In a recent essay for Education Week, Marc Tucker took issue with advocates for choice, charters and competition. He dismantled the libertarian argument for free markets in schooling. That’s not what enables top-performing nations to succeed, he says. Worth reading.
A site to discuss education and democracy
Categories Education Reform
1 Comment Post your own or leave a trackback: Trackback URL
Leave a comment Cancel reply
Search All Posts
Previous posts
- April 2024 (102)
- March 2024 (116)
- February 2024 (116)
- January 2024 (101)
- December 2023 (98)
- November 2023 (96)
- October 2023 (101)
- September 2023 (111)
- August 2023 (122)
- July 2023 (108)
- June 2023 (128)
- May 2023 (124)
- April 2023 (136)
- March 2023 (129)
- February 2023 (113)
- January 2023 (115)
- December 2022 (111)
- November 2022 (97)
- October 2022 (100)
- September 2022 (103)
- August 2022 (120)
- July 2022 (111)
- June 2022 (112)
- May 2022 (120)
- April 2022 (105)
- March 2022 (120)
- February 2022 (96)
- January 2022 (94)
- December 2021 (98)
- November 2021 (77)
- October 2021 (79)
- September 2021 (78)
- August 2021 (74)
- July 2021 (82)
- June 2021 (69)
- May 2021 (66)
- April 2021 (72)
- March 2021 (103)
- February 2021 (140)
- January 2021 (169)
- December 2020 (142)
- November 2020 (160)
- October 2020 (169)
- September 2020 (170)
- August 2020 (175)
- July 2020 (191)
- June 2020 (195)
- May 2020 (205)
- April 2020 (203)
- March 2020 (197)
- February 2020 (165)
- January 2020 (180)
- December 2019 (194)
- November 2019 (185)
- October 2019 (199)
- September 2019 (169)
- August 2019 (172)
- July 2019 (169)
- June 2019 (193)
- May 2019 (203)
- April 2019 (195)
- March 2019 (187)
- February 2019 (160)
- January 2019 (201)
- December 2018 (204)
- November 2018 (213)
- October 2018 (213)
- September 2018 (186)
- August 2018 (190)
- July 2018 (196)
- June 2018 (190)
- May 2018 (225)
- April 2018 (221)
- March 2018 (242)
- February 2018 (182)
- January 2018 (212)
- December 2017 (224)
- November 2017 (188)
- October 2017 (240)
- September 2017 (239)
- August 2017 (237)
- July 2017 (235)
- June 2017 (224)
- May 2017 (267)
- April 2017 (265)
- March 2017 (284)
- February 2017 (262)
- January 2017 (355)
- December 2016 (239)
- November 2016 (274)
- October 2016 (219)
- September 2016 (218)
- August 2016 (211)
- July 2016 (217)
- June 2016 (219)
- May 2016 (233)
- April 2016 (229)
- March 2016 (242)
- February 2016 (244)
- January 2016 (247)
- December 2015 (230)
- November 2015 (233)
- October 2015 (292)
- September 2015 (262)
- August 2015 (268)
- July 2015 (252)
- June 2015 (254)
- May 2015 (277)
- April 2015 (290)
- March 2015 (322)
- February 2015 (281)
- January 2015 (247)
- December 2014 (225)
- November 2014 (226)
- October 2014 (287)
- September 2014 (283)
- August 2014 (271)
- July 2014 (258)
- June 2014 (281)
- May 2014 (284)
- April 2014 (330)
- March 2014 (358)
- February 2014 (308)
- January 2014 (282)
- December 2013 (260)
- November 2013 (270)
- October 2013 (342)
- September 2013 (358)
- August 2013 (373)
- July 2013 (336)
- June 2013 (347)
- May 2013 (348)
- April 2013 (369)
- March 2013 (379)
- February 2013 (296)
- January 2013 (342)
- December 2012 (328)
- November 2012 (270)
- October 2012 (366)
- September 2012 (475)
- August 2012 (463)
- July 2012 (372)
- June 2012 (209)
- May 2012 (120)
- April 2012 (17)
-
Recent posts
Blog Topics
Accountability Betsy DeVos Billionaires Budget Cuts California Charter Schools Chicago Common Core Corporate Reform Corporate Reformers Democracy Disruption Education Industry Education Reform Elections Extremism Failure Florida For-Profit Fraud Funding Gates Foundation, Bill Gates International Los Angeles New York New York City Parents Privatization Resistance School Choice Standardized Testing Students Teacher Evaluations Teachers Teachers and Teaching Testing Texas Trump Unions Vouchers- Follow Diane Ravitch's blog on WordPress.com
Top posts
- Will Bunch: The Scariest Part of a Trump Rally is not Trump
- Jim Hightower: George Orwell Would Understand the Texas GOP: Mean and Crazy
- Rick Wilson: The “Both-Sides” Argument is Dangerous
- Eva Moskowitz May Expand “Success Academy” to Florida
- Thom Hartmann: The Close Connection Between Monopolies and Labor
- Jess Piper: It’s My State Too! I’m Not Moving!
- Indiana: Jennifer McCormick for Governor!!
- ACLU: How to Protect Free Speech on Campus
- Jan Resseger: What Is White Christian Nationalism?
- World Leaders Call on Hamas to Release Hostages and Accept Ceasefire Deal
-
- Follow Diane Ravitch's blog on WordPress.com
-
Follow blog via RSS reader
-
Diane Ravitch's Blog by Diane Ravitch is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at dianeravitch.net. -
Blog Stats
- 41,325,456 hits
Diane Ravitch's blog 
Excellent pieces, both the article in the link and the original article that provoked such cheap-shot responses.
Tucker’s analysis and data are precisely the points we have to keep pounding in letters to the papers, calls and letters to our politicians, and appearances at school board meetings. The simplistic argument that “choice” will guarantee “better” schools really begs the question–The champions of choice simply assume that the choices will always be better that what’s available now. Tucker shows the reality is far more complex and disappointing.