Great news! The sponsor of the Florida voucher bill withdrew it, as it sailed through the Florida House, after the State Senate insisted that voucher schools would have to take state tests.
“After promising a “massive expansion” of school choice options this session, House Speaker Will Weatherford retooled his rhetoric Thursday after the Senate dropped plans to take up a proposed build-up of the state’s private school voucher program.
“Sen. Bill Galvano, R-Bradenton, said he was withdrawing his version (SB 1620) of the voucher bill advancing in the House. At least part of the dispute is rooted in Senate President Don Gaetz’s demand that students taking part in the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship program undergo testing in private schools similar to that in public schools.
“It’s a shame. A terrible shame,” Weatherford said. “Thousands of children seeking more opportunities for a better life will be denied. I cannot see any reason why we’d quit on these kids.”
“The bill (HB 7099) sailing through the House would make the scholarship program eligible for sales tax money for the first time in its 12-year history. With the new cash, the 60,000 students now getting private-school scholarships could double in four years, rivaling the size of larger public school districts in Florida.”
There was also criticism of the political payola that the expansion would bestow on the voucher program’s administrators:
“The Palm Beach Post also reported that there was rising criticism of what the legislation would mean to the politically connected nonprofit that oversees the scholarship program, created under former Gov. Jeb Bush.
“Step Up for Students could more than triple the amount of money it collects under the voucher legislation. The 3 percent fee it collects now brings in $8.6 million but could more than triple to $26.2 million when the program reached its full capacity envisioned under the legislation.”

Looks like you are making inroads, Diane! All over!!
LikeLike
Excellent news.
If voucher students are not required to take state tests, the voucher program could gain popularity for no other reason than as a means for students to escape the tests– and the exodus would contribute to that “payola” to Jeb’s voucher “nonprofit.” (Irony to call reform orgs “nonprofits.)
LikeLike
Do the 60,000 students currently getting vouchers take the state tests?
LikeLike
“Step Up for Students could more than triple the amount of money it collects under the voucher legislation. The 3 percent fee it collects now brings in $8.6 million but could more than triple to $26.2 million when the program reached its full capacity envisioned under the legislation.”
The State of Florida doesn’t even distribute the taxpayer money directly? They funnel it thru a Jeb Bush deal?
Good Lord. Why don’t they all just resign from these jobs as “lawmakers” and turn the whole thing over to private entities. It would really be more honest at this point. All they’re doing is writing checks to private contractors anyway. Turn the statehouse into a museum and we’ll hire an accounting and auditing firm to distribute payments to a list of contractors and we’ll call that “public education”.
LikeLike
“The State of Florida doesn’t even distribute the taxpayer money directly? They funnel it thru a Jeb Bush deal?”
Why am I not surprised??
LikeLike
http://www.stepupforstudents.org/
“We Provide Scholarships for Low Income Students”
There’s just no indication that it’s even a state program.
“Donate now for corporate tax credits”
They have a page to plug the corporate “contributions” and then in smaller print it says “tax credit donors”
I guess “choice” means corporations get to “choose” which publicly-funded schools they have to pay for. Wonderful. This will end well.
LikeLike
This is a funny piece on how Ohio’s voucher bill was lifted directly off the School Choice website:
“Lawmakers interested in drafting legislation to support school choice should review model legislation on the Alliance for School Choice Web site, http://www.AllianceForSchoolChoice.org. Each bill is approved by the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) and supported by the Alliance for School Choice, the Milton and Rose D. Friedman Foundation, and the Institute for Justice.”
Directly below that excerpt in the document is a list of different school choice bills that are available. Sadly, it’s not difficult to identify the one Ohio’s state representative selected. Not only did Huffman not care to earn his pay by changing the text of the bill, he wouldn’t even bothered by coming up with an original title.
Huffman’s voucher program: Parental Choice and Taxpayer Savings Scholarship Program (LSC analysis of original HB136)
ALEC voucher program: The Parental Choice Scholarship Program Act (ALEC template)
I love how “the lawmaker” added the two words “taxpayer savings” to the title of the Friedman Foundation title 🙂
http://www.inthepublicinterest.org/article/ohio-school-voucher-bill-hand-delivered-koch-funded-alec
LikeLike
Bravo! Now if we could just have that same success here in Arizona…..ALEC or someone seems to propose all these bills across the country, now maybe we can strike ’em down all across the country too!
LikeLike
The parents of Florida worked wonders.
LikeLike
I am shocked! Isn’t accountability the secret magic to fix all that ails us? Why wouldn’t the want more of it? Testing and common core rigor are going to save us, how can they let kids escape? This is wrong!
LikeLike
This is a victory for Common Sense and fairness. Why would anyone think that charter school students should NOT be subjected to the same rigorous testing measures that traditional public schools face?
Charter proponents espouse that charter schools are public schools and obviously they use public funds. Demand the same rigorous evaluations that public schools face. Give the charter schools a public grade and share charter school testing results on the front page of the newspaper just like we do with traditional public schools. What is there to fear but the truth?
This is one small victory; but charter school opponents should not rest as I am sure the charter foxes are still spreading money all around the henhouse!
LikeLike
“Why would anyone think that charter school students should NOT be subjected to the same rigorous testing measures that traditional public schools face?”
If I may change what you have written to a more cogent critique:
“Why would anyone think that ALL students should NOT be subjected to the same INVALID and UNETHICAL testing measures that traditional public school STUDENTS face (NOT TO MENTION THE SANCTIONS PLACED ON TEACHERS AND SCHOOLS)?
LikeLike
Reblogged this on One Teacher's Voice and commented:
Success! It’s a baby step in he right direction.
LikeLike
So great to see Floridians fighting back! Just a teeny sliver of sunlight (i.e. FCAT for all students) is enough to send the voucher roaches a-scurrying back to their ALEC hidey-holes.
The Palm Beach Post reports the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship Program can spend up to $286 million this year. Charity Navigator shows that for the fiscal year ending June 2012, Step Up for Students had net assets of $216,579,435.
So shameful to see funds that should be going to the commons ending up in the pockets of privateers, including those who preach bigotry under the guise of religion.
LikeLike
“Just a teeny sliver of sunlight (i.e. FCAT for all students). . . ”
If you consider “FCAT for all students” a “teeny sliver of sunlight” then I’ve got some great ocean front property down at Lake of the Ozarks in central Missouri to sell you quite inexpensively. Lots are going fast. Call now.
LikeLike
Duane, the only reason I refer to FCAT as “sliver of sunlight” is because private schools funded by vouchers now would be subjected to the same accountability measures that public schools are subjected to. I like to think of accountability as sunlight and disinfectant. Perhaps it was a poor choice of words in reference to FCAT, but the voucher supporters are like cockroaches. Once the demand that they too, be subjected to the same glare of “accountability” forced upon the public schools, the voucher roaches went scurrying.
As far as FCAT and the rest of the high-stakes testing goes, these annual rites of testing hell destroy children’s innate love of learning, as well as teaching careers. I am no fan of those tests, and it pains me to see frustrated high schoolers quickly fill in random bubbles to get the test over with. Meanwhile, our jobs are at stake over test scores..
BTW, both gubernatorial candidates in Illinois are eyeing lakefront property in the Ozarks – right next door to Arne’s and Barack’s summer homes.
LikeLike