John Danforth was a much-beloved Senator from Missouri. He is an old-style moderate. He was in office before the rightwing billionaire Rex Sinquefield decided to buy the state. He wrote to explain why Trump is not a Republican.
John C. Danforth was a Republican U.S. senator from Missouri from 1976 to 1995.
Many have said that President Trump isn’t a Republican. They are correct, but for a reason more fundamental than those usually given. Some focus on Trump’s differences from mainstream GOP policies, but the party is broad enough to embrace different views, and Trump agrees with most Republicans on many issues. Others point to the insults he regularly directs at party members and leaders, but Trump is not the first to promote self above party. The fundamental reason Trump isn’t a Republican is far bigger than words or policies. He stands in opposition to the founding principle of our party — that of a united country.
We are the party of Abraham Lincoln, and our founding principle is our commitment to holding the nation together. This brought us into being just before the Civil War. The first resolution of the platform at the party’s first national convention states in part that “the union of the States must and shall be preserved.” The issue then was whether we were one nation called the United States or an assortment of sovereign states, each free to go its own way. Lincoln believed that we were one nation, and he led us in a war to preserve the Union. That founding principle of the party is also a founding principle of the United States.
Even when we were a tiny fraction of our present size and breadth, the framers of our Constitution understood the need for holding ourselves together, whatever our differences. They created a constitutional structure and a Bill of Rights that would accommodate within one nation all manner of interests and opinions. Americans honor that principle in the national motto on the presidential seal: “e pluribus unum” — “out of many, one.” Today, the United States is far more diverse than when we were a nation of 3 million people , but the principle remains the same: We are of many different backgrounds, beliefs, races and creeds, and we are one.
The Republican Party has a long history of standing for a united country. Theodore Roosevelt raised up the ordinary people of his day and championed their cause against abusive trusts. Dwight Eisenhower used the army to integrate a Little Rock high school. George H.W. Bush signed the most important civil rights legislation in more than a quarter-century, a bill authored by Republican senators. George W. Bush stood before Congress and the nation and defended Muslims after 9/11. Our record hasn’t been perfect. When we have pushed the agenda of the Christian right, we have seemed to exclude people who don’t share our religious beliefs. We have seemed unfriendly to gay Americans. But our long history has been to uphold the dignity of all of God’s people and to build a country welcoming to all.
Now comes Trump, who is exactly what Republicans are not, who is exactly what we have opposed in our 160-year history. We are the party of the Union, and he is the most divisive president in our history. There hasn’t been a more divisive person in national politics since George Wallace.
It isn’t a matter of occasional asides, or indiscreet slips of the tongue uttered at unguarded moments. Trump is always eager to tell people that they don’t belong here, whether it’s Mexicans, Muslims, transgender people or another group. His message is, “You are not one of us,” the opposite of “e pluribus unum.” And when he has the opportunity to unite Americans, to inspire us, to call out the most hateful among us, the KKK and the neo-Nazis, he refuses.
To my fellow Republicans: We cannot allow Donald Trump to redefine the Republican Party. That is what he is doing, as long as we give the impression by our silence that his words are our words and his actions are our actions. We cannot allow that impression to go unchallenged. As has been true since our beginning, we Republicans are the party of Lincoln, the party of the Union. We believe in our founding principle. We are proud of our illustrious history. We believe that we are an essential part of present-day American politics.
Our country needs a responsibly conservative party. But our party has been corrupted by this hateful man, and it is now in peril. In honor of our past and in belief in our future, for the sake of our party and our nation, we Republicans must disassociate ourselves from Trump by expressing our opposition to his divisive tactics and by clearly and strongly insisting that he does not represent what it means to be a Republican.

He doesn’t represent anything but greed and corruption that fills his bank account.
LikeLike
T-RUMP is a TOTALLY DESPICABLE person. He doesn’t deserve to even breathe … well, maybe I would let him breathe in LEAD particles and watch him die a slow death.
T-RUMP is HATEFUL because he has got to be one of the most insecure person to ever be potus. He is ULTIMATE DARKNESS and an embarrassment to this already shattered country. And that DUMP takes us down with every second of every day he is in office.
I truly despise that DUMP. He’s VOMIT and FECES all mixed together.
And btw, I bet he is a cocaine and speed addict, too just like Hitler was.
LikeLike
Trump is addicted to himself. He is a walking drugged, blood bag. He is so obsessed with himself that he produces his own drugs to give him a rush.
He is obsessively in love with himself to the point of an addiction. I’m sure he trolls his name daily to find comments from his most loyal Klucker-Nazi supporters.
LikeLike
I know we want to keep it clean here, but considering Lloyd’s remarks, could it be that Scaramucci got our Dear Leader confused with Bannon in his rant?
LikeLike
Please, don’t disparage DARKNESS by associating it with Trump. DARKNESS was a great, awe-inspiring thing just several days ago.
LikeLike
That Party Was Over A Long Time Ago …
You try the handle of the road
It opens do not be afraid
It’s you my love, you who are the stranger
It’s you my love, you who are the stranger.
LikeLike
I guess I’ll take it for what it’s worth. But I won’t give Danforth too much credit. He was the patron of Clarence Thomas’s nomination and even gave the introductory speech at the hearing. If Danforth wants to lament the coarsening of American politics, he should own up to his role in helping it along.
LikeLike
Couldn’t have said it better. My family won a trip to D.C. the summer of Thomas. Part of prize was lunch in senate dining room. Sitting at the table behind us – Danforth and Thomas. I have a photo. Makes me sick to this day. But then again, at least Danforth isn’t being silent like most of his party mates. Wonder how brave he’d be if he were holding office. Just askin’
LikeLike
Since you’re askin’, I offer two pieces of speculative evidence. Exhibit A: take a look around at the rest of the current Republican senators. Exhibit B: Since Missouri seems hell bent on taking over from my home state of Louisiana for title of the most regressive state political culture, do you think Danforth would stand up to his voting base?
LikeLike
Exactly what I was thinking . Trump seems like the logical extension of every Republican past Eisenhower in my life experience. He joins with Nixon, Reagan and even Bush , in treason for political gain.
His demagoguery also a logical extension of a half century of Republican politics . The attempts at voter disenfranchisement , the use of the pardon power to avoid prosecution for crimes committed in pursuit of political objectives .
Even Goldwater in policy stood shoulder to shoulder with “very good people” White Supremacists . The new Republican party flows from those roots. Objecting to the Brown decision as well as voting no on the Civil Rights act. The only states that he carried the Deep South. Thus setting the ground work for the Southern Strategy. The choice in 64 Goldwater or Rockefeller the party chose Goldwater and never looked back.
LikeLike
Republican silence in the face of divisive policies and executive orders is acquiescence.
LikeLike
This former congressman is incorrect. Trump is a Republican. He exemplifies everything the New Republicans stand for. Profits over people; Corporations and Wealth over people; Win elections at the expense of any ideals as long as we win.
The Republican party as they moved further and further away from governing lowered political discourse to levels so low – men such as Trump are able to win elections and raise themselves to obscene levels of power. A Montana Millionaire (Republican) attacked a journalist and still won. What a Grand Old Party. So no. I don’t buy the argument that Trump isn’t a Republican.
And for Republicans to fly the we are the Party of Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt banner; thats absurd. Abraham Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt would never have governed in the manner we have witnessed: Voting to dismantle health care for millions of people; tax cuts for the wealthy; deepening the pockets of the wealthy at the expense of workers; attacks on Public Education; attacks on paying overtime; and lest I forget attempts to dismantle social security. And guess what? We have at least another year of this! And probably more.
LikeLike
Exactly. Republicans had their chance to repudiate this image back when Raygun rode into office on the coattails of black “welfare queens”. But the party has been the party of dog whistles and not-so-subtle racism at least my entire conscious memory, so it’s a bit late to repudiate that now.
LikeLike
Your life experience is too short the party of Lincoln was hijacked in 64.
LikeLike
Sorry, but the GOP has gone off the cliff into far right wing/libertarian/Ayn Rand toxic waste sludge. This rightward movement has been going on for a long time, it’s nothing new. It’s the Tea Party party that hates government and wants to cut taxes on the rich, cut regulations, denies climate change, embraces Creationism and Intelligent Design and wants to obliterate what’s left of the social safety net. Trump is the logical end result of all this right wing blather and bombast. Now all of us are suffering because of this hideous horror clown, Trump The Terrible.
LikeLike
Republicans made it possible for tRump. They have been suppressing the votes of minorities for years. They allowed the racists to come to power. How many spoke out during the whole birther movement? Reagan and Nixon were racists, perhaps not as obvious to those not paying attention. No, sorry, not buying it. They made him, and now they are sorry? This has been brewing in the party for years.
LikeLike
I would say train has left the station on Trump defining the Republican Party.
LikeLike
The GOP was being corrupted long before Fake President Trump ran to be elected as the serial lying traitor known as the Kremlin’s Agent Orange. The Koch brothers and their ALEC machine, the Walton family, and other Alt-Right extremist billionaires like Betsy DeVos and Richard Mercer and his daughter were hard at work years and even decades ago to infiltrate, buy, and subvert the Constitutional Republic of the United States.
LikeLike
Lloyd,
Again, I AGREE with YOU. Bingo.
LikeLike
It is dangerous to promote so-called republican “values” as if the party is innocent of dividing the nation. People like Richard Nixon, Reagan and bush who all used push button racial issues. Or the entire party which savaged obama.
We are so desperate to grasp at every straw attacking trump we walk into quicksand. The Republican Party is the enemy even those who are. Critical of trump. Don’t let them off the hook.
LikeLike
Trump criticism from the GOP is always couched in equivocation.
The Hoover Institute’s representative for talking points in support of democracy, bemoans the election of authoritarian Trump. Hoover and Frederick Hess of AEI ought to look in the mirror to see who is responsible for Trump and spare us the pretense that they are looking for a well spring of opposition to oligarchy. That ship sailed on the policies of Hoover, AEI, Cato,… and the Republican Party.
When Hess quoted ed reformers, “We’ve got to blow up the ed schools”, it reflected the Trump disease, endemic in America’s entitled rich.
LikeLike
For forty years, the GOP paved the road to Trump’s America. Own it.
LikeLike
I support the comments re Danforth’s sponsorship of Clarence Thomas and of those who ask what he’s doing to assure Missouri’s political posture.
LikeLike
I still remember Danforth championing the supremely mediocre Clarence Thomas for the Supreme Court. Nice try John, but you and your party have been dining out on the racist dog whistles for over 30 years. You own Trump and his unholy administration
LikeLike
The only problem Republicans have with Sideshow Don is that he’s upping the volume and lowering the pitch of their usual dog whistles to the point where humans of normal sensibilities are starting to catch on to what they’ve been pitching all these years.
LikeLike
Unfortunately the majority of both democrat and republican congress people aren’t what used to be considered a democrat or republican. Both parties have moved to the right. The Democrat party is controlled by Wall Street democrats. These people used to be moderate republicans until they were purged from the party by the far right. To gain control republicans embraced the conservative christian right. Even though they are in the minority, they have enough power to determine what republicans do or don’t do. Presently we have a republican party that is far to the right and a democrat party that is more like what used to be moderate republicans. Neoliberalism and money have, with the help from the Supreme court, taken over the government. Presently the only thing that matters is promoting big money interest. The people have been thrown under the bus by both parties.
LikeLike
Half of Trump supporters believe that Whites and Christians are the most oppressed groups. The talking point is a key strategy for extremists implementing the dual agenda of Lewis Powell and Bannon. The message is delivered in right wing media and from evangelical pulpits. As the Fox executive boasted, his audience doesn’t want to be informed, they want to feel informed.
LikeLike
Mr. Danforth is a Republican. Period. His connections to thomas and other conservative views are known. Of course we don’t agree with his views and decisions. But – he is an icon in the Republican party and ELECTED REPUBLICANS DO LISTEN TO THEIR ICONS.
I applaud Mr. Danforth. How many other GOP leaders are saying to fellow Republicans “enough is enough” of the president’s despicable behaviors ?
He wasn’t writing to us. His audience is Republicans and he’s called them on the carpet.
The elected GOP is in the palm of the president’s tweets – scared to lose an election and and pandering to president’s same white-nationalist-elitist-privatized “base.”
They are silent not only about the president’s uninformed spur-of-the-moment “policies” which most republican’s hold but SILENT about his despicable behavior. Mr. Danforth has called them on the latter.
Imagine, Presdients Bush, Secretary Rice, Mr. McCain, and and host of other GOP leaders saying “enough is enough.”
Sure – they would still advocate for conservative and ultra-conservative policies but our children and young candidates and officials would not have to witness this travesty of a president who bullies, berates, baits, and gives a middle finger to anyone who does not kiss his ring.
LikeLike
Wait What: exactly right. Danforth is a revered figure among Republicans. They needed to hear his message. Trump is destroying the GOP. He is branding it as the Trump party, a party of hatred and division, of scams and greed. As the demographics change over time, this party will die.
LikeLike
By his reasoning, I would think Mitch McConnell is not a Republican either.
LikeLike
Trump shares a core world view with many of the Republicans of my acquaintance. All but one of the Trump supporters I know have not wavered.
On another note, does anybody know why Houston was not evacuated? Weren’t any lessons learned from Katrina?
LikeLike
Abigail, Houston is my home town. My two brothers living there are safe. Evacuating 6.5 million people would have been a staggering task. Where would they go?
LikeLike
It is fortunate that your brothers are safe Diane. Many other people are stranded on rooftops.
LikeLike
Remember what happened to the public schools in New Orleans after Katrina.
Expect the same thing to happen in Texas. The corporate pirates will be moving in like the parisites that they are to take advantage of the flooding and damage to get rid of as many public schools as they can and convert them into autocratic, secretive, fraudulent, child abusing, for-profit corporate charters.
To them, never ignore a tragedy to accomplish your goals.
LikeLike