Dawn Neely-Randall is a teacher in Ohio. She is in her 25th year in the classroom. For a long while, she watched in silence as the testing mania absorbed more and more instructional time. And then she decided she had to speak out. She had to defend her students. She had to defend her professional ethics. She could not remain silent. And speak she did. Here is an article that she wrote that appeared on Valerie Strauss’s blog.
If every state had 1,000 teachers as brave, bold, and outspoken as Dawn Neely-Randall, we could stop the insanity that is destroying children’s lives and debasing education. For her courage in speaking out, for her refusal to remain docile and silent, I add Dawn Neely-Randall to the honor roll.
Here are a few choice excerpts from her impassioned article.
“Last spring, you wouldn’t find the fifth-graders in my Language Arts class reading as many rich, engaging pieces of literature as they had in the past or huddled over the same number of authentic projects as before. Why? Because I had to stop teaching to give them a Common Core Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) online sample test that would prepare them for the upcoming PARCC pilot pre-test which would then prepare them for the PARCC pilot post test – all while taking the official Ohio Achievement Tests. This amounted to three tests, each 2 ½ hours, in a single week, the scores of which would determine the academic track students would be placed on in middle school the following year.”
“In addition to all of that, I had to stop their test prep lessons (also a load of fun) to take each class three floors down to our computer lab so they could take the Standardized Testing and Reporting (“STAR”) tests so graphs and charts could be made of their Student Growth Percentile (SGP) which would then provide quantitative evidence to suggest how these 10-year-olds would do on the “real” tests and also surmise the teacher’s (my) affect on their learning.
“Tests, tests, and more freakin’ tests.
“And this is how I truly feel in my teacher’s heart: the state is destroying the cherished seven hours I have been given to teach my students reading and writing each week, and these children will never be able to get those foundational moments back. Add to that the hours of testing they have already endured in years past, as well as all the hours of testing they still have facing them in the years to come. I consider this an unconscionable a theft of precious childhood time……”
“And most disconcerting of all, in my entire 24-year career, not one graded standardized test has EVER been returned to the students, their parents, or to me, the teacher. Also, for the past three years here in Ohio, released test questions have no longer been posted online. In addition, teachers have had to sign a “gag order” before administering tests putting their careers on the line ensuring they will not divulge any content or questions they might happen to oversee as they walk around monitoring the test.”
“Gag me with a test”
Gag me with a test?
Then throw me in the drink
That is for the best
At least my pride won’t sink
More than once I have posted in a comments thread the following phrase: “the tail of testing is wagging the dog of teaching and learning.”
Read the posting. Then think about it this way: the tail is getting to be so large, and the dog so ragged and thin, that learning and teaching is getting close to becoming nothing but the tail.
The dog hasn’t gone hunting. He’s ‘bout done gone and disappeared.
Somebody, please, find that dog. We’re missin’ him…
Really!
And CCSS and it conjoined twin, high-stakes standardized testing? Would we miss them?
Not Rheeally… not even in a Johnsonally sort of way.
😎
P.S. For those worried sick over the fate of OTHER PEOPLE’S CHILDREN, take a deep breath and rest easy, because when it comes to the self-styled “education reformers” and THEIR OWN CHILDREN, things are looking up.
For example, what delights—or horrors, depending on your POV—await the captive student population of Lakeside School? Bill Gates went there. His children go there.
Well, hold onto your seats, because just speaking of athletic activities for September 9-12, 2014:
Varsity Boys Golf, Varsity Girls Golf, JV Football, JV Volleyball, JV Girls Soccer, Varsity Girls Soccer, Varsity Girls Swimming & Diving, Varsity Football.
Some might say that the waste of time and effort and resources is astounding—if these were public schools for OTHER PEOPLE’S CHILDREN. And best/worst of all, many of these activities are occurring over and over again just within those four days.
And don’t get me started on September 13, 2014, when different boys and girls teams (almost all in grade level soccer teams) get their sweat flowing. 18 events in all. On one day.
Does anyone there care about all that wasted test prep time?
Not that I can see.
Double check the info by clicking on the link below.
Link: http://www.lakesideschool.org/athletics/calendar
I would issue a call for volunteers to rescue the little tykes from the unspeakable horrors they are facing, but my last calls for salvation squads have gone unanswered.
I fear the worst…they may actually be suffering from genuine and moving learning experiences.
😱
My daughter is so discouraged by the prioritizing of the “test” that she has come to hate school. She says all the teachers care about is “teaching to the test”. And no wonder since their very jobs depend on it. What a horrible waste of an opportunity to shape a young mind! Thank goodness for people like Dawn who speak up!
The test-em-til-they-drop policies foisted on students and teachers for over a decade are evidence of a pathological condition shared by all of the policy makers who are inflicting this stupidity on students and teacher in the name of “education” and under the cover stories of being “accountable” and caring about student learning.
The same pathology is present in the thinking of every policy maker and legislator who remains silent about the fraud of allowing an unregulated testing industry to be the dominant force (literally force) in American education.
The unethical use of tests and test scores is not only tolerated by federal and state officials, but brazenly hardwired into policies as if there is nothing wrong or immoral in these do-it-my-way-or-else-you-are-fired policies.
Our system of education is being militarized by the unrelenting use of tests and test scores as if these are the be-all and end-all of education.
Militarism is expressed in the excessive use of “rigor” and “rigorous” as if these characteristics of physical and mental discipline are always virtues, not the central focus of life in boot camps.
Don’t let the phrase “impacting student growth” pass by without thinking about the meanings of “growth” and “impact.” Teachers should not “impact” students. Teachers should influence students, and not just by rewards and punishments for grades, but through their expertise, the respect they earn, the feelings they engender in their students, among these being loved and supported as a learner and human being.
Teachers should not be asked to set “targets” for student learning. They should not think of their work as a matter of deploying the right strategies and tactics for reaching those targets. The metaphors are wrong, wrong, wrong for the nurture of thoughtful professional judgment and for teaching children and teens.
Teachers should not be subjected to a top down command and control system that include endless “trainings,” “audits,” “calibrations,” “interventions,” and related quests for total compliance with rules. These activities and the language describing them are NOT perfectly natural and appropriate for educating children and young people.
USDE should be outraged that its hired hands in communications tell state and district leaders to use “teacher swat teams” to induce fellow teachers to comply and conform to policies. “Swat team” is police and military language. It is wrong in concept and in language for education. Reform Support Network (2012). Engaging educators: A reform support network guide for states and districts. Retrieved from www2.ed.gov/about/inits/ed/implementation-support-unit/tech-assist/engaging-educators.pdf p. 9
I am not arguing for language police. I am asserting that this language is too often taken as if it is perfectly natural and normal for speaking about teaching and learning. It is not. It is not just benign jargon of the day.
All you need to do is spend some time in schools to see that they are becoming a hostile workplace for teachers and for too many students a place filled with a dread of tests rather than the joy of learning.
Enough is enough. It is past time to call for Congressional investigations into the conduct of policy makers, the testing companies, and the “communicators” hired by USDE to aid and abet this fraud and madness.
Sherrod Brown is responsive to constituents. I see he’s in the photo with her. She could actually get a fair hearing from him, I think. Write him a letter. Generally, they respond to letters better than other forms of communication.
I object that we’re not telling the test-takers the truth. She admits that the kids will be tracked into middle school based on the tests. That’s true. The least we could do is admit it.
They know anyway. A person, any person, could not be surrounded by this 180 days a year and NOT KNOW. That’s ridiculous and insulting to them. Of course they know. School is where they spend all their time.
Tell them this: “adults in this country decided that these tests are vitally important, and we that’s why we use them to measure your school, your teachers and you”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2014/09/05/teacher-no-longer-can-i-throw-my-students-to-the-testing-wolves/
I’m sure she knows this, but she could also write to this person:
http://stateimpact.npr.org/ohio/2014/09/03/city-club-republican-ohio-senator-peggy-lehner-on-public-education-in-ohio/
I don’t think she’ll get a fair hearing there, the speech is ed reform boilerplate, but if you watch the Q and A the lawmaker gets a VERY inconvenient question from a parent on why lower income schools get all the inexperienced TFA teachers 🙂
“If every state had 1,000 teachers as brave, bold, and outspoken as Dawn Neely-Randall, we could stop the insanity that is destroying children’s lives and debasing education.”
We don’t own presses. Maybe we need one.
I have sent out articles that have not been published.
Yes, some of us are going to have to lose our jobs. It would be best if that was taken up by teachers who can afford to, which most can’t. But there are some.