Tonight, I watched “The White Helmets,” which won the Oscar for best foreign documentary. It is well worth watching, though I don’t recommend that you watch it while eating a meal. It is heart-rending. It is about a corps of volunteers who save lives in Syria when the bombs are falling. Not much is said about politics. It is about humanity. It is hard to forget that the bombs are falling because the Syrian dictator Assad decided to obliterate his own people rather than compromise and risk losing power. The bombs are falling because Russian airplanes are targeting apartment buildings and hospitals.
President Obama drew a line in the sand a few years ago and said that Assad must go. But then he did nothing. Hillary Clinton wanted a no-fly zone to stop the aerial bombardments of civilian targets, but Obama vetoed that. He thought it might anger the Russians, who were intent on protecting Assad.
The film says that 400,000 Syrians have been killed, as Assad continues to eliminate his population, and the Russians carry out their deadly airstrikes to support their ally. Millions of Syrians have left their homes, but we don’t want them. We won’t help them, and we don’t want them.
The cinematographer for this Academy Award-winning film was barred from entering the country by Trump’s Muslim ban. He did not attend the ceremony when his film won the Oscar.
P.S. I don’t usually watch Netflix because it profits Reed Hastings, who is one of the big funders of charter schools. But I wanted to see this moving film.

note: I haven’t seen the movie and take no position on it, but thought you might be interested in this at least provocative critique:
https://consortiumnews.com/2017/02/24/syrian-war-propaganda-at-the-oscars/
LikeLike
Perhaps you should watch the documentary, learn about the White Helmets from a variety of sources (as well as other organizations that go into harm’s way to alleviate suffering), and evaluate the validity and agenda of reports you spread before doing so. Or you can just spread disinformation at random without regard for anything. That’s been shown to be effective too.
LikeLike
Along with Greg, suggest you watch it. Candidly I could care less who funds them and/or if they get paid. The fact they only work in rebel held territory may also suggest they aren’t allowed in the Syrian/Russian areas and/or there is not as much need there.
Regardless, watching Russian and Syrian jets use barrel and cluster bombs on civilian populations is witnessing war crimes…..war crimes that will never be prosecuted…..now take a a look at the US/Iraqi/Kurd seige on Mosel ….going on as we write…..it appears the Iraqis/Kurds/US are doing all they can to spare civilians….while ISIS is using them as shields….
Last, anyone who tells me an extremely small group of Syrian families can’t be granted political asylum in the US, believes in a different God than I. Witness Canada for compassion….
LikeLike
In addition to the article Lauren posted above, here are a few others:
EXPOSED: Syria’s White Helmets are Al Qaeda’s ‘Civil Defence’
http://21stcenturywire.com/2017/01/23/exposed-syrias-white-helmets-are-al-qaedas-civil-defence/
White Helmets…”and the winnner is…anything but truth”
http://www.veteranstoday.com/2017/02/28/white-helmets-and-the-winnner-is-anything-but-truth/
Much has been written that claims the White Helmets are total propaganda, these are just two that recently came into my inbox.
And then watch HyperNormalization, the most recent documentary from Adam Curtis that gives another perspective on how we got to Syria (and Libya). You can find it on YouTube.
LikeLike
thank you Kim. I value this blog and don’t want to disrespect it or anyone who participates. I know we all do.
LikeLike
In this era of fake news, I don’t know what the truth is. What I do know is factual is that the rebel-held, anti-Assad portion of Aleppo was leveled by barrel bombs and cluster bombs. Many thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of Syrian civilians were killed by Syrian government forces and Russian bombers.
Are the White Helmets real? I don’t know.
But I assume that Putin and Assad have a propaganda machine working overtime to minimize the carnage that they inflicted on Syrian civilians, including targeting hospitals.
How to explain the heated effort to discredit the White Helmets? I hope we are supplying them with equipment and money. God knows we haven’t provided any military support to defend the Syrian people against their brutal dictator and his Russian backers.
LikeLike
If you have the stomach to do so, please check out both of the websites Kim has referenced. And be sure to smooth the kinks out of your tin foil hats before doing so. Jeesh, McCain is a North Vietnam collaborator, Trump debunks Russian involvement, etc, etc. RT connections, Trump’s agenda will create millions of jobs. I feel dirty just having read this crap. Kim, Lauren, what’s your agenda? It’s obviously more than trying to discredit a documentary.
LikeLike
Greg….thank you….and wake me up, I am having a “reality” nightmare…..
LikeLike
“I could care less about who funds them” is not a good way to approach anthing today. You should Google “White Helmet Controversy” to see what is being said about the White Helmets.
LikeLike
So I took up your challenge and google it. A lot of the same garbage referenced above plus an article from The Atlantic, the website Counter-Punch, and Snopes. I think I see some of the problems. First, there is a peculiar American disease that makes Americans want to see everything in black and white and ignore gray areas—where virtually all life is lived. But after having read these through, there is far less gray than some would like to believe. The bottom line is that the White Helmets on the front lines do not bear arms, put their lives on the line to save innocent victims of war atrocities, and go about their work anonymously. That’s enough for me. I may disagree with them politically, but they are doing good works that I would hope I would do if put in the same situation. I think the whole “cast the first stone” thing applies here.
I repeat what I wrote earlier: are the humanitarian, non-violent medics and others of opposing or “evil” regimes at war complicit in the atrocities their governments commit? Are those people who live in repressive societies, who choose to “bear witness,” somehow evil for the choices they make? Are the religious persons who live in repressive regimes who choose to minister to their people part of the problem or do they demonstrate civil courage? Those with comic book views of the world will likely have definitive answers. I don’t, but admire anyone anywhere who would strive to alleviate suffering and serve their fellow human beings.
LikeLike
“I …admire anyone anywhere who would strive to alleviate suffering and serve their fellow human beings.”
It’s a beautiful sentiment. Imagine how much better our whole world would be if everyone cared about alleviating the suffering that mankind is enduring!
LikeLike
The charge is that this is an Al Qaeda organization. “I could care less…” is what the CIA said when they funded Al Qaeda in Afganistan when they were fighting occupation by the Soviet Union..and look what that brought us.
LikeLike
For heavens sake, the White Helmets are an unarmed rescue force that digs people out of the rubble after buildings are bombed and collapse. Has Trump created an era of mass paranoia?
LikeLike
I wish somebody would tell me who the good guys are in Syria, that we are supposed to support. My understanding is, it started as a secular student rebellion, but quickly was overtaken by the ‘Religious right’, Jihadists , Al Qaeda affiliate, Al-Nusra Front .
So who was Obama supposed to support ISIS or Al Qaeda.The weapons he gave to supposed moderate rebels quickly wound up in enemy hands. He supported the Kurd’s.. Convinced Turkey to enter the fight against ISIS, so they started off by bombing the Kurd’s. Who Turkey considers terrorists. So yes while it is heart wrenching to see innocents die. It is also heart breaking to see the wives, children and mothers of American soldiers grieve.
Given the choice Obama had perhaps drawing a fictitious line in the sand was the best.
Seldom do our military adventures end the way we think. We liberated the people of Iraq . Possibly up to 450,000 permanently liberated. ( As 0f 2013 ). Possibly 90,000 civilian deaths attributed to direct American actions,bombing and fire fights.
https://www.juancole.com/2013/10/american-population-sanctions.html
LikeLike
Joel, once again I’m with you. Life is messy. The move Hacksaw Ridge was about a conscientious objector who served as a medic on the front lines on the American side in WWII. There were also counterparts who served in Nazi Germany and Japan. One of them was Hans Scholl, who was later executed for engaging in resistance activities when he left the front and returned to his university studies. Every war has had them on both sides. They exist in Israel and Palestine; they exist in Russia and the Ukraine; they exist in Afghanistan and Iraq. How should we judge these individuals who make decisions of conscience, who refuse to take up arms, but still are forced to choose sides they will serve? According to the critics of the White Helmets, an enemy is an enemy and an immoral opportunist unconditionally. Nuance and context is, to them, inconceivable.
LikeLike
At this point, I don’t know who the hell to believe or not believe. One thing is for certain, Syria is an utter and complete humanitarian disaster of monumental proportions. The suffering of the people, the children is horrific and unrelenting.
LikeLike
I suggest you see the movie. The suffering is real. The impotence of the US and the UN has been real. What is the point of the articles critical of the White Helmets?
LikeLike
Do you realize there is another reality about exactly who the White Hats are, who runs them and what they actually have done?
LikeLike
This is a 25 minute news report by Al Jazeera on the White Helmets. They work to rescue people under dire conditions.
……….
Syria’s White Helmets – Witness
Al Jazeera English
Published on Aug 14, 2016
Life under the bombs with a team of White Helmet rescue workers in Syria’s most dangerous city, Aleppo.
LikeLike
A small correction: “The White Helmets” won the Academy Award for Best Documentary (Short Subject), not Best Foreign Documentary. The latter category is not on Oscar’s list.
LikeLike
“Not much is said about politics.”
Not directly, perhaps. Which means it’s designed to support the existing power structure. It’s the same as an ed rephorm movie that claims not to be about “politics”. It’s not possible to avoid politics. A work like this either has to explicitly oppose the existing power structure or implicitly support it.
LikeLike
Diane,
Please be aware that “The White Helmets” is propaganda and disinformation for the neoconservatives’ plan for regime change in Syria:
An Oscar for a Propaganda Flick – Consortiumnews
https://consortiumnews.com/2017/03/03/an-oscar-for-a-propaganda-flick/
Syrian Superheroes Or Propaganda Pawns?: Netflix’s Documentary ‘White Helmets’ Is Already Dividing Opinions
http://www.huffingtonpost.in/kabir-taneja/syrian-superheroes-or-propaganda-pawns-netflixs-documentary/
‘White Helmets’ — pawns for U.S. militarism – Workers World
http://www.workers.org/2016/09/21/white-helmets-pawns-for-u-s-militarism/#.WLw0Xb1Kb_X
Who Are The ‘White Helmets?’ Do We Really Know What They Are Doing In Syria? – Collective Evolution
http://www.collective-evolution.com/2017/03/01/who-are-the-white-helmets-do-we-really-know-what-they-are-doing-in-syria/
The ‘White Helmets’ Hoax and the Information War against Syria
http://theduran.com/information-war-syria-white-helmets-hoax/
LikeLike
Ed,
I have no evidence that any of this is true.
The US government refused to stop the carnage in Syria.
The Syrian people were bombed into submission by Syrian and Russian airplanes.
I think you are citing Russian propaganda.
Putin decided to keep Assad in power and has vetoed any effort by the UN to stop the carnage.
LikeLike
Ed,
You might want to contact CBS and warn them that the White Helmets are a terrorist group that only pretends to save people trapped under the rubble.
This just aired.
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/after-oscar-win-white-helmets-return-to-syria/
LikeLike
Ed,
I checked with Snopes.com, which says there is no evidence for the claim that the White Helmets are bad guys.
http://www.snopes.com/syrian-rescue-organization-the-white-helmets-are-terrorists/
What you cite is propaganda from the Syrian dictator and his Russian allies.
What is the neoconservative plan for regime change?
LikeLike
Consortium News is the creation of investigative journalist Robert Parry and others, and has been providing an alternative to the corporate media narrative online since 1995. I mention this to fend off those who will automatically dismiss this article for reasons of cognitive bias based on their only source of information being said corporate media.
https://consortiumnews.com/2016/10/23/the-white-helmets-controversy/
LikeLike
Sadly Trump’s mantra of “fake news, fake news,fake news is having the exact effect that Robert Reich said it would… making us question the veracity of ANYTHING. The articles cited by commentators should be checked in terms of who was authoring them! Reich said this is the perfect strategy of emerging fascist regimes when we are constantly led to disbelief our own hold on reality. And then the real action begins at creating divisiveness among normally unified people and a void which THE ALMIGHTY LEADER is all too happy to fill.
LikeLike
re the Snopes link: “which says there is no evidence for the claim that the White Helmets are bad guys.” There is also no evidence they are good guys. There is evidence of their funding, however. There is a shortage of “evidence” from the msm because mainstream journalists cannot or will not go to Aleppo to report because it’s too dangerous. Some independents have gone in such as my previous link above.
Something to keep in mind about this proxy war is a pipeline that will either benefit Syria or Turkey depending on where it goes. One might evaluate stories based on this information. Thus Al Jazzera, owned by Qatar which has a definite dog in this pipeline race, should not be considered an unbiased or credible source.
I worked in the movie business for a number of years. One thing that has struck me from the beginning, seeing White Helmet photos or film clips, is how professionally art directed everything looks. Just sayin’…
For those interested here’s some other articles to contemplate:
A long historical read from Robert Kennedy, Jr.
The Mess in Syria by Robert F. Kennedy , Jr. & response by Stephen Zunes
http://www.tikkun.org/nextgen/the-mess-in-syriarobert-f-kennedy-jr
and, of course because this is Syria, there’s different point of view:
Pipelines or Pipe Dreams: What Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Gets Wrong About Syria
http://readersupportednews.org/opinion2/277-75/39060-pipelines-or-pipe-dreams-what-robert-f-kennedy-jr-gets-wrong-about-syria
Again, and especially for this audience who place a high value on critical thinking, I cannot recommend viewing HyperNormalisation 2016 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-fny99f8amM strongly enough. It dates this Syria crisis with a betrayal by Henry Kissinger in the 1970s over Israel.
Weissman, in the article above, sums it up: “But, as journalist Patrick Cockburn reminds us, the conflict in Syria and U.S. involvement in it is infinitely complex, much like three-dimensional chess played by nine players and with no rules.”
LikeLike
Kim,
Do you doubt that Russian planes have been bombing hospitals and apartment houses in Aleppo? Do you think it is US airplanes dropping bombs?
I don’t understand why you are so eager to discredit a group that pulls people out of the rubble.
LikeLike
Second time: Kim, what’s your agenda?
LikeLike
Thanks, Greg. I hope that Western nations are funding humanitarian aid to suffering people. Is that a bad thing? This is a situation where the UN should have stepped in to stop the killing years ago, but Russia and China vetoed any effort to impose a ceasefire–as recently as last week.
LikeLike
My agenda is critical thinking and, especially on something as complex as the Middle East, not to believe the mainstream media without looking at other sources. I think I have put enough links up here to demonstrate that my agenda is knowledge and information. Have any of you read them or what others have put up? I have seen too many different reports about the White Helmets, and everything else in Syria, to be able to say definitively what’s going on there. But if you all are sure you are fully informed enough to say definitively what’s going on, then so be it.
LikeLike
I’m with you Diane. This kind of warped rationalization would have killed the Marshall Plan.
LikeLike
Since it’s Sunday, I’ve read them all. That’s why I’m still confused about your agenda. Your defensive response still does not answer my question. Sorry, “critical thinking” doesn’t cut it. Perhaps it is to infer that all Arab people are evil.
Here’s what I know after reading everything: people who do their best to save lives in war zones deserve, at a minimum, deserve our acknowledgement and respect, even if we disagree with their motives. Would it be more moral to just look the other way and let people die? I’m sure it would be, according your critical thinking, politically expedient. I think the equivocation of human life and motives that you try to nurture is reprehensible. What I am fully informed of is the value of a human life, especially it is innocently drawn into a conflict.
LikeLike
I guess if Snopes says there is no evidence for saying the The White Helmets are a fraud, that means there is no evidence that they are NOT a fraud. Somehow I feel we are sliding down an epistemological rabbit hole.
Did you see the film?
LikeLike
I have no idea what the White Helmets are doing, just because a movie was made about them. And I respect those that have written that they are Gray Helmets. My responses have not been at all defensive, I’m not sure why you perceive them as such. I have nothing to defend. And I certainly do not believe that all Arab people are evil, and not one piece I posted indicates that. Nor do I believe that all Americans or all Russians are evil. What I believe is that there are very dangerous military maneuvers taking place between a small group of the 1% and their puppets, which is some cases are the leaders of countries and in some cases are the same people, that has little to do with the well being of the 99%. We are simply collateral damage. I’m done with this. You’re all welcome to your opinions.
LikeLike
I did. It brought to mind scenes from Keisuke Kinoshita’s movie “Army,” Marlantes’s novel “Matterhorn,” and Remarque’s novel “A Time to Love and a Time to Die.” It also brought to life conversations I had with a good friend who lived through horrible events in Vietnam and family members who saw many deaths in WWII. I have little patience for people who don’t understand that enemy combatants include honorable people who provide emergency relief or think that war is between “good guys” and “bad guys.” You can still support your nation and acknowledge the atrocities of a Lt. Calley; you can oppose another and respect medical personal who put their lives on the line to save their comrades. I don’t claim to understand all the nuances of the Syrian conflict, but the individual bravery and personal risks the White Helmets can be comprehended immediately. If I or my children were ever in those circumstances, I would hope we would all act with similar selflessness and bravery.
LikeLike
I watched this documentary at a local cinema that showed all the Oscar nominated short live documentaries. I suggest readers go watch the actual documentary. Make up your own minds. I watched the footage and felt this was absolutely no Hollywood staged filming. And frankly, these men at great risk, were digging into massive piles of rubble amidst active bombings to save lives. Am I wondering their politics as I watched this? No. I am seeing human beings frantically trying to save other human beings lives amid massive destruction (former concrete shambles and current). These men whoever they are were most assuredly risking their lives to save lives amidst active bombings. If there was any film “editing” as one commentator suggested, it was so save the viewer from seeing the completely horrific carnage that they were seeing. At some point, humans saving humans just carries a powerful message of LOVE OVER HATE. This is how I saw the documentary. I do not see it as a propaganda tool but rather as a testament to our need to allow humanity to shine through mankind’s destructive tendencies in the worst of times.
LikeLike
Thank you! I wish I could have been as succinct and articulate as you.
LikeLike
Artsegal,
That was beautifullly said.
I had the same reaction.
These men were not promoting a political agenda.
They were saving lives.
LikeLike
Anyone looking for a better understanding of the Syria civil war should look at back broadcasts of the PBS Frontline program. They have excellent documentaries about Syria.
LikeLike
White Helmets: Swedish Doctors Denounce Medical Malpractice and ‘Misuse’ of Children for Propaganda Purposes
http://21stcenturywire.com/2017/03/07/white-helmets-swedish-doctors-denounce-medical-malpractice-and-misuse-of-children-for-propaganda-purposes/
LikeLike