative! Use the same messaging you would use on your posters. Be sure people understand this is more than just about pensions, jobs, benefits. It is about the hijacking of our democracy. The destruction and privatization of public schools is integral to their plans. And we must make sure people in our communities, as well as on the road to Frankfort, understand what’s at stake.

2. Pack your I.D., water, sunscreen, hats, snacks. If you bring extra cases of water and snacks, we can help distribute it to rally participants who get thirsty or hungry!

3. Get Tools! Check out Save Our Schools Kentucky’s activists tools for a stop charters stop sign you can make at home, and more!

4. Make a rally sign! 2’x3′ is the size limit & no big sticks are allowed inside.

5. Bring sleeping bags, tents, picnic lunches. Who knows? These last-gasp legislative sessions are full of shenanigans and tend to run late. We may be spending the night!

Once You Arrive

1. Check in at the check in table. We will be at the top of the steps of the Capitol building at 8 am! Look for us at the right hand side of the entrance. We will direct you to actions and areas where you can maximize your visit. Be aware that the capitol is limiting entry to 500 people at a time, but we will work hard to keep the crowds moving.

2. Find one of our “station leaders” in a red SOSKY tshirt! They will be holding SOSKY clipboards and can direct you where to go, as the situation will be changing minute by minute. We can help you track down your legislator, find where legislators are meeting, and other activities in the annex and capitol.

3. Drop off your extra waters and packaged snacks at the loading dock (rear of annex). A volunteer will point you in the right direction.

4. Get there early! For security reasons, the capitol will have limited entry to 500 folks at a time. Once the doors close at 4:00 pm, they will not let anyone else in for the day. However, we will still have volunteers inside keeping an eye on the actions of our legislators and reporting out to the crowd and those following on social media the goings-on. Also, there will be many co-sponsors there with tents and activities on the lawn, as well as bands and speakers on the capitol steps even after the doors are locked, so hang around and enjoy the continued festivities well into the evening hours.

5. Media, Co-sponsors, speakers, volunteers and VIPS: Media will have special passes for entry to the capitol. Cosponsors who want to host tents, tables, etc are also encouraged to bring literature and volunteers for both inside and outside. Everyone working the event, please check in at the table upon arrival.

6. Transportation: KEA has posted some shuttle information on the KEA Facebook page. As more school districts announce closures and any groups offering buses to Frankfort are announced, we will share that information on our Save Our Schools Facebook page. Also be sure to watch for livestreams and check us out on Twitter @sos_ky!

We need to make sure our legislators understand they work for us. They need to vote in the best interests of their constituents, not their big money, outside donors. And if they continue this attack on our democracy, we will

SHUT IT DOWN!
VOTE THEM OUT!

See you tomorrow morning!

 

 

Governor Ducey refuses to meet with teacher leaders to discuss their demands, as teachers prepare for mass walkouts to protest cuts in funding and low salaries.

“The governor’s statement comes less than a week after a request by Noah Karvelis of Arizona Educators United and Joe Thomas of the Arizona Education Association “to begin a negotiation process to resolve the #RedForEd demands.” Those include not just a 20 percent salary increase to compete with neighboring states, but also restoring education funding levels to where they were a decade ago.”

Ducey has offered a 1 percent raise, added to an earlier 1 percent raise.

 

Tom Loveless taught fifth grade in California, then earned a doctorate in educational policy, taught at Harvard, then landed at Brookings where he wrote reports on the condition of American education and analyzed international assessments. He recently retired from Brookings but continues to write.

He is one of the few original thinkers in the education think tank world. Neither the right nor left claims him. He is a straight shooter and brings a fresh perspective. He was one of the first to knock down the Great Shanghai Myth by pointing out that the student population of that city is not typical of China. Meanwhile the media and Arne Duncan ranted and raved about the superiority of Shanghai, as proven by its ranking on the international tests, which Loveless debunked.

I recently learned that Loveless had written a new paper evaluating the value of standards-based reform, the approach that is central to No Child Left Behind, Race to the Top, and the Every Student Succeeds Act.  

He presented his findings at a conference sponsored by the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative D.C. think tank.

It is, as I expected, original and important.

Unless there is breaking news today, this will be the only post.

Please read the paper and feel free to comment.

 

The Seattle School Board hired Denise Juneau, currently the Montana Superintendent of Public Instruction, as its new superintendent. Seattle is strongly opposed to privatization, and Juneau share those values. She is a Native American who grew up on a tribal reservation and is strongly committed to equity.

The State of zwashington is currently involved in a protracted legal fight over charter schools. They were rejected by voters three times in state referenda. However in 2012, Bill Gates and other billionaires assembled a large campaign fund for a new referendum, outspent the opposition 17-1, and the referendum passed by 1%. The opponents—the League of Women Voters, the PTAs, the NAACP, The School Boards, and the teachers—sued to stop charters from getting public funding. The State Supreme Court held that charters are not public schools because they do not have elected school boards. Gates and friends started opening charters anyway and used their political influence to persuade the legislature to fund them with lottery money. There are currently 10 charter schools in the state, enrolling 2,500 students, or 1/4 of 1% of the state’s students.

Seattle voted heavily against charters. Green Dot in Los Angeles is apparently planning to open in Seattle.

The battle for public schools continues, with a strong leader in Seattle.

 

 

The Network for Public Education Action Fund is pleased to endorse Tony Thurmond for the post of State Superintendent of Public Instruction for the state of California. As an organization, we are committed to the improvement and preservation of public education. We oppose privatization in all ite forms, including charters, cybercharters, and vouchers. Thus, Tony Thurmond was the right choice for us, in light of his record.

“The Network for Public Education Action is proud to endorse East Bay Assemblyman, Tony Thurmond, for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction.

“Assemblyman Thurmond has been a member of the State Assembly since 2014. He serves on the Assembly Committee on Education, and has made education policy his top priority. Before serving in the legislature, he was on the West Contra Costa Unified School District Board for four years.

“Thurmond is passionate about improving public schools. His public school education prepared him for a 20-year career in social work, where he ran after-school programs and taught life skills and career training. Those years of experience provided him with a unique perspective into the lives of California’s youth.

“Thurmond told us that he will “ensure that every California student gets the education they need to realize their potential,” adding that “California is the 6th largest economy in the world, yet ranks 46th in per pupil spending in the United States. We cannot continue to underfund California’s public education.”

“He understands that class size has proven to be one of the most important factors in a child’s learning. Thurmond said that he will “support legislation, policy changes, funding to reduce class sizes.”

“Charter school issues are sure to be a central focus of the election. Thurmond’s opponent, Marshall Tuck, is a former charter school executive and CEO. In 2014, Tuck ran an unsuccessful campaign for State Superintendent, losing to incumbent Tom Torlakson. Tuck was heavily funded by outside money from national charter advocates, including Michael Bloomberg, Eli Broad, the Waltons, Laurene Powell Jobs, Arthur Rock and John Arnold. Thurmond stated that, “California’s voters don’t want this election to be bought by the Walton family, Eli Broad, and other billionaires who want to privatize public education.”

“Thurmond has made his position clear on charters. He has co-authored and voted for laws to increase accountability for charter schools and to ban for-profit charter schools. He believes that “charter schools must be measured through the same lens as public schools, follow the same guidelines, and be held publicly accountable.” He also believes that “charter schools should be authorized by local districts. Local districts host the charter and provide the services that the students and the charter will need – they are much better suited for this than the county or state.”

“Thurmond has vowed to “lead the resistance against Donald Trump and Betsy DeVos and their agenda to undermine and defund our public education system,” promising that he will not support policies that seek to divert taxpayer dollars from public education to private schools.

“Thurmond has already received numerous endorsements, including the endorsement of Superintendent of Public Instruction, Tom Torlakson. Thurmond will be on the general election ballot on November 6th. NPE Action urges our over 21,000 supporters in California to educate and inform your friends, family, neighbors and colleagues about Thurmond’s campaign and the importance of this election for the future of public education in California.”

 

 

A blogger who is a middle-school teacher with 30 years of experience writes here about how tests are the entry point for privatization. The privatized schools won’t get better schools but once they get their clutches on public schools, they don’t let go. The rewards of privatization are considerable. The private sector gets to seize the assets and resources of the public sector at no cost. What a deal. Entire communities have been gobbled up and disappeared.

“How can parents and communities end the insanity? Be informed. Click on the links to supporting materials if you want to know more. Go to nysape.org run by and for parents. Have your children opt out. Refuse consequential use of scores… including evaluating your child’s teacher, impacting your child’s access to gifted programs or remediation, your school’s report card. Demand that tests be used diagnostically not as a tool for stack ranking or predatory take over of public institutions. And, like all important things, remember that involvement is the key. The best school is not the creation of an external entity, but the product of the living partnership of a community. Instead of investing in high stakes testing, invest in a relationship with your child’s teachers. Partner with them and with the other stakeholders in the community. Together, we are responsible for the education of our children and for protecting a future in which they can participate fully. Be part of a thriving real community.”

 

John Thompson, teacher and historian in Oklahoma, reports here  on the continuing walkout:

 

Like most Oklahomans, I misjudged the crowds of 35,000 teachers at the state Capitol. Reading between the lines of press coverage, and listening to people inside the Capitol, I assumed that a deal would probably be struck after a week (at the latest.) On Friday, however, I kept running into former colleagues, who had always been extremely a-political, and saw their fervor. Regardless of what their leaders sought in terms of reaching an agreement, it finally dawned on me that teachers have just begun to fight.

Nobody was surprised, however, when Republican legislative leaders struck back. A week into the walkout, Rep. Chuck Strohm (R-Tulsa) attacked the Oklahoma Education Association and teachers seeking an increase in education funding. He attributed the walkout to “the OEA [which] had to come up with a new reason for existing.” Strohm asserted, “Today, teachers are crying for more money from the legislature to reduce class sizes when the real problem is the education establishment whose sole purpose is to grow their kingdom.”

Strohm wants wages to be driven by free market competition. He says that the current salary schedule “is the essence of Socialism.” He believes “the problem stems from the fact that we live in a culture of handouts without any accountability.”

http://chuckstrohm.com/inside- the-captiol/

Neither was it a surprise that the conservative Oklahoman started the next week with a misleading headline, “Dark Money Group Funding Pro-Teacher Ads.” It followed the money for pro-teacher television ads to Oklahoma’s Children Our Future, the 501(c)(4) whose chief funders were former Senator David Boren and the Tulsa-based Charles and Lynn Schusterman Foundation, and which advocated for a penny sales tax increase to save our schools. The Oklahoman hasn’t bothered to investigate the really secretive investments by conservatives like ALEC, the Koch brothers and Betsy DeVos.

http://newsok.com/article/5590115?slideout=1

Players and Money Behind Penny Sales Tax Campaigns

As the walkout’s second week began, DeVos also weighed in with the “hope that adults would keep adult disagreements and disputes in a separate place, and serve the students that are there to be served.”

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/education/wp/2018/04/09/betsy-devos-to-oklahoma-teachers-serve-the-students/?utm_term=.169205f6f00f

But the Sunday Oklahoman’s lead story sent the more pointed message. It listed the needs of other state agencies: Oklahoma Department of Human Services had to cut $108 million from its budgets, with much of it due to the unnecessary loss of federal funds; the Department of Mental Health has lost $133 million, and reduced services to 73,000 persons suffering from mental illness; Higher Education has been cut $122 million; the Transportation Department has lost $500 million in the last two years; and the Department of Corrections is asking for $1 billion.

http://newsok.com/state-agencies-say-they-have-funding-needs-too/article/5589886

Of course, the question is whether teachers are selfish adults who put their needs over children and the rest of the state, or whether these multiple crises are due to the legislature, the governor, and their secretive out-of-state funders, cutting taxes for the rich.

Clearly, education supporters are winning the battle of the narratives. Even though Gov. Mary Fallin compared teachers to teenagers and tried to link the crowds to Antifa, the Oklahoma Highway Patrol describes them as the “best protesters ever.” On Sunday, a prayer vigil at the Capitol drew hundreds of supporters. Monday morning, 150 female attorneys marched in support of teachers. Thousands of education supporters marched from Edmond, Del City, and Norman. They will be followed by veterans, students marching on Tuesday, and the arrival of the marchers from Tulsa.

Fact check: Antifa, paid protesters and death threats at the Oklahoma teacher walkout

OHP on teachers at state capitol: “Best protesters ever”

Monday’s turnout was much greater than last week’s. The Tulsa World reported that schools serving about 500,000 of the state 690,000 students remain closed. Sometimes it looked like all of those kids joined the rally!

Seriously, the number of students at the Monday rally was far, far greater than the first week. And it is great hearing the kids explain why they chose to attend, and how they love the civics lesson they are participating in. My favorite sign was carried by a student, “My textbook is twenty years older than me.”

Similarly, a couple of teachers volunteered that their 6th grade student spoke inside the Capitol. He decided completely on his own to research the issue of Oklahoma and national teacher salaries.

Prayer vigil draws hundreds to Capitol Sunday night

Girl Attorney group recruits 150 female attorneys to advocate for teachers

http://www.tulsaworld.com/homepagelatest/over-students-statewide-out-of-school-monday-as-walkout-continues/article_eb4dcbe5-24f8-5b99-b7f1-e77a77faf40d.html

By the way, the determination of teachers, as well as parents and school boards, to keep up the fight is due to both the state’s budget cuts and the effects of corporate school reform. From FY2010 to 2017, the average inflation adjusted Oklahoma teacher salary plummeted by $8,150. As the state’s teacher salaries declined to 49th in the nation, the average salary dropped to a level ($45,245) that is virtually identical to the average pay preceding the 1990 strike.

Because of Oklahoma’s “Education Spring,” 3/4ths of the salary decrease has been corrected, but reversing the damage done to students will take a long campaign. Extreme tax cuts for the 1% drove Oklahoma over the edge, but we must tackle the corporate school reforms that also undermined the teaching profession.

https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d17/tables/dt17_211.60.asp

http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/books/2011/08/grading_the_education_reformers.html

https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/4/9/17214924/oklahoma-teacher-strike-tax-cut-rich-charts

This battle must lead to a conversation about what happens when teachers and students are treated like lab rats. Whether we are talking about the weird idea that extreme budget cuts will produce transformative economic growth, or the idea that market-driven experiments will create transformative student performance increases, we need to start treating the education sector with respect. And a teacher’s sign asks the key question about the task, “If Not Now, When?”

 

Mercedes Schneider noted that John White, Louisiana’s Commissioner of Eduxation, got an advance copy of the NAEP scores, saw that his state was a disaster, and loudly complained about the switch to computer testing.

She observes that only a year earlier, a friend complained about computer testing to White, and he brushed off the complaint. Get used to it, he said. Hypocrite, she says.

 

Blogger Louisiana Educator has had it with John White, who left Joel Klein’s talent pool and went first to New Orleans, then to be Commissioner of Education for Louisiana. He made some pretty dramatic predictions about the miraculous rise of test scores that the state could expect on his watch. None of his predictions came true, and I am not even including the time he said that all students in the state would be proficient.

White is a TFA alum and a Broadie, so naturally he has high expectations. But eventually even he finds that the bell is tolling…for him.

Louisiana Educator writes:

This article is all you need to know about John White’s effect on Louisiana education.

Superintendent John White, who has no formal training in education, was brought to Louisiana by Governor Jindal and LABI for two reasons: (1) To privatize as many of our public schools to for-profit entrepreneurs as possible and (2) To put as much emphasis as possible on raising test scores by forcing teachers to spend most of their time preparing our students for his lousy Common Core tests. As a bonus, he and Jindal took away almost all of teacher rights and substituted merit pay based on student test scores on invalid tests for legitimate teacher evaluation. Now we have a teacher shortage, and our national comparison test scores are the lowest ever. And the voucher schools and charter schools are the lowest performers in the state.

There should be no excuses for John White. He has failed miserably at all his efforts and our children have suffered while he experimented with untested, unsound theories. He should now be judged by the same crappy standards he has forced on every public school and teacher in the state!

The article he cites in his opening sentence is a newspaper article about the state’s NAEP scores.

It begins like this:

In the latest snapshot of education achievement, scores for Louisiana public school fourth-graders plunged to or near the bottom of the nation in reading and math.

In addition, eighth-graders finished 50th among the states and the District of Columbia in math and 48th in reading….fourth-grade math scores finished 51st while fourth-grade reading scores are 49th.

This explains why White complained so loudly about the switch to computerized testing. How else to explain the catastrophic decline in state scores when White had followed the reformer textbook to a T?

 

Remember when Governor Bobby Jindal recruited a John White (TFA, Broadie) to bring true reform to the state of Louisiana?

If there was a New Orleans “miracle,” it did nothing to help the rest of the state. New Orleans should sign up for urban district NAEP, so we have a way of gauging what kind of miracle there was, if any.

Mercedes Schneider posts the Louisiana scores here, starting in 2000-2002.p, ending in 2017.

All that reform, so little change.

Mercedes says:

“So there we have it: John White’s 2017 NAEP problem.

“Let’s watch as he tries to spin it.”