Gotta love these parents. Here is a brilliant comment to an earlier blog about parent power. What will Gates and Broad and the U.S. Department of Education and the governors and state legislatures do when parents get engaged and angry? What will they do when parents rise up and say, “Enough is enough,” as parents in New York City did today? How will they defend themselves when parents demand an end to the use and misuse of their children?
Parents are the key here. Unfortunately, parents tend to be invested in their own children’s education and that does not translate into a national movement yet. Many parents are still ardent supporters of a data driven, educational model whether the numbers tell them something useful or not. The outrage is not universal, by far, as not every state, city, or local district has embraced the testing culture to the same extent. It will come as we all jump on the common core bandwagon. When parents throughout the country start to grumble, the political machinery will start to crumble. I wonder how long powerful foundations and corporations will be able to control the agenda. They can’t possibly be totally staffed by people who can afford elite private education for their children. Will they sell out their own children?
The forces promoting the obsession with standardized testing and data are powerful, but they cannot hold back a tide of informed and committed parents. Once parents realize what is happening to their children, their teachers, and their schools, once they see how the quality of education is being eroded by data mania, once they understand that they are sacrificing their own children to the giant data-crunching machine, game over.
Rule of the day, the month, the week, the year, the decade, the century: Do not do unto other people’s children what you would not do to your own.
Diane
Indeed the people of New York city have seen today a rare sight of protest against crony Capitalism of the almighty Pearson and it’s business associates at the NYC Department of Education – though don’t let the name confuse anyone, this department has no interest in education. It was a small protest. nothing like Quebec’s months long fight that saw many thousands flooding the streets of Montreal every night – a city that is far smaller then the 11 million strong New York city – They also organized a long college strike initiated by the students to fight the neo conservative experiment we have been suffering from since the eighties – if not prior. In NYC the parents and educators have boycotted the experiment Pearson has been conducted to boost their already secure profits.
I do recommend to watch the video from this protest as shown on NY1, the local channel. One very smart kid sounded far smarter more reasonable and lucid then all the crony policymakers we have had ill fortune to listen to and be subjected to their destructive, greedy, corrupt and anti intellectualism policymakers and their oligarchs.
http://manhattan.ny1.com/content/top_stories/162683/schools-boycott-latest-round-of-standardized-testing
I’ll have to quote this fine student who said: “They’re just trying to use our brains like we’re lab rats,They just want to make more money off of testing and the DOE is allowing this.” If we only had a million smart people like this one, the struggle would have looked quite different.
Where is the PTA in all of this? Aren’t they supposed to advocate against the abuse of children?
National PTA has received millions of dollars from the Gates Foundation to promote “education reform,” specifically the Common Core standards. Do not expect it to lead the fight against high-stakes testing.
See here: http://www.pta.org/Why_is_a_Dues_Increase_Needed_Now_2.pdf
[…] https://dianeravitch.net/2012/06/07/when-parents-awaken-game-over/ […]
I agree that it would be great if more parents spoke up. I’m always surprised at how few education-focused blogs are written purely from a parent’s (as opposed to a teacher’s, academic’s, or policymaker’s) perspective. (I write one such blog here.)
I think many parents are intimidated by the supposed expertise of educational policymakers, when actually many educational issues turn on value questions that parents are just as qualified as experts to make.
[…] I am confident in parents. Try reading Dr. Diane Ravitch, instead. Link to article here: When Parents Awaken, Game Over. Like this:LikeBe the first to like this […]
I agree ! I felt inclined to respond to a NPR article that essentially said parents were helpless to counter high stakes testing.
Here is my blog/ response to NPR – I linked it to your blog here, as well.
“Shame on NPR – Never Underestimate the Power of Parents.”
http://gatorbonbc.wordpress.com/2012/06/09/shame-on-npr-never-underestimate-the-power-of-parents-national-resolution-on-high-stakes-testing/
Thank you for empowering teachers and parents across the nation to speak up!
[…] not good enough to decide lives.” (via Twitter) She also reminds us that parents are the key: ‘When parents awaken, game over.’ . BTW – Which countries lead in education, globally? Try Finland. And, surprise, surprise, they […]