Ray Richmond is a writer in Los Angeles. This article appeared in the Los Angeles Times. I won’t reproduce it in full because that would violate copyright law. I hope you will open the article and read it. It expresses my own feelings of personal fear, fear for the future of my nation and my fellow citizens, fear for our democracy, and deep uneasiness about the future.
I never thought I’d have to write that I sense fear from my fellow citizens when it comes to speaking out against a presidential administration. But I do.
I never thought I’d have to write that our president is the biggest and most compulsive liar that I’ve ever encountered in American public life. But I must.
I never thought I’d have to write that the leader of the United States has the demeanor of a middle school-aged adolescent, with mature development arrested at age 13. But it’s true.
I never thought I’d have to write that my government has declared literal war against the truth, or that the president’s chief spokesperson would go on television and with a straight face and present the idea of “alternative facts.” But they have.
I never thought I’d have to write that my president is so insecure and consumed with the size of his support that he would personally phone the acting chief of the National Park Service to produce photographic evidence of a larger turnout at his inauguration. But he did…
I never thought I’d have to write that members of President Trump’s senior staff all were using a private Republican National Committee email server after having made Hillary Clinton’s doing so the centerpiece of the general election campaign. But it has.
I never thought I’d have to write that the winner of the presidential campaign is loudly and persistently making dubious claims of voter fraud despite having come out on top. But he does….
I never thought I’d have to write that an American president this week stood in front of the hallowed CIA Memorial Wall and made a self-aggrandizing speech about his own greatness and popularity, unable to see past his own narcissistic reflection. But he did.
I never thought I’d have to write that five members of the president’s inner circle, including two of his children, are registered to vote in two states. But they are.
I never thought I’d have to write that Steve Bannon, the president’s chief strategist, has gone so far as to tell the New York Times, “The media should be embarrassed and humiliated and keep its mouth shut and just listen for a while. The media here is the opposition party.” But he did.
I never thought I’d have to write that the leader of the once-free world could consume himself with bad-mouthing movie stars and TV shows in tweets and all but declare war on information itself. But he does….
I never thought I’d have to write that waking up in the morning to the news — once an activity embraced with relish — so fills me with dread. But it does.
I never thought I’d have to write that going about the business of my daily life feels utterly empty and foreboding due to what appears to be the purposeful destruction of our hallowed institutions of democracy in real time. But it has.
I never thought I’d have to write that I feel helpless in the face of tyranny and autocratic rule from a man who believes himself at once omnipotent and infallible. But I do.
I never thought I’d have to write that I sense I’m a stranger in my own land. But I do.
We are only helpless if we succumb to our feelings of helplessness. We are not helpless when we realize that we are the majority and unite to act as such.
I agree. Never succumb to fear, hate, bully, lies, and deceit. We never succumb to Trump and the way of life he is trying to force on the American people. NEVER!!!
Diane — This letter is a well-written summary of the disaster the American people have freely elected. I am very concerned that Mr. Trump is mentally unstable and that suspicion troubles me greatly. JVK
JVK,
“Freely elected”? Ask Vlad.
Vlad the Impaler?
Speaking of Vlad, guess that call with Donald means full steam ahead: https://apnews.com/fc24e0dcf30c4535b9336d6c99ab2b36/7-troops-killed-in-fighting-in-eastern-Ukraine?utm_campaign=SocialFlow&utm_source=Twitter&utm_medium=AP
Yes, “freely elected” by those low-information folks who honestly believed P.T. Barnum. One of the prices of Democracy, at Plato mentioned some time ago, was the cost of occasionally electing narcissistic and self-centered people by those who unwisely a) trusted CNN, CBS, etc, to put the country’s welfare ahead of their profits (as apparently Moonves and his ilk did not); b) remained unread and untutored enough and unable to distinguish between political BS and real debate; or c) foolishly lumped real politicians with frauds like The Donald.
One alternative to these kinds of elections is to turn over the nation to the Kochs and DeVos of the world, asking them to relieve us of the burden of our own political behaviors. The Republic will survive The Donald but we’ll go through a lot of pain while doing it. Much depends on just a few honest Republicans and a Democratic collective that will continue to fight over a long period of time without fading out. It seems foolish to blame Putin for being Putin. He and The Donald have, apparently together, identified some weak spots in our body politic, are exploiting it, and are depending on our own passivity to succeed. We can just as freely deny them their attempts by engaging in the process we should have done more of this fall, prior to November 2016. JVK
Add to the list. I never thought I would hear an inaugural address that said we have “an education system flush with cash, but which leaves our young and beautiful students deprived of knowledge.”
Never thought I would write that we have a dictator as the President of the United States. But I have.
Let us not insult Middle School Students or 13 Year Olds!
:0)
FDR said in his first inaugural address that the “Only thing we have to fear is fear itself.”
If we let fear muzzle our protesting voices and we hide and hope nothing will happen to us if we remain silent, then what we fear will become a reality much faster. In fact, it will be much worse than we feared.
“First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Socialist.
Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”
This attributed quotation points out the perils of relying on Wikipedia for historical accuracy. It is both wrong and ignores communists, who were the first victims of Nazi terror.
Pastor Niemöller never made the statement as it has been popularized. According to the Martin Niemöller Stiftung (Foundation), he spoke about this in Easter 1976 in a discussion with parishioners in Kaiserslautern. “It was not a poem, no.” according to Niemöller, who began his solitary confinement in a Nazi prison in 1937, a year before Kristallnacht, “…you see, when they began to lock up the communists, and we probably heard about that immediately, I don’t really remember, but we didn’t protest against it, because we lived for the church and the communists were, after all, no friends of the church, in fact the opposite, their declared enemies, and that’s why we remained silent. And then came the unions, and the unions were no friends of the church, and we had few dealings or absolutely had none and we said, let them fight out their own thing. There was no record or copy of what I said and it can absolutely be that I formulated it differently. But the idea was, in any event: The communists, that we also let pass quietly; and the unions, that we also let pass; and the social democrats we also let pass. That wasn’t, after all, our affair. Back then the church had absolutely nothing to do with politics and one shouldn’t have had anything to do with it. We in the confessional church categorically didn’t want to engage in any political resistance…This is only what I can say to that history with that: When they locked up the communists, no one said anything, we weren’t communists and were completely in agreement that we had these enemies off our necks. But we didn’t see ourselves with the duty to say anything about people outside of the church, that wasn’t in fashion then, and we weren’t that far along that we thought ourselves responsible for all the people.”
According to the Niemöller Foundation, “Niemöller [in this conversation] described the exact history. He didn’t name Catholics because they had their concordant [with the Vatican]. He couldn’t have cited Jews because the great wave of persecution began when he was already in the concentration camp. Various versions exist particularly in the USA, in some cases directly modified from Niemöller, some added on.” His second wife wrote [in original English]: “The trouble with Martin Niemoeller’s ‘famous quotation’ is that he never wrote it down – which enabled so many hitchhikers over the years to ‘put themselves on the waggon’ [sic]. In his ‘Confession of Guilt’ (as he called it himself: Schuldbekenntnis in German) the Communists came first, then the Trade Unionists and then the Socialists and then the Jews. NO ONE ELSE.”
Niemöller obviously dramatically changed his worldview while in confinement and it informed his subsequent life. But as he readily confessed, history is not as poetic as we sometimes like to think. http://martin-niemoeller-stiftung.de/martin-niemoeller/was-sagte-niemoeller-wirklich#more-212
whatever you say … whatever you say … whatever you say …. whatever you say …. water you say …
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whatever_You_Say
I never thought that I’d have to write that the IPOTUS, who received five draft deferments, signed an an anti-immigration edict in front a backdrop that honors America’s highest award for valor, the Medal of Honor at the Pentagon. Sadly, I have.
And this POTUS demeaned and insulted POWs when he was in campaign mode. He called them losers, people like John McCain. Not that I am a fan of McCain’s politics but the man did survive 5 years of torture and abuse. Trump survived military school.
I have voted for the Democratic presidential candidate all of my voting life but if ever a person “deserved” to be elected to the presidency it was/is John McCain. If he hadn’t had Sarah Palin foisted on him as a running mate I would have voted for him.
If I had been in the room when Trump said what he said about John McCain being a loser, I would probably have been taken down by whatever security personnel were there. I could not believe the audacity of the fool. I really thought (naively) that the Republicans would shun him but apparently he is untouchable.
I never thought that I would live in a country with a corrupted government, but I do.
I never thought that I would survive a shipwreck once, but twice, but I did.
I never thought that I could graduate from an University in North America, but I did.
I never thought that I would live to witness HIGH authority in academe that becomes a puppet for the corporate, but I did, NOT ONLY in USA, but on the world as a whole.
I never thought that God would bless the BAD over the GOOD on Earth so long and so far beyond the reasonable DOUBT, but GOD did.
In short, all conscientious people should unite to pray for a curse on CERTAIN terminal ill disease that will capture the BAD sooner – It will work magically at our own expense of course. There is nothing for free on Earth, include being honest, compassionate, and forgiving. Everything has its own STIFF PRICE. Back2basic
Thank you, as always, May King, for your inspiration.
“If you’re trying to talk to someone who doesn’t seem to be listening, or to be fully coherent, or who switches premises in mid-conversation, or who even conjures up falsehoods without shame, there comes a point when you’re inclined to give up. If the dialogue approaches the Full Orwell (“War is peace,” “Freedom is slavery,” and all that), your instinctive reaction might be as simple as speechlessness. At least for the moment—if we’re lucky, a relatively fleeting moment in the course of human history—something close to disbelief may define the reaction to the nation’s newest President, Donald J. Trump.
After less than two weeks of making stuff up (about crowd size, the popular-vote count); of trying to haphazardly shatter complex, imperfect legislation such as the Affordable Care Act; of scaring the bejesus out of America’s European friends while pushing around Mexico, a regional ally (the shoving of Mexico may be a favorite Trump negotiation ploy); of upending America’s essential role as a land of hope and refuge, while insulting the Muslim world; of vandalizing seventy years of world leadership; of altering the dynamic of the National Security Council, established during the Truman Administration, by adding his ideological counsellor while making optional the attendance of the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Director of Central Intelligence, respectful attention was already difficult. Rather, whenever Trump emotes by tweet, or gives an interview to Sean Hannity or anyone else, it calls to mind the expressive phrase “rendered speechless,” which captures something inexpressible.
It’s an idea conveyed particularly well in Victorian prose, as in (a real quotation, from a forgotten Englishman of that era) “At first he was appalled and rendered speechless by her sudden appearance—now his emotion was of a suffocating nature—he felt as though he should choke unless he could utter a cry.”
http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/speechless-the-trump-effect?mbid=nl_013117_Daily&CNDID=45272181&spMailingID=10338194&spUserID=MTgwNzgwOTcyMzEyS0&spJobID=1082574209&spReportId=MTA4MjU3ND