Andrew Cuomo can put one notch on his belt. Carol Burris is stepping down. He better have a very big belt because his hatred for teachers eill drive out many from the profession. who will replace? Does he care? The much-honored principal of South Side High School in Rockville Center decided to retire early because of Cuomo’s punitive law. Morally and ethically, she could not continue to work in the environment he has created.
She said:
“We are now turning our backs on the very experiences that build on our children’s natural strengths in order to pursue higher test scores in this era of corporate reform. We have become blind to indicators of quality that can’t be demonstrated on a scan sheet.
“The opinions of billionaires and millionaires who send their own children to private schools awash in the arts hold more sway than those of us who have dedicated our lives to teaching children. In the words of our chancellor [Merryl Tisch], we who object are “noise.”
“Much to the dismay of Albany, the noise level is on the rise since the passage of a new teacher evaluation system that elevates the role of testing. I am not sure why I was shocked when the legislature actually adopted the nonsensical evaluation plan designed by a governor who is determined to break the spirit of teachers, but I was. What is even more shocking is the legislature’s refusal to admit what they did, which was to create a system in which 50 percent of a teacher’s evaluation is based on test scores. Whether that denial comes from ignorance or willful deceit doesn’t matter. It is inexcusable.
“What will happen to our profession is not hard to predict. Since the state has generated student “growth” scores, the scores of 7 percent of all elementary and middle school principals are labeled ineffective. Likewise, 6-7 percent of Grades 4-8 teachers of English Language Arts and math received ineffective growth scores. That is because the metrics of the system produce a curve.
“Based on the law, we know before even one test is given that at least 7 percent of teachers and principals, regardless of their supervisors’ opinion, will need to be on an improvement plan. They will be labeled either developing or ineffective. We have no idea what growth scores for high school teachers and teachers of the arts will look like — that has been, in the words of Assemblywoman Pat Fahy, “punted” to a State Education Department. Yes, they [state lawmakers] have turned the football over to the folks whom they publicly berate for the botched rollout of the Common Core.
“Well, the legislature has woken a sleeping giant. Around the state today parents are saying “no more.” The robust opt-out movement, which began on Long Island, has now spread across rural and suburban areas in upstate New York as well. Over 75 percent of the students in Allendale Elementary School in West Seneca refused the Common Core tests today. In the Dolgeville district, the number is 88 percent. Over 70 percent of the students in the Icabod Crane Elementary and Middle School refused. On Long Island, 82 percent of Comsewogue students, 68 percent of Patchogue Medford students and 61 percent of Rockville Centre students opted out of the tests. And that is but a sample.
“This is happening because the bond between students and teachers is understood and valued by the parents we serve. They have no stomach for the inevitable increased pressures of testing. Through opt out, they are speaking loud and clear.”
“She is not going away. She was already a leader in the battle against corporate reform. She has written many posts for Valerie Strauss’s “Answer Sheet” blog at the Washington Post. She will write more. Now she is joining the fight to save children and public education from corporate raiders full-time. Hers will be an experienced, wise voice in the fight for democratic public education.

If Carol Burris runs for governor now that she’ll be retiring, I would vote for her, campaign for her, and even change my political party for her to help her get elected.
LikeLike
I want to put in a bid. LAUSD would shape up if Carol would move her family to So. California and be our Superintendent. She would get back to the wonderful weather and educators who would revere her.
LikeLike
Diane,
the time has come for a nationwide teacher “sick out”. The politicians won’t change anything until educators take a unified stand against the deformers.
I purpose a date in the first week of May (or a day that interrupts any form of testing) and every teacher stays home and then keep their kids home with them. If there are not any teachers or students to test then maybe the politicians will wake up. Being sick may have to last the rest of the school year.
There is will be millions of students running the streets and creating havoc, parents and communities will begin to complain, and then finally change.
Yes is bold and on a very large scale but something has to be done.
If people are out of sick days, then maybe we plan for it at the start of school next fall.
LikeLike
Take all of May and June. My kids don’t seem to do much in school after the tests have finished, and this would open up some summer camp opportunities.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow, nasty. I don’t see this in my kid’s public school at all. Instead, they do science, social science, reading, math but the one thing they aren’t doing is test prep.
LikeLike
In fairness, I’m referring to my experience with elementary school. This year will be the first May and June I’ll have seen for middle school. Hopefully it will be different.
It makes sense that the post-test months would be a dead zone, though. When the tests have this much importance, everything after must feel anticlimactic. Or at best, like a two-month digression followed by a “Now, where were we?”
LikeLike
By the way, I don’t happen to agree with a sick out myself. I think the opt out movement is doing the job.
LikeLike
I do not think people care. Education just isn’t a priority.
LikeLiked by 1 person
People don’t care or educators don’t care?
LikeLike
Agree with you MathVale…most people here do not have a clue about education issues, and say if they have no kids, or their children are grown, they have no interest…and I find this attitude and slovenly thinking even permeating my university colleagues. It is infuriating.
LikeLike
I don’t think every teacher would walk out on May 1st, but if the Opt Out movement is any indication, the number of teachers that might walk out would be impressive and worth the effort.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Connecticut needs a new Commissioner of Education. Maybe Ms. Burris can come and save us before Malloy destroys everything. Malloy is savvy, and is learning from NY. He delayed using the test scores for teacher evaluation, but when it happens it will count for 45%. The ADMIN evals will also be based on the standardized test scores. He has underfunded public schools, while increasing funding for charters, and despite pleas from many towns, he refused to put a moratorium on Charter expansion so they could be scrutinized more.
Malloy REALLY needs the kids to take the test this year!! He needs those predicted 60-70% failures to kick in so he can “turnaround” and hand off the schools to his reformer friends.
Please, Carol. Will you come here?http://www.sde.ct.gov/sde/lib/sde/pdf/commissioner_of_education_job_announcement.pdf
Malloy has big plans…as you can see by this posting for a DISTRICT AND SCHOOL TRANSFORMATION EDUCATION BUREAU CHIEF: http://das.ct.gov/HRDocs/JobsExams/793_for_DAS.pdf
LikeLike
She is doing an Obi Wan Kenobi . Her force will become stronger for this! Her statement is a powerful argument against the new education agenda.
LikeLike
A fierce and fearless tiger has been unleashed. Can’t wait to see hear her roar!
LikeLike
What a terrible loss, this wonderful educator and public advocate for schools and kids. Sorry to say that I witnessed other sterling principals like her driven out of NY schools b/c they were student-centered, before this recent private war on the public sector.
LikeLike
An amazing educator! She has my vote for any position in Albany. Thank you Carol Burris for your many years of integrity, courage and dedication to public education and children.
LikeLike
Oh, no! What Governor Cuomo is doing to education is monstrous.
LikeLike
I may live in Texas but when I read about what he’s doing to NY schools all I can think is Jimmy Hoffa!!
LikeLike
“In the words of our chancellor [Merryl Tisch], we who object are “noise.”
“Screaming Banshees”
The loudest noise we hear
Is Merryl Tisch, quite clear
A screaming banshee
From tall banan-tree
For teaching-bashing cheer
LikeLike
I listened to Burris debate the Common Core with two ed reform experts on the other side and it was really a pleasure to listen someone who wasn’t just repeating a set piece that they deliver for a living. She had thought about it and reached her own conclusions outside what have become to me familiar terms that seem to be almost terms of art with ed reformers: “accountability!” or “high standards!” or “low expectations!”. I don’t know if she won or lost the debate but she was the only person there who seemed to be speaking from personal, engaged experience.
LikeLike
Now she is free of any constraint, maybe she can be on a school board and fight even more effectively. If not, Thank you Carol, for all you have done for teachers, education, and most of all, the students blessed to be in your schools where their welfare still matters. From an old and sometimes tired former soldier and now teacher, I salute you and wish you God’s speed and blessings for all you have done.
LikeLike
Yes, but she will now have time to focus her considerable energy and intelligence AGAINST him. Andrew, beware Carol!!! She will now become his greatest nemesis!
LikeLike
She should be appointed NYS Commissioner of Education.
LikeLike
I left the principalship at Bovill Elementary School eleven years ago for basically the same reasons as Carol. Have been fighting high-stakes testing and negative school reforms ever since. Good to see some traction being gained in getting the public involved in the fray. Hopefully Carol will take a little time off to recharge the batteries and get back into the fight for preserving and improving our public schools.
LikeLike
All I can say is, please Carol don’t abandon us.
LikeLike
We ALL wanted you for Chancellor for the Board of Regents or the Secretary of Education, you could have been either of these with the support and acclaim you have deserved! Please, stay on board when we need you the most to save our schools. We can overcome this scam, we’re so close ! There are only so many people as astute as you.
LikeLike
My heart goes out to the NYC teachers. I know they have a strong AFT footprint, but this is horrible. I am a special education teacher and can’t imagine how the legislature thought to include us. This is definitely a blow to Public Education. Cuomo has shown his stripes against public education and democracy for all. I am saddened when stellar administrators who get it, feel they must leave in order to maintain their pride in their profession. I am also from a district who had a toxic superintendent who abused the teacher accountability state wide system, intimidated Principals (schools must discipline teachers since no staff can have all great teachers), spent district money in what appear to be self-serving manners, and pushed the district’s schools into a attendance program too soon and it continues to cost the district millions of dollars in expensive consultants who are trying to fix its frailties. These just to name a few of the horrible missteps he incurred (all expensive).. This all comes from a top down mentality that does not serve the students, the parents and least of all the teachers. This craziness must be halted or we will have a generation or two of students who have lost instructional time because they had to prep for the test (let alone the weeks of instruction that is lost to the actual testing time), don’t know where anything is in the country they live in (no geography), can’t play any instrument (no time for music or art), and have gained weight because their school is feeding them high carbohydrate foods (but everyone is eating), oops except for the high schoolers who just dump the “free” breakfast food after they pick it up (and of course elementary students shouldn’t have recess, it wastes time). Really my heart goes out to the NYC teachers and their students.
LikeLike
Jaspar,
I don’t understand what you are trying to get at with “I know they have a strong AFT footprint, but this is horrible.”
Please explain!
Gracias,
Duane
LikeLike
DID YOU EVER SEE THIS’ Grassroots movie. it is not short, but there it is…the blueprint for destruction. NYC was the largest district. LAUSD is the 2nd largest. The process works, and has been imported and improved upon, so no professional voice ever gets th pulpit.
Here is the result of the first attack on the teachers, before eVAM & PARCC, we were decimated, and the UFT stood by and did not enforce our contract for grievances.
http://www.perdaily.com/2011/01/lausd-et-al-a-national-scandal-of-enormous-proportions-by-susan-lee-schwartz-part-1.html
LikeLike
Carol Burris has shown what REAL leadership looks like -leadership, courage and class.
Anyone who hasn’t checked out the link above and read her eloquent speech…..well, it’s amazing. It truly is music to my ears.
LikeLike
And from the NY Times today, an ironic article, which you should read, http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/17/opinion/want-reform-principals-matter-too.html?emc=edit_tnt_20150417&nlid=50637717&tntemail0=y
titled: “Want Reform? Principals Matter, Too”: which begins ” POLITICIANS and education reformers are fixated on the performance of teachers, but they often overlook another key ingredient for improving student achievement: principals. …Great teachers are essential but not enough. They need to be led and developed by great principals. As the federal government, states and local districts work to turn around schools, we need to figure out how to get more people with the right training and support to take on one of the hardest jobs in America.”
What a loss when such as Carol leaves. I have known a few great administrators… too few.
LikeLike
Too bad she doesn’t anonymously leak a copy of the test to the press. @NYDNBenChapman told me the Daily News will publish the test if it is leaked to them. I’m sorry I don’t work in the public schools anymore, or I would.
>
LikeLike
” Whether that denial comes from ignorance or willful deceit doesn’t matter. It is inexcusable.”
“In retrospect, . . . it . . . was perfectly balanced — equal parts ignorance and arrogance.”
Jamie Vollmer
The Blueberry Story
Burris’s comments add a third component to Vollmer’s observation: deceit.
http://www.jamievollmer.com/blueberries.html
LikeLike
More and more of us are retiring, probably before we ever thought we would. It is sad for us, the kids, and the parents. It is just what those at the top want. They’ll replace us with someone cheaper and more malleable. I too could not continue to do things that I knew were wrong and hurtful to children. My teaching years numbered 34 and all except the most recent were creative and fulfilling.
LikeLike