Last week, federal authorities raided the offices of Celerity charter schools in Los Angeles. The Los Angeles Times takes a closer look at the Celerity charters in this article.
Teacher Tien Le worked at Celerity Dyad Charter School, where she
taught in a portable classroom on an asphalt lot — not unheard of in this city of tight squeezes and little green space, but her students also had no library, cafeteria or gymnasium. The school didn’t provide most supplies, Le said, so when her sixth-graders needed books, or an extra pencil and paper, she spent her own money to buy them.
Months into her first year at Dyad, Le and her colleagues were invited by the organization that managed the school to a holiday party at a large house on a winding street in Hollywood. She parked in a lot rented for the occasion and took a shuttle to the house with other teachers and staff. Inside, there were two open bars, casino tables for poker and blackjack, and a karaoke room. At evening’s end, a limousine ferried guests back to their cars.
“I remember being really confused that night,” Le said. “When I asked for basic supplies, I couldn’t get those things, yet you have money for this expensive party? I know at big corporations and for-profit places these parties are normal, but for a public school it was not normal.”
Celerity operates seven charter schools in Southern California and four in Louisiana.
The investigation is ongoing. I can’t help but wonder whether Betsy DeVos will call a halt to the investigation when and if she becomes Secretary of Education. True, the FBI is involved, but a phone call to her friend in the White House….

If Devos and vouchers are installed as federal policy with a spill-over to state policy,, these abuses are likely to become routine.
LikeLike
They already are …
… in Los Angeles (and the rest of the country, as well.)
LikeLike
I wish you had a “sad” or “OMG” like button. I live in LA County and was concerned regarding the children attending this LA and Louisiana charter school system as explained in the LA TIMES and statements on your educational blog. Not meant as an excuse, the absence of school supplies seems to be a re-occuring theme at many schools where teachers go into their own small wallets to provide funds. Is Betsy DeVos, the Trump nomination for School Board, a friend of the Celerity school owner, or was sarcasm intended here? Maybe with her “earned” billions she can teach the educational industry “how to appropriately raise school supply funds for all district managers.
LikeLike
Celerity Clarity
Celerity means “swiftness”
To whisk away the cash
But that is simply bidness
And where went, don’t ask
LikeLike
And where it went, don’t ask
LikeLike
I thought Celerity was a new pharmaceutical!
LikeLike
Yes, one with serious side effects:
Don’t take Celerity if your heart is beating, you are breathing or your brain is not in a vegetable state
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is absolutely infuriating. I am rarely outraged. These charter school operators are robbing these children and society.
LikeLike
Think of it as teaching the children a valuable life lesson: Crime pays — as long as you wear a suit and tie when you do it and as long as you target the vulnerable who can not later hold you to account.
Bernie Madoff only got half the recipe right: he wore a suit and tie but targeted the rich who had the money and influence to come after him. Big mistake. Poor Bernie must have slept through the cheating class in business school.
LikeLike
Yes, Poet, I have often thought this. Rob the rich, they will come after you.
Rob the middle classes or lower, and you can get away with it. 😔
LikeLike
steal a little and they throw you in jail…
steal a lot and they make you a king…dylan-‘sweetheart like you’
LikeLike
SomeDAM Poet: to riff off of your comments…
I was reminded of a verse near the end of a song made popular by THE BYRDS, a shorter version of the original by Woody Guthrie:
[start]
Yes, as through this world I’ve wandered
I’ve seen lots of funny men;
Some will rob you with a six-gun,
And some with a fountain pen.
[end]
Many many links including—
Link: http://www.woodyguthrie.org/Lyrics/Pretty_Boy_Floyd.htm
😎
P.S. I wish it were not necessary, but to make this absolutely clear for the clueless that haunt this blog: I am not a fan of Pretty Boy Floyd. I provide the link so that others can see the context and perhaps be provoked into thought by how people can be furious at a single individual that commits a serious crime against another individual while the high-priced suits can crash the entire economy of this country causing the most terrible suffering and consequences for the vast majority, and the response (backed up by money, political capital and law enforcement) is “too big to fail” aka “pass Go, collect $200, don’t go to jail” [hint: the board game MONOPOLY].
Just sayin’…
LikeLike
Sadly, there is no mechanism in place to catch this earlier. Charters in California have to be renewed only every 5 years. In the interim, the authorizer is required to do a yearly oversight visit and review. However, it’s the charter that provides the authorizer with limited materials to be reviewed.
The LAUSD Charter School Division(CSD) does not like to be caught in the middle of this kind of investigation as they are then accused of being incompetent. However, this division is limited due to the low fees they receive for charter oversight.
The head of the division said at the October 2016 LAUSD board meeting when 2 Celerity Charter renewals were denied, that the CSD is not the charter’s supervisor. That’s exactly where the problem lies. In a nutshell, there is no provision for ongoing supervision. That’s the way the law is written……autonomy first, then comes accountability. Well, there’s a very big gap between those two and Celerity is the best example. What would it take for the CSD to be able to more closely supervise their charters? That would be a great question, but be assured, it would be much more than the present 3% fee presently collected from the charters.
Also not discussed is the cost of investigations into charter operations by the District’s Inspector General. It has been made clear that these investigations are taking up more and more of their time, leaving less time for issues relating to the rest of the district’s operations. That’s not a good thing.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on David R. Taylor-Thoughts on Education.
LikeLike
The worst part is the story is rarely told by the media If they do tell the story, it is not a balanced view. Yesterday, Rehema Ellis, NBC education reporter, spoke about DeVos’s charter expansion in Detroit. They showed a bright, shiny charter where Ellis interviewed on parent that stated her daughter was better off in a charter. That was the end of the story. I sent an email to NBC stating that their coverage was biased. Even if it has little impact, I think we need to let them know we are watching.
LikeLike
“Better off”
Better off in charter
Better off than what?
Better off than worser
Better off than Tut*
*King Tut
LikeLike
For a picture of how King Tut is doing
http://www.cbsnews.com/pictures/king-tut-unmasked/7/
LikeLike
Though I suppose you could say he is doing pretty well for his age (over 3300 years)
LikeLike
Diane-
I just heard of a journalist’s unconfirmed claim that the Trump administration may target the Peace Corps for elimination (https://twitter.com/SusannahLuthi/status/826631170427346944).
Two years ago you posted a letter I’d written to Congress to your blog (https://dianeravitch.net/2015/04/05/a-peace-corps-volunteer-writes-to-congress/). The perspective I gave was deeply influenced for the better by my experience abroad. Today I work in the helping profession of wilderness therapy, with a pending application for a Master’s of Arts in Teaching at Bard College (ELA, grades 7-12).
Watching students be whipped, as I detailed in that letter, has challenged me to widen and deepen my conception of and commitment to kindness in the classroom and the therapeutic milieu. Knowing the teachers who administered those whippings were passionate, dedicated educators sometimes working for starvation wages has challenged me to think systemically and from a place of humility–this is no time to shame allies, or anybody for that matter. In short, though the experience I had as Peace Corps Volunteer was difficult, I am better for it, and I plan to share that growth with whatever community of practice I find myself in, hopefully the professional teaching corps.
Please do what you can to help me preserve this opportunity for future volunteers.
Best,
Jakob Gowell
LikeLike
“Although it’s common for schools to emphasize the need for students to perform well on California’s annual exams, former employees said the charter network’s leaders made test scores their singular focus. At some schools, students were tested every Friday, but in classrooms with more children than laptops this task could consume class time for several days. Teachers whose students performed well earned bonuses. Those who did not sometimes were fired, according to former employees.
Celerity management “would go into the teacher’s classroom over the weekend and box up all of their belongings,” Fisher said. “The teacher would show up Monday morning, and they would see all of their stuff just packed up and be told, ‘You’re not going to work today.’”
They were tested every Friday but testing could last several days? So how many days a month are they taking practice tests? At least 4, right?
LikeLike
Fire them in a heartbeat?
Now that’s what I call celerity.
LikeLike
Celerity charters have been much gushed over in the press over the years — including by the Los Angeles Times.
LikeLike
Glad to hear this story is on page A1 today
LikeLike
dianeravitch: not only does this story start on page 1 of section A, a piece today by Steve Lopez (LATIMES staff writer) starts on page 1 of section B. Print edition title: “A charter raid and gutter politics 101.” Online title: “A $471,000 charter school exec, and another case of gutter politics in LAUSD school board race.”
Link: http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-ca-0201-lopez-celerity-zimmer-20170201-story.html
This sort of critical coverage of corporate charter schools and corporate education reform in general—two noticeable fairly lengthy pieces in one day!—is strikingly unusual for the LATIMES.
In spite of what I wrote elsewhere on this thread, if this is a trend…
Bravo!
😎
LikeLike
It gives me no pleasure to write this, but having followed the LATIMES coverage of education over the last six years or so, I have noticed that the editorial board in particular gushes over whatever is new and shiny and rheephormy—
Until it quite publicly crashes and burns. Then it throws its old positions and creatively disruptive heroes under the bus while neglecting to remind readers that they were all in for the now discredited so-and-so and completely on board for this-and-that proven flop of a policy mandate. Followed in quick order by jumping on the next rebranded rheephorm bandwagon until that too loses its luster.
Not so much a few of the writers for the LATIMES who sneak in some actual data and facts once in a while despite the pressure from on high.
IMHO, it’s not a question of self-flagellation. It’s about thoughtfully and carefully taking stock of serious missteps and miscalculations so that you have a better chance of getting it right next time.
Thank you for your comments.
😎
P.S. I could have resisted but am giving in to temptation.
Donald Trump uses the phrase “truthful hyperbole” in “his” THE ART OF THE DEAL. Remembering that old saw about “a sucker is born every minute,” the LATIMES never met a rheephorm promise, typically hyperbole prettily wrapped in “truthiness,” that it didn’t buy into lock, stock and barrel.
Notice all the clichés I used? Cliché…a perfect one-word description of LATIMES top management when it comes to education.
P.P.S. Cliché: (1), “a phrase or opinion that is overused and betrays a lack of original thought”; (2), “a very predictable or unoriginal thing or person.”
LikeLike
How is it that parents sign their kids up for a school that is a trailer in a parking lot?
LikeLike
No supplies, no books, no library, no gymnasium, no cafeteria.
Really? The whole thing is a scam. And the children are the victims of the scam, so that already rich people can make more money on their backs. 😦
LikeLike
The promise of success: from the parking lot to Berkeley! Or Harvard!
LikeLike
The LATimes and KTLA, along with ABC, NBC… have done a superb job of slandering public school educators over the years. Much of the damage is irrevocable. The media can publish sensational stories of crimes committed like this one about Celerity or that one about El Camino or Gülen, get readers and ratings, and the Waiting for Superman, ‘teachers are the enemies of children’ narrative still holds. Profits made. Damage done.
LikeLike
“Celerity”
Celerity is swift
In making an escape
So trailer is a gift
Like superhero’s cape
LikeLike
The California Charter Schools Association just put out this statement on the new Celerity scandals:
http://www.ccsa.org/blog/2017/01/ccsa-statement-on-federal-investigation-of-celerity-schools.html
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
January 26, 2017
CALIFORNIA CHARTER SCHOOLS ASSOCIATION:
The following statement is in response to news reports of a federal investigation of Celerity, a national charter network that operates 7 charter schools in California:
“CCSA consistently advocates for charter schools being held to high levels of accountability for academic performance as well as adherence to all applicable law. At this point, we have no details about the investigation and we are pleased that Celerity is cooperating. We do know that Celerity’s schools in Los Angeles continue to provide an excellent education for their students, including many from historically underserved student populations. Whatever the outcome, we hope this process takes the schools’ strong academic performance into account, as our foremost concern is, above all, that students receive a high quality education.”
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
It’s interesting that this makes multiple references to “academic performance,” which is cofe for “did well on B.S. tests.” Given the massive test prep the earlier article describes, this renders those test scores meaningless.
What the CCSA’s blurb shies away from is any of the financial aspects of the scandal — the CEO’s $471,000 salary, the lavish parties, etc. The only vague reference is to “adherence to all applicable law.” The unspoken message: as long as you can legally get away with the obscene salaries, lavish parties for the bosses, not paying your teachers for months at a time, forcing your already low-paid teachers to pay for supplies out of their own pockets, etc. …
As long as all of that is technically within the letter of the law… then go nuts., Charter Bosses! … and we’ll stand by you all the way.
What about the “spirit” of the law, what about not what’s “legally” wrong, but what’s morally and ethically wrong?
They’re dead silent on all of that. The CCSA instead throws out the bromide, ” .. as our foremost concern is, above all, that students receive a high quality education.”
Again, “high test scores” are the only “concern” these idiots care about. They’re basically saying, “Be as a corrupt as you want be within the law, and we’ll stand by you.” Nowhere in that statement is their an equal concern — along with “academic performance” — for any standards of moral, upright behavior, and being good stewards of the citizen-taxpayers’ money, or setting an example for the Celerity parents and students, who are no doubt reading all this, and seeing what crooks the bosses at Celerity are.
LikeLike