Diana Rogers, a regular reader of the blog, writes about her experience and her school:
I’ve worked for twenty years in a district that has a wonderful staff. There have been a few unsuitable teachers throughout the years, and the administration had no trouble identifying them and getting rid of them; a few others who just needed a bit of guidance were mentored and became better teachers.
I know I have become a better teacher each year, and I have worked hard at becoming better–taken 65 semester hours of post-graduate work, attended numerous workshops and seminars, read professional books and journals. But more important, I learned from my students and their parents, and from my colleagues. I did not “peak” after a few years, but got better and better each year at understanding my students, being able to explain material to them in ways they could grasp and retain, and at knowing how to bring parents into the teaching team as their children’s biggest supporters.
I have done everything I have been asked to do. And so have the other teachers I know. I don’t see all these “bad” teachers that are always being talked about in the media. But in recent years we have been asked to do not only the stupid, but the downright impossible, and even the harmful. Yes we are getting demoralized, attacked from all sides by non-educators who think they understand education better than professional educators. On the whole, teachers are idealistic strivers who try to do everything they can to help their students succeed. I see this every day.
And now we have to waste time on endless testing, data compilation, test preparation, and changing our curriculum to align to the Common Core.
We have to worry about our contracted pensions being taken away from us.
We have to spend enormous amounts of time assembling a portfolio of evidence to prove that we are good teachers, and are even told not to expect to be rated as excellent as we were in the past and as our administrators know we are.
This time could certainly be better spent polishing and improving our lessons, researching materials and methods, or giving feedback to students. Even though I take stacks of work home nightly and spend a huge chunk of the weekend and much of my vacation time on grading, preparation, and other school-related work, there are still only so many hours in a day, and they are not enough to do what I am required to do without adequate resources or support.
The conditions teachers work under are not the fault of school administrators any more than that of the teachers. Administrators endure the same unreasonable pressures of impossible demands, unfair evaluations and limited resources as teachers do. They are caught up in the same effort to do what is being asked of them when what is being asked is not reasonable or right.
Schools will not become better if people like me and the many fine, experienced teachers I know are driven out by impossible demands, abuse, and loss of job and retirement security.
I want to believe that sensible thinkers will prevail and that the tide in this insidious madness of false “reform” will turn.
I cannot understand why there is not recognition and enormous public outcry against the dismantling of public education in our country.
I’m hoping that the harm being done by those whose interests are not the welfare of our country and its children will finally be understood and that people of good faith in the general public and in our government (if there are any left there who are not controlled by big money) will do what is needed to save public education before it is too late.

We the Willing,
Led by the Unknown,
Are doing the Impossible
For the Ungrateful.
We have done so much
For so long
With so little
That we are now qualified to do
Anything with Nothing.
If anyone knows who wrote that, I’d be most grateful to find out. I saw it decades ago and have found it useful so many time since.
LikeLike
I think you have spoken the words of all experienced educators, thank you! The problem lies with the fact that the majority of the educators are buried in their class work. They do not have the time to battle the “reformers” but are trying to keep their heads above water and educate their students to the best of their ability. Our politicians are being bought out or misinformed about “reform” . All of us have to not only teach our students but must also find the time to teach parents, boards of education, departments of education and politicians about the ills of this “reform” push. We have to do what is needed to save public education before it is too late!
LikeLike
I agree with everything you have said.
As teachers, we are faced with essentially two choices;
Quit teaching
or
Stay and teach like the reformers and their mandates do not exist.
I have chosen the latter, for as long as it lasts.
In either case, we must continue to speak out and educate the public and our colleagues.
LikeLike
We need to get organized and utilize every resource available to us. These fork tongued legislatures and corporate suits have co-opted the language of the left, distracted us with red herrings, monopolized the conversation, and left us broke and bewildered. Let’s get real focused and collaborative. The wolf has been fleecing the flock whilst we slept like Little Boy Blue. Time to wake up and set things to rights.
http://signon.org/sign/repeal-no-child-left-1
LikeLike
Unfortunately, they will not listen to good teachers threatening to leave their schools. They will only listen after the fact.
LikeLike
Thank you for your voice. I just completed a 6 hour PD on how to continue to teach the common core in pre-k through a power point presentation. I am positive that this same power point was given to day care teachers. Every teacher in the room today has at least 10 or more years of pre-k experience and we were treated like lst year college students. Every day more is added to our plate. I am holding the line as best I can but I know it’s only a matter of time that I will be found wanting and asked to leave.
Ron, I think having good teachers leave is just what the BIG SUITS ( as apposed to lowly school administrators) want.
I truly believe the faster they can get rid of all of us, the happier they will be. Their children will continue to go to private schools with more than ample resources and the hoi poli will attend poorly run and underfunded schools where they will get a minimum education. They will be able to take menial jobs but not much more while the children of the BIG SUITS will continue to control the country.
My friend’s mother always says, “If you’re not paranoid, you’re not informed”
LikeLike
Sheila, it is absolutely what some people want. Unfortunately I think we have hit a point where we probably need to hit rock bottom before we can begin the long, slow climb back up to where we were. The privatization moguls need to be formally in charge for a period of time before people will stop heaping EVERY blame on the heads of the public school teachers.
How much of your life do you want to throw away on this? If the economy were in better shape and you could easily find a job elsewhere, would you even be having this conversation?
I love teaching; ten years ago I was unfortunate enough to have to go through a divorce but I remember thinking that at least I had a great job. I used to hear my friends complaining about their work situations and I was thankful that I didn’t feel the way they did at all. Now things are reversed.
I’m all for fighting the good fight but I don’t want to wake up in my sixties and realize I spent the bulk of my career being abused by an entire society. No thanks.
LikeLike
Ron Poirier: the honesty is much appreciated.
Props.
LikeLike
Thank you so much for your well-expressed post. I wish I could share this with my principal and colleagues.
LikeLike
My heart goes out to you all – after 35 years teaching in Australia. Finally I retired (gave up?) Now my memories are of the wonderful children and people I worked with and fortunately the bureaucracy has faded into insignificance where it belongs. Don’t ever believe you are not doing a worthwhile job.
And there is life after teaching – I am now a published author with a wealth of stories stored away for a rainy day! Good Luck.
LikeLike
No argument here. I’ve been there too.
LikeLike
Great comment- thanks for writing!
LikeLike