State Commissioner of Education MaryEllen Elia announced that only one school in the state had failed to meet the arbitrary benchmarks she set. It is J.H.S. 162 Lola Rodriguez De Tio.
Elia is directing NYC Chancellor Carmen Fariña to take dramatic action.
“J.H.S. 162 did not hit its targets, the State Education Department announced Wednesday afternoon. That means schools Chancellor Carmen Fariña has 60 days to appoint an outside entity, such as a school improvement expert or nonprofit, to oversee the school. The city could also decide to close or merge the school.
“Each persistently struggling school had to make at least 40 percent progress on a “demonstrable improvement index” to avoid independent receivership — and J.H.S. 162 reached 38 percent, missing some indicators by less than one point.”
So the school may be closed because it missed Elia’/ goals by less than a point.
Here’s an idea.
Elia should take control of the school, personally. Don’t give it to a charter chain or some turnaround firm. Let Elia do it. She set the goals. She should show the rest of the state what she can do. JHS 162 is on her conscience. Let her take responsibility for fixing it.

Having Elia take control of the school is an excellent idea! It makes sense for someone with a public stake in the school’s success to put some skin in the game. Why would you walk away and turn the corporate profiteers loose on them if they’re struggling?
LikeLike
If they fired everyone in business who didn’t make their targets, the business world would be in a mess. And to miss by less than a point deserves praise for improvement and encouragement for the following year, not dismantlement. Or perhaps a thorough analysis of WHY they didn’t reach this arbitrary target number. My guess is that there is a large population of ELLs.
A new model won’t fix unreasonable expectations.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Elia and Farina should take the school over together.
LikeLike
“Elia should take control of the school, personally. ”
Like.
LikeLike
Absolutely if Commissioner Elia is an expert at these things, I implore her to take control of this school and show us lowly teachers how to fix it.
LikeLike
I love this idea!!! It reminds me of when a fellow, excellent teacher was being given suggestions (requirements) by yet another consultant: “So when can I schedule you to come in and conduct a series of demonstration lessons?”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sadly many teachers have learned the hard way that pushing consultants — or coaches, facilitators, evaluators, supervisors, specialists, managers, and/or any suddenly-hired administrators — to actually physically demonstrate the “requirements” being pushed onto teachers most often only ends up with a “Teacher is Negative” note being placed onto her/his evaluation.
LikeLike
YEP!
LikeLike
Yeah Good idea. I won’t hold my breath… and if I know Carmen ( although I hope she proves me wrong) …she will find a charter schools to replace it.
LikeLike
Is there a case where a school take over was a success?
LikeLike
Let’s see:
A junior high school (prime age for orderly conduct)
Located in the South Bronx section of New York City (not exactly Trump Towers territory, folks)
Needs a two point “giddy-up”.
Go figure!
Heads will and must roll!
Nothing that corporate America shouldn’t be able to fix.
I’d rather put Cuomo in charge of and accountable for a swift turnaround. Elias could be his AP.
LikeLike