Thomas Jefferson famously said in a letter to John Adams in 1815, “I cannot live without books.” (Ever the worker bee, he added, “but fewer will suffice where amusement, and not use, is the only future object.”)
Neither can I. Yes, yes, I know we are supposed to read everything online, download books, and so forth, but I have a problem with that. When I use my Kindle, I turn the page and find that I have turned 40 or 80 pages, and I can’t get back to the place I left off.
But it’s more than the bother of learning a new technology that is a problem for me.
I like the feel of books in my hands. I like to mark the books I own. I underline phrases and sentences. I put asterisks next to wonderful lines. I handle my books. I like to touch them.
I like to buy new books, old books, rare books.
But there is something else I realize that I cannot live without, and that’s a dog.
I always had dogs, and for about ten years I had two dogs. I loved having two of them, walking them together on the streets of New York City. One was a Tibetan Terrier and the other was a cocker spaniel. They were both blondes. People used to ask me if they were sisters, and I would say, “Yes, but they had different parents.”
Molly, the Tibetan, died in 2010, after a long and terrible bout with lymphoma. Lady, the cocker spaniel, died in 2011 after three years of diabetes.
I thought I would not get another dog and would try to be happy with a cat. The cat is lively, and I never have to walk him. When it rains or snows or gets bitter cold, I am glad to stay indoors.
But guess what? I have a new puppy. She is a huge mutt, a mix of Newfoundland, Lab, Akita, and a few other breeds as well.
My family thought I was spending too many hours at the computer, and they conspired to make me get out.
The answer: a dog. She makes me get out and walk. A lot..
The new girl is all black with white paws. Her name is Mitzi, short for Mittens, because her paws have mittens.
She has a thick, almost waterproof coat. She is big and growing. She will one day be 60-70 pounds, maybe more.
I never had such a big dog.
The dog and the cat play together constantly, never hurting one another.
If the dog gets too rough, the cat jumps to a higher plane.
Mitzi has a gentle and calm disposition. At the moment, her job is to chew.
She chews bones and hooves and anything else that catches her eye, such as my arm and wrist.
As I said, I cannot live without books, and I cannot live without a dog.

I must agree. Books and critters are essential! Enjoy both! 🙂
LikeLike
Amen, I love my two dogs also. They are work but they also are a calming influence after a hard day at work. They demand attention while I’d rather cool out but what are you going to do, quid pro quo.
LikeLike
I enjoy both every day! I also love walking into a used book store or library just for the smell of the pages. Yes, I smell books. I love the feel, the warmth, and companionship they have given me. But I have aged. I can no longer comfortably read in bed, my glass gouge my face. So I turned to my Kindle and cranked up that font size and now I’m reading in bed again, sans glasses! I was so happy I almost cried; I did have tears in my eyes. As much as we accommodate for our students, we also must extend that to ourselves. We evolve as humans and we have the tools to help us adjust and keep our quality of life. These are the gifts we can give to ourselves…. as well as belly rubs for our besties!
LikeLike
Where the job description stops at amusement, a cat will suffice, but if you want loyal companionship you have to upgrade to dog.
Like you, I have the luxury of taking my black dawg to work, so all 70 pounds of him is within 100 yards except for hours each year. Truly my best friend.
Bigger IS better. You made a good choice.
LikeLike
Congratulations on your new addition. I also could not imagine living without a dog. They are loyal companions who lift our mood and help us to focus on what is simple, good and true.
I have a kindle fire and love it. It lets me highlight and annotate, but does not replace my books. I often have both a book and a kindle version of the same book. The kindle lets me read in the dark and allows me to travel with ALL of my reading materials. I just finished Moby Dick which I somehow avoided reading until now. The kindle tricked me into forgetting how many pages I still had to go, let me highlight the almost Shakespearean passages, and hid the title from prying eyes in waiting rooms and public places. Of course I also had a paperback version I kept and read and will return to my classroom library where it hopefully will be passed on to a student. I love both, the tactile pleasure and easy sharing of the bound volume and the immediacy and ease of the kindle.
LikeLike
I cannot live without books, dogs, chocolate, Chardonnay and Diane’s daily posts! 🙂
LikeLike
Amen!!
LikeLike
Like Julia Child, I cannot live without gin and red meat, to go with my books and my wire fox terrier.
Congratulations, Diane, on your new pup, many years of joy!
LikeLike
I am a long-time follower of your work and am extremely grateful for all you do to advance the debate on improving educational opportunities for all of our children. Now I find out that you are also a dog lover too – it just gets better and better. I currently share a home with two cats, a rabbit, a Jack Russell Terrier and a 14 year-old deaf and blind blonde cocker spaniel and cannot imagine my life without them/
LikeLike
Many students would agree with you, Dr. Ravitch, and prefer to hold a book in their hands when reading …
For Many Students Print is Still King …
http://chronicle.com/article/For-Many-Students-Print-Is/136829/
LikeLike
I had a terrible week at school and my dog died. That was the motivation I needed to quit and have more time to finish my dissertation on the effects of high stakes testing. I work part time at a vet clinic which gives me my animal fix for now, but I do want to get two dogs soon.
LikeLike
Everyone should have a dog to provide unconditional love and a cat to remind us that, aside from our ability to open cans, we’re really not all that special.
LikeLike
Somehow your comment strikes me as very “Vermont.” I am sending it to my Vermont relatives for reaction. I quietly chuckled.
LikeLike
Even Diane Ravich has to find balance! Nice blog and it made me smile.
LikeLike
You don’t know how much you miss them until they’re not there. We have a dog and a cat also.
LikeLike
This is wonderful news, Diane ! We are about the same age & I just had both of my knees replaced (at the same time!). Years of teaching on concrete floors may have done them in. My constant companion is a 70ish lb Weimaraner/Chocolate Lab mix, who is 8 years young. She is responsible for my quick rehabilitation & great spirit. Walking – especially away from the computer – is a very important activity. Just watching her run with such joy in the dog park gives me hope that things are not as bad as they seem.
BTW, I had a black Labrador who came to public school with me every day for 10 years (in the 70’s in CT). The parents even built a run, house & fenced-in yard on the school property. She brought peaceful joy – especially during reading times with the 6 year olds who loved & cherished books.
Thank you for all of your insight. I look forward to your posts & am so happy that you have Mitzi in your life.
LikeLike
really nice post. I could see mitzi and the cat–and then yu trudging through the snow with the new one on the leash. thanks for the lite and dear post
LikeLike
Play is definitely important for a young dog’s development, but it’s never too early to start preparing Mitzi for her future.
LikeLike
flerper: just the right number of pertinent words coupled with an illuminating graphic.
Bases-clearing hit. A four-bagger.
Props.
🙂
BTW, has some testing company begun developing a CAT [Canine Achievement Test] or ACT [Animal Competency Test]?
Inquisition, er, inquiring minds want to know so we don’t get left out of all the educational excellence that leads to $ucce$$ in this most innovaty Century21…
🙂
LikeLike
One of my favorite Diane Ravitch posts. We have had two mutts, both of whom lived to be 15. I blamed the death of the first one for my 15 pound weight gain because I didn’t walk as much without him. We were determined NOT to get another, but while my son was in law school the third found him. He, like Mitzi, is the largest of the three -75 pound Malamute mix. But he is a gentle giant, and I think because he lived on the street for a while (this thought still brings tears to my eyes), he is very, very appreciative of his new cushy life. Because of work schedules, etc. the pooch Iives with us. He must look have a special look because we get many “what a beautiful dog!” as we go for our daily walks. All three dogs have left their own marks in our lives.
As for books – there is no substitute for the real thing. I still have. Hard time giving away even the latest best seller I have read.
As always, thanks for this great insight.
Jeannie
LikeLike
Congrats, Diane! And what a lovely post!
LikeLike
Diane, I can definitely relate to the walking! I am currently fostering a sweetheart of a dog from a local shelter. He’s looking for a forever home and is listed at Kent Animal Shelter’s website on Long Island.(Scotty Boy) A perfect adoptive momma or papa for him is a retired teacher, with a fenced yard, who doesn’t travel as often as I do. A quiet home, without pets, commotion or children would give this little couch cuddler a wonderful life. He hasn’t had it easy, and trust doesn’t come easy, but he will melt a heart if given a chance. If interested, contact the shelter, and they’ll arrange a dog meeting.
Dogs certainly do leave paw prints on your heart! Congrats on your new addition, Diane! And thanks for letting me share this with the most caring group of people in the world, teachers!
LikeLike
Congratulations Diane! I’ve had a dog since I was very young, and we have a “German Shepherd” mutt from the local pound now, along with a cat that likes to clean the dog by licking it. My dad and I built a dog house for my first dog, and I believe it still exists back home. We built it big enough for both the dog and I to go in.
My nephew was a lover of books. He was also smart and a little different from most. He was the first home-schooled student in WV to graduate from high school. He went on to college at Guilford in NC, but suffered from depression most of his young life. He started a book store near Guilford, and became an expert on rare books. In fact, Antique Roadshow asked him to be their rare books person, but he turned them down because he didn’t want to have to drag his dog around with him to all the different shows. He committed suicide at age 29 several years ago, due to his depression and alcoholism. My brother-in-law, a sculptor, made his gravestone in the shape of a book.
LikeLike
I like you even more now. Dogs have been a very big part of my life. When my alcoholic father was verbally abusive when I was a child, our dog Lucky, was the one I could turn to. He loved me unconditionally and didn’t call me names. When I had cancer at 48, my dog never left my side. When I completed chemo, he was diagnosed with lung cancer. The Vet didn’t know how he had survived so long. I know he survived for me. Now I am retired, I have a boxer named Max. He is a great comfort to our whole family after losing Jeff. My daughter’s dog is also here, as she and her husband are living with my son and I until she finishes her certification for Montessori. She is a little pug, who loves to sit by my side while I read or blog. Last year, while teaching, I asked Anthony, who told me his mom was drinking again, if he had a dog. I told him to tell all his problems to the dog. The dog would love him no matter what. I hope that helped him. Anyway, I am so happy you have another dog. Thanks for sharing.
LikeLike
No doubt you have heard this old line:
Outside of a dog a book is man’s best friend. Inside of a dog it’s too dark to read.
LikeLike
So how did we all get this love of reading? My mom had a lot to do with it for me. She took us seven kids to the local library each week or so to get a book to read. I read something like 120 books in 2nd grade because of that. I loved reading Tarzan and Hardy Boys and other adventure books.
Now I read more online than I ever did before, but I wish I had time to read more books. I have a stack of good ones to read at home. Maybe in the summer…
LikeLike
I still remember the excitement of getting my own library card, which was earned when I learned how to read. Does anyone else remember Dick, Jane, Sally, Spot and Puff?
LikeLike
Oh, yes! Despite the overly-controlled vocabulary and the wholesome family who could never have lived in my blue collar town, I loved reading those books. I actually started collecting them a while ago for old time’s sake.
LikeLike
They both bring us JOY:) Not fear and intimidation:(
LikeLike
This is truly wonderful to hear. I am happy for you. A former student of mine calls his white footed cat, Leuka, from “Leukopodes.” As they say in DC, “If you want a friend in Washington, get a dog.”
LikeLike
I love it! Congratulations on the new addition to your family…
LikeLike
I currently have two cats, litter mates, who have been with us for 13 years. They were with us back when we raised sheep. No more sheep, but they still insist on eating at 4:30 a.m., the time we would feed them before we went out to the barns. They make up for this major annoyance, though.
LikeLike
If you want to see a couple adorable pictures of Diane’s sweet Mitzi, go to her Twitter page: http://twitter.com/DianeRavitch
Diane, I’m surprised you didn’t include the pictures here on your blog.
LikeLike
I don’t know how to import photos.
This is the twitter URL: http://t.co/IBP5PS8MHN
LikeLike
If you have digital photos on your computer or on a disk, you can upload them to WordPress into your Media Library.
To do add photos to your Media Library, in the left panel, click Media and then click Add New. Then you can either drag and drop the photos from your desktop or you can click Select Files and locate them on your computer.
To add the photos to your Pages or Posts, select the correct page or post and place your cursor in the textbox where you want the picture to go. Then, above the textbox to the left, click where it says Add Media and select from the pictures you placed in your Media Library. Then click Insert into Post on the bottom right.
If you do this in the tab that says Visual on the top right above the textbox, you can then see the photos, but if you do it in the tab that says Text, you’ll just see html code so click the Visual tab and you’ll see the photos.
Hope this helps!
LikeLike
I have the free version of WordPress and I’m hoping your version functions in a similar manner.
LikeLike
BTW, you should be able to crop and resize your images in the Media Library by clicking edit and playing with the tools there, such as scale to resize. Click Update to save.
LikeLike
Congratulations on your adoption of Mitzi. In these crazy times when we worry about our very precious kids–their learning and their voices, their welfare and their autonomy, their present and their futures–a dog could be just the right choice of a companion to help us sort things out in this of profit seeking, power scheming world. Unconditional love. Silent empathy. Loyalty. Boisterous joy. Intuitive sniffing and wagging. Problems chewed on and chomped down to size and out of existence. Tongue-hanging-out fun and mischief. Companionable nearby breathing. A warm furry foot rest to comfort us at the end of a day. Yup. Maybe a dog could help us find a way to set things right in this world.
LikeLike
I wonder if Bill Gates or Rupert Murdoch has a dog….it might help.
LikeLike
My sentiments as well. Many thanks for all you are doing.
LikeLike
Wonderful
LikeLike
I find it difficult to keep up with you, but I do try __ with joy!! Along with all your work and passion, I am delighted to know that you love to touch and hold books, making them yours; and of course that you must have a dog!!!!!!!! Few things compare to the pure joy of dog love and loyalty. Enjoy Mitzi! And thank you for ALL your work.
LikeLike